High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/8476/2014dismissed

Ajay Kumar Jain And ORS v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2015-11-18Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal,Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan10 pages

"#$$%&'&()

* +",-./"0"&(#1$0'

$#&#&($0'

3$0'.'

4#"#$"0,"("#1$0'

$'5(6$(#'

0$'$(#)2 04"(+",-".'1"784069%"#$:&#1 00+.(41.;7"869%"#$0#1$5$#&#&($0' 0 "1.7$988"0,"(" 0-.76$$5&:"0&869%"#$0 <<<

$#&#&($0''$$;=."'1&(>06$06"#$6

(($?.0$ @!85"''$6A,#1$'#"#$ &%$08 8.0>"(0$'./&(>"0$'&6$(#&"7 57# $#&#&($0'"0$"7'">>0&$9$6#1$06$0'6"#$6*

(($?.0$

!"(6

@(($?.0$ !85"''$6A,#1$55$77"#$"(6 $9&'&("7 ".#10&#&$'0$'5$%#&9$7,"&0/&(>#1$"%#&(0$'./5#&(

7#@B84$%#0 @C @28.0>"(:"'"77##$6&(#1$ ("/$41-"&(&$"#1$05$#&#&($0( (

B.5(1&'

A&6 '@8 8

C21"9&(>A$$("%%$5#$6&("(5$(".%#&(77#/$(# 7$##$06"#$6

B(($?.0$ 2!:"'&''.$6A,#1$#1&060$'5(6$(# "(6#1$#$0/'"(6%(6&#&(':1&%1:.76A$0$7$9"(#0#1$50$'$(#%"'$ "0$0$506.%$61$0$.(6$0)2

. /

1 30 !.

4 && )

- 5 !!

4$%#0 "/$ 0A"( 0$"

7# 550? 6&/$('&( 0 6$'%0&5#&( "'

(#&&$6 "# #1$ #&/$ ".%#&( 0$" &( 4= /#0'

0&%$

@ .0>"( @B

@ ?

6 .

7%%(5 !

" /

. 79&4&9(

.: !

" (

6 9; !. . :

< *

" :

" 0 ! ! 4

. !

(;

" 0 .

. 9 6 .

74%'49&9(5

5 .!. "

" '(

. 6 . "

> .

< . "

(;

. .

6 4 "0 4

' 6 !

0 !. "

: =

0 ! 4 !

4 "0

0 " (

& < . .

< *

0 .

" !. !

0 0 % = .

! (

< *

??? ??? ???

9 6

0 '

" 0

" "

6 . . > < *

" !

. "

.: 5 "

! .

< *

! .

??? ??? ???

. 1 "0

. . .

??? ??? ???

9 =

!. 5 .

. @ %; "

! A @

*D#1$"77#/$(#50&%$1"9&(>A$$(6$5'&#$68(.0#1$0 &('#"77/$(# :"' 5"&6 3&6$ /$/ 6"#$6

* BB (($?.0$ 2*!

5''$''&(#1$57#&(=.$'#&(:"'$0$6'1:%".'$(#&%$6"#$6

BBB (($?.0$ 2! .(6$0 4$%#&( ! #1$ "0,"(" 0A"( $9$75/$(#%#8 B1$0$&("#$0#A$0$$00$6#"'#1$ B%#!:"'

&''.$6("%%.(#((26$5'&#&('#"77/$(#"(6"''.%18&/5'&#&(" 5$("7#, ' 8@@8 *C2:"'%(#$/57"#$6#$0%('&6$0"#&("0$57, 6"#$6

@ BBB806$06"#$6 * BBB(($?.0$

!:"'&''.$6A,#1$ #1&060$'5(6$(#&/5'&(>"5$("7#, ' 8@@8 C2"(6"''.%186&0$%#&(> #1$"77##$$#6$5'&##1$$(#&0$.#'#"(6&(>"/.(#"7(>:&#1#1$5$("7#, :&#1&("5$0&6 *6",'(26$5'&##1$6.$"/.(#1"'7$6##1$ 5"''&(>#1$0$'./5#&(06$06"#$6

(($?.0$ 2@! 0&>&("7 "77##$$41-"&(6&$6&(#1$,$"0

"(61&'7$>"71$&0'&$50$'$(# 5$#&#&($0' 5.0'.$6 #1$ 50%$$6&(>' #1$0$"#$0 6/&(&'#0"#08 8 .0>"(0$+$%#$6#1$"55$"750$$00$6A,#1$5$#&#&($0'9&6$06$06"#$6 *

(($?.0$ !"(6$9$(#1$ $9&'&("7.#10&#,&$ 0&(%&5"7 4$%0$#"0,#9#"0,"("8:(8.(#0, 7"((&(>"(6 0A"('#"#$'

$5"0#/$(#1"'0$+$%#$6#1$0$9&'&(5$#&#&(50$$00$6.(6$04$%#&( !

#1$ B%#&(#1$7&>1##1$06$06"#$6

*(($?.0$ ! E$"0($6 '$(&0%.('$7 "55$"0&(>0#1$5$#&#&($0' :.76 9$1$/$(#7,%(#$(6#1"##1$$05''$''&(/"6$9&6$7$##$06"#$6

* BB:"'(#"9"7&6$0&("'/.%1"'6$9$75/$(#:0;'&(#1$"0$" 1"6(#A$$(%/57$#$6#1"'A$$("0>.$6#1"#"'5$0%(6&#&((#1$ "77#/$(#7$##$0#1$5''$''&(#1$57#:"'#A$$0$6(%/57$#&( #1$6$9$75/$(#:0;'.('$71"'$9$("69$0#$6##1$0$57,6"#$6

2*2

@ BBB'.A/&##$6A,#1$"77##$$##1$'1:%".'$(#&%$8:1$0$&(&#1"6 A$$('#"#$6#1"##1$0$:"'"5.7#0,"0/'&#."#$655'&#$#1$57#&( =.$'#&("(6#1$0$:$0$$9$(1&>1#$('&($7$%#0&%%"A7$'5"''&(>9$01$"6 "(6("%%.(#:1&%1%('#0.%#&(:"'(#5''&A7$ 0$%&'$'.A/&''&( 0"&'$6&'#1"#'&(%$6$9$75/$(#:0;'1"6(#A$$(.(6$0#";$("(6#1$57# &#'$7:"''&#."#$6"#"6&'"69"(#">$.'7%"#&(8"%%06&(>7,8&('#"77/$(#' 1"6(#A$$(6$5'&#$6"(60:1&%1#1$$?#0$/$'#$50$'./5#&('1.76 (#1"9$A$$(0$'0#$6# $7&"(%$1"'A$$(57"%$6("+.6>$/$(#6"#$6

*0$(6$0$6A,"&9&'&($(%1#1&'.0#&(

#&#7$6"'

8:1$0$&( #1$0$'./5#&(06$0&(0$'5$%#"0$'&6$(#&"757#("%%.(#((2 5",/$(#&('#"77/$(#'C6.$'9$0"%('&6$0"A7$7$(>#1#&/$1"6A$$( '$#"'&6$'.A+$%###1$"77##$$#1$0$&(6$5'&#&(>#1$$(#&0$.#'#"(6&(> 6.$'"7(>:&#1&(#$0$'#"(65$("7#,"'"557&%"A7$ * 0 -.76$$5 &:"0&8 7$"0($6 %.('$7 "55$"0&(> 0 ".#10&#&$':.769$1$/$(#7,55'$#1$5$#&#&(A,0$$00&(>##1$(#&%$ /#&(06$06"#$6**

8:1&%10$"6'&(#1$77:&(>#$0/')2 6

. (%%

. !

! ((4

" !! !!

! .

0 !

. !

( . 6 "

B "

4 , / C 4

! .

9((

5 )27 6- D23 < 5 )E=

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

$! &

'( )** (+)& "(6&#:"'A'$09$6"'77:')2 = E: " 30 !.

0 ,C !

4 )- ## 4 " " 0 !

0 !.

0 !!

0 ! 4 " .

F 0G4 " !

0 " ! ! 4 . .

04 .

0 !

4 8

6 0

0 ! 0 !.

4 0 !!

" . 0

" ! . !

4 .!

= .

0 !.

! 6 0 !.

. 6 0 !.

= .

0 !.

.4 !! 0

. .

0 !.

0 !. .

0 !.

0 ! .

0 0 !

. 4 I

. , -.//

& - /-

/- /

0!/!!

0 /1 - /-

/ $ /!

. $ / &!

30- / & /

30. 4

/ /3

/ 50!

.6 !/!

30 $ & !

- /-

- /. #!

/- ! !

- /-/

-.// 0 ! $ - / / - / & -- / +

-/! 7

- /-

!+$ -- 4$

& . / 3

-$+ 0 4 $ &-

% /

, +. &!

!$!

, &

+ $ & !

& - /-

/ 8/ 0 - &- - /-

/ &!

! !

0 - ./

-/ 7- -

- & $ & $ !

/ + $ $ !

-+ 9 ( 9&$: #1$ A'$09"#&(' 0$506.%$6 1$0$&( "A9$ #1$ +.'#&&%"#&($0$6(A$1"7#1$5$#&#&($0'#1"##1$&('#"77/$(#':$0$ (#6$5'&#$6("%%.(#6$9$75/$(#:0;'1"9&(>(#A$$(%"00&$6.# "(6#1"##1$57#&(=.$'#&('.$0&(>0/%$0#"&(6&'"69"(#">$'8%"((#A$ "%%$5#$6 #1$0$1"6A$$("(,A("&6$&(#$(#&((#1$5"0##1$ 5$#&#&($0'#0$#"&(#1$505$0#,8&#:"'"7:",'5$(0#1$/#1"9$ 6$5'&#$6#1$&('#"77/$(#'.(6$050#$'#"(6#1$0$"#$0'.>1#0$60$''"7 #1$&0>0&$9"(%$8&"(,8A,#";&(>.#"55050&"#$50%$$6&(>' $#&#&($0'

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

2B2 &(#$0$'#1$'%1$6.7$&('#"77/$(#'$?5&0$6(

BB1$"77##$$ 6&6(#5","'&(>7$&('#"77/$(#6.0&(>'.%1#$(.0$ 9$(#1$0$"#$0( 5",/$(#:"'/"6$"(6:1&%17$6##1$&''."(%$"'1:%".'$(#&%$ .(6$0'$%#&( !#1$ B%#9$(#1$((5",/$(#:"'6$5'&#$6 #&'(7,0#1$&0'##&/$&(#1$0$57,6"#$6

@ BBB(($?.0$ 2B!# #1$'1:%".'$(#&%$"57$":"'#";$(#1"#6$9$75/$(#:0;'1"6(# A$$(%/57$#$6"(6#1"#1&>1#$('&($7$%#0&%%"A7$':$0$5"''&(>9$0 1$"61$0$'./5#&(06$0:"'5"''$6(

5$0.'"7#1$06$0 5"''$6A,#1$55$77"#$.#10&#,6"#$6*

(($?.0$ !:.76 0$9$"7#1"#"&(6&(>1"'A$$(0$%06$6#1"##1$"77##$$:$0$'#&77(#0$"6, #%7$"0#1$6.$' (#1$0:06'8"#$06$5'&##1$&(&#&"7 *D#1$ "77#/$(#50&%$&(#1$,$"0 B#1$"77##$$C'6&6(#6$5'&#"'&(>7$ &('#"77/$(#$9$(#&77#1$6"#$0$+$%#&(#1$&0"55$"7&(#1$,$"0

# "55$"0' #1"# #1$ 5$#&#&($0' "0$ 5.0'.&(> #1$ 50$'$(# 50%$$6&(>' "(6 '$$;&(> '$##&(> "'&6$ #1$ 0$'./5#&( 06$0 5.0$7, 0 '5$%.7"#&9$ %('&6$0"#&( $/","7'50%$$6#(#$#1"#$9$(#1.>18(#&%$ /#&(06$06"#$6**

*1"6A$$(&''.$6A,0$%06&(>#1$%(#$(#&( 0"&'$6(A$1"7#1$5$#&#&($0'#1"##1$,"0$0$"6,"(6:&77&(>#'$$; 0$'10$2"77#/$(#"##1$%.00$(#50&%$A.#7$"0($6'$(&0%.('$76.0&(>#1$ %.0'$1$"0&(>#6",1"'(#"69"(%$6"(,'.A/&''&(&('.%10$>"06 1&'&'(7,0$7$%#&9$#1$7"%;#1$A("&6$'(#1$5"0##1$ 5$#&#&($0'"'0$>"06'#1$&00$=.&0$/$(#"0$'&6$(#&"7'&#$ B 1$ 0$7&"(%$ 57"%$6 A, %.('$7 .5( #1$ &9&'&( $(%1 +.6>$/$(#&(6%"'$'.50"!&'/&'57"%$6(#1$"%#' '.%1%"'$"0$'&6$(#&"757#"77##$6A, &(4$%#0

8/A"7":"'

0$'./$6&(#1$,$"0

@("%%.(#6$".7#&(6$5'&#&('#"77/$(#'

1$&9&'&($(%1'$#"'&6$#1$06$00$'./5#&(&(#1$7&>1##1$ 5$%.7&"0"%#' #1$ %"'$ "' :.76 A$ 6&'%$0(&A7$0/#1$ 77:&(> 5"''">$%(#"&($6&(#1$6$%&'&(6"#$6 @

*)2

4 "

! 0

! . "

! 4 0"

0 .

((94

1 ..

! 6 .

0 4 ! ! 4

! "

! 0 A 1$"%#'#1$50$'$(#%"'$"0$%7$"07,6&'#&(>.&'1"A7$"(6"' '.%18#1$+.6>$/$(#&( 6 %"'$'.50"!:.761"9$( "557&%"A&7&#,

0#1$0$"'('"0$'#"#$68:$6(#&(6"(,>0.(6# &(#$0$0$ :&#1 #1$ &/5.>($6 06$0' &( $?$0%&'$ .0 6&'%0$#&("0, +.0&'6&%#&(

0&#5$#&#&(&'6&'/&''$6

#$ % #! %&''

% ( "

)* %&'

#+(* )# + &# ,-,,./,0 7.%;, 1$#1$0#A$0$$00$6# $50#$0H$'