High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/7434/2015allowed

Karan Singh v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2016-10-27Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan5 pages

!" #$% &%'()(*+ ,#-#*.(*/0 %$($(*%-)"

1%-)2) .$#$% #-3#*##*&$0%-) %)4*&%*$)"

!+ 56 ! . , 6. -%)%*$+7 !-#8#* #-/#*&!) %%$#*9#:( 00#;-#<&='#$%)<

-$0%4%$($(*%- !- #2-#= %:<))()$#*$ #-3#*# 0%$0%-$0%%4-$%-) :'#:*%>)4#4%-8#3;%#::>%&$ )%%$0%92&/8%*$?

;%-% %--%&$$0%%4-$%--*$ 0%$0%-$0%92&/8%*$)02:&;%-%4-$%&(*$0%&(/%)$? 77 77 , 6. 6"

0% 4%$($(*%- >#) >-@(*/ #) # -@ !2*)0( >($0 $0% -%)4*&%*$ &%4#-$8%*$ * >-@ '0#-/% ;#)() * #''2*$

(84:%8%*$#$(* $0%#-3#*# (=(:.%-=('%)))2-%& #-%%--/-%))(*"

2:%)<AAB(*)0-$5 AAB5"<$0%4#3 $0%4%$($(*%->#)

(C%&>($0%

%'$ -8AA(*$0%-%=()%&4#3)'#:% )

0%&#$% (*'-%8%*$ $0%4%$($(*%->#)$0%->()%$ #::&2%*)$

!#3%=%-33%#-0%-%# $%-<0%>#)/-#*$%& (-)$#*&)%'*&#))2-%&'#-%%- 4-/-%))(*(*)0-$5 5">($0%

%'$ -8AA#*&

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

%-=('%)2:%)<1:28%7<#-$7<() #44:('#;:%$$0%'#)% $0%4%$($(*%-#*&0()4#30#);%%*-%7 (C%&#*&($ >#)&%*(%&$0#$2:% $0%2:%) AAB()#44:('#;:%$$0%4-%)%*$ '#)% *$0%>-($$%*)$#$%8%*$#:)<$0%)(8(:#-)$#*&>#)$#@%*$ 92)$( 3$0%#'$(* 0#=%0%#-&$0%:%#-*%&'2*)%:) -$0%4#-$(%)#*&0#=%#:) '#-% 2::3/*%$0-2/0$0% (:% 2:% "("#-3#*# (=(:.

$>($0)$#*&(*/#*3$0(*/'*$#(*%&(*$0%)% -2%:)< >0%-%# =%-*8%*$%84:3%%0:&(*/#4)$(*# $%84-#-3-

('(#$(*/'#4#'($34-8$%&-#44(*$%&(*# )2;)$#*$(=%<$%84-#-3-

('(#$(*/'#4#'($3$#*$0%-4)$ '#--3(*/&2$(%)#*&-%)4*)(;(:($(%) /-%#$%-(84-$#*'%$0#* $0)%#$$#'0(*/$$0%4)$0%:&;30(8<0()(*($(#:4#3(*$0% $(8%)'#:% 0(/0%-4)$)0#::;% (C%&#$$0%)$#/%*%C$#;=%

77 0()4#3&-#>*;30(8(*$0%:>%-4)$4-=(&%&($()'%-$( (%& ;3$0%%#& $0%%4#-$8%*$-%#& $0%

('%>0%-%0% () #44(*$(*/ #2$0-($3 (* -%)4%'$ :#)) #*& 1

=%-*8%*$%84:3%%)(*>0('0$0% =%-*8%*$%84:3%% >#)0:&(*/$0%:>%-4)$$0#$0%>2:&0#=%'*$(*2%&$

('(#$%(*$0%:>%-4)$;2$ -0()4-8$(* #44(*$8%*$ $$0%0(/0%-4)$ $%7 0%*# =%-*8%*$%84:3%%()#44(*$%&$# 0(/0%-4)$*$0%&#$%*>0('00()(*'-%8%*$(*$0%:>%- )2;)$#*$(=%4)$ #::&2%<0())2;)$#*$(=%4#3 -$0%42-4)%

(C(*/0()(*($(#:4#3(*$0%0(/0%-4)$)0#::;%(*':2)(=% 0() (*'-%8%*$#''-2(*/*$0%&#$%F 2:% AAB()-%4-&2'%&#)2*&%-+7 E2:%7 #$% *%C$(*'-%8%*$(*$0%(-)$#*&.%'*& )'#:%<#)$0%'#)%8#3;%7 0%*%C$(*'-%8%*$ #

=%-*8%*$)%-=#*$>0)%4#30#);%%* (C%&(*$0%-%=()%& )'#:%(*#''-&#*'%>($0)2;7-2:%" -2:% )0#::;%/-#*$%& * $0% &#$% 0% >2:& 0#=% &-#>* 0() (*'-%8%*$< 0#& 0% '*$(*2%&(*$0%4-%)%*$)'#:% -=(&%& $0#$ (* '#)%) >0%-% $0% 4#3 #

=%-*8%*$)%-=#*$())$%44%&24(*$%-8) $%$ )2;

-2:%"#*&#:))%'*&4-=()$)2;7-2:%" -2:% <$0% *%C$(*'-%8%*$)0#::;%/-#*$%&*$0%'84:%$(* D2#:( 3(*/ )%-=('% 8*$0) -8$0%&#$% $0%)$%44(*/ $0%4#3 (*$0%-%=()%&)'#:%G -=(&%& 2-$0%- $0#$ (* '#)% $0%- $0#* $0)% '=%-%&;3$0%4-%'%&(*/4-=()<$0%*%C$(*'-%8%*$ #

=%-*8%*$)%-=#*$<>0)%4#3() (C%&*$0%)$ &#3

#*2#-3<AA-*#*3<)2;)%D2%*$&#$%<#$$0%)#8%)$#/%#*& (*$0%)#8%4#3)'#:%#)$0%*% (C%& -#*$0%- =%-*8%*$ )%-=#*$92*(-$0(8(*$0%)#8%'#&-%#*&&-#>(*/4#3#$$0% :>%-)$#/%$0#*0()(*$0%4-%)%*$)'#:%<)0#::;%/-#*$%&*$0% )#8%&#$%#)#&8())(;:%$0()92*(-<( $0%&#$% (*'-%8%*$ 92*(-0#44%*)$;%%#-:(%-G -=(&%&#:)$0#$(*$0%'#)% 4%-)*)>00#&

77 ;%%*&-#>(*/8#C(828 $0%4-%)%*$)'#:% -8-%$0#*# 3%#-#)*$0%)$&#3 #*2#-3<AA<*%C$(*'-%8%*$(*$0% -%=()%&)'#:%)0#::;%#::>%&*$0% (-)$&#3 #*2#-3< AAF 2:%A $0% AAB4-=(&%) -=%--(&(*/ %

%'$ )#(& -2:%) =%- $0% . #*& ) #- #) $0%)% #-% (*'*)()$%*$>($0$0%)#(& 2:%) ><( 2:% "(" #-3#*# (=(:.%-=('%)2:%)< 1:28%7<#-$7<()%C#8(*%&<($'8%)2$$0#$($()#44:('#;:%$$0%'#)%) >0%-%# =%-*8%*$%84:3%%()#44(*$%&$$0%0(/0%-4)$ *$0% 4-%)%*$ '#)%<($ () #&8($$%& '#)% $0%4#-$(%) $0#$ $0% 4%$($(*%- >#) >-@(*/#)#-@.24%-=()-#*&'*$(*2%&$>-@#))2'0$(::$0%&#$%

0()-%$(-%8%*$0#$$0%-%)4*&%*$)0#=%&*%()$0#$<=(&%$0%(842/*%& -&%-<0()&#$% (*'-%8%*$0#);%%*)0( $%&$ AA<>0%-%#)($>#)&2% *AA#*&'*)%D2%*$:3<$0%4#3 $0%4%$($(*%-0#);%%*-%&2'%& #*&-%7 (C%& -$0%'8(*/3%#-)$(::0()-%$(-%8%*$ #8 $0%=(%>$0#$(*$0()'#)%>0%*$0%4#3 $0%4%$($(*%- >#) (C%&>($0%

%'$ -8AA(*=(%> 2:% $0%

AAB< $0%&#$% (*'-%8%*$>(::*$'0#*/% $()*$#'#)%>0%-%$0% 4%$($(*%->#)#44(*$%&$$0%0(/0%-4)$0%-% -%<2:% "("

#-3#*# (=(: .%-=('%) 2:%)<1:28%7< #-$7< >#) >-*/:3#44:(%&

*)%D2%*$:3< $0% (842/*%& -&%- &#$%& **%C2-%77A" () 0%-%;3 D2#)0%& #*& $0% -%7 (C#$(* &*% 4-(- $ $0% 4#))(*/ $0% (842/*%& -&%- () -%)$-%& *)%D2%*$:3< $0% ;%*% ($) (*':2&(*/ $0% 4%*)(*#-3;%*% ($))0#::;%-%:%#)%&$$0%4%$($(*%->($0(*$>8*$0)

-8$0%&#$% -%'%(4$ '%-$( (%&'43 $0()-&%-#:*/>($0(*$%-%)$#$ $0%-#$% AH4%-#**28 $%-$0%-%7 (C#$(*<$0%'*)%D2%*$(#:;%*% ($)

)0#::#:);%-%:%#)%&$$0%4%$($(*%- 0%4-%)%*$>-($4%$($(*()#::>%& , 6. "

)9@) 0%$0%-)4%#@(*/ -%#)*%& + %) 0%$0%-%4-$#;:% +