← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaVATAP/53/2009disposed of

Unique Chains v. State Of Punjab And ANR.

2016-12-19Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain,Mr. Justice Jitendra Chauhan17 pages

       

  

  !"!# $ %&'(  )))   & * +& , -

( ))).

-   !" #$%&'()*+,-' .'*/ ,#0 & #$%&'()*+,-' ,#0'1,#2/1,0/) +  

 * -/ 0"-1  ( 

 +0&(2 "/"+& ,  11 3 !

(  ('

& 4 ( - --  -0(&---5 & "+& , (  6( &  

8)  4(  9 & %&

 9 ) : ;(( & - *

!# (+& ,  " 

  4 4(4

-

&-(* +& , (.90  " %& -   (4

- <''=  ;((  4( 

&-(& -  !

*

!"(9 ->4

-1(6

( 9(

(   *

!9  :(  

 

( 4 4

-1(?

 ;(( 

( - &   ("

 ( 

- 9(( 0&@ !7(  -= 1 ;((    -  9(   

  4 -  & -  ( 1

 (+& , 9& -

 &@ !  (- - 

 1 

" 0 0 &@ !7  -&

( =?

(    -- ( -  ( &   (

! !

8



9 1-0A;  

*( /& -* 4("*B"/.+"  ((  (-- -

  C( 9( 9 0 44 -

 9( 1 40 - A5   

   +   (A9  2 *

 -(C- C( & - *

! (+& ,& ---5"  ( 6(6  / -

 9  -

4 ( 

(5 

(4

- 1-( (9 

 1 -0   -4 & - &  %& -& - *

! (   (4 94( (4 -

 9 8"!

4   - 94(8"# 84    (1&(  9 - 7#"#!"D#@) (- 4  &-( 9&

  (   (4

-& - *

!# (

 - -   1 (  9  -0( 4 

(  4 -      

 & -  *

!    (    ( A';  (

&

(( 91 

*



! - !D (9(19 1 -5(4

-9  5 -    - ( ( ((4

-9    ( 9 4 4 -  ((

 9   -

 4 -  41  0  (   "  9 

  -   -  -  --

!

8-0(A';   0  "7"

@)9 -& - *

 !7 -9(*

!! ( (   -  0  (     9  - -  0  A'"  E -( 1

1- - --

8 (& (  ( & 9

 - -1- - --   2   (   & "    (-     4&- 

 (    (   (( 1

 *

 ! -D (9  

0 9( 4

-9  4   - 64

1(6 .0 4

(- 

64

-1(641 *



("9 4&-(1(  &

4&

5- "9 05&--

(- 

64

-1(6  - 40"  C( 

9(  

"(4 -

 9  -"9  1 4   "( 1

 *

 ! - !D ( 9 

 -   . 9-

-

('

& 

#+'# +,# &14,+-/' *5*#,#',+6 / #0,2 /7+/'* 89: 1; 87:

( & "( 91 "--

4 9((    <9(-((,&-4  14,+-/' *  &-

 -&

9  

& - *

!D)2 (+& ,/  *5"!D8 ( 6(*56"  ($

  0 '( -4 ("9((( 1  --

(1    ( *

! ( (   *

! ( -& - ) 

             





 



  



  

     



 

          

( &  (- (   ( " ( &-  6 

6 -

6 

)( 4 4

-1(6"   (  

 44

-9( &-(* ( &    )  - 

 ( & ( & & (-- 

9(

< &( & " 0  -  .&# (+& ,& ---5.&"  ( :(.&?(- 

  -

(  *

! ((

 ( &    - F

! *&(- 

9 41 (   <



'



'   ( :<''? '(C+  ( &4( ( 9 <'' &-.90*

"G&-( "

&(- 

9& (- ( 4&  ('

 ( ((

- - &- & - *

! ( ((  -  & 4 -- "  

& - *

 -

(9 ,- <9(-((4

-9   -   "( 9 1 

(  &)

 *

! (  - 40"(9- -

<( -  ( & 9((( &4 - (    #

*( * -/ 0"G- '

 ( ( 4&- (( & ( -  0 4

( - 4&((   

( 14,+-/' $*&  B 4&-(( 

 - ( 

 -

0( &  (

(    - (

5 (  *

!" & 0&) 

(  "9((

 -

09((0 (6

 

( 4 4

-1(6   64

- 4 -

(  4

-  1(6   <   

0  1-  (  +& ,  &  ---  5  - "!

9((

   

 !

"(*

!

((  --  ( -  *

! ( "(9 -&- :(    

< ( 4 (4

- 

-1(? - 

06(    

< ( 4 (4

  1(6( 1  *   - (1 - *&) 

 "D -  *

! (  &)

 *

! ( (9 -:  4 - (4

1(?(9 -:

0 0 (   ?(1  -9((

-:  4 - (4

-1( 0 0 (   ?

(  (   -- -(9 -:   ?(   - B& (  4&-(  0    4*

! 5- (!

 - ('

&  ==' &;

 - >1+ +' )#. % #0 #+/'*(?*#06 '#+ &  #*=+@+0 #0+/'*A---

!# 8 !#(  -(4

 4   - 1( &

4&

5-  &-

- - - *

! (

 - 40"G- '

( 4&-(((C 49 -

   4

-

 4 - 4

-1( 90   (   - 49 9( &,& -

B &0

 -- (9(1  0(   

( 1

 (!

 - "( - 4 ( & 

( (& ) -- 1



&

G- *'



( ( ( -" 9(&  4( 

4 ( &  4&-((  *

! (9  0 

 0 4 4

- ( &   ) - 1 9(( (4

-9  4   -

4

-1(

 B "(- 

  ( 

& (-"(((C 4"- 

 - 

 0

&( 

9 &-4 -1-1 (4

-9 

    - 4

-1(

B ;(1( -G- '

 (  - &-(  - !  ( ( -"(  9 4&  %&

9  -

;(( (& ( 6 

6 (  

*

!- 

6(    

( 4 4

-1(6 *

! ( 4

 

( & ( & & (-- 

(

  -"

 0 

 44

- ( &    )* - 

 1 9( &(4

 

 4   - 64

-1(6= !!

*

! (5-( 1     -&- )  



 

   

  !  

  

   "

 





   # 

  $ 



%   

     

      

  

     "

        

    

    

  

 

   

'

    !

  



      



   

   

 "  



 



  

      

         

 

          



     

 

 

 





 



  

 

      !

  "

                

"

  (# 



'#  )   "

 



   * 

             





 



  



        



 

        

 

* 

  #

     

;

         



 







           



    



       

     

  

 

 

 

  

 

 

+ $

  "

        

    

   ,

    

    

&  

     !

 

 



  





"



      

   

 

  !

 

 "

  

      

 

 

(              "

 

       

-+     "



   



  "

   

"

 " 

    

        

  

  

 

    

      

,

 

 

  

 

          

 







    !

 



  

 

- '

    !

  



  

    

   

    

    "

          



 

      

    

   

  

      

  

 







  !

 

 "

 

      

'

  !

    

 





   

    !

 

 







   





 



  ,   "

  * 

 

 





  







   

 

    !

 



  



   

  !

 

 "

        

      

  



 

 

 

      





'

    !

 

 

 

   

  

 

  

  !

 

 "

        

 

   

#  

    





    



  



 

 



 

 "

 

      

,        



 

 

 

*

9 

  



  

 



  

  

 







  



   



     

  

 

  

 

 

    !

 

 * 

     



  

   



 

    

 

.

$

         

 

 

  

       ,

 

/    

 

  

 

  

 



 



      "

     



#    

 

 

  

 "    

  







 

 

    

 

 

 



'

/    

--

 

    





#      

  

    " 

    

  







  

 

  



    "

   "  "     

! 

  !

 

 "

        

        

   

&        

  

 

   





 

  

  

     

    

   

-    

    

      

   #

   



   

   

   



   

    



  



#

 

 

   



        

#   

  

  

 

 

  

   

 

  



  $  

    

  

 

 



   

 

   



  $            

    "



 

"

   

,  

   





 

   

! 

  

  !

 

     



     

   





-  

    "

          

  



  

   

#  

    

 

  



  



#

 

  1   

 



    

'

 

   

  

  

0   



     

  

    

 

      

 

    !

 

 





 ,

  



      

  

    

   

 

 

   

 

'



  



     



   

 

   

 

        

,   

 3

'

 

   

   

,  

 

 

    

 

 

 





   

0  



  -.

  

 



  

,         



      





#



 "

 





  $

  



 

    

 

      

,        



 

 

! 

     

 



 

  





    

 

     







       

 



  

     

,  

3

 '

  

  

  

   

,   

 

 

    

 

 

 





    





    

 



  

,       

 

   ,



  



-  

  

 

      

 

 "

  



  

      





#



 "

 





  $

  

  



   

 

    

 

   

,        



 

   

! 

     

 



 

    

  



  

 





 

  





         

   

 

 

    "



 

"

   



,  

   











       

 



  

     

,  

3 '

 



  "

 

      

     

     

&   



       

  

   





    





    



  

- 

 



     

   

  

 



 5'

 

  





  





 





 

  

 5   



2    

 

     

,             

   

5    

  



 

 

-0

,    

 

 

 

  

,   





!

<

- -  &4(  4&-0( 

- )*"

((    *

 ! - !D ( 4

0 6(

   

< ( 4 4

-1(6"( 

 9    ( 1

 - (4

- 4   - ( 9( 

-1(6 < 19 (5&

61( &

4&

5-  6  

 (  - 

  64

-  1(6   (   9 &-   

,& -

- 4

- 4   -

 90  (-0 ('

&  #06 '#+ & #*=+@+0$*&  !

(%&

9(( (  *

!-  -  

&

= !D

< & 19( 9 (  ( 41 !

(  ( -0   -&- 1   *

! (6(    

( 4 4

-1(6 %& -  09(( 4

-1(  -"4

- " (

 4)

C"   (

   4



  (&   & 9((  4 - (4

1(   -   -&     0    (  - &     (  (C    



 

    0 (   

 9(  C A5 -5

 (C 4(1( 0 !#

   *

! 

 44

 9( &-  (  *    (   &       )   - 

 ( & (- 

9(&( & " 0   -

!7    - 4  ( 1  1

    ( *

! ( 4( -1 06    

( 4

4

-1(6  09(( (- &   -( 

 4

-   (&   &  - 4 - (

-1( !8

2&   4

- 4 -

9( &-( * ( &    ) - 

 (    --



-

& ( 4- 

9(&( & 

0  - (&(&   (     %&  & ( 4  --

- 

  4

- 4 -

9( &-(* ( &    ) - 

 

(- 

9 &-  --

(- &  %& -   -   1 04

-1( 0 44

- (&   &  < - 0(& (9 -6( 6 ( 

! < 19 (- - 

(&)

 *

! (

0   4

- 4 - 4

1( -( 4&4 (  0  4 --





-

& ( 4- 

(

  -" 1  - 1 ( %&   &)*

 *

! ("(

 0C  & 

*

! (  4( 0 ((  1 -0(   

 1- ( %&   &)

 *

! ( 9&)

 *

! ( 4

- 4 - 4

-1("(

9((   --

 4

1  - 1&)

 *

! ("9 &-  - -  4-

0

 



& 44

-1(     (4

-" &(  

    44

- ( ( 4

-1(" 0 0 (  

(  

"

 %& -  0(- & 

 - *

! ("

 9((  04

1(  -"4

- " (  4

C   

4

1(

0  - 40"( (-((   0  4

- 4 - 4

-1(( &4( 4 -

(&  - ( " 4 -9( &-( *" ( &    ) - 

   (&"  0(& ( 6 

6 ( -

( 6    

( 4 (4

-1(69 &-

 & (

&

( & (  0 



-  9( &-  ( *    (   &      )   - 

 1 ( &4(&(4

- 

 4   - 4

1(

!

(

&

& (  -9(  1

 .&#  -#D (.& C

  .&  #   -  #D    (  .&      '(  )<H  -

 > #*=+ +,# 0*$  .&# -> '&,5'6-/ && # #0 0'-&  +,#$ .&# ! (.&"(- 

  -

(  &)

 *

! ("(

 (  &    - F

!

!  -&-



  

'-&  +,# +-/'-C=*+   <''

<'''

- * 

< @A5  *

F.) # 

?   ?



@ !

.

'

('

4

  '

-- 

('

4

.

'

('

4    '

-- 

('

4 

 

/

#    ---  (    '

/.@.@;02@G

C@ *( & /.@.@;02@G

C@ *( ?

?

( &

< !    ---  (

  ( 

( 4 4

!!

2@1 0'(

! 2@1 0'(   ?

?

!

& /

* !D  

/

*4 &  ( ) ( 4 

49(('

-

 -*  -- ((C

*4 &  (&  

( 

    4(4

.&#D (.&-$-'0)'  )#,*/,#2,# ! +,# ++/'

# ! +,#&&'-+,#'#+'$ (   -&-

0- !

"#$% #  &  &% '()  &

    (#

&

#"# # '

     

 

 



  



 

   

!  /   / 

*

 7   8$'

  

    



   





        

 



 9 8$'+0 

  

 %  :



    

     "  





'

 

   

!  /   /  

 



 

 

 

  

  



   9 8$'&  9 8$'+. 

    

    

 





 

   

 

     

 

9 

 

+ '

 

   

   

 #

 

/    

 

  

     

    9 8$'  9 8$'+.  



  

  

   

 

 



- '

  

   

 

 



    

  

 

    



      

  



  9 8$'&  9 8$'+.  



  

   

 

!  /   /  * 

   

  

  

,



   9 8$'+0   

.

'

  

 

!  /  /     

    

   

 9 8$'+0 

  9 8$'&  9 8$'+.  



 

  

 



 



  

 

   

     

 

 

  3



  

 

  8$'

  

    



  

  

  "

   

  

3

  9 8$'&  9 8$'+.  



 



 

  9 8$'+0* 

 

9 8$'

+0   ,



 



 

  

   

    

  

     

 



*

# (F

)!"(   ---  (    '

0 %& -   - *

7(/.@.@;02@G

C@ *( &     - *

8( /.@.@;0 2@G 42

C@ *(- -  *

"((     %& -   <  (    9         1     

    44

- ( 9( 4

-1("( ( 9

- F

! 

 ( &

9(    (    '

0"/.@.@;02@G 42

C@ *( &   -- -( (

F& ( "&) &! .&#D (.&9(( %&  & 

- &  -F

(<



'



'  "

B &) & 9((-9(( 4 4&  & 4

&    & F

)! F

)

"&) &D9(( %& (( - &   - &) &!

49((-&04 - 

)! F

)

& - (   ( 4 ( <



 '



 '  "   &) &     9((      (  (

 ) )( 4    (  <



 '



 '    (    (

4   (- 

& (- - & (-&0 - - 4 - (  "&( 6    

( 4 (

-1(6 D (& (  -(,& *

! ("(

4

& (- 

  (  *

! (

6(     

( 4 (4

1(6  -

  0 (  

9( 

6(     

( 4 (4

-1(6

B "    -(    ( 1

( 1  "(& ( 6 

6 (   *

! (- 

6(    

( 4 4

1(6 *

! (- 

  4

& ( 4 - 

  (  "

 0 

9( 4

- 

  4   - 4

-1( <  -( ((  (*

!( 1  "(- 

  (  *

! %& - & (-

006(  

 

( 4 4

-1(6   4

-  4 - (4

-1( (&   

- ( 

 #

< (4( ( 9  (%&

"( 9-

(   - 4   -  4   (        (-      9( &

; ,& -

( -  ( & --  %&(- (

- --

!

8 (A';  "  4 0  "7"

@)& - *

 !7 -9(*

!! (

(      -  ( -  --  

8    A'  " E -( 1

-  4( (   %&(-

81  @: 8 11 :

   

'-'!%'3

B 4

;(( C 4@ 

-

I@

;(( . 

I@