Dr. Nisha Gahlawat v. State Of Haryana And Others
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH **** CWP-16913-2023 (O&M) Date of Decision: 17.09.2025 DR. NISHA GAHLAWAT ...PETITIONER STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS ...RESPONDENTS CWP-19338-2023 RAJENDER KUMAR AND ANOTHER ...PETITIONERS STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS ...RESPONDENTS CORAM:- HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ASHWANI KUMAR MISHRA HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ROHIT KAPOOR Present:- Mr. Karan Bhardwaj, Advocate for the petitioner in CWP-16913-2023.
Mr. L. K. Narang, Advocate for the petitioners in CWP-19338-2023.
Mr. Raman B. Garg, Standing Counsel with Mr. Mayank Garg and Mr. Karandeep, Advs.
for respondent No.2 (in both writs).
Mr. Aman Chawariya, Advocate and Mr. Harmanjot Singh Gill, Advocate for respondents No.3 and 4 in CWP-19338-2023. Mr. Saurabh Singla, Advocate for Mr. Sehaj Sandhawalia, Advocate for respondents No.3 and 4 in CWP-16913-2023. **** ASHWANI KUMAR MISHRA, J. (ORAL)
! "
# $% & %
'
(
)*"
# $% &
'+,
! (
# -./ 4.
" (
"
0 1 0 %- 0 '
"
-
"2 )
* ( 033/ ( 44,54 46
! (
, 5
)*'
#
(
"" '
, 3 #/ 7 2/ "$ 8 ) *
9
1%
' :) *
'
,5'
'
'
(
"
'
'
"( ,5'
'
7
;
)*
'
!<!<! " 1'
,5'
-
'
1'
: / 2
!=!! 6.
'
/
"
>?!?! >23@ !=!! 0 4
$ # "2 )
* 6 < -
" '
5 ,
('
"
!=!!
"
!=!! 5 2 (
! "#
$
%
! "
#$ % &'() * #$ +
,- . $/# "
% %
' 0 #0 *
0 # $ 1--1 0
! "#
&% '
() - ! #
)
'
,- *"
#$ 232 # $ 4 ! #
$ $ . $/ - 5 ,- * * $ '#. $/ - 5
' # !
$ 2 $ - 2
% 2"
$ 5 '
(
!=!!$('
A * +& ,-. /
' 7%"2%/2%"/8
#
0 $ ,' 0 ! ) *
0 # 1
41
* ' )
! 9# ' '# :
2/ 2/ -"23 -.23 -3
0 ,/ '
; ,/ 7)8 ,/7/ 8 ,/7/ "8,/73 .8,/73 38
/ #$,-
41 ) 7&9- $ 7&/%82 <
$ < 7<<82 ,' 7,8 =3" 8$ ,/
' $
),/-,3 3,/-,),/- =3"
. 9'$ ,-
7 8
0
$
0
'
'# >%#-#>'
! 0
0 0
- * 0
'
0 "
#$ <' * 0
'
*
0 0 "
#$ "
#$ % &' ) # 0 $7. 9' -.8* $'&&!-2&&!-%"/ 9$ 0 3&9$ ,
,- '
0
$# '2 $#
0
0
$ ' <'
0 * $ # # 0
5$ '&&!-2&&!-%"/ 9$
?????
, ! - 7,/8
'
0
'
# 4 / )'
@
# '
4*
9
2
0
' * #
#
0 9
+
!=!!"
.
, 5
0 '
?#'
/ 2
#
" 2
#
5 ,
( 0 '
! 1 " (
'
!=!!
/
#
5 2
B
'
.
'
'
$
!
! !
#
/ 2
+(
(
!=!! '
/
( " ( " '
C
/5
0 1
'
#
5 2 6
!=!! D =
!=!!
#
5 2 %
!=!! 8
+("
"8
!=!! #
# ?3 ?'
" 5 2 5 '
!=!!
(
( ( ( 1'
# ( 1'
# # 0 4
$ "
6 7 " 1'
; B
'
!=!!
#
6
> +(6
-
#
/%'
!=!! #
5 2 " (6
#
5 2 '
!=!!
#
( ,5( (
(
( 0 ?#
# 0 4
$
' )*
!=!!
.
- * #''
' 0 0 % 2"
/ 4
$ % 2"
,'
0 0 "
#$ % &' ) # 5
17.
'=
!=!! 8 6 #
2 '
/ $"!>) )'
@*
(" $ "
'
5 ,
( '
#
$ !> / "#
( 0 ?#
# 0 4
$ 19.
+ /
!=!! .
" (
#
2
2 ( "
"
"
(
!=!! ( - /
! !=(
'
" % (
!=!!
"
(
'
(
'
" ( %
( ?
'
, 5 #
! - "
'
(0 1 )*
,5'
"
46
B(2
(
!=!!
80 1
033/
,5# B
'
"
" (
'
" (
%
:
,5'
( "
A )* ,
,5 '
)*
,5 '
46
B( )* ,
80 1
2 ( "
0 1 6 ,
"
,5 )*"
,5'
= ,
)*" " )* ; ,
)'
A
1. Whether Speaking/reasoned Yes/No
2. Whether Reportable Yes/No