High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/6519/2016dismissed

Khazan Singh And Others v. State Of Haryana And Others

2022-02-03The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Arun Palli13 pages

CWP No. 6519-2016 1

!"!#$ % &'

( #)!#*' #+ '," -

.,"/" )

,0 #+ '," - "1#+#

,"# $2 3,

4!5)'

,6 7+5

7, !#," 3, #8/, 3!

97 ++9 +5

#, 97 ,0 :!

' 3,) /, ;'3 *7""!"

#, 9 ,0 3"&/"'

9+1& /,3 # '

#+ 7+5

, ',"1#+# " <' ,"

!+ 1,"# !" ;!#* , ,++ ',/*' 5!+ #,# !#* "!# 1, +!#*" ,;!#* #+/ +!#5!, 9/, =

' # ,5,"0!#595+!# '6

#+,595" ,/#+

119!

;!9!

0 ) !# ><= !*'

!, 61#"

, #"1 ,# 0 !# ?

#+ @/!"!

!#7 ;!9!

96# 7 %# '

" ":',!# :

,+/#+,"

!#' ?

#+ @/!"!

!# A>:

##/# +# %A!6, #!5 ,"1,!, ' 66# 6# %# > # #++;0 !#,"7 '1""""!# #+!#@/"

!#!"#

8#;0

' 61#"

!#'

9"# ;#1 !+

'67 ',,7 1"!#* !#1, +!#*"'

5;#"/*'

;0 # #+!#*

; ' # !#*# !" "1,5!++/#+,) !#><=

% ,/9!99+

CWP No. 6519-2016 2 ' # ,5,"0 ,11+/1 ,/#+!# ,1,

!#) !#><= % :

"1/

;0 ' #"

!# # ' ' #B;9 )/1,6 /, #+!

!# "

',;09 0!#*+:#1,!# !19" ,+ 9 ,!#* !#+6+ '

5;#9 1"+/#+,"

!#><= % ' 1C /, '

" +!" /""+ !# +

!9 99 "1 # ""

,0 #+ ,95 , !# ,1, !#* "

!# ><= %7 ':5,, '1/,1"+ !+!#* '6

#+7 ',,# # 9/+!#* 1 *, 1' ' 4/+*6# :/9+ ; "/! #+ "

6 !" ,1,+/ +',!#;9:$2 D- ! "

$#$ " %

" !"

! &' ! "(

) !"

! & " % ) % %% !! *"

( " ) ! " ' "(

$#)$! "

! & "

! +

! ) & , % -. "

#$ ) %

) -. -., ! "/ "( "

#$ ! "

! & 0

" % "

! ! ! "

" ! "

' ! ) 0"

) %' " ) 0' "

)

'!"

)

' ) 0

,* 1 1 !"

#$ ! "

! & "

! "

" , "/" ! 2

#$ " ) % "

3 ! (

)!" # %$ ! !" !

"/ "

! "

! +

) "

"""% !

! &" ) ( "

& ! 4 "/ "

! +

) ! !

' "

& ! "

")( 52 !"

#" $

CWP No. 6519-2016 3 "/ "("!2 % "

3 ! (!! '"

! & ) 6 %6

! !" ! "/ "

! +

7 " ) "

& $ ! "

' "

"/ "

#$ 2 2 ! "

" , ) ( "

)

( "

& $4%% ! ""

%( !" ! ( "

' " "

"( "

#$! "

! & , "

#$! "

! &

) ! "

#$ ! "

$#)$ 8 , ! 0( "

#$)%(! / 9 :"%)

0( "

! "

! +

' ( "

#$ ! "

! &'" ) 0 "

#$ + , ! "

#$ ( ! ! "(

") " ! "

0 "

! ! )! "

! & " !"' "(! "/ ( % ""

, ! ) " ! ) " ) *"

#$! "

! & (

% " ! "

/ ( ! ""

"( ! "/ "

"( ( !!" ! "

! &' '

2) ""

% / ( ! ! 0(

"( ! ! "

! " "/ . % ' C1"!

!# 6 + !# ,"

!+ 4/+*6# # ; "/66 ,!(+!# '99:!#*6 ##,,6, 9 ,!

0# '1,!# !19"9 !+ +:#;0 '#"

!## '$2

CWP No. 6519-2016 4 < = # 99 '" "" :',!# !# 1, "" '

+ ;# !#!

+;/ :

,+'

"# ;# ##/# +/#+,"

!# A>7# '+

66# 6# % ! >7 ', !" # 9 1" 1, +!#*" 6 :!99 # !#/7 ':5,7 :!

' ,!+,

61#"

!#'

;+ ,6!#+/#+, '1,5!"!#" %99 '" "":',!# :

,+/#+,"

A>'

";# ##/# +1,!, 66# 6#

%7 '1,5!"!#" %:/9+'

5# ;

,!#* , 119!

' 1, +!#*" :!99 # !#/ !# ,"1 '" ""7 " !7 ' A> '

" # ;# ,1 9+ <;= ' :,+ D,B /"+ !# ;

:# ' ; ' # !#*# !" !#><= %!" ;, "-., "-. :'! '6 #"

"89 1"!#* !#1, +!#*" ; ' # !#*# !"6/"

;/9!99+3 #!#* ',;07

' 1""""!# '

+ ;#

8# ;/ ' 61#"

!# :

" # , !5+7 ',:/9+;#9 1")!6!9 ,907! 61#"

!#'

;# +;/ '1""""!#'

"# ;#

8#7 ',:/9+ ; # 9 1"!#* #!"

&&#$ ! 3( $ < = " "1 61#"

!# , ' 9 @/!,+ !" # ,#+7 '#B;9)/1,6/, #+!

*,!

990 ;",5+

' C1,""!# 1 !+ !# ' 6 !# 1 "

><= ' % +" # !# 9/+ +1"!

61#"

!#!# /, '

!",@/!,+ ;1,5+!"

61#"

#+,+:'! ''

";#C19 !#+!#

CWP No. 6519-2016 5

#+,!#* :/9+6 #

!"6 + !9 ;9 #+:#,

:/9+; +!" '

,* ';9!*

6 8 06# #+!#

5# "/ ' 1,"# ## ;1# 9!(+, '+ /9 !#6 8!#* 06# '!9,,,!#* "

!#%<=7%<=7%> A> #+ 61 ,!#* '6:!

1,5!"!#"! !#E #+A %7 '#B;91C/, " 9 ,!!+

' #90 #"@/# ##21 06# 61#"

!#!" 6 8 06# !# ,"

"1,"

%> A>5# '#B;9)'

"/, ', 9 ,!!+

06# 61#"

;# ,+F #+,+ /#+, "

!# %<=7 @/!,!#* ',!

## ;1# 9!(+,##21 06# ",6 !# /#1 !++/ ,/"

;0 #+:#, 9 ,!0!

/, ',7 '#B;9)'

"/, ',;",5+

! 9 #+:#, "!9+ ',,# ,'!*', 61#"

!#' ## 9 !6

"# 1 !+ <+= '!9, +!#* '1,5!" "

!#;1 "

!#><=

%7 '#B;9)/1,6/, " 9 ,!!+

"7 ' , , 1 06# '

" ;# 6 + ;/ # +1"!

+7 9!

;!9!

0 1 0 9#* :!

' !# ,"

"/;"!"

#+ ! # +1"!

+ , 6 4,!

0 '9+!#*" , !5 0 ," , 6,7 61#"

!# /#+, ' % '

; 1 !+ #+:#," " # ' +

# !!

!# , 9 /#+,"

!#> A> * ,+!#* '+1"!

;# 9 ,!!+ !# ' 4/+*6#

, ' '!*', 61#"

99:7 ' 6#0 "'/9+ # '

5 ;#

CWP No. 6519-2016 6 +1"!

+:!

#+ @/!"!

!#99 ,,!# "/,0 , !# ' /, :!

' ,"1 6 4,!

0 9 #+ '9+!#*"7 #!#* ',;0!!

"+1"!

+!# #0 ',6+" :!

' ,"1 6 4,!

0 '9+!#*"7 ' '!*', 61#"

:!99# 99:7;/ !# ,"

/#+,"

!#%> A> :/9+; ' #"@/# <= ",* ,+" '6+

8!#*1""""!#7 '#B;9)/1,6 /, + 9 ,!!+

+, :!#*!#@/"

,1, F66, #+/6 :/9+ 6 #

1'0"!

9 1""""!# '

" ;#

8# ' 9 : :!

',* ,+ 5"

!#*9 #+'

"# * !#;,!

'9+

# '1""""!#'

";#

8#/#+,"

!# A>7 #+5"

', ## ; #0 +!5"

!#*,9 1"!#* <= '!9 61/ !#* '* 11,!+!50 ,";

:# '+

,+ #+ 66# 6# %7 #0!# ,!6,+, "/;"!"

!#*!" ;C 9/++:'! '6 #"

,C 9/+!#* !# ,!6,+,7 '1,2,@/!"!

* 11,!+0 ,"!"# ',7

'1,5!"!#""

!#><= ## ;!#58+ <*= '#B;9/, "/, ', 9 ,!!+

! !# #+'

,9!,;# '

99#*+ !#:

"/1'9+7 :'! ' 6 #" ' 1, +!#* "

+ # 9/++7 ' /6;,99 1,

!#"

!#><= % ## ;!#58

+"# ,5!5"

9 !6;

,,+ 9 !6" <'= # 1 %%E7 ' #B;9 /, '

" 6 + !

1,5!"!# "

!# ><= ' % !" 6 ; !#58+;0 ';#! !

,!"!9 #+:#,":':,, ,++ "

!6!""/ # # !!

!#/#+,"

!#>

CWP No. 6519-2016 7 A> #0 "/;"@/# 1/, '

",7 '9+, , ',:!"7 ## !#58 '1,5!"!#""

!#><= % > " 1, " 1/ , ' ;0 ' 1 !#,"7 '0 , :#, !# 1""""!#&'

", EF>F><2>=7EFF<E2>=7EF<A2 =7EF <A2 = #+ EF F <>2 = # &'

", EF>F> #+ EFF7 '0 '

5 #"

,/ +"'1"F6 ,8 #&'

", EF<A2 =7 '0'

5;/!9 '!, '/"" #+ !# &'

", EF <A2 = #+ EF F <>2 =7 '0 '

5 #"

,/ +"

+!'"

!+9 #+:

@/!,+;0

,0 5!+ # !!

!#" +

+ E AAE #+ AAA !""/+ /#+, "

!# > !# ' ?

#+ @/!"!

!# 7 A>7 99:+ ;0 :

,+ +

%A, '1/;9! 1/,1"# 6907,+5916# #+/ !9!(

9 "#"

!# ) ,%7/,* # ,9!, '0 11, '+ '!" /, ;0!9!#* %A A9 0!#* '

99#* 1, +!#*":'! ':

"+!"1"+# # *,6# ,,!5+

;

:# !"

'# !# # !

9 66!""!#, < 5#/= #+ ) ,

,0 5,#6# ,0 :!995!"!

'"1 " " ,

!# :'

', #"

,/ !# #;C61 +,6 !#7!!

"!#

'" '6 '!#*":'"+ !"!#"'

99;

"!# 9 !" "

+"1!

5!#* @/!,+ #+!#@/"

!#7

!9+

81""""!# !99+

'0 ,!#

91'0"!

1""""!# #+!#@/"

!# /, ',!

";# # #++

'0 5# ;#1 !+ 61#"

'#'

# 6# 75#

'/*' '0!9+ ',,# 1 !#/#+,) !#A A>

'/"7 ; ' # !#*# !" '

5!#* ;# /9!99+7 1, +!#*"@/ '!,9 #+!#@/"

!#'

59 1"+

CWP No. 6519-2016 8

, # 3, #8/, 3!

97 ?+ ++!

!# 9 +5

#, ,0 ,!#*,

,0 "/;6!

' # !#

!#,";!#*!# '1""""!# #+!#@/"

!#!"+5!+ 6,!

'1""""!# #+:

8#;0, ,+!#*

(# 6 '

# +

+ %A #+ "

6 :

" '

#++ 5, ' ;#! !

,0 +1 6# '

" /, ', # #++

' 1 !#," '

5 #

11, '+ '!" /, :!

' 9 # '

#+" '0 '

5 +9!;,

90 # +!" 9"+

!6!#!

!# !#1, +!#*"7 '0'

"6 #"

,/ !#!#&'

", EFF #+:'! ':

",9 "+ #+!

9 #+#907:'! ':

@/!,+"!+"7 !#,"'

5 +9!;,

90# +!" 9"+

' 61#"

, #+ 99!#* !#&'

", EFFF><2>= #+EFFF<E2>='

5 9, +0;#, !5+ ;0 '6 #

' 61#"

, ' # !, 9 @/!,+ !# 9/+!#* ' 9 #+ !# @/"

!# :

" +/90 #+,+ #+ 6 + !9 ;9 , +!";/,"6# '!" "

#+" "/;"

+ ,6 '

,+ ">7%7A7 EEF27 "%77>7A F2

#+" +!";/,"+ ' 1 9" , !5+ ' 61#"

!# , '!, 9 #++9!;,

90'

8# ' 61#"

!#, ',6 !#!#* #+!

;!#*"7!

+"# 9!!# '6/ ' #

61#"

!#'

"# ;#1 !+ '6'

"/, ', ,*/+

+6!

+90'

5!9+ ',,# 1 !#/#+,) !#A

' A> '/"7 "/*'

,+ ,6!#

!# ' 61#"

90!#*#

>#+,5916# / ',!

0<)/1, =' # #+"

"!# !#,"'

"!9+,,# /#+,"

!#A A>,"8!#*#'

# 6# !# 61#"

, "

11+ ,6 19 +!#*

61#"

!# :

" # #+,+ '!6

CWP No. 6519-2016 9 1 ,6 '!"7 '1,"# 1 !#+",5" +!"6!""

9# /#

!# # ,9!, ,/#+ 9!

!# '

11#+ 9#* ;

8 !# ' 0 A7 ',:,!

1 !#:

"+!"1"+# # *,6# ,,!5+

;

' 1 !" "",

' 1 !#," '

5!#* # '

99#*+

#0/, ', '+ !"!# '!"/, +

+ A !99

'!9!#* '!#"

1 !#!# '0 , 7 9 ,1,"/61 ,!""

;/ ' "

!# ' 1 ;/ 1, +!#*"'

5!#*;# +;0 '6 '/"7 + 0

## ; 99:+ /,#;

8 "89 1"!#* '"

6:/9+ 9 ,90; 5,+ :!

' 1,!# !19" 9 !+ +:# ;0 ' #B;9 )/1,6 /, #+!

!##+,5916# / ',!

0<"/1, =

'1,5!"!#") ><= %+"# *!5,!" ,"' /"

',5!5 9"

9 9 !6"',,7!

!""/;6!

"!# ## # !#*# !"6# !#+!#) !#><= % ,/9!99+ 1""""!# #+"

#+"+/90

8# ';9!*

0 ' 61#"

!# "

#+" +!" '

,*+ :!

#+,F1 06# 61#"

!#G '1,"# 1 !#6,!

"+!"6!""

9 ,'

5!#*1,/"+ '19 +!#*"; ' # !#*1 !" , ,+!#* '!, # !#"7 : '

5 # '"!

# 9/+

#+ !" "@/ ,90 5,+ ;0 ' 1,!# !19" 9 !+ +:# ;0 #B;9 )/1,6 /, #+!

!# " #+, 5916# / ',!

0 <"/1, = ' 1, 0, ' 1 !#," 9 !6!#* 9 1"!#*

!# 1, +!#*" +",5" +!"6!""

9 !# 5!: ' 99:!#* "#"$2

='/*' !#,"'

5 # #++

'0 ,!#

1'0"!

91""""!# #+!#@/"

!#7':5,7 '"

CWP No. 6519-2016 10

5,6# !" # ;9 !# 5!: ' !# ,1,

!# D

B 6 + ;0 ' #B;9 1C /, !# #+, 5916# / ',!

0 <)/1, = :',!# ' #B;9 /,

*,!

990'9+

':,+1""""!#/"+!#

' A> '

" "

6 6 #!#*

1'0"!

1""""!# /"+!# ) !# > <= % '# )

5,#6# @/!," #++, :"66, #+/6

8!#* 1""""!# :'! ' !# ' 1,"# " !" ;0 , ,+!#*

(# 6 '

+ %A7

8!#* ' 1'0"!

9 1""""!# ' 9 #+ # 1""""!#!"

8#7 ',!" ;"9/ 5"

!#* #+!# )

', ,5#! #+:#,,

!#" '1""""!# #+7'!" ,"1 "",7 #+"/ '1""""!# ,"1 "", #/," , '!" ;#!

#+ # ;'

9 ' :#, ! )

)!# 1""""!# '

" ;#

8# ;0 , ,+!#*

(# 6 '

+ %A7 ',,7 '1'0"!

1""""!# #+"

#+"+/90

8#;0

'19 ' 1

'0 , !# 1'0"!

9 1""""!# #+ !" '/"7 ',;0 ,4 +

99 1""""!# '

" ;#

!#+;0'!67!

!"#90 ,"1 ""," #+# ":#,""

#"@/# 7 ', # ' ""# 9" , 9 !6!#* 1"!#* !#1, +!#*"*" ;=" "1 61#"

!# !" # ,#+7 +6!

+90 61#"

!#'

";#, !5+;0 !#,", '!,1 #+ :'! ' !

"9 "':"

' 61#"

#+,+ ', '

" ;# # !#

!# # 1 ' )

',!

!"!#+!" '

,*!#*!

";9!*

",* ,+"1 06#

CWP No. 6519-2016 11 61#"

!## ++!

!+7 !#,"'

9" !9+ ,,# /#+, ) !# A ' A> "8!#*#'

# 6# !# 61#"

!# # !

!""7 '" #+ # !#*# 01," ,!;+!#"

!#><= % 9" *" '/"7 " ## ' # !#*# !" 1," ,!;+ !# "

!# ><= % !" /9!99+7 +6!#*!

!#9 1"!#*1,5!++/#+,"

!#><= % ## ;!#58+" '19

+1"!

;

8 ' 61#"

!" # ,#+7: , !# *,6# :!

' # !# ' ?+ /#"9 , )

',!"#1,5!"!#!# !# 7 +1"!

;

8 ' 61#"

#+'# 7 '"

!+19 !" 9",4 + ='1 !#,"'

519 ++

'0 ""

!9+ 1, +!#*";, '!"/, ;0!9!#* %A A :'! ' :

" +!"1"+ ;0 '!" /, 5!+ ,+, +

A A # # *,6# ,,!5+

;

:# ' 1 !"7 :',!# ' 1 !#," '

5 *,+

'# !# # !

66!""!#, 5#/ :!99 5!"!

' "1 C19, 1""!;!9!

0 ' ,9 " ' #"

,/ !# 1, !# !#, #+ '!" + !"!# :!99 ;

" !# 9 ' !#,"'

5 '"# #5#!# 90,6 !#+"!9# ;/

' 1, +!#*" '

11#+ 1/,"/ ' ,+, +

A A;/ 3,3!

9!",!*'

!# '!",* ,+ #

'"!9# 6 !#

!#+;0 !#,","/ '9#*1,!+ E0 ,", 11, '!#* '!"/, !#5!: 6!#*!# ' % !" "/! !# !#, ;/ '!,

# " ,* ,+"

CWP No. 6519-2016 12 1, +!#*" '/"7 + 0 ## ; 99:+

' + +F"

9 9 !6" :'! ' 9# !" "/! !# +!"# 9 ' 1 !#58 ' 1,5!"!#" ) ><= % E 3,#8/,3!

9# '"

,#* ' '

"19 ++!# ':,!

6# "5'6# 90 # #++

@/!,+ #+, 1/;9! 1/,1"1/;9! 1/,1",/ !9!(

!#9 #+,#"

!# !# ) ,%7/,* #'9 #+!#@/"

!#!"5,06/ '""# '!5

'1/;9! 1/,1" #+!

'19 ##!#* '+!"1#"

,0"!

7%#" *,/1 '/"!#* "!

7 1 "'11!#* # ,"7 6 , :!+ !# ,# 9 , +7 ",5! , #+A6 ,:!+!# ,# 9, +!#) ,% #+% 6 ,:!+ ) ,+!5!+!#*, +) ,% #+% "1, 0/ 19 #'

5 #"!+,+ '!" 1 ,*/6# , !"+ ;0 ' ,"1#+# #+ : , !# 619 *,6# :!

6 '!"!" #!61,

, ;81 !# 6!#+:'!9+ 9!#*:!

" ,!"!#*/ !#9

'!5 '1/;9! 1/,1" #+!

!" '"

',!

0:'!"!# ';"

1"!

+ !+ ;/ / !9!(

!# @/!,+7 ,!

5!#*;# 5"

+!#)

A " "@/9 ;5+!" /""!# #+!#5!:9 :"/66 ,!(+!# %%#+,5916# / ',!

0<"/1, =7"1 !!

990 ,'

5!#* , ,++

!# " !# '

#+7 ' 1'0"!

9 1""""!# ' 9 #+ !# @/"

!# '

5!#* ;#

8#7 ' ;9!*

!# , 1 06# 61#"

#+"+!" '

,*+ 9" #"!+,!#*

#+!#@/"

!#!"5,06/ ' ""# '!5 '1/;9! 1/,1"7:'

5#'"!

'9+

' !#"

"7 ' "

" /990 +!" '

,*+ !

" ;9!*

!# @/ ;

CWP No. 6519-2016 13 # !#*# !" /,,!#*!#"

!#><= % #+!

;!#*"7 1,"# 1 !#6,!

"+!"6!""

#+'# 7 '!#"

1 !#!"+!"6!""+ 5!#* +!"6!""+ ' 6 !# :,!

1 !#7 99 1#+!#*

119!

!#"7! #07 9"6 '"

':,!

1 !#!"+!"6!""+ )

/"@/! #0"

#+"5

+ < .)& = ) <

??=

% 5!#+, '

',"1 8!#*F, "#+ "F '

',,1,

;9 "F