← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/27864/2017dismissed

Narender Singh v. State Of Haryana & Others

2019-11-06Mr. Justice B.S. Walia9 pages

  

    

"&'$'()*)#+ 



, 

 

 

   

 

 '-'+ #./0' -1*&)('2"0)" 

 ! "#$ % &' ( )     $% &'  

  

$ *%+$     $% &'

, -. /01,2/ ! ("+"$% &'

3 -. /4420  

+

$% &'

, -. /4420 555 2"0)"3 -"0!    

'

 6

"' 7

 )    $% &' ''

 '

"

"' 7

  89   :

56

;    :



$ :

 ""(

  %:

 ( 

 

 "

"'   #

")#"*' <= > 

 ""

'

 -. /01,  2/ "

   - '  -

8"

:

   (      %        89 '   ( ""-./4420  

 '

"8"

 

:

 %     $  & ( -& 8



8



 " '  -;' &

#

 :-./01,2/ <= ?  ' ' "

 "  ( 

 

%

@ 7(

8   8"'

&'

-:: 1221 & 

:      %     $ -""

  -

  -6AA   89 '   %

' 

:

 

$ " 8: 

( @

22421>

( '":  8 "8"

      %        8:

 :$%

@ 738  '6 8: 

 :

'":



 :



6 

  

    

    !  "  

 "  #$%  "

"    &'()

546

%

" 

 "    '

"'  (

 +&

78"' '  B

# $   (  &

" :

"8: - :  (  . 

   ( '

'

    ' :

   



   24232/ 

"    ( 

   (

 212/ (

 ( (

 '

"

  : 2/"",2/ <3=

  "    ( 

     212/$

"

-./01,2/ 242/('("

    2/2/        - '

'  (' 

   8 :   22/ " ""

  -

8:

8

 2321 <,=

- "

8 )     $% &'



$%

@ 7,

2321( '



  - (  

  

 (



  8:

    -   22/  -. /01,  2/ ( "

         2/2/   ('  ("

  

'

  : $ 

 (

'

  '"" 

   (   D  & ""  ""( E

    (   - 

 

*

 :

F"

 F '     

$

    (   32/ 

 

" '

$

: : # "'

 '

  %     ( $ -(

8



" 212120(



56

(

'

'

   D  (

, * :8 $ 2/ 

  " "    

42/ <4=

"

 :

"

- " 



 "  

  - 2321

(

' (#

:

$ 8:



22/

'

"

   - 

 

 :

"   212120 '"

 ( #  

9 '

<1=   '  $ "

 ' "     -::  '  '""



"

 ::# '"

  '

"' 8 

+&

78"' ' B

# $

"    :

 (

  8  :



  :

 '  '" D

 (  "

 '":

 : D  

"' 8: - :   (C

' "'

  D

 ( 

":   '

 '

' ( 

@:  $

:

 '

'



' "  '

 ' '  (8 

 8  

(1221

:

( @

8' 

:22421

"

'":

    - 2321 8 # ' 6  -8

G

(

""

" ( 

  212/ 

    " 

   

   

5%6

  - 22/

 (

"

( 

242/ </=

 - " '

  8     :$  ((

'

'

(

,* :8 $2/

 "

"

42/(

 '::

   '

'

 (

 :

 -::     ':

    

:

  '

'

   '::

 $

:

 (

 :

 2/20 

  " 

   : 

    '  

  

 ( :&

$  :

(



 "('

:

  '

'

 (

:

 <0=

' "  -:: '

 

 (  8  ''

 ("

  "   '

 

  ("

   '

  '

':

   "8" :



  ' :'

 " "C

' " 

 '  

8 -::   :

"

   8:    -  :    8

 '  "" ""(

  :" ' ""'

7    

:

 1,/ %     & '    <= 

"8

"

"

G   * ' $F"

 F ' $   # $ ' 4$  '#" <2= 

 - " '

  

 '

 8 :

   ' 

"

" 

"

-./01,2/ "

G

56

( (     -$    - ( 

  8 "

"  212120 <= 

 ' "     -::    

    &   

     '   

  - $( $  '

'

  8  ' ': 



 

 '  

#

       (   :  8 

   :  C

 ' "    '

    '

 8:

  - 2321$

 

 ( "

& 8:

 :

 "

   "

  ( 

&#    9  '     -    

 8"

   :

          

   -  (  

 : 

"  ""

" ( 

  <=  >

  - 23218

      :

 #  

 @'

  "



       -   22/  8$ 

 ( (   &

   -  :

"  (   '

 -  :  "

 :     (  %" 

 '":  &

  - ""(68'# 2321$ &     (

' :  '"

 

 : 

"  

""(  D 88: 

:

  :

&#  9  ' -     '

 '":

56

   -%" '

G   -   

  ( 88"

$     ' :      '    :

  

'      8 

  

 ("

 &



'"     - 8  '

      (( $8



8& $  " " ( 

( "" ((

42/(

  -( 

:'" 212120>

"   -

 *

 :

(' "'

D

' :

      -::  (' (  '::

 

' %"

'":&

""   - 2321$  : 

'"

 

 

 "    "" 

   "   212/   (' 

         -  

 :

 2232/      ( &   &#

 9  '    -      

            - 8 '

 

'":

&

8:

2321 <3=  '  :

 8: ':



"



   8  '

      

 $   :

 ("

  :8  "E

 <,= 

 ' "     -::  

 

' "710 -"/7"8"-9 1#:"/'(7#)("0 #)9'-*)&;3 ,,

!

< 4'

  :

' 

&



$8 ' 7

 :& 8  '" 



 

 ' 

&   :   :

  C

 ' "  

         

 &  8

56

':

& ( 

"

- "

:

 &

:

$8

$  

8

&

$



"  

 <4=  & '

8: "

' " 

  $A: & ("



   - 22/ 

" ( 

   212/$      - (  

 "" 212120 (



"  "

' ('

'

 : ,* :8 $2/(

42/(

 & (  

  "

 - "$ 

:

 &  " 8

 :

2/20>

 :

 :  



8: 

 :   21    '":       - (   8 '    &# 9  ' -  "

" ( 

 22/

 "(

""242/ ('  "

( 

     - <1=  ;  

"$     &    $  

 '     -8  @

  ( 

8"

 :  ':

" (   '

   "

 : ('

$$ &

:

#



   '' ("( </=  "   

8& $( 

 -. /01,  2/ 

 -. /44  20  :

( $ '' "

G '



       - (  8"

   :

$ ' 

5,6

  42$22276   :



      8  *

 :

7 

( "8   *

 :

7 '& ' : '

8"

"       -   ':

"  (  '    " 9'

? ." H  212 : 1. Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No.

2. Whether reportable Yes/No.