High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/17998/2024dismissed

Union Of India And Others v. Sunil Kumar And Another

2024-11-07Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma12 pages

"#$%&

#$#'$( "#$%

!" #

$% )% *+) ,,

, -

*+) , ,, , ) & %'() " *+,,-%./, 01 $ 2 ,

, -

#1&11 ,4$ -1 $ 1 5 0%,-$,(01 &,% 01 % %, %6 6 6 7 8 59- , $, % '( 1 + , % * % / #',+ // %-41 '(1 /+,*0 $% 01 &,0 %,'+($ 4,,++4

/(0'/1/(23 #'$"

#1 $% : %*( ;;,0, 0 ,+1 &1 / 01 -1 / %%,'+ 0 <= > # " > # = =

# 7 # = ? # > # =

# " @ #=A ,% < # #B # 7

#C ""9 " =#A $% 4,%/1,& %0* C6 66 1 * 0 %/1,& -1%,'+ 4 $ /.

+(, %DC6E0+0

#1 %,'+( + * /+,*01 $% 4, :

/ '(1 =*$ 1(.% + %, % 66-11 &%1,1 $,%,'+ 4 1 ,','+ '

& ,&&,., %'( %0*+,(

$% 0+ %0,$$ ,+%, % 6C 6,% ,+ .

%+ &,+/ %, % 6F 6$1 $,* % + %, % 66-1 =*$ 1( :

/ %1 %,'+( $ /+,*0 $% #1 ,0 - $% 0+ -'

0 1 + , %* %/ #',+// %-41 '( /,,/1,++ & 1 ,0 ,% :

/% #1 ,% - /,* ,++4 %.% % %, %6 6 6 #1 $ ,.

$,01 ,%% 8,/ %1 ,0

$ %&'(() * +,$

-(- (%

'.*/

+&,&& .

%0*1 ,0 ,%% ,$, %$ 1 7$,9-'(1 + , %* %/ #',+// %-1 $ 50%,1,0+ %1 ,&,1 ,4$ 0 1= $4

$( #4056#' 0

0 $/

%&*,G , /.

,%:%/,$ 1 $ 4$ - , 0+,,/ 0% *&41 1 1 0,++* 0,(% .5H5.,(* *'

01 % $ +-'$1'

& ++ %1 ,*(-% $ ,1 ,+ ,& -$1'

/*& + %-,,* *'

01 /*',, ,'+1* -,1 1 ,* *,&% / %-( 1 ,$$ $-1$ +* 1 &/,'+ '

1 /& ,+'

&/,'+ '

,&&,., %'

& ,','+ *+,( -1,/I %-0*-1 $/$+ 011 :%&* %'(1 J'+ $ 8=-/, + ,

- $ % !

#1 + ., $,,&,$1 0 1 ,% .

%/ , 8,/ ,0

$ $

1 2 3 45

$ $

$ -

(" $

6 7

89 , :

0&(;

<-**3,

=#4

3 4

* $ 7

$ >, ! ', %34? 3 4. 3

3, 04 3 $4*

$ >, %34? 3$4*

$ @

$ >%34? 3$ 4*

>%34?C 3$ 4* A

-** ;D

3A :

4 (( E ;9 2 D

;

= & 0

$ #

$ $

,%&7901 ,'.

8,/ %$/$+ - 1&1$ %+(% /+, -1,41 ,%,'+('

,+ %$ ,(* *'

01 /*',,% ,'+1* -,%41/1 1 8 0 6 E .

- 1 $- 1&1 ,( /1 %,'+ * *'

.,+% % 0*1 *(-'( 1 ,& %1 00%,'+($ 1 + -1 ,&* 0%,'+($ ,( * *'

01 /*',,% ,'+1* -41'

# 41,%,'+(,I,*06E* -'*$ ,.

+( , % /+,, 0* 1 "

%/,+ ?,%- ,1 /,%%+( $/&1,1 ,%,, %%,'+('

&,','+ /*&,&&,., %'(*+,(

#1 ,%% /+,,'

: %'(1 89 , :

0&(; <-**3,

=#4 ;

1 * -1&11 ,$ *$,& .5H5.1 %$1(/,+,%* ,+1 ,+10,(* *'

01 ,'+1* // %- $ /,++(41 ,1 ,& 01 /*& ++ %-1 /%,'1'

/*&'

41,(%

" .

-1&11 1 ,+,01 $ *$- 1, 41 ,( % , 1 - 1 // ' I +(- 1 '( 1 ,% 1,$$ & 0 % ,79 &0,(% -,1 '

$ * , I +01 & , , * *'

0 1 % ,'+1*

*$ ,.

+(-1 0$.&1 %4* I,'

0 7$,9.5H5.1 // %-' %1 *$+( -,% /, -1 ,% *,5%/1,& %-1 $-1 /+,*, + % / .

%,'+($ " .

-,++1 0,/ ,% //*,/ , %, 1 % 0 '( 1 // %-, '

/+ +(/K %-10% /+,&41 1 1 0,(% .5H5.1 // %-, I +I, % 0 *+,( ,%2 1 ,* '

& ,&&,., % '( '

& ,','+ *+,(

" 6 ?

1,,*,(-1 '

,+ 01,01 $/$+ 791,( 1 /,'

% ,+0%,'+($ 1 // %-'+($) ,91 * 0,// $,/ 01 // %*+,( -* &'

/*& /% %'(1 "

%/,+ ?,% .5,5. 1 '

& '

41 , % 41/1 14 .

//+% ( &1* 0'

'9 ( 01 % , 1 0- *,( ,+ ' I +('

//+% %'(1 "

%/,+?,%- , 0* % 0 *+,( '

& ,','+ *+,( -,1 1 ,* &, /& ,+%

1 -01 * %/,+$1+%1,1 % /+% 1,.

% / %* %/,+ 8,*,01 // %'

& *,% -1$1'

/*& + % -1 $-1 ,* 4++'

* %1,.

, %& -( 1 ,7$,9-1 "

%/,+?,% %, 1 ,0 //+%&

" .

-,+% /+, %$,-1,*,%,( 01 "

%/,+?,%0++41 &% + +,%%4=1,$ 5 01 LB% "

%/,+7"+,(

9-66>L + * ) ,+ /$+ L

C #1 0 -1,'

4% * %41 1 *0 1 ,'.

$/$+ -41 1 ,1 * 0 +* 01 $ $% 1 *(-1,0 ,$ +*,(* %/,+ 8,*, &*,% .5,5.11 ,+1-1, /,* /% %,' * % &1*,%241 1 * /,* ,$$ 1,1 ,%% 4,,%*,,&

" .

-,+ % * %-0*1 0,/,1,%-41 1 1 , /,,+ 8 5 1 $01 % -,%21 & 1 0-1$ -1$1 ++* 01 $ $% ,G& $+,/ - .5,5. 1 ,/.

% '( 1* 0 *+,( -41 '(-1=*,(//+% 1,1 0 1 % ',1 4,, I +01 & 1 *( ,%,/14,,','+ '

/,* ,&&,., %'(1 & *+,(

,%%-,+ &,1 %0*1 /%-41 1 1 "

%/,+?,%-%%,++($/

%*,G , ,+ %/.

, / ,+/1 /G-$,/+,+(,$$ ,&1 ,%.

01 % -1&1 *$+(* 0 , 0* %/,+ /1I - 1 .

+& 1 '+/G /1, & / / /- 0*-,1 1 % /,* / " .

-01 ,%

*$+(* 0,+ +,+(-1 '(*,('

//+% %I,

$1 0-1' I 1 ,$$ +* ,G& $+,/ -,1 4,/& ,+'4 %& %0 *+,( % '

&,','+ '

/*&,&&,.,

'($ 0*,/ 0*+,(

=,+(-01 $, *$+( /1I ,1 ,& 0,$$ +* ,G&$+,/ -1'(1 "

%/,+?,%// %-+ ,%,//+-1,1 , ,1 %*,/% 0,(% -'( 1 ,%%*,% $1'&1 +* 0,($ +1 ,*(-,.(, 0/

+,+(1 ' I ,/.

% /2 $1 0- %&1 / 0 %0*+,( -'4+%,,++( + ,%,4 ++//+'(1 "

%/,+?,%-1,,/.

$ ' '

/,* / % 0* , /.

/,,+ & / / / '(1 4+%'

% ,+0%,'+($

4 .

-41 ,% ,.-1= '

8,/&1 / 01 $-,'

/,* /% %'(1 + * %/,+',% ,'+( ','+ &&,., '(

, <= > # " > # = =

# 7 # = ? # > # =

# " @ #=A ,% < # #B# 7

# C ""9 " =#A # # 5 #$ 0#4"6/761608#(('

!6$3 6$ :

/( / / ;/!

/$3/1# .

-/ $/0/2/< 5

$# /00 67'0/71 # /33 /!/06$3 4/(0# /:

"/8(5/ 0 #4 "'06 4 #=)/ 0#

: 5 :/06 $04#11#9 "

$# =/1 #'06$ /$""/80#"/8 /(06!606 5 :/06 $0 "6" $#0 5/!

/$8(#=# 76"606 162 # ) 956(5 =/8 (/'

/33 /!/06#$ ' 05 6$"6!6"'/1

=/6$ " :#0 " 6$ :

1#(/06#$05

/40 $ 056(/

$ 6== "6/0 $# : #1#$3 "

>( :06#$/1 0 $# 0 /6$ 6 $#0 !6"

$0 5 $( (#$( "

78=6160/ 8 !6( /:

:/ / ?)

/ 66$3 6$ 9561 !6$3 6$

1"@@ , / / 6$ /$ 6$"6!6"'/1 (#$6"

/00 67'0/71 0# =61 !6(

/1#$39605

!6"

>( :06#$/10 /$"0 /6$#4 =61 , !6( $ 056 (/ 60 6

,%&01 /% .

,+1,,1 * 01 ,$$ +* ,G&$+,/ ,1 /,* *,% * 01 $/$+ 7$,9% /+, %'(1 J'+ $ 8=/, + %,

$%!'(1 "

%/,+ ?,%-1,* % 41/114 .

-%%0'%1 $ $% -'

+ %1 *(-%%*,G $ +*,( & 0 - 1 % /+,, 0 +,4 :%&* 7$,9 1, 1 '(1 ,$ *$1,1 /&01 ,%% 4,, I +0 %0 - 0,.,'+(

%4 %.5,5.1 $% #1&1 1 ,% $ *$ ','+ '1 + ,% .% '1 ,%$ *$ /,* /, $ 1 $ 4 .

- 1 ,% /, .% ,%%/&%/1,&&.5,5.1 $% -,1 0/& +( '&1 ,%$ *$-',,++(,+%%/,, %(,+$1 "

%/,+?,%- &,& +01 ,.0 ,1&- 1&1 *$+(* 0 1 , 0 '+/G /1, & / /,,+ / / /1I 79- 41 '( *,( '

/,* ,.

+ %1,1 &01 % 1 ,*($ +- /,* / %0*, / ,+& /0,*+(1( " .

- 1 '(4,,+ , %1 * %/,+$-1, 1 % '0,4 ++0* % ,,1 4,,/& ,+% ,%'

/,* 1 ,&&,., %'('

/,* ,','+ *+,(

4 .

-, ,%&0$7$,9-%/+ 1,1,

/% %, ($ %0*,% ,1,.

/% 1 8 7$,9 , %+(- / .% ' 1 $ *$7$,91,'

+ %'(1 $ -1 '(-1= /, %&.

4 &1,& 1 $01 * %/,+',%- , 8,/ % 7$,9 =$/+(- 1 '( / /, '

,& %1 $,++0* % ,-'

% 1 '(1 & 01 % /,'

,%'

, I +0, / ,+& / 0,*+(1( =,+(- % /+, %, 0* %0*+,(

,%%- % /+, % ,','+ '

/*&,&&,., %'( %0*+,( '(1 $ $% " .

- 1&1 , % 1 1, 1 % // %41+ /,* $ 0* %'(1 % $ + ,1 ,$ ,/ , ,-'/ 1 8$ *,%, 1 + ., &+,-41/1*,G 1 &01 % , $ ,/ , ,-'

& ,01 I +1,,/1-J &%% , 0*1 %0*+,( '

/,* ,&&,., '( %01 *+,(

/ I -1 +,/G01 ,%

8$ *,%, 1 &+,- % /, 1 = //+% -1, .

01 &01 ,%% $1 $ $% 1// %,$ ,/ , ,-1 '(-1 ,% & , '

% /+, ,&&,., %'('

&,','+ %0*+,(

;

1 -/ *01 :%&* %'(1 $ 8=-/, + %,&

'()@

*+,"- 41 -,% /+,,*,% 1

8 -1,1 00%&00-,1 1,'

%4 1 // +,+(,+1 % ,% ,'+ &1 /,* .

% 1 $ $% 0 1

G& I, 1 ,$$ %&00'

&*,% 10,. 6

1 4 / 1 % /+,, 0 +,4 *,% .

%/7$,9*,G 1 ,%% /+,,'

, 8$+,0+,4 *-1 '(-1 8$+,0+,4 *-,*,% .

%/ 7$,9,+*,G 1 1 % /0 %'

0.5,5. 1 $ + // %- - - ,+ + 1 // %-1,,(*

G1 &,&01 %4* , *,% 1 % -,%1,-1 0++ /*$+ * -,$ + 1 % -'

% $ /.

01 ',-0,(-0% +,(,%+,/1 #1 0 - 1 &,& 0 1 '

0 0 1 ,$$ %&00- *01 .

%/7$,9 %'(1 #',+ // %-,+% 00 0*,(++ &,+(,% $1 +%

6$/1 "

#4056#' 0

,0 *,1-1=0%* 1 4$ ,%41' .,,'.

-1 ,* %*

#1 *$& %% -,$, %'(1 + , %#',+ // %-*,, %,%,00*

$ %0,+&41,++$ %&,$$+/,79-0,(

, -

< ;, , )<

G,.

&1 5 :

/26$3@ /#$ "

@# 5 :# 0/71