Chetan Gupta & ORS v. Subeg Singh & ORS




  

 

 

 !""#$%$&'()
*"! &+,!  -% ,,".. &!%
/ 0
0+1"20$&2* -%   "%,&3"&!%




 

-"%"&!' -/ $1* 40"*2 .534# !"-!*" ,,".. &!%

-0 !, .* 6$7 534# !"--"%,&3"&!8
&%+- &#" 6, &9


   
 











 











 









!



" #
 #
$
% &

 
 


'
 (

)


 





*+
#
 
%)#

  


#


 ,
 


 
 
- 


)





.+#

,/




$





.#

,/
 


- 


,/
 


#

 
 


.#0.#

,/

1
 

 




 
  




 
- 











!#

 



 
 
1
 









 









  




2





$% &


3
 #

 


/4  
" 




  




 


  






 
.


4

 



   


 

 





 



 





#



  





 
  


 
*


   #



*+





 

'()'*+(,'-.+)/0('1.2 (3
(2 ('30  ""4
# 45







*+
#
  



  


#
  








 


)





 
%

#






 

0

,/






 
)

 ,
#


 5.+#

,/

 












,


 #



)



.+#+++,


#











)


.+#+++,/
6
 

 

 






6+ & (
  

'30 1')1.6('17+ ,2'18 0,03+9-.:('1'8+3/0'19 3/+(.;

"#<

0-0)#""4








* /+


#

2
 
  




-
 


)






)



 


+


 
#






*+


#
 #

2


  






-
 







0






+ &

(
  




&(




*#

,/

 
 
- 
 
 )

$% &
 
 






.

,/



 



#




.#

,/


,/
 
- 






*#

,/


- 


*#

,/
 




7

% 8 


 

3 
% #
9 : 

%
"

'=,'+1+(')1.6('17+
 39-. '16',)0'.
/6/(6 ', &3!*"-%3"#$3"3&):)$&$4$.,," .:())5*".3 !* !#6,"&% !$&$%, 9 1."& ##+&!.%%, -"&! .#&%-!$+6!!*" #*$.3-"&!*"3"#" %"3##-3$&2.95!*" ,,".. &!%$"!*-""#*$.3-"&!*" 3"#" %"3;+.31""&!$!."3! ; -3
5<8" #*& ##+&!.%% , -"&! .#&%-!$+6
1
 

 





 



 
9 ' 

%
"

6>+01=/'19'1 3/+(-./8', 01=/ 9+'9 '19 3/+(. "#5   
 
0-0) # #
 




 




#






;
2




1
 





 

#




 

#
 #





 
+2

2







 


 
9 ' 
%
"

  


&(#


 


 
 
+2

2



#


 





 #


 
)




<
(

+'9 , 613 '..+..+9 >8 (0>61')01
 , 613 '..+..+9 >83/0.
6(301
 
&&+ .
&#6"
=5<8
=5<8 

+!+-",-%,"#!%

>
?@=<8 
"3+#!$& !; -3% ,"-%& . "A,"&%"%  3"#" %"3
<-3!! .$&#6"
=5<@
#<8
<-3!! .$&#6"

B0

<@(=<8

$%&

&&+ . 3","&3"&#9 --$4"3 !
= <8

;-&2.9 # .#+. !"3 %<8
(<8
(

+.!$,.$"- ,,.$"3

: 6,"&% !$& ; -3"3
=A@
55=<8 ;-&2.9 # .#+. !"3 % 55<8
(A: @55::=<8 -+&3"3!
55<8
=

+&"- ."A,"&%"%
<8
(<8 )
>%%  , -"&! . #&%-!$+6 ! !*-"" #*$.3-"&

>
5<8!" #* !*"#*$.3-"& ! .@55<8
:

&!"-"%!
?
:? 
! .
5)5=<8

;-&2.9# .#+. !"3 % 5=5<8
55::=<8 -+&3"3 !55<8
 ##-3$&2.95$&!*".$2*!!*",%$!$& %&!"3 14"5 ,,".. &! % &3  +&6 --$"3 3 +2*!"-% -" *".3 "&!$!."3 ! #6,"&% !$& & ##+&!  3","&3"&#9 !
55<8 ! 1" %* -"3 "C+ ..9 % 2 $&%! #6,"&% !$&
.#+

<8 ;-&2.9 ,,-!$&"3 %
55<8 .&2;$!* $&!"-"%!D:?,"- &&+6;$!*""#!-6!*"3 !"#. $6,"!$!$&!$..3 !" , 96"&!."%% 6+&!5$ &95 .-" 39, $3



 
 #
 
6




 


.

,/

 
 
 6




 

8




- 





#
 
6


 

  

#7

,/

 
 
6


 


.

,/

 
 



#

,/
  


 
- 



 
  
 
6


9#


 
 

 
6







 ""3."%%!6"&!$&5! A.$ 1$.$!9C+ +!+-",-%,"#!%%* ..1" 3"3+#!"3$& ##-3 &#";$!*!*"3"#$%$&$&:('1'8+3/0 .# %" %+,- ;*$." , 9$&2#6,"&% !$&

$%?&
 ##-3$&2.95 ,," .$% ..;"3; -33 !"3:, %%"3 19 !*" ." -&"3 5 !"*2 -* 0 *$1 $% 63$$"3 ! !*" "A!"&! % &!"3 14"
  

-+,>+(#? "#5  2.
E*"!*"-%," F$&2<-" %&"3' "%<
E*"!*"--",-! 1."' "%<