Baljinder Singh Dhaliwal v. State Of Punjab And Another
!!" #$%$
!!"& %'"!
$("!$
!"#$%&'(# $#& !
) $
$!) *++ +,-".!&"!
(!!"+ *+(!
,+++, %'+ *++ +!!,-".!&"$("!"+/+ $#& !
) $$ *+ $!! (!!" $ ' & % .!" 12/ + (3 &"4%$ "& "+56!/6+7+/8/9% .!"$1:2 , 6/6,587 ;$.!"$6<7 ,187,587,6<<,61 != $!!
". !!",* ,$!.!*"
!
$%'$4%!(". $ !
&"> " !
'$$ "& !
.">(">$ ! 2+98+/8/9 ;?% /=+
4%$!" $ "! $!'3.">(! $("!
"+/ !
-$! !" .">>. !
"+ " -, !
!
!-!""&$(.!'$,&3!
(!$-!$!!>! !
3$"-!
!$$(%!, $((!&">!
.">(">$+ !
$>,!
(!!"$-"@ !(" "& !
$"%!'3(3 !."!%!""&!
$(". $ "%' &%!?.$'%$"&(".$$"&!
"%!!
%$,!
4%$!"!
$%'$4%!(". $$ &">>3'
4%$ !
!$!"&%$!.+ $"%!-"$!/2+1+/8//.!! (!$!"
(('&"!
4A%!3* $!!&"." $!!>!$,$ ."!'&"!
"%!!
4A%!3* $!! $$".! !"$!$("!+ (%$%.!"!
$>,*,*"
$! ("!
!/6+5+/8//!"!
$"%!+B!
("!$ $$"?!
" $!!>!$"&.">(! "">
>..%$A(!!"
.""9<+5+/8//+ !
$!!>!$, *,*"
$.".%!
("!!
!!(($!
!!
(!$ -!!".">(">$-"%!3! !!
$""!
..%$ !
($! .$ !
! (!!"A..%$ $ "! ' . ".> &&!
$.$+ - ."%$&"!
(!$,(%$!
." !
("!$!'3*,*"
+ '(%$"&$!!%!"3("-$""&!
12/+ ++ "% " !
!!
"%!>3>@$%.
"$,$>3'.$$3!"
-&&.!!"3"%!
$""!"(-!'%$"&!
(".$$ "&3"%!""!
$!"$.%!
$"&%$!.+ .!"6/8+ $4%3-!&"."$!", ($.'$!
(".%&" .">("% "&!
"&&.$%!
"+ C( - !
!%"&"&&.$ 3.">>!! !
&.!!
!'"!
(!$ ->.'3$!!!
$(%!,!
."!%!""&.>("$.%!" "%'&%!?.$+ "D'
%(>"%!%>'"&.$$.%
!" !!#B.S.Joshi and others -$State of Haryana ,-* &./*0.* 1 &"" '3!
$"%! %.
.$"&2.+3,*&4-, -*5&6.78,-*91 -!
!
("("$!"-"-!
($!.$$!!!
+ &!,"D' %(>"%!Gian Singh :State of Punjab and another &./*0.* &%!
!
!
$$%!
$!!'3!
%(>"%!&"4%$
"&!
State of Haryana :Bhajan Lal9 &.// &
+
79"&!
% >!$$%)
!
"
#
$
%&'
(
"
)*+ , #
- +
,
(
!("
( - "
-
(
(
.- -
(-
(
/
(
$
(
(-(
.0
1
(
.
(- *
(
2 ( 3
(
-
(
- -
-
-
.
(
(-
(
(
( -
(
-
-
(
.
# "
#
(
-
(
#
#
-
+ ,
-
#
4 ((3 $!!'3"D' %(>"%!(!
" "&% >!$!
$
"%!,!$((!!
! !
(!$ -
!!".">(">$,!
."!%!""&!
(". $ "%' >3'%$"&(".$$"&!
"%!'3" ..(! (3"&!
(!!"$'34%$ "%'$.% $"& %$!., $(>3!
"'.!"&!
$!%.! %
.!"12/+ "%!$."$."%$"&!
&.!!
! .!"$6<7A6<<+ + "%$"&&.$" .">("%'+%!! (.%&.!$ ..%>$!.$!
!$!"&'"!
(!$!"$.%!
$"&%$!.,!
$"%!>$!(("(!!"%$!$$.!"%
.!"12/+ +&-"%"&!
(!$+ $$%!,!
$"%!&$!
!!
.$ $4%3&$ !
!
>'!(>!$$!!'3%.(.!$ .,
"+56!/6+7+/8/9% .!"$1:2 ,6/6,587 ;$.!"$ 6<7 ,187,587,6<<,61 != $!! ". !!",* , $!.!*"
!
$%'$4%!(". $$ &"> 4%$ 4%!
(!!""!
.">(">$+ $$!"$3 !
!!
(!$$ >'"%'3!
!>$."!"$"&!
.">(">$!
$!!>!$."'&"!
."%!'" +
!!"$!$" + $#& !
) $ $%;# %.@3 !
$(@ A$") $A"
!
("!') $A"