← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/6935/2016dismissed

Sohan Singh v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2016-09-15Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan7 pages

       

         

         

         

   

 

 

 

 

   

 

 

  !

 

 

  !

 

 

  !

 

 

  !

"

#$%&'()* #+'$ ,$-+ # ./01 

*&,&,#$*2 *2%3%

&'&*#4'25'$''$6#&+*2%

*%7#$6*$&%   8

9      

   

   8

9      

   

   8

9      

   

   8

9      

   

 2*%*$& 2*%*$& 2*%*$& 2*%*$&  #7*2'!6:#;'&*4#2&+*7*&,&,#$*2 ':, 2'&'7 ,$-+!%%,%&'$&6:#;'&**$*2')!

'25'$'

<=<=<= <=<=<= <=<=<= <=<=<=  

   

!  

   

!  

   

!  

   

! +*7*&,&,#$*2!>+#>'%%*2:,$-'%'#$%&'()*>,&+ &+*'25'$' #),;*!'%%',)%&+*:'),6,&5#4#26*26'&*6 0!

$$*"32*  !  >+*2*(5  +*  +'%  (**$  6,%?,%%*6  42#?  %*2:,;* +'))*$-*,%')%#&#&+*#26*2%6'&*6 0'$60 !

$$*"32*%   '$6   2*%7*;&,:*)5!'$6 ,$&*2?%#4>+,;+&+* 7*$')&5  #4  6,%?,%%')  +'%  (**$  '44,2?*6  (5  &+*  77*))'&*  '$6 *:,%,#$')3&+#2,&,*%  *&,&,#$*2>'%*$2#))*6'%#$%&'()*,$&+*#??'$6# #),;*!'25'$',$ #:*?(*2! +,)*7#%&*6'&'25'$''@ +'>'$!  +'$6,-'2+!  7*&,&,#$*2  '(%*$&*6  42#?  63&5  > .

  *>'%7)';*63$6*2%3%7*$%,#$:,6*#26*26'&*6

     *&,&,#$*2  2*7#2&*6  (';A  #$  63&5  #$  0  *-3)'2  6*7'2&?*$&')  72#;**6,$-%  >*2*  ,$,&,'&*6  '-',$%&  &+* 7*&,&,#$*2#$&+*%7*;,4,;'2&,;)*#4;+'2-*#4+':,$-2*?',$*6 '(%*$&42#?63&54#2'7*2,#6#46'5%'$60+#32% $%7*;&#2 ':,$6*2B3?'2#??'$6#! ':')B'2$')>'%'77#,$&*6'%&+*

$C3,25 44,;*2 +**$C3,252*7#2&>'%432$,%+*6#$.

+#)6,$-&+*7*&,&,#$*2&#(*-3,)&5'$6+':,$-2*?',$*6'(%*$& 42#?63&53$'3&+#2,D*6)54#2&+*7*2,#6,$C3*%&,#$ $ 0!

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

 *'2$*6  ;#3$%*)  '77*'2,$-  4#2  &+*  7*&,&,#$*2  >#3)6 '2-3*&+'&&+*;+'2-*42'?*6'-',$%&&+*7*&,&,#$*2>'%&#>'26% +,%7*2,#6#4'(%*$;*'$6%3;+;+'2-**:*$,463)572#:*6>#3)6 $#&4'))>,&+,$&+**"72*%%,#$E-2':*%&';&%#4?,%8;#$63;&F%#'% &#@3%&,45&+*,?7#%,&,#$#4*"&2*?*7*$')&5#46,%?,%%')  +* ,?73-$*6#26*2#46,%?,%%'),%')%#%&'&*6&#(*,))*-'),$'%?3;+ '%&+**$C3,2572#;**6,$-%+'6(**$;#$63;&*6,$2*)'&,#$&#' %7*;,4,;'2&,;)*#4;+'2-*, +':,$-2*?',$*6'(%*$&4#26'5% '$60+#32%!>+*2*'%4,$')#26*2+'%(**$7'%%*6(5#(%*2:,$-

 &+'&&+*7*&,&,#$*2#$72*:,#3%#;;'%,#$%+'62*?',$*6'(%*$& &,?*%   2-3?*$&  2',%*6  ,%  &+'&  &+*  7*&,&,#$*2  +'6  $#&  (**$ ;+'2-*6,$2*%7*;&#4&+*72*:,#3%#;;'%,#$%#4'(%*$;*'$6 '%  %3;+!  &+*  72*%*$&  6*7'2&?*$&')  *$C3,25  ;#3)6  $#&  +':* ;3)?,$'&*6,$'$#26*2#46,%?,%%')  %3(?,%%,#$'%2*-'26% :,#)'&,#$#472,$;,7)*%#4$'&32')@3%&,;*+'%')%#(**$2',%*6(5 ;#$&*$6,$-  &+'&  ,&  >'%  +2,  '2>')!   !  *73&5

37*2,$&*$6*$&#4 #),;*#??'$6#>+#>'%&+*;#?7)',$'$&'% ')%##$*#4&+*72#%*;3&,#$>,&$*%%*%632,$-&+*;#32%*#4*$C3,25 '$6>+*2*'%&+* $C3,25 44,;*2>'%'$#44,;,')@3$,#2,$2'$A, $%7*;&#2':,$6*2B3?'2 *'2$*6;#3$%*)>#3)6;#$&*$6&+'& *$&23%&?*$& #4  6*7'2&?*$&')  *$C3,25  ,$ &+*  +'$6%  #4 ' @3$,#2 3$6*2%3;+;,2;3?%&'$;*%+'%;)*'2)5>#2A*6&#&+*72*@36,;*#4 &+*  7*&,&,#$*2  '%  '$  #44,;,')  #4  &+*  2'$A  #4  $%7*;&#2  >#3)6 ;*2&',$)5(*%>'5*6'$6,$4)3*$;*6(5&+*;#?7)',$'$&'%')%# 72#%*;3&,#$>,&$*%%+#)6,$-'%*$,#22'$A .

*'2$*6;#3$%*)4#2&+*7*&,&,#$*2+'%(**$+*'26'& )*$-&+'$67)*'6,$-%#$2*;#26+':*(**$7*23%*6  3)* GH#4&+* 3$@'( #),;*3)*%!.G4#2%+#2& 9&+*3)*%.9H'$6'%'77),;'()*&#&+* &'&*#4'25'$'2*'6% '%4#))#>% ,%?,%%')%+'))(*'>'26*6#$)54#2&+*-2':*%&';&% #4?,%;#$63;&#2'%&+*;3?3)'&,:**44*;&#4;#$&,$3*6 ?,%;#$63;&  72#:,$-  ,$;#22,-,(,),&5  '$6  ;#?7)*&* 3$4,&$*%%4#27#),;*%*2:,;*!,$?'A,$-%3;+'$'>'26 2*-'26%+'))(*+'6&#&+*)*$-&+#4%*2:,;*#4&+* #44*$6*2'$6+,%;)',?&#7*$%,#$

.

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

6,%;,7),$'254#2;* *+'6(**$'%%,-$*663&5,$&+*'25'$''@ +'>'$  '&  +'$6,-'2+   +*  '%%,-$?*$&  ,$:#):*6  72#:,6,$- %*;32,&5&#'+,-+72#4,)* 3;+'%%,-$?*$&;#3)6$#&'44#26 '$5)'",&5 +*;+'2-*#4+':,$-2*?',$*6'(%*$&#:*2'7*2,#6 ,$*";*%%#46'5%3$'3&+#2,D*6)5%&'$6%72#:*6 $+,%%*2:,;* &*$32*#4#$)54,:*5*'2%!7*&,&,#$*2+'%2*?',$*6'(%*$&#$'% ?'$5 '% #;;'%,#$%  $6*2%3;+;,2;3?%&'$;*%!&+,%#32& >#3)64,$6$#@3%&,4,;'&,#$,$,$&*24*2,$->,&+&+*#7,$,#$4#2?*6 (5&+* 3$,%+,$-3&+#2,&5,$+#)6,$-&+*7*&,&,#$*2&#(*3$4,&&# (*2*&',$*6,$%*2:,;* +*  %3(?,%%,#$  2',%*6  (5  &+*  )*'2$*6  ;#3$%*)  '% 2*-'26%:,#)'&,#$#4&+*72,$;,7)*%#4$'&32')@3%&,;*'$6'$ 44,;*2 #4'@3$,#22'$A;#$63;&,$-'$*$C3,25,$&+*(';A62#7#4&+* ;+'2-* )*:*))*6 (5 &+*;#?7)',$'$&>+# >'% +#)6,$- '%*$,#2 2'$A!  >#3)6  (*  #4  $#  ;#$%*C3*$;* 32,$-  &+*  ;#32%*  #4 '2-3?*$&%!,&+'%(**$;#$;*6*6&+'&'7'2&42#?&+*;#?7)',$'$&

 >+#>'%+#)6,$-&+*2'$A#4 *73&5 37*2,$&*$6*$&#4  #),;*!

4#32  #&+*2  72#%*;3&,#$  >,&$*%%*%  +'6  (**$  *"'?,$*6  (5  &+*

$C3,25  44,;*2  &#  72*%%  +#?*  &+*  ;+'2-* :*$  #&+*2>,%*!

7*23%')#4&+*%&'&3&#25'77*')72*4*22*6 '-',$%&&+*#26*2#4 6,%?,%%')  >#3)6  2*:*')  &+'&  &+*  7*&,&,#$*2  +'6  '6?,&&*6   +,% '(%*$;*4#2&+*7*2,#6,$C3*%&,#$'$6>,&+#3&':',),$-#4'$5 '3&+#2,D'&,#$  +*2*)*:'$&*"&2';&42#?&+*'77*')7)';*6#$ 2*;#26'$6'77*$6*6'%$$*"32* 2*'6%'%3$6*2 E+'&&+*'))*-*6'(%*$&#4&+*'77*))'$&*"8#$%&'()*

#+'$  ,$-+  # ./01    >'%  $#&  A$#>,$-)5  '$6 ,$&*$&,#$'))5  (*;'3%*  #$  .

 0  ,$  &+*  ?#2$,$- '4&*2&+*63&5#4&+*'77*))'$&#$%&'()*37&#  '

?

 ,%   #:*2!  &+*  '77*))'$&  "8#$%&'()*  '))  #4  '

%366*$+'62*;*,:*6'&*)*7+#$,;?*%%'-*42#?+,% >,4*&+'&$%+36'3-+&*2#4&+*'77*))'$& "

#$%&'()* +'%  (**$  %344*2,$-  42#?  7$*3?#$,'  '$6  %&+?',; 6,%*'%*  '$6  ,%  %*2,#3% $  &+,%!  &+*  '77*))'$& #$%&'()*  +'6  ?'6*  +,%  (*%&  *44#2&%  &#  -,:*  +,? 7*2?,%%,#$#2)*':*(3&$#$*#4&+*%37*2,#21#44,;*2 +'6+*'26+,%2*C3*%& 4&*2'))+3?'$(*,$-+*>*$& &#)##A'4&*2+,%?,$#2;+,)6>+#)'&*2#$2*?',$*6 3$6*2&+*&2*'&?*$&#4';+,)6 "7*2& #;&#2!##6'

'&*2$,&5'$6 32%,$-#?* *+'?>+#>'%$*'2*%& &#+,%+#?*  +*2*>'%$#'$#&+*2&#)##A'4&*2&+* 6'3-+&*2#4&+*'77*))'$&'$6&+*'77*))'$&2*?',$*6 >,&++,%6'3-+&*2&#)##A'4&*2+*2&,))%+*2*?',$*6 3$6*2  &+*  &2*'&?*$&  #4  &+*  '(#:*  #%7,&')  37&# .



+*  %3(?,%%,#$  2',%*6  (5  )*'2$*6  ;#3$%*)  4#2  &+* 7*&,&,#$*2&+'&6*7'2&?*$&')72#;**6,$-%>*2*;#$63;&*6'-',$%& &+*7*&,&,#$*2#$&+*%7*;,4,;;+'2-*#4'(%*$;*42#?63&54#2' 7*2,#6#46'5%'$60+#32%'$6>+*2*'%>+,)*7'%%,$-&+*

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

$5  '%   #;;'%,#$% +*7*&,&,#$*2+'6$#2*%7#$%*&##44*2 :*$)*'2$*6 ;#3$%*)632,$-&+*;#32%*#4+*'2,$-+'%$#&(**$'()*&#2*(3& &+*4';&3')'%7*;&'%2*-'26%7*&,&,#$*2+':,$-2*?',$*6'(%*$& #$#;;'%,#$%,$+,%&*$32*#4%*2:,;*  7'2&42#?4,$6,$-&+*,$%&'$&7*&,&,#$&#(*)';A,$-,$ ?*2,&!&+,%#32&4,$6%&+'&&+*>2,&7*&,&,#$2',%*%'+,-+)5(*)'&*6 ;)',?'$66*%*2:*%&#(*6,%?,%%*6#$&+*-2#3$6#46*)'5'$6 )';+*% +*#26*2#46,%?,%%')7'%%*6(5&+* 3$,%+,$-3&+#2,&5 ,%6'&*6  77*')>'%6,%?,%%*6#$ 0'$6 2*:,%,#$>'%2*@*;&*6#$0   +*,$%&'$&7*&,&,#$+'% (**$  ,$%&,&3&*6  ,$  &+*  5*'2    '4&*2  '  7*2,#6  #4  %,"  5*'2% *'2$*6  ;#3$%*) 4#2  &+* 7*&,&,#$*2 >#3)6  ?'A*  '$ '&&*?7&  &# #:*2;#?*  6*)'5  (5  %3(?

,&&,$-  &+'&  &+*  7*&,&,#$*2  +'6  *:*$ 72*4*22*6'?*2;5'77*')(*4#2*&+*66,&,#$')+,*4 *;2*&'25&# #:*2$?*$&  '25'$'!  #?*  *7'2&?

6*;,6*6(5';257&,;#$*),$*#26*26'&*60 '$6&+'&&## '4&*24,),$-#4&+*,$%&'$&7*&,&,#$ :*$%3;+%3(?,%%,#$,%(*,$- $#&,;*6#$)5&#(*2*@*;&*6 *'2$*6;#3$%*)+'%$#&(**$'()*&# '6:*2&&#'$5%&'&3&#2572#:,%,#$3$6*2>+,;+'?*2;5'77*'),% ?',$&',$'()*'4&*22*@*;&,#$#4&+*2*:,%,#$7*&,&,#$'&&+*+'$6% #4&+* ,2*;&#2*$*2')#4 #),;*!'25'$'

$&+*;'%*#4')@,$6*2 ')@,$6*2 ')@,$6*2 ')@,$6*2 ')B'32 :

&'&*#4 3$@'('$6#&+*2%!0G.H  ')B'32 :

&'&*#4 3$@'('$6#&+*2%!0G.H  ')B'32 :

&'&*#4 3$@'('$6#&+*2%!0G.H  ')B'32 :

&'&*#4 3$@'('$6#&+*2%!0G.H !'

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

   

H G 

   

H G 

   

H G 

   

H

  !

  !

  !

  !      

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

#&*

#&*

#&*

#&* +*&+*2%7*'A,$-12*'%#$*6I +*&+*2%7*'A,$-12*'%#$*6I +*&+*2%7*'A,$-12*'%#$*6I +*&+*2%7*'A,$-12*'%#$*6I

*%1 #

*%1 #

*%1 #

*%1 # +*&+*22*4*22*6&#*7#2&*2I +*&+*22*4*22*6&#*7#2&*2I +*&+*22*4*22*6&#*7#2&*2I +*&+*22*4*22*6&#*7#2&*2I

*%1 #

*%1 #

*%1 #

*%1 #