M/S Kapurthala Beltings v. State Of Punjab And ORS.





    


  

    !"#"$ 

  !% &'!  ()      
  
    
  

  



       

   

  

   

    )*%*  +#",-  !

""  .! /,"0,&'

 
  !  !""  
  1

  $!" "  !  ,++ '!

!

"23- ,!  '$4  +
 

!'   '.!

""5  % 6 !&'
"4,

7 ! ,8!9:$!   

,4 6 '.

!  &' 
"    4   '",  ;!$ !  7  ! ,  8!  '"9:,"+$ ""3$'"< "35

8:=!! !  + !, !"  '"& "3 !"$ !  ""    4+       



674  :> :=!! !  + !, !  "    '"    &     $  ! "" 4+ 74  :

'.!"$!! !'-" )" 745 :    !  *4+   )"  3!!        "> :=!! !"  '""! ""   !4+    74   :3! $-"   "  - ! !)"+!  ,$ '"$ !

""4   ? !

  !-! @*4   A @> -:=!! !  + !, )"67:7-:!' $!".-B> -:=!! !"  '"& !"$ !!

""!-"! )"

745: !*4+ )"3!  C, !     

""  ! .  !       .

$!>9 C   3    "-    !      !   - .

-"-        
    

 +.  '    !

""'"!-""$!3B!/$ ,/"! ),

 !"+  !)'' D! ."%3!#"$ !  +'"$! ". 

$ $ @" @ !   3!"&'0 "

%"4, 67  ! ,@0%@:" !; "%" 4,  7!      @!;%@:- $ 

CC!   ,&'
"4,

7  ! ,@!
@:+'$3!

 +  

 !

' $ 4'"   E C 

  $" ". "<  ".   !0%3"" ;% E!. 

,4    ., !

""  

"    !  $     -    "  4  4+ , 3!  ,  0 "  $ ,      !"    "$'".

  C1C 

74 5:! F$B -   "  4  4+             .      ! +4++  +   
 ,1,

5  3!  

  +  C

 

       ! ,  !    *4    4 ;++ ,  !""4+ 

5

 C 

74 5 :74 ':!

    *4    A   G  7*AG:    $".,  !  

""   3 4+   +  .+    "  4    !     C

 

  '&    !  +4++  "+   
 ,1,

5   A  !   !' +'.!4$! , 'B ,"-  $!. 



5

3  B  $".,  5*4 4A

 5+5$! .,  !", 

 )"6 !&'0 "%"47  + *4+ :)",

7  ! ,@!)"@:4 "3!. 4+ !"'""  ""$"".""$" 4 
,, 6 5 ++ !!  !"$! $ -" ! % 7:C 5 !0% !

""!,B$! "!!  +

 
,, 6 53! $8!"$! $98"49 + + 23- ,!'- " !

"""-   "".,-  

74 5 C:,!""!4+  )"67:7-: !)"

 -"$! )" 745:  7:  3!C 5 !0% E3"!"!!

"4  " ?  !+ BE  $!    



5

,!   ,

"

" !+++ <" .$ < + "38*4  A  G9  )" 745: !)"$$ -'.!     

74 5C:,!

"" "

"'   !   .  *4    4  ;++  7

":,  /"! -,/"! 3! +!'B  3!    !     $!  ". !

-   C 

C74 5:  $-$

 .

! $!

"",  

 3!! $ $-         

 74   5C:    ""  ! 4+ $ !

""-  C 6

 74   5:  $$ -  '.  !           C 6

 74   5:,   !  

""      3      

"   %

7:7: !0%'    C,3!!3  +-  1

74 5 :#$ , !  

""  

!  !  &' 
"    4   '", ;!$ !7!      @! '"@:'.3. "$

",'  +  " 2! 

" '.!

""5

  =!-! " "  !    D "  !

""'+!!!  '"3+ !  @*4  A G@$- )" "745: !)",3!!3!  -!!

3"$"".'4   ?  "+4+  )"67:7-: !)" 2,5!-$! @*4   A G@ )" 745: !)"" -" . ! - ! !)"+!       "!  !     3!  &     "

  ! "" !4+ E3  ! '+!! ! '"3! !"$!!

"" !$ '

8!"$  ! $9  3  ! F".  ! $$  8"  49  +   + $8;9H +8%IIEE9H +!"- -" 0% )"*-! 3,!  + E , &'!-  ++!"" 4+ 

!

"",!   ,!+33 $".""'.!  5 !  A!! !," %"3!"  $! '- $+ " "  !

"" .  +"

!

" 1 =  !-  $-     '"  !$!    !  -" '++'." "  !   6 !3!    !

"  5 7:=!!  !  !   '"3       ""$  ! 4+ $ !  '$*4  

A G> 7:=!! !

""!! $".!"$! $

++ >

#  "$3!! $+, .   !  @*4  A G@$-)" 745: !)" 3!! !5 8)" 7:74:

III III III 745: 



      

  

! 

   " 

#     ! 



       

 

    

   $%#  &

'



 

         

         ( 

#  )$*    " !'- -!3!4   "

? ! '.@*4  A G@!+ B E+ " . E!'$ "".  '.!$ ! .!!+. 



5

,!

4    !$    E   E  !  +  . 

5

,  !

""4  ". 6?  !+ BE H ! ,  $$! $!!"-$ +,3 '.!$! .!!

""!! $"4 !"-! " !+!"'B !  -!8%97&'%"4:8;%97; "%" 4:!+.' !$! ." !!

""!! ! $  - .!"$! $ +! +  +!+!"-! A".+'""  3 $ $93! $3!!3   $". !  " "$!"4"+3 !   ! ! + ,!,! ""+ $ "$!"43"" +!+ 23- ,"4 ""  + !  +   3       '.  !  

""   0- +  .-" ! % 7: 5 !0%"  .!'- ,!$! .

-+!" "-! !  !'- "-! 3 -  '.!

"" ! !

""!!".! $8!"$! $9 ++  3'"-'.!$! .   $!

3!3"$  $C     !"25! '"  -D+7

""
 1

:    

 !"#"$7

""
 

:3! !   8;%9 
, C, 1 7H +/5 C $:8%9
C ,6

 89 
  C6 3     $ ""$
, ,1 C C

! !

""!! 3 3 $".+3 ' $"$-.  .  ".!

""3" '"-,' +$ ! $$ 8!"$! $9 !"- '"" !"'B*-! 3!

!+'  !$! .!!+ - + !+ ""4!,3 $!".!"'.!$ ! .!!

""!-"! ! "

 $".,3".4+  )"67 : !)" ! "- $  '.!$A

  "$! $$ "4 !5 82 ,!!" 3$ 4+  

 C

-""44+  
,1,

5  !   +C



   !-#!" "".'.-"$ ! "3 "! $"" "4 !!; " +!+      !  +  3!  !+    ""$"    "  !+,3!!!++!+! "- '""!!34+  + .+

"4!!+ "- B3!! "" 7!" :34+  + .+ 4" ! $"""4 +!+! ! 

+"-  "! "=!!+,! !' "! $$""$4 +! + ! - +! "    

6  %+3 * ,;+' 

  J   !"25! '"7:D+, 3!  -  ! $$?;%$@;@  + $  ; . !$ +-"'"   %+"    'B'.!! " " !" !! $"4 !! ; "!"-!  !+"'B  !  -!8%97&'"4:

8;%97; "%"4:!+.'E  

- .'""   .!'+!"'B! "  !  ! $    -  . !"$  ! $

+!+ !+! .3!  "-!  "'BA".+'""8  3 $  $9! $3!!  $"." 'B "+!  "  "$!"4"+ ! !

!+ !! ""+ "  $ "$"4"" +!+ !+ "4! $""
 ,  5
,

,  !!; "  -". $!.

5

+!+ 3!!!' '.! " !0-  .3 !"    $$ ! $! !     "". "-! , 'B!  "-  ,E !!" !! $4 B'!3! F    -  !  < +  +      -"$ 4+ '$*AG!-' "

""'.!+!

!! -! !&'  + *4+ )"

E-3 !'-+ , !4+ $  !&'*4+    +)",

! '.""9 !   .  *4    4  ;++  7

":  !"  !

$     '.  !  $  A

   A   !  

"  '.  ! ,  !   '"     3!  !  $     '.  ! !   '"3  !   '"     !  !  

""  3    @*4  A G@3!! ""3$' -5 8)"  67:  -    ""      +   *4+   ;        "  7-:    !  ",  ! 7*4+       +:      3  "'"    ' "" . ! !3 -" ;"    !  

""   $  !  !  4+    !'3 $".""

""! -". "23- ,  $ 4   E

 3 ' ? $"3<  

, 6? $!. 

5

 ?!   <  

C;"  !

""!  ".

!!

""!''"+! < + 4     ?  !+ B



E""!+.''"""-

 ,3!!-". !4+ 3" ! 34   =!

""!! $!''"+ ".

3!  < +    +  3!  !       *4   A G$-)" "745: &'0 "

%"47K*:)"-+.''"+!  $""!! -" )"67:

;"7-: &'0 "%"47K*:)",

 G ! +,!4+ 3 "'"'"",!- . !,!  + !

"!+ $".,+9  #!  !    !-  $!".  '  "  $  !

""D "  !

""!''"!3.

""$".   - .! $  '.!! '"3 3 $  '.!; !,< "3"+  3 $!

""!

";<".,'!!

"+



 !

"#$$ %& 

 
&  '()    '() )*$)!+)",-,./0 "#12 3(1