High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/25844/2018dismissed

Ramavtar Singh v. Permanent Lok Adalat For Public Utility Services (Pus) Bhiwani And ORS

2023-05-16Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj13 pages

"#$%&% '(&

"#$" *+ '(&,(#

"#$" - ./-%0

0%' 22222 "%& '()*+,-(.$/0* 1(#"

22222

0%'3%*45+

( (" 3 #" * '- $0$$ '+ * 0)) 4,$-)*""#**#"(*/'15$'+ ,"'*$6!1*-*"

&& ( *3*$ $*$ 7 8:; #*""$ '+ ( )* < $*5* ,'50 5+/0" . (3*5*3$11 (,)'"3$ '+ ( #"

!(5 !&=;>>&8:; (*" ' #1$ *-*"

( >;",*$ + . (3*? !&=@&8:;5*"

( >9 (-,$"10(*55-6*""1$")""*5)*( "*) ( 1*05+ 1 10. 1*0" (*/ ' A*0$ 1)

!&=;>>&8:;

15+.(0*"1(#"(*(3*"*55$

( >; * + . (3* '+ ( "#$& /$ *55) 5 787$*$:7 8@ 88;

(*/#0 1(#5 3*""

:=.7:.888B&*$(#$#"$*",)1" :.=7.:88B&*" '$ )+ /$ 0# := $*$ @ 8;

88;

(*1. ( *$$*5*),1"

.C>.:=8B&3*"*5"$#"$'+(#/$ 0# :79$*$8C ::

88;*<-(*5$#"$*),( A1=D1(*/#01( ( (#0$" (***"",*03*"-/(#*()1*55)1( '((*("3,5$'$/5#$/+"*$111#"""" "#0 1 ( '(B#5 355 ' )*$ ))$*5+ 0)#5 1 $/5#)3<*("#3(0((*$'0)#5$*()1 *55) *$ ( '*"0 *)" 3 #/$$ * ( "# /*5 #"*"BE,""3"'+(#$/5#(""*$ #/$('*"0*)".(3/.($3*"#*$",0(E,"" *$(**E,"3*"$/5#$ (#""""3*"*5" 11$'+("#$"

",5*5+.(#"##$()*0 1('*5*0"*55)"

"1,(*/$(**(-("500 33*"*5"#*""-(,-((**1('(B#5E,"*$(

&C& "#$3*"E,"$)/((-("5003"(*( 0,5$ 0))0 ( 0",0 3< 10 3*" )*$ /*," 5"B0)),0* $*$ :8 8 8:. 8;

8= 8:. > 8:. 8 ::

8: *$ > 8:C 3(0( (*/ ' " (-( *,(" *" 355 *03*"*<("*)*$(#/*##*0($ ( (1$)"*. 1"<-$""*51("-/*0 ( "#$". (3/. $)*$$ * " 1 $5*+$ $#" 1 ( )+.

*1 ( #"""" 1 ( #5 3*" 11$ 8:= ( #05*)"(*((*"E,"$("#$&*,("3*/ 11("("*55)"*"(3*"$100+"/0( #*1("#$&*,("'+#/$-('*"0*)"( "#*$("#$"51'-*#"11#""""1 (#5*00,1((-("3(*/-'0$/( #5E," (*,("1*5$11(#(+"0*5#""""1( #5("#1*#$189+*".(#3*""*$1) *"-0",0("*$#5B'(")(5+,("',""" #*")5+.

::.98.9=8B& (*$ ' "(3 *" ,"*$- *), 1 "*55)*$*",)1"

;.7=.@7B&3*""(3#*+*'5*""( $1*,5-*), "*/$(*(*'/"*$$)*$3*"4,"1$ *$ (* ( # " *--/$ '+ ( (-( (*$$"" 1 ( "#$"*$5$0/$*)*-"11*0*55"""0*,"$ () *" 355 *" 0)#"* 1 )*5 (**"") *$ *-+ *##50* 3*" (," #1$ '1 ( )* < $*5* ,'50 5+ /0" . (3* ,$ 0 1 ( -*5 /0" ,("0.:@;9*$03*""",$"#$"3(,#(+

&>& 15$ ( "#" *<- /*," '40" 05,$- ( '40 #*-50,""*$.)***'5+.4,"$0.&4$*$)"& 4$10""*+#*"

$$*55+3*"*5"0$$(*(, *$)**51*0"05*)$'+(#&*##50**00 3*" "*$,(*(#5E,"(*$'*55$(#** */ #0 1 "

:=.7:.888B& '- ( (-(" '$$ """" 1 '( 3*" *5" 11$ 3/. ( "*$ 11 3*" 0/$ '*0< ,$5/$ ("*)3*""*-*/$5 7=99$*$87 :8 88; 3(0( 3*"$,5+ 0/$ '+ (#&*##50* *$ "#$ (#*$(0&3$#"$**),1" :.=7.:88B&*" '$)+'-:8D1(*5#01(#5/$0# := $*$@ 8;

88;*$$#"$*",)1"

.C>.:=8B&)*<=D1 (*5#01(#5/$0#$*$8C ::

88;

*##50*3*" )*$'+(#:8 8 8:.E,"-1)/*51(500 3#*""-/('(*$0(*-"()*-*), 3(1101)($*1)/*51(500*53 ("*$E," 3*"13*$$(A0,/-. .500*5/". "* /$5'*- $") ::;=$*$ 8@ 8C 8: $ )

8;C $*$ 89 8> 8:=. ( A0,/ -. . 500*5 /". "*)*$(*(3*"3#*""-/(00$ '(B#5*"#(#1(,'/"*5- 00$-5+. ("('*5*0#01(#53*"*00,3 87 :8 88;

3/. ( # *$ ( "#$ ( 3" $$ $#"('*5*09=D*),1(*/#0 3*"*5""*$(* ("#$ :3-5+*$*$/5+"",$*111#"""" 1'( >;/$) B:>99$*$ 8:=3(0(3*"

&=& 3($*3/$5 =CC$*$:= 8:7 1,(*/)3*" )*$(*111#""""1(#5(*/-')*$87 :8 88; 3(*55'*"0*)"'-0)#5.(#3*"5*'5#*+( "1$5*+$#*+)1('*5*0"*55)" "(005* #0$-" )" 1 0 & > 9 1 ( -*5 /0 ,("0.:@;91*5$0+"*55F*"5,.(*$4,$0* 1 ( $"#, 3*" *$ '+ ( )* < $*5* ,'50 5+ /0" . (3*,$0G ; 1(-*5/0",(" 0.:@;9 #0"$*1("#0/0"*$/$0 *$$,0$0$.(*##50*#1$'+(#3*"$")""$ --/$(1.(#"#(*"'15$ >

0 1 ( "* 3 # (*$ ' "",$ ( "#$"3(3$,5+"/$ 3/.$"#"/0(+0(" *##* "E,5+. ( "#$" 3 $$ ' #0$$ *-*" A&#* /$ $ $*$ ;

8:@ ( )* 3*" (*1 *$4,$/*,"00*""*3**##**0.1*+.*$(*"1*55+ '(*$)"

= *$0,"5*##*-'(*511(#*" (",')""0$*'/*$0$"(*('*"0*)"*( "# (*$ ' #/$$ 1 *$ (* * (-( " 500 3 3*" #*""- (,-( ( #5 E," *$ *" * ",5 3(1 ( '( E,"0,5$'0",0$*$,5F*1("*$##+' $ 0$"(*(1)*0/$ 8:="*'5"(" (*(111#"""""(,5$'(5$1)("*$$*5+*$(*

&7& *+#"""""05*)$B0(*-$'+("#$"1*+#$ #("5*'5'"*"$ (*/ (*$ 5*$ 0,"5 1 ( #" *$ - (,-(($0,)"*/*5*'50$ (#3*"$0$1*+)**5*/*5*'5 0$('*""3(1)*+'*"0*$(*('*"0*)"*" *E,$#/$$1*("#'1"",*01111#"""" (*$')*$*/*5*'555 8:= (*"1*5$1*+ ",0()**5*$(*"*5"*##$$*+($0,)('*"" 3(10*'(5$(*('*"0*)" 3*",##5+.500 ",##5+."3*-*$*$"3*/*5*'5*("#3((111 #""""3*"*55+ )*$ ,(.

(#(*"'*'5 $"#,(1*0(*(111#""""3*""'+("#$"/$ 5 7=99 $*$ 87 :8 88; "*'5"( (* ",0( 11 1 #""""3*"/0/$'+() ()*<$*5*,'50 5+/0" . (3*(*$.*10"$*1(/$0*$$,0$ '1.

#$#

&9& &

###

(

)

+,-.) -

! /

)* 01 ) 2 +,-.3

)

+,-.)-

)* 0

)* 0( 4

)*4 #$###!

)*4( 0

)*4 #$#

)*0! #5#$ +,-.

#$#

#$###! '

&;&

#$###!

+,-.

)*0$ 4

#$#

! #$# )*0$ 4

)*0!

#$###! #$#

)* 0!

#$#)*0$

)* 4( 0(

#$###! &

)*4( 07

8 4

)*4 4

)*4 #$###!

)*4 ###

##! #

! *

#$#

6 %

&@& ;

" /$ 1) * #,"*5 1 ( *'/ "*$ *3*$ *$ ( 1$- 0$$ (* ( )* < $*5* ,'50 5+ /0" .

(3* "#010*55+ ,$ * 1$- (* 500 3 3*" #*""- /('(E,"*$(*/*("*-3((1"53*" ",')$'+(#.3*"("0*"(*('*"0*)"*( "#3*/*5*'5 (5+-,""#,"$3*"(**5003 #*""$(,-((#56,-(')/$ 0*(,"'0",$ (*('*"0*)"(*$'#/$$1'+("#$& . * ( "*- 1 ( 0 1 ( # *', *'"0 1 '*"0 *)" 3,5$ ' 00. ( 3*" *" 3(+ ",0( "(0)- 3,5$1$)(0)#*,"0"#$0 ". 3(5$$(-(5-(($100+"51 @ ,(.

("/$00$*5"",--"(**+ 500*")""53*"#*""-/*$*'/(#5*$(*( #"3/#('$1)*"-*0",0(#51 3(0(#""""(*$*5*$+'11$'+("#$& :8 5*0(*"'#5*0$'+(#"55+(5 $*$ 8:=.(3/.

'11*+",0(*$/00*'A$$**55"#0*55+ 3((513($*3*5$*$:= 8:7(*$/'*""*5$ 0(*55-$ "E,5+.("/$0',-('1( ,. ('*""3(1)*+((5$(*(1$-0$$'+()* < $*5* ,'50 5+ /0" . (3* ",11" 1) *+ 55-*5+. #/"+. )##+ &*##0* 1 ( /$0 *$$,0$ 0$

&:8& ::

(*"'*$'+*/" 0(1(" ,( )* 1

'*- ! ""#"$ %&&%$*$:;

88C(***550*1*1)#*+)1( "*55)")5+(*55-*"-*$-*)"(*/#/$$ *("# (#"0*"1*5"150(*('*"0*)"(*$ '#/$$*("#3((#""""3*"11$ ",5*5+.( #(*$4,"10*1&#*+)1("*55)*$B(*$* /*5$'*""0$*$05*)(*("5*'5#*+"( $5*+$ #*+) ( 5/* A*0 1 ( 4,$-) 1 ( /"

0("#$,0$(*1'53% H (

% -

;

< % (

=4> ? , .

= >

@&4'

8$A ##;

-?B 3 4 ? .

@ .

8## ##=8>0@0=@

>#=4C+>@&4'

A8$ ## + 3 ? B

+ , - .

!8##( ;

-?B 3 4 ? .

@ .

= > @ *

@ 4 % =- 0

> . A5 6

% ;

< % (

=4> ? , .

= > D

&::& E(

;

< % (

=4>? F= >

0 0

. 0

(

0 0

* 9

(

&:& % ;

< %(

4 ? = >

9 9

(

E : (*'"01*+/$0",'"**6"*'5"(( 05*) 1 ( # *', 5*0< 1 '*"0 *)" 6 ( *,(*/ #,0)1(/" 0((0*"13*"*,#* )*$*- #*+) 1 '*5*0 "*55). 1*5 1$ *+ ( *3*$ :C $-55-*5+.#/"+)##+(*3*$" #*""$*$*'"01*+)**5"(3(*("*)"&*##0* 1/$0*$$,0$'1( ,.(*3*$$*$7 8:;#*""$'+

&:C& ( )* < $*5* ,'50 5+ /0" . (3* 0* ' 1$3(*$("*)"*00$-5+,#(5$ (#"3#"**00$-5+$")""$ *1

0%'+ -#$3 1 !(("#*<-B*"$

"B !((#*'5 %