High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/28005/2017dismissed

Devi Lal v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2017-12-19Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath5 pages

!" "#$%$&'

!" "#$%$&' (

(

")$* + "!$!$&", -% ! !" ,. & &/!0",% "%1&/"&!% 2' 2' 2' 2'3 *24 3 *24 3 *24 3 *2442 42 42 42 ,"%"&!' 2,5$!$0 67/)# !"7

,!0"1"!$!$&", 44278*9 44278*9 44278*9 44278*9 0" 1"!$!$&", 0 % #0 ++"&6"/ !0" ) +$/$!. !0" ,/", / !"/ :

; 1 %%"/ <. !0" =1",$&!"&/"&!$&6 & +

0 >, !", ",)$#"%$,#+"7$,% ?

,%0,!@!0"3A &/!0"+"!!",/ !"/ :

; <. B0$#0 !0" C !!", 0 % <""& %"&! < #> <. !0"

"0, & !",",)$#"% $)$%$&7 & ++&.7$,% ?

,%0,!@!0" 3A !!0"=< $)$%$& + & +

,=B +$ !",",)$#"=< $)$%$&7 & ++&.7$,% ?

,%0,!@!0" 3A ,,"%!, !$& !0"/$%C &!+"/ B !",#=,%"&!0"C$//+"+$&" "#! DD:0" 1 %%"/!0" ,/", ,"%!, !$& !0" B !",#=,%" 1",C &"&!+. )$/" 0$% ,/", / !"/ :

:0"% $/,/",B %#0 ++"&6"/<.20 ,$&60<.B . & 11" + <"

," !0" 0" 11" + B % /$%C$%%"/ &/ !0" ,/", !0" B %

$,C"/)$/",/",/ !"/

:20 ,$&60!0"& $+"/ ,")$%$&<"

,"!0"7B0 +%=10"+/!0",/", !0" &/ <. /$%C$%%$&6 !0" ,")$%$& 1"!$!$& &

E 20 , $&60 !0"& $+"/

E;E

E$&!0$%=,!7B0$#0B %/$%1%"/ &

B$!0!0" ++B$&6,/",' F*$C$!"/1+" !0"1"!$!$&",$%!0 !$&# %" B !",#=,%"$&G="%!$&0 %!<","%!,"/7 /"G= !"#C1"&% !$&$%,"G=$,"/!<"1 $/ !1"!$!$&",=&/","#!$& !0" ,. & & + &/ , $& 6" #!7 (E B")",7 !0$% $%%="0 %&! ! ++ <""& #&%$/","/ <. !0" =!0,$!. ##,/$&6 ! 0$C7 !0" ,/", &""/%!<"%"! %$/" &/C !!",<","C$!!"/ !!0"% C" =!0,$!. , /"#$%$& ,"%0 , .", $% &! 11%"/ <. +" ,&"/ #=&%"+ ,"1,"%"&!$&61,$) !","%1&/"&!% &)$"B !0" <)"7,/",%7&&"H=,"; ! ," 0","<. %"! %$/" &/ C !!", $% ,"C$!!"/ ! !0"

"0, & ,"%1&/"&! 7

, /"#$%$&

,"%0 !",0" ,$&6!0"1 ,!$"% ++B"/$&!0"%"!",C%I 1,1%7 & 11+$# !$&B % $+"/<.!0"1"!$!$&",!!0" &:E

, ,"%0/"#$%$&0" ,"C &/"/!0"C !!",< #>!!0" )$/" 0$% ,/", / !"/ :

0" 1 %%"/ !0" ,/", ,"%!, !$& /$%C &!+"/B !",#=,%"&1",C &"&!< %$%$& )=, 1"!$!$&",&(

0",/", !0" B %#0 ++"&6"/<.20 ,

: $&60<"

,"!0" <.B . 11" +$% 11" +B %/$%C$%%"/)$/" ,/", / !"/ :

(

0","

!",7 0" $+"/ !0" ,")$%$& <"

," !0" 7 B0$#0 0 % <""& ++B"/ )$/" ,/", / !"/ :

; B$!0 !0" ++B$&6 <%",) !$&%' F0" ,"#,/ B % # ++"/ ! %"" !0" $++"6 +$!. &/$C1,1,$"!.D% 8:9 !0" & +#! !",# ,"

=+#&%$/", !$& !0" ,6=C"&!% 1=! ,!0<.!0"+" ,&"/#=&%"+ <!0!0" 1 ,!$"%76$&6!0,=60!0"# %" $+",/", <!0!0"+B",#=,!% %B"++ %,/",% &3<+" =&5 < J ,. & $60 =,! 0 &/$6 ,06$)"&$&E;E

E ,C 1",=% + ,/",% !0" &3<+" =&5 <J ,. & $60=,!6$)"&&!0$% $%%=" $& E;E

E !$!+"/ % 20 , $&60 %D =,5 C -",%=% =<

,=B +$ =<

$)$%$&7 $,% &/ !0", $% #,.%! + #+" , % !0" +" ,&"/ #=&%"+ 0 ")$ * + %D

6, B !0 % +%&!11%"/!0"$%%=" #C1"&% !$& 0=% !0" /"#$%$& !0"

$#",7 "0, & D

$)$%$&7 $,% $% &! ##,/$&6 ! ,/", &3<+"$60=,!

E &/", !0" #$,#=C%! &#"%7 !0" # %" $% ,"C &/"/ !

"0, & D $)$%$&7$,% !! >"=1!0" C !!", % 1", /$,"#!$&% !0" &3<+" =&5 <J ,. & $60#=,!6$)"&$& E;E

E 0" ")$%$& 1"!$!$& $% /$%1%"/ ##,/$&6+.I 0" 7 !", ,"C &/7 B,!" +"!!", ! !0" / !"/ :

; &/ %>"/ 0$C ! 1,"1 ," ,"%0 %#0"C" B !",#=,%" & #C1"&% !$&< %$% *" ,&"/#=&%"+ ,!0"1"!$!$&",0 %%=<C$!!"/!0 !$!$%&! # %" &"BB !",#=,%" ,B0$#0#C1"&% !$&0 %!<"1 $/, !0",$!$% # %" ,"%!, !$& /$%C &!+"/B !",#=,%"!$%!0=%%=<C$!!"/!0 !!0"," $%&G="%!$& 1 .$&6 &.#C1"&% !$& 0 )" 0" ,/ +" ,&"/ #=&%"+ , !0" 1"!$!$&", &/ !", "H C$&$&6!0","#,/7 C !0"#&%$/","/1$&$&!0 !!0","$%&C",$!$& 0$% ,6=C"&!%$&% , %!0" #!% &/#$,#=C%! &#"% !0"1,"%"&!# %"$% #&#",&"/0"1"!$!$&",B % 1 ,!.$&E;E

EB0$#0B % /$%1%"/ <.!0$%=,!$&!0"1,"%"&#" 0$%#=&%"+!!0 !!$C"7!0$% =,!7 B0$+" %"!!$&6 %$/" !0" 1,")$=% ,/",% 1 %%"/ <. !0" / !"/ :

;7 / !"/

: &// !"/

E,"C &/"/!0" # %"< #>!!0"# & + =!0,$!$"%& +$C$!"/1+" !0"1"!$!$&",!0 !$& # %"B !",#=,%"$&G="%!$&0 %!<","%!,"/!0"& /"G= !"#C1"&% !$& $% ,"G=$,"/ ! <" 1 $/ ! !0 ! !$C"7 !0" 1"!$!$&",7 B0 B % ,, ."/ % ,"%1&/"&!E7/$/&!11%" %$!$%%1"#$ $# ++.<%",)"/$&!0",/",

!0" $60 =,! / !"/

!0 ! F1, .", $% &! 11%"/ <. +" ,&"/ #=&%"+,"1,"%"&!$&61,$) !","%1&/"&!%I &%"G="&!+.7 !0" C !!", B % ,"C &/"/ < #> &/ B0"& !0" &/ /$/&!1 %%!0",/",$&,"6 ,/!#C1"&% !$&7!0" 1 %%"/!0",/", #C1"&% !$&&!0"< %$% !0"%! !"C"&!%=

","/<. !0"1"!$!$&",B0$#0$%%,"#,/"/$&0$%,/",!0 !F+" ,&"/#=&%"+ 0

")$ * + %D 6, B ! 0 % +% &! 11%"/ !0" $%%=" #C1"&% !$&I 0=607+" ,&"/#=&%"+ ,!0"1"!$!$&",0 %%=<C$!!"/!0 !$!1",! $&%! !0"1,#""/$&6% !0"B,$!1"!$!$&<=!!0","$%&!0$&6&,"#,/!%0B !0 !$!1",! $&%!!0"1,#""/$&6% !0"B,$!1"!$!$&, !0",!0"<%",) !$& C /"<.!0"%0B%!0 !!0"% $/%! !"C"&!B %C /"<.#=&%"+ ,!0" 1"!$!$&",/=,$&6!0"#=,%" 0" ,$&6 /$!&!<""&%7!0"1"!$!$&", B=+/0 )" $+"/ & 11+$# !$& ,!0B$!0 ,,"# ++$&6 !0",/", 0=%7$&)$"B ,"% $/ #!% &/#$,#=C%! &#"%71"#=+$ , ! !0$% # %"7 !0"," $% 0 ,/+. &. C",$! $& !0$% 1"!$!$& , !0" 1=,1%" $& ","&#"

$%C$%%"/ 84429 84429 84429 84429

(

0"!0",%1" >$&6D," %&"/

"%D 0"!0",,"1,! <+"

"%D