High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5873/2012allowed

Shinder Pal Kaur And ORS v. Vipin Kumar And ORS

2015-07-14Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan3 pages

"#$ %$&'(')* +,')%$-".")%#,$-( //$..")#( 0$-(1( +,0'/')213"-")%#,$-( $(/)%$)#(

* 45 + 2 5+ -$($)#*6 -(,7")'--"8%9&"#$8 -#,$"//$..")#( -+,".'7".8%9&"#$8 -8 -+")%'7".8%9&"#$8

--$(/)%$)#( ")% --3')%$-+'):,+'%,18%9&"#$8

--$(/)%$)#

;,$#,$-#,$$/-#$-( .&".)$7(/"/$-3"<=$"..7$%#($$ #,$>1%:3$)#?

=$-$ $--$%##,$$/-#$--)# ;,$#,$-#,$>1%:3$)#(,1.%=$-$/-#$%')#,$%':$(#? 66 66 5+ 8

,'( '( &."'3")#(4 "//$". - $),")&$3$)#

&3/$)("#') "7"-%$% =< #,$ #- &&'%$)# ."'3( -'=1)".8 :" ')(,-#4#,$-'=1)".4!89'%$-%$-%"#$% )#,'(&"($8")>%,+'):,8":$%"=1#<$"-(8%'$%') " 3#- 9$,'&1."- "&&'%$)# ) ,$ %$&$"($% 7"( 1)3"--'$% ,$ -'=1)". "(($(($% #,$ )#')". ')&3$ #,$ %$&$"($%"((86/$-3)#,")%"//.'$%#,$31.#'/.'$- 4@48 "(/$-#,$":$ #,$/"-$)#(")%&".&1."#$%#,$%$/$)%$)&<"#(

66 8 A86(867$-$"7"-%$% - 1)$-".$B/$)($(")%##".

&3/$)("#') (8 867"("7"-%$% ,"9$ ,$"-% .$"-)$% &1)($. - #,$ &."'3")#("//$..")#(8.$"-)$%&1)($. --$(/)%$)#( ")%

%-'9$-")%7)$--$(/$&#'9$.<!8.$"-)$%&1)($. --$(/)%$)# 6')(1-")&$&3/")<")%,"9$".(&"-$ 1..<:)$#,-1:,#,$ '.$ ,$ ).< &)#$)#') #,$ .$"-)$% &1)($. - #,$ "//$..")#('(#,"#"%%'#') ')&3$)"&&1)# 1#1-$/-(/$&#( 7"()#"%%$% ,$31.#'/.'$-8"(/$-#,$":$ #,$/"-$)#(,"( =$$)"//.'$%87,$-$"('#(,1.%,"9$=$$)"//.'$%"(/$-#,$":$

#,$%$&$"($% #,'):,"(=$$)"7"-%$% -.(( .9$")% "

$&#')##,$/"-$)#(")%).<(86,"9$=$$)"..7$% -

1)$-".$B/$)($(87,'&,'(&)#-"-<##,$."7."'%%7)=<#,$/$B

1-# $&$)#.<8#,$"1#,-'#< ,-$$1%:$($)&, #,$ )4=.$+1/-$3$ 1-#')

8 ') '9'. //$". @ 8 %$&'%$%) 87"($B"3')$%=<#,'( 1-#87,$-$')'#'( ,$.%#,"##,$ 1#1-$')&3$ #,$%$&$"($%'(#=$"%%$%'),'( /$-()".')&3$ ,$-$ -$8'#,"(# ..7#,"#$9$)')&"($

($.

6$3/.<$% /$-()8 #,$ 1#1-$ ')&3$ ) "&&1)# 1#1-$ /-(/$&#(,"(#=$"%%$%")%#,$31.#'/.'$-"(/$-#,$":$ #,$ %$&$"($%'(#=$"//.'$%((1&,8(86')&3$)"&&1)# 1#1-$/-(/$&#('("..7$%8 -37,'&,C'(%$%1&#$%"(/$-()".

66 $B/$)($(,$"%%'#')".')&3$&3$(#( 86)#,'(7"<8 #,$%$/$)%$)&< #,$&."'3")#("//$..")#(&3$(#(86 /$-3)#,,$"31)# &3/$)("#')8=<"//.<'):#,$31.#'/.'$- "(/$-#,$":$ #,$%$&$"($%'$4 48&3$(#(A8 86

(8B B !( 886)"&&1)# .(( .9$")% "

$&#')##,$/"-$)#()"%%'#')".(13 (86'(".( "..7$% #7"-% 1)$-". $B/$)($( ,$ ##". "31)#

&3/$)("#')&3$(#(88687,'&,')&.1%$((86 "7"-%$% =< #,$ -'=1)". - 1)$-". $B/$)($( ,$ $),")&$% &3/$)("#')(,"..=$/"'%')#$-3( #,$"7"-% #,$-'=1)".7'#, ')#$-$(#"##,$-"#$ D/$-"))13 -3#,$%"#$ '.'): #,$ &."'3/$#'#')#'..'#(-$".'E"#') ,$"//$".'("&&-%'):.<"..7$%

5+ !

(>F(