High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/8979/2014allowed

Gurmail Singh v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2016-12-23Mr. Justice Inderjit Singh12 pages

Pooja Sharma 2016.12.28 11:43

!"#"$%& '("("$'

)'* * (!(' $+!,!$-(&'* .'*/$-'$(*

'*'$(0 1$" '*&&! !2-34!('

(&'/'("("$' 15)"62--# 2 $+!, &'/'*'$(/'("("$&!*,''$ "#'- $-'("4#'*

(&'$*("( ("$ $-"! "** !$4' !9"("$(&'$!( ' 4'("!"

!*&"$%(&'" / %$'--'-!('-

$$';

'023"-'9&"4&2 (&' ':

'*( (&' /'("("$' $("$!# / ("$ ( (&' /*(

*(!,#"*& '$(

"4'!*9'##!* /'"$('$-'$( !-'0!#$%9"(&!## 4$*':

'$("!#,'$'

"(*9'

&!*,''$'+'4('-

(&'/!<'

&!*!#*,''$ !-' "** "$%-"'4("$*((&''*/$-'$(*(/ ('(&' /'("("$'((&'/*( *(!,#"*& '$(

"4'9' % *(2

"'9&'$ &"*/ ("$,'4! '- '!$-!#*(/ ('(&'/'("("$'((&'/*(

/'"$('$-'$( !-'0$("$!##<9'

"$*('!-

="'

#<2(&' !4(* (&'4!*'!* !-' ("$(&'/'*'$(/'("("$2 !'(&!((&'/'("("$'+"$'-(&''/!( '$( ,#"464&"('4( '

"$%2 $+!,!*#'6$ &''!

('2&'9!*/ ('-!* '$" **"*(!$( $ > !$- !* /'"$('$-'$( !-'0 $

,<(&''/!( '$(!# ("$ "((''&''"$! (''

''- (!*?(&'?$' (.!+ !("29&9!*+ $"((&'/'("("$', ( 9!* ! '*'3'- 4!('%< 4!$-"-!(' 9!* !#* / ('- ( (&' /*(

/'"$('$-'$( !-'0$

!%!"$*((&'/*(3!4!('-,<'*'3'

4!('%<4!$-"-!('9'

- '('("' '$(@9'3'2*!"- ( .!+ !("&!*,''$*&9$(,'+ $"((&'/'("("$'"$(&'*'$""(<#"*(

/'"$('$-'$( !-'0&'%"'3!$4' (&'/'("("$'"*(&!(/"(&"* / ("$!* /'"$('$-'$( !-'02(&'*(''%"*('9!*4&'46'-,< (&''*/$-'$(0'/!( '$(!$-(&',!46#% 4&'- #'-!*('9!**&9$ (,'?"#?&'/'("("$'9!*#'

(9"(&(&''<'!* *'3"4'!*&'9!*- '

('("'$

!$-(&'$';(/ ("$!#/*( /'"$('$-'$(

!-'09!*((&'/*( /'"$('$-'$( !-'0!$-(&''!

(' /'"$('$-'$( !-'0((&'/*( *(!,#"*& '$(

"4' 5'!$'-4 $*'# (&'/'("("$'4$('$-*(&!((&'*#"(!< /*( /'"$('$-'$( !-'0 '##3!4!$($

- '(/ ("$

$' (" !# !

(! &'/'("("$'9!*&!3"$%':

"*"('';/'"'$4'

$(&'/*( /'"$('$-'$( !-'0!$-9!**'$" *( / ("$ ( (&' /*( /'"$('$-'$( !-'0 &''!

(' (&' *#"(!< /*(

*(!,#"*& '$(

"4' '##3!4!$($

$(&''("' '$( *!"- " !# !

(! 5'!$'-4 $*'#

(&'4$('$-*(&!("$*/"(' 3!4!$( /*( !$- &!3"$% ':

"*"(' ';/'"'$4' ,< (&' /'("("$'2 &' 9!* $( 4$*"-''- / ("$((&'/*( /'"$('$-'$( !-'0!$-(&'

*! '9!*6'/('*'3'-"$('$("$!##<29&''!*2(&''9!*$,!46#%

'*'3'4!('%<4!$-"-!('5'!$'-4 $*'#!#** , "(*(&!((&'/'("("$'

!-'3!" *'/'*'$(!("$*, (&"*4!*'9!*$(4$*"-''-@!3"$%#'

( 9"(&$/("$2(&'/'("("$' "#'->

'(&"* ( :

!*&"$% -'-!('-

!$- / ("$((&'/*( /'"$('$-'$( !-'0,'"$%(&'*'$" *(/'*$&'!4("$ (&'

'*/$-'$(0'/!( '$(9!*$( !"!$-+ *("

"'-!*'3'$(&''/#<9!*$(

"#'-((&'*!"-/'("("$ !/'"- '(&!$$'<'! ,*':

'$(#< (&''*/$-'$(0'/!( '$(9"(&-'9-'-!('-

!$-/#!4'-(&'

*! '$'4-"$(&'!

'*!"-/'("("$&'/'("("$'9!*/ ('-((&' /*( /'"$('$-'$( !-'0,<(&''*/$-'$(0'/!( '$(3"-'-' -!('-

!$-!*(!(' '$('%!-"$%(&'*! '9!*!#* !-'- "$% (&'/4''-"$%*"$>

(&!(!*(&'/'("("$'9!* / ('-((&'/*( /'"$('$-'$( !-'0$

2(&'/'*'$( /'("("$&!-,''$'$-''-"$

4( * 5'!$'-4 $*'#!#** , "(*(&!(- '("$!-3'('$( "*(!6'

'*/$-'$(0'/!( '$(2(&'/'("("$'9!*$(/ ('-((&'/*(

/'"$('$-'$( !-'0$

("##

(&'* , "(*(&!( (&'/'("("$'9!*/ ('-((&'/*( /'"$('$-'$( !-'09'

"$*('!-

29&''!*2&'9!*- '('("'$

((&''$-2#'!$'-4 $*'# (&'/'("("$'* , "(*(&!((&'/'("("$'"* '$("(#'- -'' '--!(' / ("$9'

!#$%9"(&!## 4$*':

'$("!#,'$'

"(*5'!$'-4 $*'# (&'/'("("$'&!*!#*'#"'-

/$(&'+ -% '$(* @$?,#'(&'/'; ("$

! " #$%%& "

' (" ( )$

/' ' ( !*'*

2 (&"* ("$ )*%"

" #$%& + , ( *

"#$ + )

!$- !($!@"%& ("$ -

.&$/+- $%&)) '"$

5A.2"$* //(

&"*4$('$("$* 5'!$'- 4 $*'# '*/$-'$(0(!(' &!* //*'- (&'

* , "**"$* !-',<#'!$'-4 $*'# (&'/'("("$'@'* , "(*(&!((&'

4#!" (&' /'("("$' / ("$ !* /'"$('$-'$( !-'0 9'

"$*('!-

!$-

(&' / ("$ ( (&' /*(

*(!,#"*& '$(

"4' 9' % *(2

2 "* ,!*'#'** &'' "* $

#'8/4'- ' ( / (' (&' /'("("$' $ 4 /#'("$ :

!#"

<"$% *'3"4' 5'!$'- (!(' 4 $*'#

(&' * , "(* (&!( ( .!+ !("2 /'"$('$-'$( !-'09!*!-+ *('-!(4!< 9!-/"$( 29&"4& 9!*'*'3'- 4&'- #'-!*('5'!$'-4 $*'#!#** , "(*(&!($ /'*$+ $"((&'/'("("$'9!*'3'/ ('-!$-(&'/'("("$'4!$$( 4#!" / ("$!*! !((' "%&( @'!-(&'!% '$(*!-3!$4'-,<#'!$'-4 $*'#(&'/!("'* !$- &!3' !#* %$' (& %& (&'" / %$'- -' !$- (&' -4 '$(* !3!"#!,#'$(&' "#' &'%"'3!$4' (&'/'("("$'"$(&'/'*'$(/'("("$"*(&!(&' 9!*'$("(#'- / ("$( (&'/*( /'"$('$-'$( !-'09'

"$*('!-

&'4!*' (&'/'("("$'9!*(,'

4$*"-''- / ("$ (&'/*( /'"$('$-'$( !-'0((&'

/*( /'"$('$-'$( !-'0 $

!$- ( (&' /*(

*(!,#"*& '$(

"4'!

('$'<'!"'"$ % *(2

@9'3'2(&'

/'("("$'?*4!*' / ("$((&'/*( /'"$('$-'$( !-'09!* "%$'-!$-&!3"$%#'

(9"(&$/("$2&' "#'->

'(&"* (29&'',<2(&'-'*(!$-"$%$(&'9!< /'("("$'?*

> / ("$ 9!* 9"(&-!9$ !$- &' 9!* / ('- ( (&' /*(

/'"$('$-'$( !-'09'

9&'$ &'9!*- '('("'$

&' /'("("$''("'-!* /'"$('$-'$( !-'0!$-!

'("' '$(2&' !-'!'/'*'$(!("$ $("$!#/ ("$((&'/*(

/'"$('$-'$( !-'0 9'

!$- (&''!

(' ( (&' /*(

*(!,#"*& '$(

"4'9' % *(2

&'/'("("$'!$-$' (.!+ !("29&9!*+ $"((&'

/'("("$'!$-9!*!'*'3'-4!('%<4!$-"-!('29''/ ('-((&'/*( /'"$('$-'$( !-'0$(&'*! '-!('"'

(.!+ !("

9!*/ ('-!%!"$*((&'/*(3!4!('-,<$''*'3'4!('%<4!$-"-!(' 9'

- ,( /" ( (&' / ("$ (&' /'("("$' !* /'"$('$-'$( !-02(&'*(''%"*('9!*4&'46'-,<(&''*/$-'$(0 '/!( '$(!$-(&',!46#% (&'4&'- #'-!*('9!* $-(,'?"#? &'$';(/ ("$ (&'/*( /'"$('$-'$( !-'09!*((&'

/*( /'"$('$-'$( !-'0&''!

('((&'/*( *(!,#"*& '$(

"4'&'*"$%#'/*( /'"$('$-'$( !-'0 '##3!4!$($

- '(/ ("$ $' (" !# !

(! &'/'("("$'9!*&!3"$% ':

"*"('';/'"'$4' (&'/*( /'"$('$-'$( !-'0!$-9!*(&'

*'$" *('#"%",#'/'*$ / ("$((&'/*( /'"$('$-'$(

!-'0, ((&'4!*' (&'/'("("$'9!*$(4$*"-''- / ("$!$- (&'/*(9!*6'/('*'3'- '*'3'4!('%<4!$-"-!('29&''!*2(&'' 9!*$,!46#% '*'3'4!('%<4!$-"-!(' &'/ ("$ (&'

/'("("$'((&'/*( /'"$('$-'$( !-'09!*- '$

, ( &'9!*$(/ ('-("##

!$- #(" !('#<'("'-$

!* /'"$('$-'$( !-'0(&!*!#*,''$!% '-,<(&'#'!$'-4 $*'# (&' /'("("$' (&!( (&' /'("("$' 9!* !#* &!3"$% (&' 4&!%'

*(!,#"*& '$(

"4'9'

("##(&'-!(' &"*'("' '$(!$- $(&"$%&!*4 '$'4-(*&9!*(9&'(&'!$<"$: "<84 /#!"$( 9!* /'$-"$% !%!"$*( &" ( $#< (&' / ("$ ( (&' /*(

/'"$('$-'$( !-'0 9!* -'#!<'- ' (&!$ $' <'! , ( (&'

/'("("$'4 #-$(,'/ ('-((&'/*( *(!,#"*& '$(

"4'$- '

-!(' / ("$"'"$(&' $(& % *(2

" "#!"** '9!*-'!#(9"(&,<(&''#&"@"%& ("$4!*'

' (" ( )$ &%& !5.

//'#&"2 9&''"$2"(9!*&'#-!* $-'0 B&'/"$4"/#'9&"4&4!$,'-'- 4'-"*(&!("

!/ ("$"* -'$"'- ( !$ ' /#<'' ,'4!

*' (&' "*(!6' (&'

!- "$"*(!("$!$-- '($ !

#( (&'*!"-' /#<''2(&'$ (&'!

(&"("'*!', $-(/!<(&'!'!* *!#!<'(4 /$ %"3"$%&" (&','$'

"( '(*/'4("3'/ ("$!

(''!#"C"$% (&!( "*(!6'&"*/"$4"/#'9 #-,'';('$-'-'3'$((&*'

4!*'*9&''- '(*&''$'%#"%'$4'24!'#'**$'**$!44 $( !#!

"-'*!$' /#<'*-'$"'*(&','$'

"( / ("$((&'

' /#<''!(!//'(" '9&'$"(,'4 '*- '!$-%"3'*&"

('9!-*(& %&'(*/'4("3'#< #**''(!(' D'!#!

!$-(&'*)*D=&!*6!!$"##!"EA

F 1&-& '-)*"C! %!!4(<!$-(&'*E

F!#"$"D!$("$&!)*(!(' ="&!!$-(&'*E // $(&*'4!*'*9&''4$4'$'-' /#<''**'$"*!*9'##!* + $"*!'%!$('-(&','$'

"( / ("$!$-(&'*!#!< (&'/'"-"$:

'*("$2*! '*& #-"$3!"!,#<,'%"3'$(* 4&

!$' /#<''9&"*%"3'$,'#!('-/ ("$'(*/'4("3'#<!* $$%!$( !'!* /!<!$-!##9!$4'* (&'&"%&'/*(

(&''#'3!$(/'"-2"$* 4&4"4 *(!$4'*29 #-! $(( &*("#'-"*4" "$!("$G ! '3"'99!*(!6'$,<(&'!#4 ((!@"%& ("$(&'4!*'

",(&

*%&)) '0&) #! ( )$ &

!#5A " "#!"** '9!*(&'','

'(&"* ("$)*%"

" #$& 1&2&+3 4 &''#'3!$(/("$ (&'*!"-+ -% '$("*'/- 4'-!*

$-'0 B&' !4(* (&'4!*'"$&!$--'/"4(!/"4( ' !$' /#<''2 9&&!*,''$ !-'(*

','4!

*' $ !

#( &"*$(&''

,'"$%!$<'!*$9&<&'*& #-&!3'$(,''$!//"$('-!((&'

"*(/#!4'&' !4(*'3'!#!*(<9&''!&'#/#'**' /#<'' &!-,''$6$46"$%!((&'-* (' /#' + *("4' 4#!" "$% &"* "%&( $ (&' !- "$"*(!("3' *"-' 1!< ,' - ' ( 3'4!

(" * !//!4& (&' @"%& ( ( !3"- 4 /#"4!("$*2-'*/"('(&'','"$%$&"(4&" /'-" '$("$ %"3"$%(&'!//"$( '$(((&'/'("("$'2 ''#<,'4! *' (&'

/'$-'$4< (&'9"(/'("("$2(&'/'("("$'9!*-'/"3'- &"* "%&( !//"$( '$(-'*/"(','"$%*'#'4('-"$!44-!$4'9"(& #!9 $ ' /#<''2 9& "* '!-< !$- 9"##"$% ( 962 "* -'/"3'- &"*"%&((96$$'(&'(&!$,<(&'@"%& ( "(*'# !$-!,3'!##29&'$&'"*$(!/!(<((&'#"("%!("$ '*/"(' '/'*'$(!("$*2 &"* 4#!" "* 6'/( /'$-"$% !$- (&''!

(' 9&'$ (&!( "%&( !//"$( '$( &!* ,''$ !46$9#'-%'-!$-!44'/('- (&'-!('(&'3!4!$4<!*'2&'

"*,'"$%-'/"3'- &"*4$*':

'$("!#,'$'

"(* ("*!*'((#'-/'/*"("$ #!9,!*'-$(&' !;" !4( * "!'$' "$' %!3!,"(29&"4& '!$*(&!((&'!4( (&' ( *&!##/'+ -"4'$$'&"* !;" "* $-'- /$+ *("4'!$- %- *'$*' 9&"4& *'3'* ! *!

' !$- 4'(!"$ % "-' (&'

!- "$"*(!("$ + *("4'/'*$4!$$(,'/'$!#"C'- $

#( &"*$!4!*'9&'' ''#<,'4!

*' /'$-'$4< (&'

9"(/'("("$2!/'*$"*-'/"3'- &"*"%&(-'*/"('(&''

,'"$%$#'%!#" /'-" '$(2(&' ("* $-'!$,#"%!("$(

$-(&'9$%-$'( !<$(,'!-"'4(!4( (&' (, ( ! 4$*':

'$4' (&'' 2 9&"4& (&' *

'' 4!$2 "$ $ !$$'2 ,' &'#- '*/$*",#' " "#!#<2 !$< $-'*'3'-

$ !"!-3!$(!%'%!"$'-,<!/!(<"$36"$%(&'+ "*-"4("$

(&' ( *(,'$'

(!#"C'-2!*(&'"$*("( ("$ #"("%!("$ 4!$$(,'/' "(('-(4$ '!$<!-3!$(!%'$!/!(<,<(&'

-'#!<'-!4("$ (&' ($4'/( '*("( ("$,'4 '* !//#"4!,#'"$* 4&4!*'*(&'9"*'(&'/!(<9 #-4$("$ '( %'(,'$'

"(,< ''#<"$*("( ("$%(&'#"("%!("$-'*/"('#*"$%(&'

4!*'"$(&' ($* 4&!*"( !("$2(&' (4!$$(*"(!*!

('*/'4(!(, (*& #-/!**-'29&"4&9 #-';/'**#< $'

(!#"C'(&''

'4( * 4& $ '"('-#"("%!("$* !!* /**",#'2 (* *(!#9!<*!" (/'*'3'!$-/('4((&'

"%&(* /!("'*!$-';('$-&'#/('$ 4'(&' !(&'(&!$ -'$<'#"'

!$-(&'',<'$-'(&'"%&(*(&' *'#3'*("*' $(&' ,!*"4 /"$4"/#' + "*/ -'$4' "* B G29&"4& '!$*9&''(&''"*!"%&(2(&''"*!

' '-< 4&!4 *'9 #-,' '4$- 4"3'!$-,'(('

4$ ( ! !"2 '!*$!,#' !$- //' !- "$"*(!("$

+ *("4' !$-2 (&''

'2 $''-* ( ,' !-/('-2 ##9'- !$- '$ 4'-,<(&' (* #!9 $ /!,$ )" (5 )"&" # 3* - ) %"-! )$ "1$ "2

.."3"# 2(&'@$?,#' /' '

(9&"#'4$*"-'"$%(&''

'4( (&' #(" !('-"* "**!# 9"(&-!9!# !4!*'!$-(&'4$*':

'$4' (&''

'4( (&'

"$('" '#"'

"$/!!0>&'#-!* ##9*0 B>#"("%!$(4!$-'"3'!$<,'$'

"( (&' ''

/'$-'$4< !4!*'"$! ( 5!92!*(&'"$('"

-'!#9!<* '%'*"$((&' "$!#-'(,'/!**'-"$ (&' 4!*' !$- "

(&' 4!*' "* #(" !('#< -"* "**'-2 (&'

"$('" -' *(!$-* $ ##"

"'- !

( !("4!##< /!(< 4!$$(,'!##9'-((!6'!$<,'$'

"( &"*9$9$%* ,< %'(("$% !$ "$('" -' !$- (&''! (' ,#! ' (&'

(&' !4((&!((&'4!*'"* $-2 #(" !('#<2-'3"- !$< '"(2(&'/!(<9"(&-'9(&'9"(/'("("$2 *&9*(&!(! "3# *9"(/'("("$&!-,''$ "#'-&'

!;" B4( * "!'$' "$' %!3!,"(G29&"4& '!$* (&!((&'!4( (&' (*&!##/'+ -"4'$0$'2,'4 '* !//#"4!,#'"$* 4&!4!*'$* 4&!*"( !("$(&' ("*

$-'!$,#"%!("$( $-(&'9$%-$'(!/!(<,< (&'!4( (&' (& *2!$< $-'*'3'- $ !"

!-3!$(!%'%!"$'-,<!/!(<"$36"$%(&'+ "*-"4("$

(&' ( *( ,' $'

(!#"C'-2 !* (&' "$*("( ("$

#"("%!("$4!$$(,'/' "(('-(4$ '!$<!-3!$(!%'$ !/!(<,<(&'-'#!<'-!4("$ (&' (;;;;;;;;;

;;;;;;G $/!!*!$- 2"(9!*&'#-!* ##9*0 B$ +)$&) !'"!(&)(3*)) ' 6 &2.

2(&"* (';! "$'-(&"* "** '"$-'(!"#!$-&'#-(&!($$'*&!##*

',<!$!4( (&' (&' !4(!((!4("$%(&'!//#"4!,"#"(<

'*("( ("$"*$((&'!4( (&' (,'"$%9$%

"*(!6' ' 4 "(('- ,< (&' (F (&' ('*( "* 9&'(&'!$!4( (&'/!(</'* !-"$%(&' ((/!** !$-'&'#-!((&''$-!*$(* *(!"$!,#'2&!*'* #('-"$ $' /!(< %!"$"$% !$ !-3!$(!%' "( 9 #- $( &!3'

(&'9"*' '!$'-2 (&' (&' /!(< *

'"$% !$ " /3'"*& '$(9&"4&"(9 #-$(&!3'*

''-, ( (&'-' (&' (!$-(&'!4( * 4&/!(<&''"* $(&"$%9$%"$(&'/!("'*-' !$-"$%(,'/#!4'-"$ (&'*! '/*"("$"$9&"4&(&'<9 #-&!3',''$&!-(&'

($("$('3'$'-,<"(*"$('" -'29&'$!((&''$- (&' /4''-"$%*2 (&' ( /$ $4'* "(* + -"4"!# 3'-"4(9&"4&-'*$( !(4&9"(&!$-4 $('$!$4'"(* 9$"$('" 3'-"4(&'"$+ <2"

!$<24!

*'-,<(&'!4( (&' (*&!##,' $-$'!$-(&'%!"$9&"4&(&'/!(< 9 #-&!3''!$'- $#'**"(9!*"$('-"4('-,<(&'-'

(&' (9 #-,''*('-(4$ ''-$(&'

/!(<,<* "(!,#<4 !$-"$%(&'/!(<#"!,#'(-*

$</"$"$((&'4$(!<9 #-#'!-( $+ *("

$( -"*!*( *4$*':

'$4'*;;;;;;;;;G ( " )$ 3* )) '-"!(+6 &2

2(&"* ( ,*'3'-(&!($4'(&',!*"* !/4''-"$%"*%$'2!## 4$*':

'$("!# !4(*2 !4("$2 -'* 9 #- !## ( (&'

% $-!

( !("4!##<!$-(&"*/"$4"/#' 4$*':

'$("!# -'9&"4&"*!//#"4!,#'(+ -"4"!#!$-:

!*"0+ -"4"!# /4''-"$%* "* ':

!##< !//#"4!,#' ( !- "$"*(!("3'

-'*G @$?,#'(&'/'; ("$(&'4!*' !" "/ )" $%& )) '"$ .>&'#-(&'/'("("$''$("(#'- !'!* !#$%9"(&"$(''*(!**&'&!-*

''- '$(!##<$(&!(4!*'2(&'/'("("$'

9!*-'$"'-/ ("$9$%#<, (* ,*':

'$(#<$("$!#/ ("$9!* %"3'$!$-(&' "*(!6'9!*'4("

"'- $ (&' /'*'$( 4!*'!#* (&''9!* "$!4("$ $ (&'/!(

'*/$-'$(0'/!( '$( !$- 4!*' (&' /'("("$' 9!* $( 4$*"-''-2 9&''!*2 &' 9!* '$("(#'- / ("$ $( $#< $ (&' /*(

/'"$('$-'$( !-'0, ((&''!

('$(&'/*( *(!,#"*& '$(

"4'

!*9'## 44-"$%#<2 (&' /'*'$( /'("("$ "* !##9'- !$- (&' '*/$-'$(0'/!( '$( "* -"'4('- ( %"3' $("$!# / ("$ ( (&' /'("("$'!* /'"$('$-'$( !-'0!*9'##!**(!,#"*& '$(

"4'9'

!$- % *(2

2'*/'4("3'#<@9'3'2"("*4#!"

"'-(&!((&'

/'("("$'*&!##$(,''$("(#'- !$< "$!$4"!#,'$'

"(*!$-(&'$("$!# / ("$9"##,'4$*"-''-(9!-*/'$*"$!<,'$' "(*$#<

2 4 /+!

&'(&'*/'!6"$%8'!*$'- H'* &'(&''/(!,#'

H'*