High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/7288/2015disposed of

Gurdip Kaur v. Union Of India And ORS

2015-04-22Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh4 pages

!"!#$% &'(!)* &'

!#' +'"&"

#!##(!

#( ,'"

")#(# "

-$ .'"/* 0!

1(2

' !#'

! ! / !# # , "3!#4 , &'

1 .' -&#!0 *&/ ' -, '/ # '

02'#/# -

#(!#4&#"0 ) "# ! #5, 0 #!# #(!

6'")#(# 1 .' !",! * &", 01 (2

6'")#(# #( ." .&#!", #(,!1 ((0 (2

01 &#7 5''")#(# 8 8 '#( &#"0' !#', ", #((2' : )!" !# , , 0 '#( &#"0" ' '")#(# " % #2!: ,#

&''(':,! ,:)')" ) ""1# ')0;< !( 2!

!"'=&!'( 5!0(5; ,'")#(# "

, ) !#' !" '"!(# 2!00 4 +'3 1 ,"!0 !"

/'!

''0 #(1 "&00;(" '!5(!#) '

,:'!

) !#1 , ( 5# =&!'( 5; '")#(# " #( &#('

;" 1> ? ? , :

'( :

" ) ""( !# , ;

' 5; , 9 =&!"!

!#00 '6/) # & ; ,) !#'@"/ !#4'!2 # !"

:,!0 """"!#4 /)#"

!#1 ,5#!

" - !#" 81 #( 8% , 9 =&!"!

!# 1>%1# /0;1"0

!&/ #(!# :'# 4'

# (

,/(")!

,!"&'

!# "#$%&'( )(*(& +''% ,)-.(-#/')#0#(.( (&.**(&+1')#!

2342./.%45!

4'!

00;,0(

2#!# , " =&!"!

!#&#('

0 !4,:

;" 1 > ?1 , 52 /# !#( : "

& ';

5#!

" ' =& 00; (/!""!50 , ( 0 #(<:#'" , ) !#'" 0" '0; &)# : ( !"!#" ,!" &'

1 5 , (

( >) ""(!#3

21*- .(-1*(&*(+1') /')#0# 66.##.(')! *%*(&1*) 7./.#.( *(& +1')#4 #( 383

2)'6 *0)/')#0#(.( (&.**(&+1')#4 :,'5; ,5#!

""0

!&/ #(!# !# '/" , 52< !

( ( !"!# ,!"&'

1, 25#A #(( ,"!/!0 '0;"!

(0 #(< :#'" 0!

# :

")0 (&)# ,'('"1##A&'" < #( <81 ) ""(5; ,!"&'

!#"!/!0 ' !' &/"

# " # ,' 4'!2 # !#' !"

5"!("

"&5/!""!#

!#" 1",!"'&##!#4'/)!00 ' )"

,! '"'")#(# <

;"& ;' '0 " 52/# !#(5#!

"5& ,"

/ ':!

,,0(#0;#

,)0

#(!'

!#", 25#4!2#5; ,!"&'

!#,' " , 44'!2() !#', "#: ))' ,( ,!"&'

> , 2, '(0 '#( &#"0' '

5 0#4 , #(4# ,'&4, ,' '( ,)'!# !)0"0 !((:#5; ,!"&'

!#0(#'# - 0 '4!#4"@" "B"&)'

C1 '# !#(!")& &'

,'1 ,

,5#!

""0

!&/ #(!# , 25#A #((5; ,!"&'

,"!/!0 '0;"!

(0 #(<:#'"2!('('(

(>!#, -!#4,@" " B"&)'

C1 # 0" 5 , '(0; (!")& ( # ,"

!' &/"

# "1: ' ,2!:

!"!/)'

!2&)#'")#(#

" #( #"!(' !#'@" 0 !/' ,4'

# "0

!&/

#(!# !# '( # :!

, ,( !"!# ,!"&'

!#0(#'#

#(- 0 '4!#4"@" "B"&)'

C ,:'!

) !#!" '(!#40;(!")"(!# ,00:!#4

'/"$< B!C , ) !#' ", 00 /2

!# 5' # !!( /) # & ;< &/<9 #( =&!"!

00 ':!

,!# )'!(#/# ,' ,4'

!(5#!

"D B!!C ,"

!(/) # & ;:!00!""&# !

00' ,' '("6')0;'/ ,

;

& ;#(!

D B!!!C ,/) # & ;", 00 ,'

'( '/!# :, ,' ' # !#' !" # 0(

!(5#!

"1") !

00;!#2!: ,( !"!#"

,!"&'

#( ,#E50-&)'/&'

'0!( &)#5; , 0 !/ # "D B!2C !#'!"&#(# 0( 1 "0") 3!#4 "&))0/#

';:

'( ,!" ", 005) ""( :!

,!# )'!(&'/# ,"'/ ,(

!0!#4

!#D B2C ,

;"& ;#(!

", 00()"!

, /&# 1! #;1) ;

50!# '/""&))0/#

'(1!#!# <5 '!#4!A(()"!

&# B"C!#

#;#

0!F(5 #3 #((!"5&'"/# ,'", 5 "&57 , !# 0 ( !"!# , #E50 -&)'/&'

!#-) !

0 9 2 )) 0B!2!0C % % 0($ '7 !'

!4,:

;1+2"

7",:

'-!#4, #( '" '!

) !#"

#("(!")"( '(!#40; 2

4 7$ 9).% !

4 45"