Dev Bala And ORS v. Union Of India And ORS

 



  
    

  ! "#$$  % "' )!



)! * )!+!

" "
"'

"' )!



!
 

 

 





-# .)!

/0 1'%

)

)!  

   

/ "  "  !2 "3     +) 1  .)  -+" &  0+/ )  -( )/  &% )"/ -

"' "3+"!

&

, !"

"4 & " "

 
"'

5)  1  .)  !(  0 +!( &1  '%

 ) 
5)  "'.!.+" !(  "'( 1''

&'%

 &1 +"6 4)) 7 7

)"

'+"!

&)

)!( !( '% 9 , !   

" 

(     &

)"

'  +"!

&!  ) 

! $
"% 9 "

+) )'

)9( (9 ,),!

, !!1" ,&:;

 '

 !) <+ ) 4  & !  & "'

)! 9 ! <+ ) '4:)

!=+"'

:! 1>?),+4& ,+),!

!)

  9 '

" "35+)& " "35/

,

"

)

" !

(& "')/@0. >0. ? )'  9 !  , !!

'  "   :

)    4:   8 <+ !

"&&

)5/,

+ : 

)!A/ "3)  !

9( & !!

!! "3

/, "!

"1 4  !  -

"! 71 @ "' 7$   8 <+ !

" 1@>$1"

&:1!&

+/ "' "

9 " 3)



/'

!,



( !+)  " !"#$%&' (')'%*&&$ +(,-',".&("/"'-' '%-))'%*0&(" 

123
1
-.-$34 !

3) &&:( &'

" "  <+ !

"+"'



&   3(9 :!   1  >?1  4%  / '  9  !

+ ):

 !  <+ &&:  '/ !! 4& 

'  & "';9"

)!  (

,

)!  &!  ) &:  +,"  9  '

 ! "!    ( !  +) 1  4 (  '

'

>, !!

' "
2 

10),-',0)'%)'*0&( .&("/" 
55-""-'&( )$)'%0)( 6-.-"-'  )'%  *0&("3  "' 
 

1(&5)/(.&("/"'-' '%-))'%*0&("3 9( 4: 4  !!&

+/ "' "

)/! 4% ;

'

'

 ! " ( !+) 1( 4

"

 ! / & )&:!

+

'& "';

9"

)!

9 !,&

'+," )'

)!1""

B+) ! ; "' ;71 , !!

( !+)  "! / & ) )+/!

! @ " )  3)   

)!  ! 

 4 ! '

!+4/ !! "

"!

1 : )+"" "3)/ , && ,!

)  )!) ;

:!+ :)

 4%  !4+ !

9 (( &'"&:

" ,&

"' )

"!( 4

"3 % "4: ( !+)

C!D( 33) ',

)!( "9 ,,) ( !
+)  >  ( (

)'&

)"

'+"!

&)

!

!/

4 "3 ( "'3"

()+3( )'  ,) " ,& !& ''9"4: ( !+)  "&'

"
)" -

& )3 "3!A! C!+,) D1 "  "' !,+

 +) )1 

4  !!&

+/ "' "

( 4

"

( !+) 

! / & )&:!

+

'& "';9"

)!% '

)'

)'

'> "( - "3(A!   C!+,) D1  "  &!  4  ( )'&:  ' !,+

' 
" 

 )+/!

!19  % 9

 ! /,

+,")

!= "! '

)!A& /) 3) !&

+/

)'

9 ( '

 ! " ( !+)  "&'

"
)" -

& )3 "3!A! C!+,) D  9)

" ! )' "3&:' !,!

' " &&9 "3

)/!#;

C D

)!!( &&/%

"C!D4 ) 

"  '  /,

 + :;+/;8 "'  <+ !

&&

)9 ( " ) '"

/"

() 3) 

)  !E C D !

'/,

+ :9 && !!+ "

&&) )'!5) ,&:)/

+ :
"'

E C D /,

+ :!( &&



)'

)/ "

9(

)  )  "

)! 

' 

)  !1 !,

&&: "% 9 '

 ! "!

 ( !+) "' "F4& -+,) +) '

+,"4: & !E C %D


)! +"'

1 !

&!,

2 "3 !+,,&

):9 )'  ( ! 

!( &&4 !!

'

( " ) '+)/"

(!)/ '

 & "3

2

"C!DE C%D

:!+ :
"'

!( &&'

,!

/+"

1  ":1, 4&

)/!!+,,&

):

)'1 " "

;4

) "3 B ''

,!

+"

C!D "

":"

& G "2 "'' !4+)!

!( &&  !+46

  "

&  '

 ! "     "F4&

-+,) +)  "-,

& 8

,,

&C % &D $    $ 

'#  )6

  )

)1  

 3(9 :1
*%!

!(9 )- "3( "' )!  )

"!

"'!' !,!

' )' "3&: 1 

3 6# 8(-$ 2 

 1

3 34!

6#