← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/28019/2017disposed of

Kanta Yadav And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2019-07-16Mr. Justice B.S. Walia3 pages

    

      

 !" #"$%&%'( )

* '!  # + '#!,"-&  ."!%!%'"-& /"-&0& 1! !"  -2 '  '# '!,"- ."&3'#"'!& "

-"( '456"7-0&!%$"1 6%  -"&"'!( 7-* 8-%9#+$ !" -!,"3"!%!%'"-& 7- ': ;706< '%9 9 -2 '  ===   

 > ?

6 %@ %' !," <-%! 3"!%!%' %& - !," %&&0 '$"   <-%!%'!," ' !0-"   7 '# @0& - #%-"$!%'8 !," -"&3'#"'!& ! -"@+" !," 3 2 '@ 62  '# 8- '! &"6"$!%' 8- #"    ABC D  BC <"    

) %'&!" #     ' !," 3&!   E"$!0-"-&  %' !"-@& 

+"-'@"'!  -2 ' 6"!!"-9''"F0-"C # !"#

 +%#"<,%$, " #7 &!"-& +"-'@"'! %8,1$,6 '#G$ #-"3&!& E"$!0-"-&  +"-'@"'! 1"'%- 1"$'# -2 1$,6& <"-" 8- '!"# !," 5"'" %!  &"6"$!%'8- #" &3"-;0#8@"'!# !"# 3 &&"#52!,%& 0-!%'

 H )%'$ &"!%!6"# & 8 !1%'8, '#!,"-&+1! !" -2 '  '#!,"-& >? E" -'"# &! !"&!, !3"!%!%'"-&A9 9 9 9 9 A9 )9

9 9 99H9A9) '#, +"5""'8- '!"#!,"5"'" %!3- 2"# - '#!, ! --" -&<06#5"3 %#!!," -"@"'!%'"#3"!%!%'"-&%'$ &"!,"

0-! & -#"-"#  ' !,%& -"8 -# 6" -'"# $0'&"6 , & %6"# $32   -#"- # !"# )

 %' $0-! !# 2 <,%$, %& ! :"' ' -"$-# 32 !,"-" , '#"#+"-!6" -'"#$0'&"6 -!,"3"!%!%'"-&

>? >? E" -'"# $0'&"6 - !," 3"!%!%'"-& &! !"& !, ! !," 5"'" %! , & 5""' 8- '!"# '!%' 662 '62 <"    

) '# $!0 662 3-&3"$!%+"62 <%!, "

"$! -@ !," # !"   3 &&%'8   -#"-9 <,"-" &   H   )%'!"-@& <,%$,-#"-# !"#)

, &5""'3 &&"#9, ##%-"$!"# -"@+ 6   '@ 62 '# 8- '!   8- #" #@%&&%56" <%!, "

"$! -@   

) %'&!" #     <%!, $!0 6 5"'"

%!& ! 5" 8- '!"# -  3"-%# @'!,&3-%-!!,"# !" %6%'8 !,"<-%!3"!%!%',"-"

-"9 !,"-"< &'-" &' &!<,2!,"3"!%!%'"-&'!5"8- '!"# --" -& -  3"-%# @'!,&3-%-!!,"# !" %6%'8 !,"<-%!3"!%!%' >H? ,"& @"%&'!33&"#!52!,"6" -'"#  >A? $$-#%'8629 %' +%"<   !," 3&%!%' & '!"# 5+"9 !,"

-"@"'!%'"#3"!%!%'"-&%"3"!%!%'"-&A9 9 9 9 9 A9 )9 9

9 99H9A9) '# -","6#"'!%!6"#!8- '! 5"'"

%!%'!"-@& -#"-# !"#)

<%!, --" -&!5"3 2 56" - 3"-%# @'!,& 3-%-!!," %6%'8 !,"<-%!3"!%!%'<,%$,&, 665"-"6" &"#<%!,%' 3"-%#  !<@'!,& -@!# 2 %6%'8<,%$,!,"& @"&, 66$ --2%'!"-"&! !!," & @"- !" &< &-#"-"#%'  H )<%!,"

"$! -@!,"# !"  "'!%!6"@"'!!%66# !" 3 2@"'! <"+"-98- '! !,"5"'"

%!%'!"-@& -#"-# !"#)

<06#5"&05;"$!!!,"!,"-!"-@& '#$'#%!%'& $'! %'"#%'!," -"@"'!%'"#-#"-5"%'8 %66"# >)? &-"8 -#&!,"!,"-3"!%!%'"-&96" -'"# &! !"&!, !-#"-& , +"5""'3 &&"##"$6%'%'8!,"-"6%"

$6 %@"#52!,"@ '#!,"2, +" 6& 5""'%'

-@"# !,"& @" >? '!,"6%8,! !,"3&%!%' &'!"# 5+"9!,"<-%!3"!%!%'I0  3"!%!%'"-&A9 9 9 9 9 A9 )9 9 9 99H9A9) '#%& 66<"# & 5+"<,%6"<-%!3"!%!%'I0 -"@ %'%'83"!%!%'"-&%&#%&@%&&"#

>? &'!3-"&&"#<%!,!,"6%5"-!2!$, 66"'8"-#"-# !"#)

9 &, & 5""'3 &&"#52!,"-"&3'#"'!& 1 6% 

)

0#8" @%! 1. Whether speaking/reasoned:

Yes/No.

2. Whether reportable :

Yes/No.