High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18284/2024disposed of

Union Of India And Others v. Arvind Gupta And Another

2024-11-06Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma10 pages

!"#"$%&

! "#

'% ()'

* +

()'

* ** * ' $#%&' ( )*+ +)* *+*+ ,+-#./+ 0 *" ( "+4+5-#./+0 ( +.#"$*-#./+ 0 "# *

* +

, !* $** +4 "-*" 0 #+- "

+& 0 * $ + # 0 * #

#+# 7 7 7 18 2- + "+

# %& * 5+ # ,# / !

%+5 // #-4* */5+,0 "# 0 *$ +0 # +%5&" 4+ +554#

- . !/01-$2 "# 9# ,& ::;+0 + 0*+5* $*/

0* ./-*/

#*# +%5

0 3"4 1"5 1667

$#"$389 1."

43""4:*) ' 3&9 1 ."

4 $2 3"""4 *'

) *39 1."

3!57#"

9 1 ."

4 +# 4+ # /*+ $# 0 , ./ 7 :*,0# /*+ $-* # +%5&4+ +

#< 7=>1/," 20 50%&*(#/+5)+ #

7 !*# +%5&5,/5+,0* "#4+ 9/# %& * ," * &- * * $ # *+ * + # +%5 4 * + %+%5 %$ +$$ +.+# %&

#0,5+ ./ 5$+$$ .#- "# 05#-%0 * 5+ # ,# / !

%+5 // #- 4* * /+ + /*+55$*+0 +# 9/ # 2!* +#-%/+, +554#.# # #+#7 7 7!*" +."+ 0* +# # 8 +/#* +0

&'(

)(

**+, = 5$+$$ .#0 ,*+0 +# # + "+

#" *1 +2-%&*5+ # ,# / !

%+5// #-* " 0#+*+ 05#* +$+ * +4 " %0 *

$ $!

# ;"#-1 ? )0 "

/#$,+@+00/.+#9#/+" *"

4 "- + 05+

+/0 # ,$4**

*%0+55,0+&# . A. +&,,% 0*#0/ "

5-%" * %$ 55#*+ ,&-# "+*+5

+$-"* %/,$5 #-+ +,,% 0*/,%++ #0/ +%5 *,- * +, ,+$#/#-&* +"" "-* " 5 ,*/%$/ +%5% * /$+5 %$/ +%5%/,+$$ +.+# %$ + %+%5,5+ ./-* +/B #-0 ,-*"

/"5 0 **9#$, #%&*CD%5"8 -/+ 5# +

! - " # "#$% #& !* 5.+ "+ +$ +"* 0 * +# . #/ + 8 +/# * +0 *-!

$ $

/ 12

*( $ " %

5 6

-7*8 !

93::05 ;)1

: $

<5 '=5 +01>

05 -1 $1:

<5 +0 1> 0$1:

<+01> 0$ 1:

<+01>C 0$

3:: 8D

1 ** E 84

/ D

;

7 -

$ )

$ $

; / . +#$1 20*+%.8 +/#"

/"5 - *$*"#5&#/5+ -*+4*+# +%5&%/, +5#" +&,,% 0*/,%++#0/ +%5 *,-+#4*/* * 8 0 > . - * "- *$* +& /* # +%5# ,,% #% .+5## 0 ,* ,&-%& *

#%+

$#*%00# +%5&"

-*+

$,0# +%5&" +& ,,% 0*/,%++#0/ +%5 *,-4*%/, +5# 4* + # +%5& + B+, 0 > , - % ," +.5&

+ #/5+ + 0 , * (#/+5 )+ #- /+##5& /$*+* +#++## +%5&%$+ %+%5

%/,$+$$ +.+#%&,5+ ./!* +##/5+ +%/,

9#%&*4

5 6

-7*8 !

93::05 ;)1 : , -*$** +"

," +

$# $

3G3$

* #"*& /+5+#,+5*+5*0+&,,% 0* #0/ +%5 *,// #- "/+55&4*+* +$0*

%/,$ 55#-* / #+%* %/,$% 4*+&# ( . -*$** * +5 +0

,"- *+ 4* +& # + * - * //

% B5&- * * +# *+""$ 0 # +1 2

$ 0+&# - %"

,#%+ B50*

$ ./ + + ,,% 0 * #0/ +%5 *, ," +.5&-* 0 "

.$*#4, B+%0

+2$

3G3$

*// #-% #*,"5& -+# /+ -* +# ,+ # /*+ $#-* "-*/5+,+ %/, 5# /.# +%5&" ( . -+55*0+/

+# / /, +/ +#+ * # 0 ./ %& * // #-+ %/5 5& / E#-* 0 #/5+ $4** * 0+&# . A. *// #- + B5B+ #

0 ,5+ ./ +#3 * +, %$ +$$ +.+# %& %$ + %+%5,5+ ./ )*++ ,+&-* %/, +5 0 *+0

/"51 2*+&* /+%#+50# +%5&" * // #-%5&"'

+2*,0+//"+/0*// #,5+ &

./- ,$ %/,$ / ##%&*(#/+5 )+ # . +. * %$ % 4* + # 4*/* *4. -%/, //5##%& $*, 0%/,5 # %2 & 0 # + * 0 - ,+& +5

% B5&%/,//5##%&*(#/+5)+ #- + 0 , # 0 ,5+ & ./ %$ + %+%5,5+ ./- * +,%$+ /$+5# -0*,#/+5"*5# *+*# /5# *+.%#/#,#/+58+,+0*// #%$ ,+#-* "

* %/,$5 # ./-* " -*

+,455%#,#*+.+ # $ ./-&*

+1 +2-*(#/+5)+ # # +* 0

//5#$ ( . - +5 #/5+ # +-*+ ,+#+ & 0 *(#/+5)+ #0554*$#5 5+##4*+" 0*F #(#/+51(5+ & 2- GFH5,'

+5 /"5 F 7 !* 0 -*+ %4# ,#4** , 0 *+%."

/"5 -4** +*,05 ,0*"

"#* ,&-* +0 +"

5,+ &,#/+58+,+ %$,+# $

33$

*+5*-* +%/+, / ##+%

,# % $*,+#3 4** ,%/+,+""## *+* +## 4+ +# ,+ +$( . - +5

;

#%# ,#-0 ,*0+/ +*+#-4** * + /+ +58 * "0*# -+#3 * $

0 -* "

-* " * 55,0*"

"# +@$ "5+/- $

33$

* +/. # %& *, 0 ,5+ ./-4* -* ,+&//5#*+* 0 *# % 4+ + B50* $ ./* ,& +#+ /*4+ + %+%5 %/+,+$$ +.+#%&* $ ,5+ ./ +##- +5 #%$+* #0 ,*

/ # -4** *(#/+5)+ #-##+55&"

/#,+@+ #+5#/ .+/#+5/*/@-"+ /5+ 5&+"" +$* +#.0*# -* $*,"5&, 0+0 ,#/+5 /*B - * .5$ * %5/@ /*+ $/ //- 4* 0 , - *# %/+, /#( . -0* +# ,"5&,0+5 5+5&-* ,+&%/,//5##B+ " * 0-* % B*+"" 5 ,+@$ "5+/- 4+ /$+5%4# $ #0 ,5+ ./% # %$+ %+%5 %/,$+$$ +.+# %&" 0 ,+/0,5+ ./ + 5&-0* +,"5&# /*B +* +$0+"" 5 ,+@$"5+/-* %&* (#/+5)+ #// #-5+# +//5 -*+* +

# ,+/#/ 0+&# -%&* +## ,+# *%$*5 ,0+&"

5*+ ,&-+.& +

0 / 5+5&* % B+/.#/3 "* 0 - # $*/

0 #0,5+ ./-%45#+ +55& 5+#+455//5 %&*(#/+5)+ #-*+ +/. "

% %/+, /# 0 , + 00/. /+ +5 $/ // 4* * 45#%#+50# +%5&" = C4. -4* +##+. -* # %8 +/$*/ 0*"-+ %/+, / ##%&*

5+ ,#/+5%+ # '( '

')*+,-, ./' + +55+ *"0* +%5&4* .//# * 4 +%5& %+%5

./ $$ +.+# %&

./1I3

//# 4* ./ + 3/+ 3 "/0/ /# +# " #

./ 1I3 1I3 1+2 ,+ & C&"

/+ +5

5+ *"

./ +%5 *# 1%2 & 5"#,+

IH (+%5/ #

1/2 ,"5 % &

IH +5 #

? +#$0* / # .+5 *++*,0* +"" 5 ,+@$"5+/ %/+,,+# ,

0*"

/"5 1 +2#/5+ #%&*CD%5"8 /+ 5#+

! "0 $%&*(#/+5 )+ #-*+ ,# 4*/**4. -##0 %#*"

"#-%/,5 #* ,&-##,+@ "

5,+ & $ 0 - * #/5+ + 0 5+4 9#$, 1 +2 *+ * +"

,"*+*/

$0* +## 4+ + B50 #0 ./- #%0+. +%5& #4#. +. * "#!*$* * +# "

%+%5%* 5+#.#/ %* +#"

," %/+, /+ " * " C4. - * +# /+ .#/ +##/$# /*+ $$ . +. * "#- 0 /$5&

%$* +#"

,"-%+ +55&+5 ##/+ +

#&+5 "*(#/+5)+ #-$+$ 50*#+. 0 + *$- * $* ,"5&, 0 * + 0 %5/@ /*+ $/ /+ +5 // /*B1 2- 4* ,+& %/+, +.5#*+* $0*# *+ ,&"

5- %/+, /#0 ,+/#+5$/0+,5&* &( . - 4+ +5 #% +#*,#/+5"-*+ *# %0 +4550 ,# 4+ +/$+5# +#%/+,* +$$ +.+#%& %/+,+ %+%5,5+ &

./ ; C4. -+ +#$0"1 +2-# /5 *+*+

% / ##+ &"#0 ,+# *+.% / ## * 8 1 +2 +#5&- / .#/ % * ,"1 +2*+ %5#%&*" -* -* / +#$.4$*+$*"0*,#/+5%+ #- + 8 +/# 1 +2 "/ 5&- * / #/ /+ % +

$#* +550 ,# -% # * * $ 0*# /+% +#%+ B50+/#+5$/ 0+,5&* & + 5&- #%#/5+ #+ 0 ,

#0,5+ ./+##- #%#/5+ # %+ %+%5 %/,$+$$ +.+#%& #0,5+ ./ %&*"

"# - / , 0*9#$, #%&* "8 -/+ 5#+ 1 @

'%&2 4* -+#/5+ + ,+#* 8-*+*%00 #$00- *+ %/,#4#

*// # 5+5&+5 * #

+#0+ %5 $* %/+, . # * "

"# 0 * @$ B+ * +"" #$ 00%$,+#* 0+. : H. * 4 / * #/5+ + 0 5+4 ,+# . #/1 +2,+@ * +##/5+ +%+8" 5+05+4 ,-* -*8" 5+05+4 ,-+ ,+#. #/ +2+5 ,+@ ** #

#%0 . +. * #0/ "

5 // #- -

- +5 5 * // #-* ++&, @*$ +$0*#4, +

,+#* #

-+#*+-*055 /,"5,-+ "5 #

-% #

"/.0*%+ -0+&-0#5+&+#5+/* !* 0 - * $ +$ 0 * %0 0 * +""

#$ 00- , 0*. #/1 +2 #%&*!

%+5 // #-+5 # 00 0 ,+&55$+5&+# #% "*5#

"$ . 12 1 ;"#-1 +0 ,+*-* 0# , *4 " +#4*% .+ +%.-* +, # ,

# !*,"$# # -+ "+

#%&*5+ #!

%+5 // #- ,++#+#+00 ,# 7 " #0+5$4*+55"#$+""5/+1 2-0+& 3*

* +

3* * '4 & JK ** "+@$3 # '

I ** " +%5 '