Mahesh Kumar Gupta And ORS v. State Of Haryana And Others
CWP-189-2020 ( O&M ) -1-
! !
" "#$%&'$( "& ))! *& + ,&- "& )!. ./ ,012 3.!45+6 3./* +,/0#3.4,/7, 3845+6 3 ,012 3.!45+6 3/.50/
& &!"
&+7/9 7
&"( ! &!(:2;- 7/;!/9 ' &;7,&- ! &!/ :$& ;7/9 7 !* "&/
<7/9 7 !#$ ";(#$&7/9 7
&& 0! ! ====
&; ""
;&
; &"(& 7"&
"%
(&( &-! /((;
&
>;-7;;?! 6"
( " @
; @- " ( ;;>;-
($@;
& &
> "
$ (@; ?& " &
"&:"
&>&
>@; :> ?&> %! 6"
$&7 9 && ! 7 " & " +$"& $@% &(&
& ( $((;- (@;
CWP-189-2020 ( O&M ) -2- ?&"&
"&:"
? ""%& ? $&>
"&>&! 6"+ ,&- "
; &(&@-?-
9 " 3A 9 3
&7 $@;
,;" 3
&
7 "&:"
7 %
> "&
: @- " $"& & $((;- (@; ?&! 6" &;9 (& &(&& "$
*))
+* #+ )
( , # +($' , %%
% +$ +" -
- . ) %& $!!%&*+ ) +#"
, $!!%&
+,* +,* ' *) ) ) +/+* , "
" ),
) ## * , ,+ 0 1!% * )'+-
$!!%& +#, ) ! *) +* - %'
& *) $!!%& # +( "*% #+ *) -+
() $!!%&, +( ! "!
! )& $!!%& "%"$% )'+- % , ,
$!!% )+*% * )& +*+* )&, , $!!% 22 3+* *) +* + )& , , '
$!!% + % # +- 223+* +, - "+*
) , , '
$!!% ) +* % * )& +*
*.% )& ( ,
0 * $!!%& , " , 4$ )! "!
! )&
+( * #) %&! "!
$!!%&"+( +5267 *
*
*.% )&
%#867 , '
*.! +- ) )+, - *+,"+*
) .
-*"
) *
+ .$%
$!!%&+#, +$ +#3+* 9:3+* '
$!!% +*) %&'
+, -
/+*
%%'
$!!% , +*% * )& +, #"
* ) ! +- ) ! ! % * #+ '++
+* *) /+* , "
'
+# *+, * + ) + .$% / ,
$!!%&
+#/+* , %%*)#+ ( *
'$).
+#
;<699 %0 ' * #+ )(
- !! +-% #+ $.( *
+* +# , $!!%& " ( '& ! +- ) *. ,, !$(!
+* *+-
+*=$!. )
$"
0 ) * ( *
(
CWP-189-2020 ( O&M ) -3- , * ,
'
$!!% ) +* % * )& '
) #+ ) , "
) , $!!%& #+
*.% )&
'
*..
- * + +( 4$ ( *
,+)& $ "+!&+#
'$).
#+ !! +-%
** 1 ) ,
** 1$ >5#+ 0 *)! $ %+#
+*?'% +$ <
), $!!%&#+ /+*
.
- * *' %+,@> + ( +# ,=,
$(!
A B
" . A7 CB
$** %& ,
$!!% A7 B
+!$%
+* 8655 8688 +# , $!!%& A7 B 585966668866 D52E 5 (!> !$ 596 9666 5 51:61 9666 D 9266666 9:;;E E2E8 F 56 G D 8866 8 (!> !$ E9 ;966 55 551:61 ;966 D 8;56666 ; !++ :6 2666 59 591:6 1 2666 D 2226666 + %@ 58596666 56
# .
-*"
. ) ,.
( *) '%+"0.
, . %+*.,
"+* ( *
+* +# ) *0 *. ,
"+*" * )
$"! +'% ( '
*. #" ) +, ,+ (H+ +* #
%&
#+
) *
+ %& )+,* !
#+ !
+*% "+** "
+* +# , $!!%& *) (+ +# & $ '%"0 !
.
"+(( *) ).%-* / ) +*!
! %"0 !
%& )
$"
'% *) ,
( .
,
) ,&
#+ (+ +#
) *
#"
! +'% (+#% 0.
55
+ ( , . '%+"0.
) '
+* *)+ "+*
$"
+* (
%
+,* ) *. *)
, #+$*) ) % ))+,*'& C$* !%+$*"
%- ' * "+** "
) ,
,. (* +% ,
+$ *& ! (
+*# +( ) ! ( * *)*
*&
" "!
' *
%% )*+ ! +! " * - ' *!%" ), " % ) + "+0 *. +# , .
( . '. !%
" '+
" - .
'% ,
) %& +,* ,
CWP-189-2020 ( O&M ) -4-
( *
. ) C$* !% +$*"
% ' * 4$
- %
( + (+- "+** "
) # +( ,
(*) +"+- ) ,
! +! " * *) "% * %% (H+ ) +, - *+ $'
*
%
. )- ' * 0 *+* ' %# $ "+!
+ C$* !% +$*"
% ** 1 ) ,
** 1$ >8 #+ 0 *) "+*
)
+* +#
+*?'% +$ 58
! +'% ( +# "+0 *. +# ,
( 1..
+ ( , ) *. *))
!+ %+# *,
)+* +$. , .
( +*%& *)
*+ !
( - %'%
+,* #+ , )
!+ % +, *.+# . '. *)*+*>'
+) . )'% ,
)) ! +'% (
* + ) +%- ! +'% ( ! +!+ % ' *() #+ ! +- )
+ (, , *) )
!+ % 0 ) +,* *)
) '$).
' * #+ !! +-% +- *( * $ "+!& +#
) '$).
#+ !! +-%
** 1 ) ,
** 1$ >; #+ 0 *) "+*
)
+* +#
+*?'% +$ I 8&% " @97
9 " " + $"& &
? $((;-
> (@; ?& " &
"&:"
!
7 "?9&7(&
""$>""
&
; " (& " + $"& 7 @$ ((& " &>&
> @; :>
?&> %7 "9 @ : @- $
(; $
;7 "&:"
!" B$
"
&>&7;&
; &" ( " (
$ " " +7 "&:"
7 ?"
/%
&& $
(;$
;7"&:"
7" ;> 8 . >
"3A 93
& "$@;
&:
(&% 7"&:"
& !
";>
"&"&" :
>$("
$ ;>
; ?"
;(& &%
>"$ ""9@ %( $( "
%$ &
CWP-189-2020 ( O&M ) -5- " $&- (&9
" ,&- $
(; / 7 C7 " " ;> 8 .>
"3A 93
& "+'9& % !
;
9 " " ( "% ;9 & &%& $
(; $
;& $
(; $
;7 "&:"
7 ?"& &(& $@% @- " + $"&
" $
(; $
;7"&:"
7
$;;-&
@; &" %
&
:
> ?&
" "- "9
"
?&>&
>?
"*( ( (&%
D
:?& "&$>"*( (;
7?"
"" ; %
"&
:
?&!0"
>" @ (; & &
"
& %@- $
(;$
;7"&:"
"
&>&! "
$%
7 " %&> $&>
$ $((;- (@; ?& " @ &
&% " &(&
;@ &"
$&
""@$> % &;-
>?
&
:
>?&( (;
?;; ?>( ( ;
"9;&- @ "$"& 7 ?"
"&(
>((&9;7
"
&>&&$ &(&
7 ?
-& &
"(& ( ! 6"(
&
>;-7
! ./* +,/0#3.4,/ , 3845+6 3 /.50/
45'3 - 7
< ""& (:
>& E 0 ""&&(&@; E 0