High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/7535/2015allowed

Vizender Singh And ORS v. Guru Jambheshwar University Of Sciences & Technology Hisar

2016-12-13Mr. Justice Darshan Singh50 pages

!"#$#%# &### #% # % ''(

)

! "

% $#$ %& )*

' ( () #() %& )

*%+ ( () #() %&

+**

,) -

." # %& ,*)

/("

&0 () #() %& +

1 () #() %& + **

2 ! "

%& + ))

34 ( -

# %&

5 6") 6 #% ) %&

78) () #() %&

77$

() #() %&

7'9 -

# %& ,,

7*"):" 6 %& ,*

7, 0 6 %&

7/; )

." # %& *

71; 6 #% ) %&

72;

&" 6 %& )

73 6 6 %& *

75&

6 #% ) %& ,

'8(

%& )**

'7 &! 6 #% ) %& + ,)

'';" + () #() %&

, )

'*%+

$ %& * ,

',64 <

)

) '/ +( () #()

% %& )),

) '1;)

6 #% ) %&

) '2 "( () #() %&

) '3( () #() %& ,

) '56 () #() %& , ,

) *86 ) 6

%& +*)*

) *7;

6 %& ++

) *' ):"

6 #% ) %& ,

) **;& () #() %& ,

*,$ 6

! "

#$; %& +

) */; + " ! "

#$; %& + )

) *14 6 #% ) %& )++

*2;( 6 #% ) %&

)

) *3 % 6 -# -"" #$ %& --- #.( /$0 . "1 #"2# # ## = 6%(6")# ;

6%&"(

6%+6#;

# 6 ) " #;

# 6:

& (#;

# ) #;

# 6 .":"#;

# 6 % #;

# 6 4 "#;

# 6("

4"#;

# 6 :

+#;

# 6;

0 #;

# 6("

4"#;

# 6:

& (#;

) #;

# 6 ++

6")#;

# 6&);

"#;

# 6&)( #;

# (%

# & 6;%#;

# 6; "#;

# & 7 ->?7'32,#71'**#7/,78#7/2//#71,,8#72,78# 787/'#',/'3#7'733'87/#/113#5,1,#558'#7'581# 7*155 64 :

+#;

# & ?

->473'/8'87/ 6;(

# & ?

-->473'/8'87/

)#;

# & ?() 6; #;

# & 47 ->47/8/8#5/,,#2/*/'87/#7'/3/7'/58'871 6 " +#;

# 6; ( "#;

& '->?',/'3'87/ 6! #;

& ->45/11 78**7'87/ #"2# # ##3" !

& "" "

" &

; " ''1 - # @ " #! ; & " " #% A ; ) " " " & "

-"" ? ? 6 ) ; - " "

& &" " &

$ : &" & "" # ; && - () #() # ! "

# $# -

# # <

# % -

." # "" "& & B C-"" " )& ) "" " " )& ) ) & & " "

)

& B C-"" "" & & "" "" "&& !

& & " & & " &" " "" & & " " - #4"

" 8/8''878 " # & A D & !

) & B C-"" " & " "&" & + - " %"#7528# &&" "$ "" # ) - ?

" "& " & " @ " #! ; # % 9A : ; & ' < & -% " "" D "

< 6 -"" ) # #"# " & % " !

- < # " E% " 6 F" ;&& ! ; -"" 6 6 $

9 #'878G E% " B'878G# &

* !

% " D" && -"" ! # . #

"9 &

& "< - % " B'878# & # "" "" , !

% " & &; " && "

& 7888C? & " A " " '/#888C? & !

- " "

" C ! ! $ # 2 - " - %& / !

% "

- "

&- "

# 755, && * -- /71 = 755/ 7 -! 7 "

% " !

&&" "" "+

" E4+6") $ G#7551, -!77* : +

" -> 4',,,2 '87' " E; " ( $ G 8/8*'87* 1 !

" % " - &&"

& # . & " " "

" - #" " & -"" -"" ? ? !

$ & % " - 7557 % " &&" " && -"" "

" ; "

% " - " " # "

& " "" -"" &

-"" " !

" & - "; # "; ; # #

* - ; #75/1 2 @ ) +

&""=? 7 "

; + &" A A

" "

" = () H -> 478'38#78'25#3,1/#1,2*#5787#75*31 1272"" '87/H->4238'#22/7#2'77#7873'#*8'1""'871 =->47'/58'871

." H->47/8/8#25,, '87/ -

H -> 4 5/11 78**7'87/ <

# 6&#%H; @ " -> ',/'3 '87/ -> 73'/8 '87/ I4= ")&@ " &*"J ' "

. C; & & "

"" " () "

" "" ) "" " " + # = -> 4'83'1'87/ ->718**'871 *!

" =->4787/'#72,78# 71,,8#7/,78#71'**#7'733#7/2// 7'32,""'87/ ,!

! ; " "

! "

#$->45/,,'87/# 2/*/'87/I 6 -J -> 7'/3/""'871 "

"" &7& && & K " " L ;

" - '87, "" " / % A 6 # % ) -> 4 5,1,# 3'3/# 7*155# /113# 558'# 7'581""'871

3 @ " # D "" &

& # D" & D" )# " +"" " ""+ & & ; !

) " & " -> 42/*/ '87/

/' ! ; ! "

#$#A & & 5 :"

&# ! "

#$ I->2/*/'87/J

& ! ; !

" &&" " " """ -& D" " & ; & - D" # A& @ " C " -"" C " E")? ? G " & & " & !

&& " ! ; & &" "" " &"

"" " )"

" # " !

&& ! ; "

;

" - " " '*#888C?& &*88/'87/# & "" " && # "$ # &" &&

7'83'87, ; A ?* "

" " " "& "H && "" "" " "

"" & "!

& & + ! ; I J;"& && ; # @ " # 9A . A 78 !

- #4"

D" @ " # ! ; "

& % " ! C-""

-% " "

&& & !

- &" 1 % - "

& - " " E!

;&& C$ C ! ! G# " - 8/8''878; A?, % #;" 6" #;" !

" "&" ! "

"" # & # 77 !

"" "&& # & "

& - $ &&

+ #'8827* --'5'!

" &-

&&"" " " && # "

" & " "

"" " && !

" "

+ !

" & "

&&" "

&" " && A& # "

" " -"" && &

A& $ # &- && $

- &" "

" & " "" " & && 7' 6%(6")#" "&& " & " & # " & " +

&& "

& &" "

) && &

"" &" " & " + "

< "" A & "

-> 45*88 '87/ " E6 6 ) $ G 8/8/'871!

& ; C9A . " "" % " & & "" &" " + . "

D & "" ) &"" "" MH & "

" & M & " 7888C?&" '/8C?& - " M !

& "" "" !

D +

- " ->47*5,1'88, " E; "( 6 #% ) G# " & &-+

% ." $ # 753/, --,* @"": +

- -> 47,251 '88* " E;

+G 7777'877< @"":

# "

# "&& ) " &#&& " & & D" && "" " " # "" " " & " ; & A 78

&&" +

'777'87, .; 4'78, '87* . - 43/8, '87/ "& &- 728,'87/!

# D & "

" & "

% D & # " "

" & : 6 "

" #I->4'*2''877 8,78'87*J

" . # -&& & 7888C?&" + A '/#888C? & && . ;&&"47*2'87," +

'/8''87/ ; "" &" "

& " &!

" & & ". ?

; # 7* ; < +

# < " ?A & ""

&" & &" "

C C " && & " && & & ) "

# 7888C?& " + '/#888C?& : A&

- & + & "" " &"

& # < "

6 ! && -

->45/11'87/ " E4 ( - %

".;47*2'87,

#" - "

818''878 I " ) && J "

" & " """ "" D &" - .; 47*2 '87, !

& .; 47*2 '87, " E: 6 " "#( &(" #

% & G '/8''87/ " & 6 & ""= K!

&&" & ) &"

' !

D - - "" - "C &&"" ? !

&&""

818''878 :

" - & 1 % - " && C C?

!! !

- C?

D" & "

& 7888C?&" + A '/#888C? & !

" & & 4 7 5 && . & 7281'878K>")?

?< L & . + !

& " ?. & '/8C?&" + A78#888C?& * !

D - G 818''878 &&"" , 6 )# " ;

" ;

" && $ +

: - 8/8*'87* && - "> 4',,,2'87' !" "#$ ! " < &&"" " "

&&"" " &"

&& - " "

&" / < # &&" 4 "

& "

" "+ """ "" D L 7, !

& - " 818''878 6 & +

N "

# " "

"" & ; - " $ I->4715/,'87/ 8/8/'871J 7/ < 6 & & && "A $ - +

)

0 & #'8817'

--,3' & < &,# &- = K, < ""?" & &" " && & C & & "A & "

&< # & &

& && " &" && + & D &

& & &" && "" & && "& "A # & ) && "

&& " "

& &" !

" " & # # "" + < " ""?" " "

- && C& "A & "

& ) " L 71 ; "

# & &"" &

& " && &" ) &" "

& A

& "" &&

" D " ; " - "A " " &

& &" "G "

" "" # & -"" & "

" "

&& D" !

A "A# &" # #&& # #& " " "

#+ ; #@ " . #% # ! ; "&"

& " !

) " " ) : # & " & &" " " # & # #

") "" !) A&" " "

& "

"" "

) ) &" & ? & " # & " " & " "

& & 9D" & " " "!

? ? < & & & "

"# A& G " " && " "

" " ) "" A "& "

& <"

72 6 " - -

# G# & $

" $ 9A 8283'87, ! &

'* ', " && & " - && & " C; C; ! " & ""=

K'* 7 ;"" && & "" 9A - " " - ' && -"?; & ?

C " "" 9A - "# 9" C " - * ;&& &-"?

: "" ?

- "" &"

& " " ;&& "

& -" - &" "" % &"

& " " , 4 "7# ' * # ?- "" # # ) & && & A A # &" ") "&& > && 9A - "# ) ?- "" "" & 9A - " A ', 7 ; " - && C &C & "" =? ?- ""H @ " H - & & # H & A &

?- ""H

& #

# ?

- "" & "

& ; - " & " ) "

+ "" H ?

- ""

& " & " & ; - " A # - "" ' !

& " & ; - "

# # ?- ""# & # "" + && " - "" A& " & " -# & # & "" " & " - "" " A?

" -" * !

?- "" "" & " - % "" !

" - "" ?- "" , !

" - "" 9A - " && < 9A - " " &

-# "" - "" " '/ !

9" - "" N '1 7 !

; " : "" ? ?- ""H &

"" && - "" ?

- "" H !

% "" : ' !

: "" &" && &&& * < ""

&" "& & ""

& L 73 $

;

" - ',7# " ED" && & &"G ; "717 - & &" & -"" && ? ? & $ #

&& & ") & & & & "? & -"" ? ? " !

& "

& "" "" "" ; # " " &"

?& !

D "

" &&"

& &" &" # & " & &" &" " !

&& & & " "" ";& " # " " ; " 71' - & A A& @ " # ?

!! #! ; #; # && ; A& N # "

& &" "

- &" " "" " & " "

" ""

& !

" "!

" : & "# 75 !

& - %

& 7532 !

" " & !

&- %

" "

; "*' - " " "" - # " "

& " " &

" " + #

" ! && & "&

%& D ""

& "

=? '(

" " ")

#"!

" * " " +" " "

" ! "

"# !

$ !

, #" "

"# - "&" &"" "! "

, "

"# - !

$ !"

, #" "

! "" !" " "!" "$ # $ , , "# ! "

" !

* !# !#"

"#"$ ( !$"# +" " ""

$ "

, .

+" "#$ # ! " !

( ,

#" ) "

"! "

, #" " "!

!," * "$ #, " ( "

" !

#" "! "# - " "$ ! $ * ! # , "# # * !$ .

, "#

"#$* " " ! " ! "

, $ !

!(#

! ,

" ! $& $ *"! ,

!" , # "# ""*

$!"*

"# "! !""

& ! & $ , " +"

, # !

! "

",$ "

" "# " $ "# " !" ! ,$ +" .

! "

! " ,$ ' ! #/ " $ .

* " " , "# ! ! "$ ! " !"

", "! "

, *

, "!" "#

+" ", -" ". " "! " " $ ( ,"! "

" " ! " " ! ! !$ .

" $ "# '! "

/ #""* !,$ +" #"" "! ! " , "# 01 ! 02 "# 3" " " ", !" $ " (

" $ +" -

!"# " "!

"$ 4 & #" &!

+" " ! "#

" !"! "

, "* *" ! " "* "

* " "* "!

" ! "

, " "

!$ # !.

* " "**"" ! "

, # $

, ! )# " $ "$#", " ! $ "

+" $ " " !

$ $ )

" "# - )# " "# -

, !#"" " "

"# "

* " ,

"# $ "#'! "

/ " (#$"# "

" !

$ - ) ! " , ! $" !

, " !

! ,$ +" ! " "!

4 "$ !

" $ "# +" !

* '! "

$!"*

#" "!"# ",$

"" # ", "# $ # !"," .

'! "

, !

$!"*

#" "!"# " " $ "! "##

. "

* " !" $" ! " , !

(# " $ "

& $ $" 3""#,!$ .

"!$! "

!"# '8 !

& "" " " @ " #! ; % A &?

& &" &" & " "< " # & &" %#

" "

- ""

D A&" && & "& " "# # # -"" " < % && && > A& & - "

&&" &" & ;

) & ""

& " " && " & D ""

) " &

& " " " & & " ; ""

D "" && "" ) "" &&

& &" " ?&" ") & ;

& ""

" " : &&" " &" " "

& "

)&&" "

-"" "# "# "

& &&" " " N ; "7, 71 - " &&" M>

& ) : < "

" " +> &? & " ) & ?" " A "" #") && # & " !

) H

" "" "" &

# ?" & " & '7 !

"# "

" & "

& "

?? & < D # ""

"" "" & ; # ! ; # @ " % " " & " "" !

" &"A

" ""

" - "

" " & &" " "" "") & &" !

) !

) ! -

" && "" & &" ) " "

") "?

) "" !

+ "A& "

& && # C -"" & + & && " - # 4 "

" !

" " " #" & & # " A & "

" &< ) "" " "

; #! ; #@ " % " " && &A "" !

" "& " # & '' $ # # - ) & & ?& &&

A&" " & & &- % !

" ; " /7;+ + " & # # A&" " & " " " +& " "<&& "

" & &" + #D ?" )?

" "

& "" <

# & # "" )"" "& &" " & #

"" "&& H +" " " & " & & & "" ED"& D")GA&" &- $

- & ; ; && &# # + " & & " & " # < "

" "

& ! ; #@ " % "" ) & &" & D" ) & D" & " "" D" !

" " & & " "

" " " & " " " &" ! ; #@ " % G " !

D" ; ) & "

! ; A && & & A " ") ; "

"" "

&" & '* < "" "& "

) "A & ', < &&"

E &" G# #"" "" # "&& ""?" & "

&" " &# "

" "

# ""

&" "" " ""+ #& ) -&" " ) & ) " && !

" " & & "

""" " " "" N "")& "

& !

" " " ) &

&& !

&& < "" ""D"! ""

"" ) &" ") & D & && &" # & "" &

# & & " & & & A " # & " " - & " )!

"" " ) &" && & " & > " "

< &" "

) " && &"

" & # "

? ""

"" "&" !

") - & "" ) E ?

&" G "" "

" " ") ") %# & 5, "#$ #'88'' -!*/,: -"" # " ? ? & "

? & &""

#&" "

"" I ) "" J "

"" "

&# "" D"#A " & "

'/ $ # & ? ? # "

#< )# &"" &&"

& &" @ " #9A . ! ;

" " & - )" : ? ? && " ? & &"

D" & &" &

& &&"

D" & D") '1 !

&" & "" &

? ? &" &"? # & &" "

&&"

"" "

D" " - " & & D""

& > "&&"

& "& &"# -

" 818''878"

& " A &" % " &"" " & " "" & & + '2 < & "&& # ! ; # @ " ! % " ; "

A # " "

" && " " & & & "" &

% "

&&"

> "A A C "

" & " "" ) "" &" & C !

"" " #

"" ; 7'

& & & 2 : " & " & ; & & "" &-" + +

&&" N '1#'871 - ";&&"4 '7*'87*6 @"": - ;

+#'87'' -!*7='877,% /'' " & &" " + # &- "

& & /' &=? K/' < "" " # "" $

- ;

+ N -> 7,251 '88*# 7777'877#"" # !

- + N %+

N# .; 4 **2 '88*#

27'885""" # " > + N %+ ( .; 78','885# *83'878# # &" "

" & ? "# " # "

" "" & "

'3 !

& "& " "& 6 & & "

& & // +

" " +& -&&"

!D=? K//< #"" " & " ; &" )# & " # & & "- "

# " # ) ;

# &"" )" # " "

#& " "

# "& # " # @ ) #

& "

# & " ;

#& " # & ""

# A&" " # &

# && # && # &" " + L '5 ; A&" =!

" %

" "

"C-"" - & ")@ " ! ; !

" "" ""

! ; #@ " ! % && &

" " -"" " && " *8 ;"# & "" ""

"" "&& # " & " # && I ; J & & " " & && & " C $ # ! ; # @ " ! % & &" "

" & & " H "

# && & ") ; "

# " & &" A & ) D" " "

& &" & & )

" & &"D"& D")# &A "

" & + 6 " "" & "" &+

&- &" " " ""

" & - & +

; " "

" & & & &" " & & !

& "

&" - " #" " '878 "

: & &" ; &# "

" " & " " " & & && D" ) "" &H " "

& - 6 N '1#'871" "" & &" " @"" : +

- & : + %+

#'8853 .%2**= '885 , -! 33 " " " : +

+ %+ ( # .;78','885 " ; 3#'878# &" "

" & " " # "

" "" & "

# & &" C "

C &" "

& ""

" " " 6 &!

& """ & "&& *7 - D "

#& &7'

& & 2 "" & & "

&" D" & "7/#188? *5#788C?# # : &" ; " 1#888C? '7#188& & '/#188 & ;"" "" & " "&" " D" "

& # & &" " " & 6 & $ #

" ""&" & "" &" " &" & "

" !

& & "" " & & . C; & "

" D" & < " "&" # E" # G & &" & + ?

C ?!

" "" A & " " " ; "7, 71- " " - !

) "& "

" & + " < # # & & " " "

&& & "" " &"

& &" !

&A& - *' ! " " &# "

""=?

** !

& "

@ " % & " & &&"

& &" ED" & D" )G + D & &" "" " " &&"

& &"" 6 & ; && & !

" A &" !

D")D"& " " !

&" ""

" ""A & "

& " ED"& D")G "

&&" " & D "

# & "" & ) <" & " )$#" )*"G )&" & "" D"!

# -# - & & "$ #") ; "

"& &" <"

" ?"# ?

& " !

) A&" & A & ) " !

& "

; " " &" & D" ) " !

& "

"" & & " && " " & &" ) "

& & & " !

" "" ) & "" " " A& " *, !

" @ " % & " + &

&" & - " " & - " & "& && $ # " &" " A - > " "

&& &7#888&" " " "" " & ) "

" " & " " & A&" &" &" " " @ # @ " 78 "

,/8C?&. A'2#888 6 #% ) & & " && & - & 7#888C? A A'2#888C? "

A !

% I6 J & + $ # % ")@ " D " " "

A ""

" &@ " % "" " "&" <"

&" A &!

") ; & &

" -"" ; @ " <

#% "

" & " "

A&" 3 & &" " & & &" 4; @ " L && " )" &" & ; @ " # " "

" + ""? + "&" & < ; @ " < #% """

" !

" )

& < '*5'87/" < #% ->73'/8'87/ K!

& " & " & L!

& & * & ) " &; & 6 " " " '87,?'87/!

K )L!

- " C 2''878 & &" O7#888C?A'/#888C?

&& < # & -> 73'/8 '87/ ;&&" - & (

49! D" A '87/?71 & & !

- *73'87/ & "" &" "&" !

& & - !

"& ) " && &

< ->',/'3'87/ < #% " &"

& '57'871 &" <"

&&"

& &" ? & & !

"" " &7 *1 6

" " & " "

& "

" !

# " &" "

D & #&"# & 6 : ; # 7517 "# > C &")"

" " ) "

@"&" A& "

&" "

" " """ " & " ) && " $ # "

& ""

"" & , / !

C-""

&" " " "" "" & & & 2 # "

&" *2 !

& "

; & 7 && C& &"

" &" ? "" "

"" "" & + "" # # "

) " # "

& &" ) + ) !

" & ? " " "" " & &" . & &- 6 && " &" " "& && "" & " &" " & &" & & &" & & C "&" !

& & " " "" "" ;""

& " "

& & " & "

& ; " <" & ) "

& *3 !

"" &'->4718**'871 -> 4 '83'1 '87/ " & "" "

() "" & !

& "" " "

&" "" " & " "" & & ->4'83'1'87/ " " ""

" && A " *5 4 " "" "

& # & + " ?) &" ) ""

# "" & "

& & "&" ) & A& & D" < " && "" N

&" "

+ ) " ) &

& !

&&"

& 4 "#

& )&" "

" D -"" & )& +

,8 ;" & "

#"" & & "" &"

# A & & & **

" " & ; "

# &

) 5 #"2# # ##6 " "%

7 " !8

", 8 9