Avtar Singh v. State Of Punjab And ORS

  
  



  


   

 ! "# $ %&'

( )( 

*+ %, $ -.!.%&'

( )( 

/  0

(( +.+.%& "

/ "!1!

0   



0

(( !2%&$ &+!

 '

3 4 ( 0


4 50 
 



    

  







 
  !"

     # $ 

%&     # '

4 50  ( (

& & 





*  +   +*    

* 


 &

*


 +

   & "    &  * , $( -' $-$.  

 &   &

  /      &     +*  

$

 &  





 

 , -' -( $-($   0& 1 & & 2" & 

 &  0& 1 &

&&  "

  "

          &

.

 &*

     && 3

   
       


 
  




 

  


    !"!#$!%$ 
         &

'(


&



 ('
 '

 )
  *

     
*
 
+'
   '

' , -
.


*'

(  /012+'

 '(*


+'
'  &%34#  !3!#$!%$ 
*  '



+'
     * 
 
  2+'
  
      
     

  


   *



 -, 

5 
  2   
      
  

'    *

  
 
 ( 

('      (   
   
+'
  
  
    
 '
 -, 

5 67

8'






 



('  '*





  
 

   
  
  
  
  '*

    


* '

*'

( 


'

*'

(  
 '  3!4  !#!4$!%$
 ' 



**
(
  '*

 (' 
 
 '*

!4!#$!%$

   '
 
+'
  '  
  
* '

(  

  *  





 , 


'*
*
)'  !%!4$!%$

 

 

(' 
  (   
*      9


*  

('    4%!4$!%$    



**
' 
( 
 
+'
 '

( '

*'

(  
2    '
  

 (     0     

*
(
  


  


 '



 *  


   *
(')
 *

 ' **

 -
 
  
*
*-, 

5  
  2       67

 8'  






' ('
 


(

  '*

  ('





*

   )
    '
* 

('
   *
  *
)'    

  *    *     * 
*  * 


( 0'7(8*:*

 '6' %;<<(
 '(

 *


 
   -
='

 

      


 
  
 

 
   
  
 
  
(   0'

*  '   0'7( 

  
  /0'

*  16' %;3!' 6'>?

'

4   &&   &&&

3

 &%@ *     
  
'*    

 *

  
 
 


  

    
       


 



 &$@ 2      *       
'

 '
  **
 ( 


  
  
 
  


('
*
*
)'

 &4@

*     
  
'*   


 
     

          *  ('


*
 


6'>%;<</ 


  0

   6
1    6'  ;

/ 


*    8*1  
    (  
 





 &"@

*     
  
'*   


 
 

  
  
 *   
(

 
  
 


 

?

)

  & &  

  &    & 



 "

&&   & 

 4

 

  $-(( 

&  &

 %&

 2"   

&* && 3 *7 %,  $.-.& 82."9

*+  7*.&.&:

7%1&+

.& !( 83)/

& $9 2 * $-($ '/:;.$ ('': '-

/**&

& .(  $-($ $/6;($ ('(( $-

*& ) & .(  $-($ $/5-;(-- ((7- --

)& '-.- -- :

   &*   

  +* 

      &  &&&

&&*


  +*  
 &

* &  # $   &* 

    # (

&&*



 # .

'





&*  &* *  

&* 

    &  <  # $

 &
 &

*      =    # . *    &* /




 

*

  &*           & /



 >  &

&* +*

)


" 0 %&       +*   ?/
=.@ 4   &&

&&     4 &&

& :

 ? &* A0B

& (966 A  C(966

&DB  &

 / 3 >



    A%B  &  8*  * 

  ) 
   
'


CA 
( ' 
B 

 
 '


 

  * *      

       

 '(

CCA
:
-
B CCCA$B&8**

)
 
'


 8*  
(

' 
)
 (

  

'
 


 
(  
(' 
 




 
  
 
    *    *'

    '

*'


 *   0
  ' 


(+'
 


'  
('
  (    

 
     ' 


 


  ; 


*8*D&8**



(  
*

   '*  '(


 
    *   *'

 '

*'


 *   
**'

 


   '(
  '  *    *       

D /
1

    


* '

 8* 2
  8*    0'7(          8*E /

1 

 
 (    *(
     
 (  8*0'7( 8* 2
 8* 
2
E /


1 

 
 (    *(

     
 (  8*2
 8* 0'7(       8*      
  E 

 

'



* * 


)

(8* * 
 
 

  
   
     ' *  '
 

 
*?

; (- , & 

& :

&& (966

&  

  &&    & )  &&   &

& :

& & 

  && *

 &   *   *  

&*  

 4 


   &




 

 4  * 

 ,     

         * E 

 4   

 &
  )  -' -5 $-($  

&  &     &"

  ) &* 

 

 &         *  3 0& 1 &

    *  4 /  

 & -7 -5 $-($ &    " 

      

 )  

     

    

 & 4 

           "

"

*    *    &*  

    * 

 &  /





    1   &   

(( ) 0 

   # '

&&&



  

  

   )  

&




* &
*   &

  

   #   
*  &&  &     &
*  /  +* &

  & & 1 

   &

($ 1  # '

&   

(.

)

 

 /  # (   

 /  & &

  "  &  , -' -( $-($

 &  0& 1 &

&&   0& 1 & & 2" =    

    "  1   &* 

*

 & 1 *

 2" -' -( $-($ &

   "

  &

 & 1 *
  (6 -' $-($ 

&*   &&   "

 

<  2& 033& 1 * (6 -' $-($ A

 /
.@)B        , -' -5 $-($




" &   +*   &*     3  "    & 4 &&

-5 -5 $-($

*






  & # 7-.

 -5 -. $-($



    "

 ) &  +&*      +&* 4  + +*   

 >& 

     # 7-.

 -5 -. $-($   * & 

 & 1 * 2" 

 /
3$7

)   &  &

  *   > F&  3  1 

 /
3($      

 & 1 * %& $9 ($ $-(-  

& &&  &  -' -. $-($ .( -. $-($ =  > F& +   &*     & 

  & "

('

,  

 %&

 ,  

 > F&   &  $5 -. $-($ "

&*   
&* 0& 2"  83)/

&  2 * $-($ 

    .( -. $-($ A

 *B (5 >         

 

&*       $-($  

 &* * 

 

 ?   

&*      /  *    4  

   &* *      4  

 &  (6 4   &  &  & )  0   &* 

  

 &      

&&*  &&

 &*   * 

&*  

 &   0 

   4 *      &   

 

&&*   &*  &     

  

 

(7 0+&* 

 && 

   $( -. $-$.

  4 

&&   & 

  

&& & +&     *



& 

 

 (:

&&

 &&

&  * &   *9

+=6  

4 50  4 

    
 F 

@ G F&  ( @ G F&