Maninder Singh v. State Of Punjab And ORS

   
         
         
         
      
 
 
 
  











 
 

    
 

    
 

    
 

   !"#$#%&' $#()*+#+,

++') $#()

&-$-$+#&'

&'*.*

-"-&+, .#/"01+-)&'*

&*2+#%&#-*
!

3

4 !  
       
!

3

4 !  
       
!

3

4 !  
       
!

3

4 !  
        '&*&#-

'&*&#-

'&*&#-

'&*&#-

!'

5 )"'6" %7+8"-&,+'-)&2&-$-$+#&'

!* !+#$8"
))$00&' )"'6"  &#$+'&2.-9%7+8"-& &#&'":  .#/"0 ;<;<;< ;<;<;< ;<;<;< ;<;<;<                                     &-$-$+#&'  =)+  $*  *&'7$#(  +#  -)&  2+*-   +,  .#$+'

#($#&&'.#%&'-)& .0:$8+'>*&2"'-6&#-?1'"#8)@  -"-& +, .#/"0 )"*,$:&%-)&$#*-"#-2&-$-$+#$62.(#$#(-)&+'%&'%"-&%

  ##&B.'&    "#%  $#  -&'6*  +,  =)$8)  -)&  "##.": $#8'&6&#-*-)"-)"%0&&#('"#-&%-+)$6 )"7&0&&#=$-)%'"=#  &'.*":+,-)&$62.(#&%+'%&'=+.:%'&7&":-)"-.2+# =$-)%'"=":+,-)&"##.":$#8'&6&#-* 2"9+,-)&2&-$-$+#&')"* 0&&#'&3,$B&%"-":+=&'*-"(&"#%%$'&8-$+#*)"7&0&&#$**.&%-+ -)&8+#8&'#&%$7$*$+#":88+.#-* ,,$8&'-+&,,&8--)&#&8&**"'9 '&8+7&'9 )&='$-2&-$-$+#)"%8+6&.2,+'2'&:$6$#"'9)&"'$#( +# "#%=)$:&$**.$#(#+-$8&+,6+-$+# '&8+7&'9+,-)&

 "6+.#-":'&"%92"$%-+-)&2&-$-$+#&')"%0&&#*-"9&% !'

5  )"'6"  :&"'#&%  8+.#*&:  '&2'&*&#-$#(  -)& 2&-$-$+#&' 6">&*"*-"-&6&#-%.'$#(-)&8+.'*&+,)&"'$#(-+%"9 -)"-)&$*8+#,$#$#(-)&8)"::&#(&-+-)&$62.(#&%+'%&'%"-&%

 ##&B.'&  +#:9"*'&("'%*'&8+7&'9 #+-)&'=+'%* -)&  2&-$-$+#&'  $*  #+-  "**"$:$#(  -)&  "8-$+#  +,  -)&  '&*2+#%&#-3 .-)+'$-$&*$#)"7$#(=$-)%'"=#-)&"##.":$#8'&6&#-*-)"-)"% 0&&#('"#-&%-+)$6"#%-)&8+#*&D.&#-'&3,$B"-$+#+,2"9"-" :+=&'*-"(&  #*.22+'-+,-)&:$6$-&%'&:$&,*+.()-$#-)&2&-$-$+# :&"'#&%8+.#*&:=+.:%"'(.&-)"--)&"##.":$#8'&6&#-*)"7& 0&&#('"#-&%-+-)&2&-$-$+#&'09-)&'&*2+#%&#-3&2"'-6&#-+, -)&$'+=#"88+'%"#%#+-+#-)&0"*$*+,"#9,":*&'&2'&*&#-"-$+# )"7$#(0&&#6"%&09-)&2&-$-$+#&'

-$*"'(.&%-)"--)&'&="* #+8+#8&":6&#-+,,"8-*+#)$*0&)":,  '&8$*&*.06$**$+#'"$*&% $*  -)"-  $,  #+  ,'".%  "#%  6$*3'&2'&*&#-"-$+#  $*  "--'$0.-&%  -+  "# &62:+9&& '&8+7&'9+,,$#"#8$":0&#&,$-*":'&"%9('"#-&%=+.:% #+-0&2&'6$**$0:&  &'8+#-'" :&"'#&% -"-&8+.#*&:=+.:%*.06$--)"- -)&0"*$*+,=$-)%'"=":+,$#8'&6&#-*)"*0&&#%$*8:+*&%$#-)& $62.(#&%+'%&'$-*&:,$ & -)&2&-$-$+#&'=)$:&*&'7$#("*.#$+'

#($#&&')"% #+-2"**&% -)&%&2"'-6&#-":&B"6$#"-$+#  -$* *.06$--&%  -)"-  *$#8&  -)&  2&-$-$+#&'  ="*  #+-  &#-$-:&%  -+  -)& $#8'&6&#-*"#%*$#8&$#8'&6&#-*)"%0&&#('"#-&%&''+#&+.*:9 $-="*":="9*+2&#,+'-)& -"-&-+)"7&'&8-$,$&%$-*6$*-">&$# -&'6*+,=$-)%'"=":+,$#8'&6&#-*  .'-)&'8+#-&#%&%-)"--)& $62.(#&%+'%&'%"-&%  ##&B.'&  )"*0&&#2"**&%

",-&'"%)&'$#(-+-)&2'$#8$2:&*+,#"-.'":/.*-$8&$#"*6.8)"*" *)+=  8".*&  #+-$8&  %"-&%      7$%&  6&6+  + ACA ##&B.'& C )"%0&&#%.:9*&'7&%.2+#-)&2&-$-$+#&'"#%$-$* +#:9-)&'&",-&'-)&$62.(#&%+'%&'="*2"**&%  &"'#&%8+.#*&:,+'-)&2"'-$&*)"7&0&&#)&"'% "8-*"'&#+-$#%$*2.-& 
+#8&%&%:9 $-="*+#:9.2+# D.":$,9$#(  -)&  %&2"'-6&#-":  &B"6$#"-$+#  -)&  2&-$-$+#&'  ="* &#-$-:&%-+-)&,$#"#8$":0&#&,$-*+,"##.":$#8'&6&#-*  &-$-$+#&'

)"*#+-D.":$,$&%-)&%&2"'-6&#-":&B"6$#"-$+#  &-)"-"*$- 6"9 $#8'&6&#-*+7&'"8&'-"$#2&'$+%+,-$6&=&'&'&:&"*&%$#)$* ,"7+.'

  )&  "**&'-$+#  +#  -)&  2"'-  +,  -)&  2&-$-$+#&'  -)"-  -)& '&:&"*&  +,  $#8'&6&#-*  ="*  #+-  +#  "88+.#-  +,  "#9  6$*3 '&2'&*&#-"-$+#  +'  8+#8&":6&#-  +,  ,"8-*  +#  )$*  2"'-  )"*  (+#& .#'&0.--&% )&  *)+'-  D.&*-$+#  -)"-  "'$*&*  $*  -)"-  .#%&'  *.8) "%6$--&%,"8-.":2'&6$*&=+.:%'&8+7&'90&2&'6$**$0:&F  #-)&8+#*$%&'&%7$&=+,-)$*
+.'- *.8):$6$-&%$**.& +,'&8+7&'9*-"#%**&--:&%$#,"7+.'+,-)&2&-$-$+#&'$#-)&:$()-+, -)&+0*&'7"-$+#*6"%&09-)&+#40:& .2'&6&
+.'-$# -"-&+,

-"-&+,

-"-&+,

-"-&+, .#/"0"#%+-)&'** ",$D!"*$)?)$-&"*)&'@&-8 ?@ .#/"0"#%+-)&'** ",$D!"*$)?)$-&"*)&'@&-8 ?@ .#/"0"#%+-)&'** ",$D!"*$)?)$-&"*)&'@&-8 ?@ .#/"0"#%+-)&'** ",$D!"*$)?)$-&"*)&'@&-8 ?@ 

   

   

   

     )&$**.&%&":-=$-) 09 -)& 2&B 
+.'-="*"* '&("'%*'&8+7&'9,'+6&62:+9&&*=)&'&2"96&#-)"%6$*-">&#:9 0&&#6"%&09-)&&62:+9&'$#&B8&**+,-)&$'&#-$-:&6&#-"#% )"%8.::&%+.-8&'-"$#*$-."-$+#*=)&'&'&8+7&'9"--)&)"#%*+, -)&&62:+9&'="*)&:%-+0&$62&'6$**$0:&$#:"=  "'"+,-)& /.%(6&#-$#",$D!"*$)4* ",$D!"*$)4* ",$D!"*$)4* ",$D!"*$)4*8"*&?*.2'"@=+.:%0&'&:&7"#-"#%$* '&2'+%.8&%)&'&.#%&'

G  -  $*  #+-  2+**$0:&  -+  2+*-.:"-&  "::  *$-."-$+#*  +, )"'%*)$2 =)$8)=+.:%(+7&'#&62:+9&&*+#-)&$**.& +,'&8+7&'9  =)&'& 2"96&#-* )"7&6$*-">&#:9 0&&# 6"%&09-)&&62:+9&' $#&B8&**+,-)&$'&#-$-:&6&#- &-)"-"*$-6"9 0"*&%+#-)&%&8$*$+#*'&,&''&%-+ )&'&$#  "0+7&  =&  6"9  "*  "  '&"%9  '&,&'&#8& *.66"'$H&  -)&  ,+::+=$#(  ,&=  *$-."-$+#*  =)&'&$# '&8+7&'$&*09-)&&62:+9&'* =+.:%0&$62&'6$**$0:& $#:"= ?$@&8+7&'9,'+6&62:+9&&*0&:+#($#(-+
:"**3 "#% 
:"**3 *&'7$8&?+''+.2 4
4"#% '+.244 *&'7$8&@ ?$$@  &8+7&'9  ,'+6  '&-$'&%  &62:+9&&*  +' &62:+9&&*=)+"'&%.&-+'&-$'&=$-)$#+#&9&"'+,-)& +'%&'+,'&8+7&'9 ?$$$@&8+7&'9,'+6&62:+9&&*=)&#-)&&B8&** 2"96&#-)"*0&&#6"%&,+'"2&'$+%$#&B8&**+,,$7& 9&"'* 0&,+'&-)&+'%&'+,'&8+7&'9$*$**.&% ?

$7@&8+7&'9$#8"*&*=)&'&"#&62:+9&&)"* ='+#(,.::9  0&&#  '&D.$'&%  -+  %$*8)"'(&  %.-$&*  +,  " )$()&'  2+*-  "#%  )"*  0&&#  2"$%  "88+'%$#(:9  &7&# -)+.())&*)+.:%)"7&'$()-,.::90&&#'&D.$'&%-+=+'> "("$#*-"#$#,&'$+'2+*- ?7@#"#9+-)&'8"*& =)&'&-)&
+.'-"''$7&*"- -)&  8+#8:.*$+#  -)"-  '&8+7&'9  $,  6"%&  ,'+6  -)& &62:+9&&=+.:%0&$#$D.$-+.*+')"'*)+'"'0$-'"'9-+ *.8)"#&B-&#-"*=+.:%,"'+.-=&$()-)&&D.

 0":"#8&+,-)&&62:+9&'4*'$()--+'&8+7&'9 I  )&2&-$-$+#&' 8+#8&%&%:9 $*)+:%$#("('+.24
42+*- )&:$6$-&%2'"9&''"$*&%+#0&)":,+,-)&2&-$-$+#&'-)"-'&8+7&'9 $#-)&:$()-+,-)&$62.(#&%+'%&' %"-&%  8"##+-0& &,,&8-&% $*8+7&'&%09-)&&7&#-.":$-$&*J*$-."-$+#*:"$%%+=#$# ",$D!"*$)4* ",$D!"*$)4* ",$D!"*$)4* ",$D!"*$)4*8"*&?*.2'"@  +'-)&'&"*+#*'&8+'%&%"0+7& -)&2'&*&#-2&-$-$+#$* 2"'-:9"::+=&%  )&$62.(#&%+'%&'%"-&%  ##&B.'&  $*.2)&:%-+-)&&B-&#-+,=$-)%'"=":+,$#8'&6&#-*"#%'&3 ,$B"-$+#+,-)&2"9+,-)&2&-$-$+#&'"-":+=&':&7&: +=&7&' $-$* )&:%  -)"-  '&8+7&'9  2.'*."#-  -+  -)&  $62.(#&%  +'%&'  %"-&%

 8"##+-0&&,,&8-&%  '%&'&%"88+'%$#(:9 A &-$-$+#%$*2+*&%+, ?       @ ?       @ ?       @ ?       @             







!

!

!

!

+-&

+-&

+-&

+-&

)&-)&'*2&">$#(J'&"*+#&%F

&*J + )&-)&'&2+'-"0:&F

&*J +