← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5843/2012dismissed

United India Insurance Co v. Sonia & ORS

2025-09-22Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma10 pages

     



!"#

$ %$ !"!&"'

!"# $ %$





(  $$$$$$)) **+",

$ (

($ $$$$$$

)!"

",

-#  ./-($( ( (-  

   

       

( (- $  !

"#$ % &'

() &(!&#   

" #*  

 

 *

!++     !,-- .  /" #01%  

%  # 



 

2  !   3 45,4+526  $%  7) 58  $   9 



 #  $ 

&

   



      9 



%#" # 

  

    9  #   : #  (- ((  ( /  (/   (

"            6;  

  

#" #   $  # " #  %

 



#%

'

   

2  %  $



%    %   

2  !<=6)'56&(!4:

$ 





% 

2  "  

 

;    %    %  # 

(//0 - (  +

> 0#*     Sarla Verma Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and Another 12

%34(&)

!& ,+

6   %%   



   6 ?30  

      

     

   

         

  

  

     



 



  

 

  

       



    !"#$      

 %#  !"&$       

 &'    !"($      

 

 31)

      

        *              (+,      

   







                 

  -

 

           

        

   

         $          .  /

 

     

     

            

  *  

 

              



         

      32 

     

           (+,          

           (+,    

                  



  

                                         

 

             * * * * * * 42.)     

   

       &$        

     0

 1    $        !2    !(%+ %!%(

$ 

    

 3!4 %'#+

3!'#!#(

3!(#'&+

3!&&!&(

 3!#&'(+

  

    

 3!!(!((

35(''+

34 '!'(

 3(''4+

)

> 0#  *             National Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. 12

73 4(4 6   %*

!++!+46!+-     !,--   % $6 .1 

          $  @   

   A .B1 *

         $    $   A .1 $  #   $   A

 .1 3 # $  

          @ % 

A .C1 <  $      $%  

#A6    @  " 

  $   6 ?52. 6  conventional heads



  

   

 7/

8 *   7 %(+++  

7

!+++++    

       7  !+++++  

  

    

  

      

 

 7/

  0   9 

 



         



             

  



   



  :    

  

    6                 

 

     



  

      

   

  

  

 

 

; 

  

    

  

 

  

     

4  

    

        



                     

      

   

  * 

           

 

         

   

  

   

 

    

   7 !(+++ &++++ 7 !(+++

             

   <       

   

 )       

    

 

 



  

  

 !+,   

)   

  



  

 

 

  = = = = = 59.3)   

  (+,    



 



 /      &+

   

   #+, 



 

&+(+

* 

  

  (+'+

    !(,        

 59.4* 







 $      &+,

 

7

  

  

 &+

6  %(,

  

 &+(+

 !+,

  

 (+'+



 

  

   

   

     

  59.5.             

    

     #+#%0> ?

    

    59.6.



               0  > @         &%     /

 59.7 

        59.87   

        

  



 

   

    7  !(+++  7  &++++     7  !(+++

   

    

   !+,  

A - > 0#  *             -+85+   "

+*

"

& +"'

!5)+"9/:5:, ;

$ +"&+5+*:+ <&< &+5,<

2 3( 6    $ (+ *+;

5+ 2 &) +3   +"+9 ( ,<:2(&) +3%$ $   

3    6

 B216  <

  C  0 8        

 

    

;

  

    *     

  D D    

      



 D  

D  D   D     D

D   

          

  

   

 

  

   )

 

 

 





%!!Spousal consortium 

   

         

    



      

  

    /  D %!%Parental consortium     



  

D  

   

     

   

     D %!# Filial consortium     

  

 

  

6 

      

         

  

   



   

    

%  

          

  22 



 

     

       3  /     

 



  E  

  

   

        3   /                 

      

 

        

 

  

      

 23 3>  

6  

    

     

  

  

  

* 

  

         

     



     C 

   

     

    6 6   



       

      

       

   

           

   

24         

         

    

 

   D

 D   C  0 *  







    

  7 &++++ 

 ,

       FAO-745-2013, titled as "Sonia Vs. Amandeep Mittal and others"    # 

2  !# %#    

 ; %   

   $         

          $     #         $ 

!(

; % #  

 $#   

!!

" 

 3 &5(((26 #6 ;



 



    #  

!&

 $ 

.1     

$ %$  2( (-3      D:

$2 6:

$ E2 D #  E