← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5950/2012allowed

(O&M) Sonia And ORS v. Amandeep Mittal And ORS

2025-09-22Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma12 pages

 

  

    

   



 ! ""  # $

 ! "" %

 %"

""""""&&''( )

"

*  *

+  %"

""""""&  ) *!

 ,+ *%"

%  %

%* 

         





   !"  

#### %

%*

"

$

%  

& '

  (   )* +, )+$) &    

% & -  

  - $..  

$/00 1 2  % & 34 

 '  

 5 ,+$.++6! '( 7, 89            5 :         

    $* $) )+$+

)

        ;   ( &  % &  



       ; &  :& %* %% % 

+   %+ 





%

%   

!

 

  &  % &  (   &

 %   

   & ( 

 &

   (

*

              (   '

   (  

'

    !"   

<=!80* !)+$)  >? "

"    -

 @

'

' ;   %       



"

       ( 

 (

 &   

%

+ +-

* %

.

A3&-     Sarla Verma Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and Another ./0 %#& 2 # ) (  3

(  (          !

>30  

      

      

   

         

  

  

     

 

 



  

 

  

4          



    !"#$       

%#  !"&$       

&'    !"($      



  31)

      

        *              (+,      

    





 

                 

  -

 

           

        

   

         $          .  /

 

     

     

             

  *  

 

             



          

      32 

     

             (+,           

           (+,    

          

5         



  

                                          

 

             * * * * * * 42.)     

   

       &$        

     0

 1    $        !2    !(%+ %!%(

$ 

    

 3!4 %'#+

3!'#!#(

3!(#'&+

3!&&!&(

 3!#&'(+

  

    

 3!!(!((

35(''+

34 '!'(

 3(''4+

,

A3&  -             National Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. ./ 60 % 173

   (- $..$. ! $.0  

$/00 ( ' !

14

            '  B       C 1D4 -          '    '    C

 ' &   '  C 5  & '        B (  C 1E4 <  '    '(  &C! B %    '  !

>52. 6  conventional heads



  

   

 7/

8 *   7 %(+++   

7

!+++++    

        7  !+++++  

  

    

  

      

 

 7/

  0   9 

 



         



             

  



   



  :    

  

    6                  

 

     



  

      

   

  

  

 

  

; 

  

     

  

 

1   

       

    

        



                     

      

   

  * 

           

 

         

   

  

   

 

      

   7 !(+++ &++++ 7 !(+++

             

   <       

   

 )        

     

 

 



  

  

 !+,   

)   

  



  

 

 

  = = = = = 59.3)   

  (+,    



 



 /      &+

   

   #+, 





&+(+

* 

  

  (+'+

    !(,         



6 59.4* 







 $       &+,

 

  

  

 &+

6  %(,

   

 &+(+

 !+,



  

 (+'+



 

  

   

   

     

  59.5.              

    

     #+#%0> ?

    

    59.6.



                0  > @         &%     /

 59.7 

        59.87   

        

  



 

     

    7  !(+++  7  &++++     7  !(+++

   

    

   !+,  

A A3&  -             *(82(   ('

# ( $ 2&( 9 +:2:)

;"

( # (2 (':( <#< # (2  )<  . 7/ 70 % 43

  ' %( '( ; 2( /#& (0   ( (9

7 %)<:

/%#& (0

  ('

 '  5     !

B216  <

  C  0 8         

 

    

;

  

     *     

  D  D    

      



 D  

 D  D    D     D

 D    

          

  

   

 

  

   )

 

 

 



 

%!!Spousal consortium 

   

         

    



      

  

    /  D %!%Parental consortium     



  

D  

   

     

   

     D %!# Filial consortium     

  

 

  

6 

      

         

 

  

   



   

      

          

  22  



 

     

       3  /     

 



  E   



  

   

         3   /                 

      

 

           

 

  

      

  23 3>  

6  

    

     

  

  

  

* 

  

          

     

 

      C  

   

      

    6 6   

 

       

      

       

   

           

   



  24         

         

     

 

   D

  D   C  0 8*  







    

  7 &++++ 

  /

   (  (

  (  8   EB F (  &  '

5 $++++6!  F   ( A( 

 & 

   &'

 "  (    % &

     & :

'    ( ' :

 &  - A   )+$+ %    &

 '



     5 * ++6!   (  &   

'



$+

    (  

 % &

   '       %    (   (  

 ''

  '  5= &    

$$

<    (  

  % &

'

          '

    $6      (   B       

  ( '     (  B

             (           (   ; 

'

 

   +%

$)

" (  (

(& A3&-   &'    ( %  (   )* +, )+$)         '  %    !

    

       !

Sr. No.

Heads Compensation Awarded $  " 5 * ++6!

) <7*+9 5 $,)+6!1*+9* ++4

 (  B  $6  5 )++.6!1.+)+G$6 4 * % " 5 *+*$1.+)+!)++.4    $.

.

  5 ,,+.006!1*+$*G$)G$.4 , HE  5 $0$8+6!

< EB 5 $0$8+6!

/ H   5 $*8)++6!

- 5 *0*++6!B$  5 *0*++6!B <

5 *0*++B) $+   B 5 $$*,//6!

$$

)('

2& ():

" >11>76 ? $)  #$):

( & % & "6> >1? $  <( $

(2# ) "4>1>476? / >11>766> >10 $

-        &A3& -  Dara Singh @ Dhara Banjara Vs. Shyam Singh Varma    4 61 R.Valli and Others VS. Tamil Nandu State Transport Corporation (2022) 5 Supreme Court Cases 107 >   !

  '   7/9  

     '

      I 

  $*

% "   !   

   '( (  % & (

  (   

' % % &   & 

   '

(     

6     &        % &        (     )* +, )+$)  % 

6      & : 

 % &

$8

 '   14     

""

/%

%*0 



 J   :

'6! :

' K6 J   &  K