High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9592/2013disposed of

Jct Electronics Ltd. v. Presiding Officer, Indl Tribunal Patiala And ANR

2016-04-27Mr Justice Jaswant Singh23 pages

!"# #$%&%'( ) *

+ !"# #$%&%'( ) *

2#-#&%/%'3

%$#-4'/1&"-%!,-%51'!,4!"%!,!!'/!'"2#- * )+

* )+

!-'!%,7%'32!'/!'"2#- * ))

* ))

#"%"%'#- !,8%!"7%'32!'/!'"2#- * )9

* )9

!: ;"!-!'/!'"2#- * )

* )

71&2%,<1:!-72!-:!!'/!'"2#- * 9

* 9

2!'7%'32!'/!'"2#- #&6'/#'"

* 9

1-$2!-!'7%'32!'/!'"2#- * 9

* 9

<-%&2!'<1:!-!'/!'"2#- * 9

* 9

-1'<2&,!!'/!'"2#- * 9*

* 9*

-!2!:#;!'/!'"2#- * 9

* 9

!-3!"7%'32!'/!'"2#- * 9+

* 9+

.!82:%-7%'32!'/!'"2#- * 9)

* 9)

<1,/##67%'32!'/!'"2#- * 99

* 99

'%,<1:!-!'/!'"2#- * 9

* 9

< ,!:!'/!'"2#- *

7!"6!,7%'32!'/!'"2#- *

71-#&2 2!'/!-%!'/!'"2#- *

2!'7%'32!'/!'"2#- *

!/2#=72=!:!'/!'"2#- * *

* *

!3>%"7%'32!'/!'"2#- *

!,>%"7%'32!'/!'"2#- * +

* +

2!'#&2<1:!-7%'32!'/!'"2#- * )

* )

72!8"%2!'/!'/!'"2#- 9

!,/#;7%'32!'/!'"2#- 9

7!'>##;<1:!-!'/!'"2#- 9

7!-?!'<1:!- 2!'/!-%!'/!'"2#- 9 *

9 *

:!->%"7%'32!'/!'"2#- 9

2!3?!'7%'32!'/!'"2#- 9 +

9 +

'>!=<1:!- !%'!'/!'"2#- 9 )

9 )

!:<1:!-!'/!'"2#- 9 9

9 9

!-!:>%"7%'32!'/!'"2#- 9

7!'"827%'32!'/!'"2#- 9+

!&5%-7%'32!'/!'"2#- 9+

!->%"7%'32!'/!'"2#- 9+

.!82%!:!'/!'"2#- *)

!8#&2%&2-!!'/!'"2#-

71'%,1""72!-:!!'/!'"2#-

!-%&2!?!"!'/!'"2#-

!2#&272!2!'/!'"2#-

!-5!'&7%'32!'/!'"2#-

/!%0##-7%'32!'/!'"2#- #&6'/#'"&

!>#&2<1:!- !/!;!'/!'"2#- #&6'/#'"&

2%,,%6#-3#!'/!'"2#-

!:#&!'/!'"2#-

2!'7%'32!'/!'"2#-

1-:!%,7%'32!'/!'"2#-

##6!872!-:!!'/!'"2#-

7182>%".!,!'/!'"2#-

216%'/#-7%'32!'/!'"2#-

)

2%'/#-!,,!'/!'"2#-

71-%'/#-<1:!-!'/!'"2#-

!/!'.!,!'/!'"2#-

!-#&2<1:!-!'/!'"2#-

!,>%"7%'32!'/!'"2#-

)

%-/=!!-!=!'!'/!'"2#-

:-!8!&2!'/!'"2#-

!-8!&22!'/!'/!'"2#-

'%,<1:!-!'/!'"2#- *

!&!'"7%'32!'/!'"2#-

!-/##6<1:!-!'/!'"2#- +9+

+9+

0%'/<1:!-16"!!'/!'"2#- +

<1,/##6<1:!-!'/!'"2#- + *

+ *

%'#=<1:!- 2!!'/!'"2#- +

&2%&2<1:!-7!'"-!!'/!'"2#- + +

+ +

!81'>!!-&2!/!'/!'"2#- + )

+ )

2!'7%'32!'/!'"2#- + 9

+ 9

!"%'/#-7%'32!'/!'"2#- +

1-/#;7%'32!'/!'"2#- +

:%-7%'32 !/!;!'/!'"2#- +

!% 21&2!'!'/!'"2#- +

:#&27%'32!'/!'"2#- +

1-:1827%'32!'/!'"2#- +*

!:%'%<!'"2!'/!'"2#- +

!->%"7%'32!'/!'"2#- ++

1-5!$2!'7%'32!'/!'"2#- +)

!:7!-!'!-&2!/!'/!'"2#- +9

!'$2!'!'!,!'/!'"2#- +

!,,%$8!'/!'"2#- +*

0%>!=<1:!-!'/!'"2#- +*

!-7%'32<1'>?!,!'/!'"2#- +*

1-'!:7%'32!'/!'"2#- +*

!>-!>7%'32!'/!'"2#- +**

+**

2!-!:!,!'/!'"2#- +*

0!-%'/#-<1:!-!'/!'"2#- +*+

+*+

.#82!:!'/!'"2#- +*)

+*)

!;%'/#-<1:!-!'/!'"2#- +*9

+*9

!,5%-7%'32!'/!'"2#- +*

!: -%>!1-=!!'/!'"2#- +

1,,!<1:!-!=!'/!'"2#- +

#:!><!6%,!!'/!'"2#- +

7152!&22!'/!'/!'"2#- +

7!"%'/#-<1:!-!'/!'"2#- + *

+ *

7.7!'"-!!'/!'"2#- +

!,?!'"7%'32!'/!'"2#- + +

+ +

!;%'/#-!,7%'32!'/!'"2#- + )

+ )

2%'/#-7%'32!'/!'"2#- + 9

+ 9

18#&22!'/!'/!'"2#- +

182-!>7%'32!'/!'"2#- ++

!-,$2!'7%'32!'/!'"2#- ++

!,>%"7%'32!'/!'"2#- ++

72=!:71'/#-!'/!'"2#- ++

-!2!:#;!'/!'"2#- +)

!-%&2<1:!-!'/!'"2#- +*9

+*9

<1&1:72!-:!!'/!'"2#- +*)

+*)

!:#&2<1:!-7%'32!'/!'"2#- +)

!: !2!/1-!'/!'"2#- +)*

+)*

7152!&22!'/!'/!'"2#- +)

0#-:!!'/!'"2#- +)+

+)+

;-%!-&2!/!'/!'"2#- +))

+))

!:#&22!'/!'/!'"2#- +)9

+)9

!'5%-7%'32!'/!'"2#- +9

72!-/!#;% #&6'/#'" +9

!'!8!:!'/!'"2#- +*+

+*+

.!@:!'7!21!'/!'"2#- +*++

+*++

.##,!::! = #&6'/#'" +*)

+*)

7252!#3% #&6'/#'"

.!82:%-7%'32 A& ,#$"-'%$&!'/!'"2#- )9

+ )9

+ 2%'/#-7%'32 A& ,#$"-'%$&!'/!'"2#- ( ( ( ( B . 7

B . 7

2#"2#-#6-"#-& "2#,$!,6!6#-&:!=5# !,,?#/"&##"2#>1/3:#'"C

5#-# #--#/""2##6-"#-&-'"C

2#"2#-"2#>1/3:#'"&21,/5#-#6-"#/%'"2# %3#&"C -#&#'"( -!><!1&2%84 /;$!"# -"2#6#"%"%'#-& &8"!2!81-4 /;$!"# -"2#6#"%"%'#-&%'

&)9 !'/ 9

+ -7#"%!47#'%- /;$!"#?%"2 -71-%'/#-7%'324 /;$!"# --#&6'/#'" -8:#'!'/ --#&6'/#'" %'

-7!1-!52 --!4 /;$!"# -

%$%!,.%D1%/!"- EEE !>!'"2-%4 -!, !>!'"2-%4 -!, !>!'"2-%4 -!, !>!'"2-%4 -!, 2%&-/#-?%,,/%&6&# ?-%"6#"%"%'&5#!-%'3& 4 * )+4 * ))4 * )94 * )4 * 9 4 * 9 4 * 9

* 94 * 9*4 * 9 4 * 9+4 * 9)4 * 994 * 94 * 4

* 4 * 4 * 4 * *4 * 4 * +4 * )4 9

9 4 9 4 9 *4 9 4 9 +4 9 )4 9 94 9 4

9+ 4 9+ 4 9+ 4 *)

94 4 4 *4 4 +9+4 + 4 + *4

+ 4 + +4 + )4 + 94 + 4 + 4 + 4 +

+4 +*4 + 4 ++4 +)4 +94 +4 +*

+* 4 +* 4 +*4 +**4 +* 4 +*+4 +*)4 +*94

+*4 + 4 + 4 + 4 + 4 + *4 + 4 + +4

+ )4 + 94 + 4 ++ 4 ++ 4 ++ 4 ++4 +)

+*9 4 +*)4 +)4 +)*4 +) 4 +)+4 +))4 +)94

+9 4 +94 +*+ 4 +*++4 +*)

*4 9

!'/)9

+4!&$::'D1#&"%'& ,!?!'/ !$"!-# %';,;#/ %' "2#: ?2%$2 $!' $';#'%#'",= 5# /#$%/#/ 5= ! $::'-/#- 1-%'36#'/#'$= "2#&#6#"%"%'&4!F-/%'!"#

#'$2 "2%&1-"2!&6!&&#/!'-/#-%'

)

%'"2#:!""#- A& ,#$"-'%$&.%:%"#/4?2%$2-#!/&!&

,,?&(F -# #-#'$#2!&5##'-#$#%;#/ -:"2# -#$::#'/%'3?%'/%'316"2#$:6!'=%#A& ,#$"-'%$&.%:%"#/ .#!-'#/ $1'&#, - "2# $:6!'= &15:%""#/ "2!""2#-#D1%&%"# 1'/&$1,/'"5#!--!'3#/" -#;%;#"2#$:6!'=42#'$#4"2#$:6!'=2!&' 5>#$"%'% "2#&!:#%&?1'/16!'/-;%&%'!, .%D1%/!"-%&!66%'"#/ .#"'"%$#5#%&&1#/""2#$-#/%"-&!'/"2#- 6!-"%#&4 ?2 !66#!-#/ 5# -# "2# -

+ ' ;%#? "2# !

-#&!%/ !$"1!, :!"-%@4 "2# 6#"%"%'%&!/:%""#/ 2#

%$%!,.%D1%/!"-!""!$2#/""2%&1-"%& !66%'"#/!&-;%&%'!,.%D1%/!"- "2#$:6!'= #&2!,,"!8#"2#$2!-3# "2#!&&#"&!'/-#$-/&

"2#$:6!'= .#" !$"1: !/:%&&%'5#615,%&2#/%'B2# '/%!' @6-#&&B '3,%&24 B1'>!5% -%51'#B 5"2 2!'/%3!-2/%"%'!'/ %'"2#

%$%!,!H#""#

;#-':#'" 1'>!5 2#615,%$!"%'&2!,,5#:!/#5="2#

%$%!,

.%D1%/!"-1" $::'6, 1'/!$$1'" 2# #@6#'&#&&%'$1--#/&2!,,5#-#%:51-&#/1" "2# &!,#6-$##/& "2#!&&#"& "2#$:6!'=I ';%#? "2#!

-#&!%//#;#,6:#'"4"2#?-8:#'

!-# /%-#$"#/ " :!8# '#$#&&!-= $,!%: 5# -# "2#

%$%!, .%D1%/!"-!'/?2&2!,,5#$'&%/#-"2#&!:#!""2##!-,%#&"4 '"5#='/'#=#!- "2#$,!%:& "2#?-8:#'$!''"5# /#$%/#/ ?%"2%' '# =#!-4 "2# ?-8:#' &2!,, 5# #'"%",#/ " %'"#-#&"'"2#!?!-/#/!:1'"J

K6#-!''1: ' "2%& 51'$2 6#"%"%'&4 "2#-# !-# ',= "? 6#"%"%'&4%#&)9 !'/ 9

+ %,#/5="2# ?-8:#'4?2#-#%'"2#=2!;#$,!%:#/%'"#-#&"2&#-#,%# $!'

5#$,!%:#/5="2#6#"%"%'#-&5# -#"2#:6!'=1-"5=

%,%'3'#$#&&!-=6#"%"%'& 71$2$,!%:&&2!,,5# %,#/5="2# ?-8:#'?%"2%'!6#-%/ "2-##:'"2& -:"/!=

,,"2#6#"%"%'&!-#/%&6&#/ %'"2#!5;#"#-:&

6-%, )4

8!'$2!'