High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/2816/2010allowed

Ranvir Singh v. Land Acquisition Collector And ORS.

2019-01-16Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari23 pages

"#$ %& '((#)*

!" #

) +,- . -.. /, $% & $'!

( & ) ! * + ,-./,.0.#12-34,505 &

( & 7 6

! * ,3/8,505 & $

(! !4 & +

! * /.0,502 & $ ! * ,3.8,3./,505#* ,052,502 4 & & )! "79 & :

;(!

"!79 & $ ! 47 << .. /,0 0 4 * + ,.0/ 4 ,505 #& = * + ,.0-!,.0.!,3/8!,3.8!,3./#12-34,505=* + /.0# ,0524,5024:9 ( * >4:9!* + ,.0/ 4,505: ;

434 :9 ( 824 !0.32 ((44 4!" 08 ,505 ( :9 ( ? ,5 > :9 : 9!

4 4 (! (

, ( 4 : 4 44 : ! ( 9! ( ! 4! 4 ! " 08!2>01 4( (+ ,4,55,,55251 5, ,552!,5!55!555@ : ( :9 1 :9 4 44 24 01 ,55, AB $C0@ !AB $C0@AB $C0@ (4:97D

:> 9! AB $C,@1AB $C,@15(> AB $C,@1 ( 52 5, ,55- ( ) ( 4 4 4 : > "

9! AB $C,@2 AB $C,@00! AB $C,@0, AB $C,@,0 AB $C,@,, AB $C,@,- ( 44 ! 9! >"

:B 9033/0333 ;

AB $C,@0, AB $C,@,0 : :9 < * ( AB $C,@,,AB $C,@,-( :9 &@ & $ $ & AB $C,@,3 AB $C,@15 > "

: :9 E &@ ' < ;

44 E ( ) 44 ( : ( :

9 9 4:> 4 >4 AB $C,@,.( 4 08 0333 4

: ( ( 0.

0331 ? 3155@

4 4 &>'$ ,- 0332 (

:94 44 4 9! 0-44 ( ( 2

9 4 + 21.4 ,2 ,55/( :) 4

! "

# $% ! ( ( : 4 : :9 ( :08 0333:9 9 44!

:9;:! 41!0-!12!1-8@ : 4 :9 7

10 ,555( 4 4 ( ( :4 : ,1 ,550 AB $1 () ( 94 4( )

! "#

" $%&' 8 & $'& 6 44 (: 4 44 ) ! 4!(4

> 4 ) : > ! 4()4) 44

( ( 9 4 E

E 9> <(4 :

: > ( :9 4

: 4 4 9 4 4 :> (B 4 9 : / & 6! ! ! :

4 9( : 4: 44 4!> ( 4 4 (4 ( > (( :94 ! ( ( > 4 : : ! :> - & & )! "79& $ !

: 447 << ! !4 ( :

( :> > 4 4 ( ( 9! ( (

> ( (94 (

-!("

%#"12 %"(#3&4 ( &'% ) . 4 ( ( :9 4 ( ( + 201@5/ ' $> !4(>( : 4(

: (51 5, ,552( :9 4,5

> (((< D9 !" ( ( 9 B + 7

(9 + .! 9! 6( 4< D9 (: ? 08555@ 9 * ( 484 3 < ( 4:97 << ! (> :E49 B4 D(:@ $): 4 D !03/1( ( ( ( !

(B ;

B 9 4 < ! D9 +7.! 9! 6 ( ( > 4 * <(4 ( ( 2 05 $C06 44 4

::403-2 (B : 4 ! ! !&7!+ ! >

9: : 4 ( (4( ;

:4 !

: 9! 9!&D9 :4 9 (85!555@ 9 <B ! AB $C0@ ! AB $C0@! AB $C0@ ( 4 AB $C0@AB $C0@ (4 :97D

00 :

( $C, :

4 9 4 "& ' 4 ! ! > AB $C,@0 ( $C,@, 4 ( ( &D9 () (9( ;

>&> &>

! :( ! >9: (:,.4(94 AB $C,@1$C,@15(B :( ( 4 &> &>

&>A ( (:24 494 ( AB $C,@, < ( 4 ( ,> (94 " ::&D9 ()) 4$ <!D9 !" ! 0.!03!,,!,1 *9() :(::9 ;

( 9855 (94 +7

(9+ . " < 4 < " < ( :9 ( 4 < B ! AB $C,@, &> ( & : (,.(94 3 (9 4 +7.

7 4 :9 4 ( ) AB $C,@,( 4AB $C,@0 0, C07 :

! "& !7 << !" ( 4

! ( 4 E : ( D4 $4 ( 03.0 : ( 8

;

( 4 ( 4( 8 4 " 7 &D9 ( 4

4 > 4 :

(: &D9 7 (( (4$ < &D9 (B " :(12> (94 <" < (05> (94 ;

( :00@,,> 4 +7

(9 $ <( 49 4 ;

(

B4$ (

(9 7(( (4 ( : 4( 4( ;

( 4 (4 4 4 01 C, '' &! & ! 7 << ! D9 ! " :

() ( 4 + ( ;

: ? 88555@ ( ( :9 )

47901 03..

;

( 4 ( 4( <B ! ( :9 0.03$ <(4>4 0. #039 ( 903.0 ;

( > 405> ;

4 108( :97 << 403.2( ,55/ (:(+7. +7

(9 <4(6

(9 4 + 4

4 44:( ( 2> ;

4 : )

(9(

: + -!("

%#"12 %"(#3&4 #"'% ) 02 9! * + ,3/84,505( ( ( 411>0- :4: 08 0333 :9 9 44! ;!

( :4 10 ,555 9

:B,1 ,550 ;

4 4 D4 4: 9 4 <; 4( <D( ( 0/ ,55, :5- ,55,: 9 :4 201 ,552 9! 4 :94 (( :9

: 9 C$ + 0-,/8 4 ,551 ;

( (:9: (

;

( 9

(

?-5.5> 08 4 4 7 << ( )* '+ ( (9 9B ( (

:)4 0/ < 4! : &+ ,2/,<,50. * ,.0/,505 4 : 4 20 ,- $ 4 4 B 9 4 9 4 9 ( 4 ;

( : ( 9 ( ::( 4 : 0- ,2 ,55,! ,0 5.

,55,!,3 ,55,!0.

,550!,3 ,551#53 0, ,55,( : B , - < :

: 4 9 4 4 ! 494 ,## : 94 9

:( 0.

4 , - 9 0 ( ( @44 D9 ! " ( : 9 9

, ,2 ,55,( ( (

4 D9 ! $ < 2555

4 : ( 4 4! 4B! 4 4 4 08 4 :> >4 :4 9! ,0 5.

,55, 1 ( ( 0555

D9 :9 7 << ( ( 4 : ! 4! 4 4! 4 ( : 4 4 ! : > ,3 ,55, 2 444 :9 ,055

D9 !$ <! " ( :9 7 << 4 > ! : 4 4 4 44,115 4 0.

,550,3 ,551 8# / 4 @4 ( > 4 53 0, ,55, - ! 44+ ,51

0555

D9 !$ <!" 4 9 ;

9 0, ,55,4 :> > (:9 B 03 <() * $""+,(

4 44 : :4 4B 4( (

,5 < ") * -

,+"".%, :9 B ( (

: ( 4 9!( :99 4 4 > 9 ! 4( 944 E4 !( 4 !B4

94!> 9 4 9 4 :9 9

9 >4(@( !(>!: > 4 ! ! >! 9

9@ 44:9 @ 4 :9

9! > 4 ) 4 9

/)'

+""+,! B 4(

>:99 49( ( 9! ( 4 7

,0 < : ( ( > 9 : B(! (! ! 4 : 4 4 ( ( (4 02 ,55. 4 ( (

4 52 ,55.

B 4$C,( ,/ ,553 9( 45.

,553 ;

( 44 ,.

,553 4 ( (,1 ,553 ;

4 : 4 02 ,553 : ( 5- ,505 A9! (08 ,505 ,,

9! 44 ( ( 4 >: 4 ( 9 ! 4(:

:9(94: 4 :: ( (4 )

4 B ) 0#

".(

: 4:( 4 (> <( ( 4 4 (

: ( ( >( 4 9 > B4 9! ( 4 &+ ,2/,<,50. * ,.0/,505 9 ,1

+F &! $C0 :

44 4 4( :9( :/

: : 4 + /1! F + -88 !.23 !3@0,01 !01@0,2 !02@023 4 4.3-/ 9 : <B ( :9(94

9 <(4 : &@&

( > 9 4 ,2 C, F F ! $( 03 > ( : + , &@ " :9

,8 C17 :

! "&!7 << ! : (()4: D (( 4 4 <(4 9 4 4( 9 :D .3-/ 9 :4:9 ;

4 D9 $ < $ ) $ < &D9 ( 4> 4(94 (49 <( 4944 79( ( ,/ * ::! 94 : ;

4 ( :( " + 7

(9 + . ) ,1 > (9 4 79 : ;

44 ( 4 4 ( (> < 9 ( >

03.04EB >4 4 ;

: : > 9 4 ( :) 4 :> :9 4 ;

4 ! (! 4

: ( : >4 4 >( 9) > 4 9: )

4 B : ( 4( :9 @44 (

4 BAB $C,@,2$C,@,-( ( 9( 0, 0, 033/ ( ;

(:9 4$:

B4>( (

0,53 1. 9(( (>,>- : ( 4 ( :) 4 ( (> 9:(%

!"#

" $

%"&" $

'"(( )*

,. ( ( ) 4 : ( AB $C,@, 4 :>B 4) : >4 4 > ,3

9:4 (: 4 94 4 ) ! : ( 4 ;

(( 4 4 ( ( (! 9! :94 4 4 ;

:( !:> 4 > 4

( :B :9 :9 ( > 4 ( (: < ! 4:> 4 ) : 4 >! 4 ) ( : 4 : )

4 B -

# /)+""+%1( 4 ( 4 4 44 :9 ( : ( ( 9 < ") 2

) & ) /

- 3 2 #

) '4 $""$,5!( %

-(#% #. # #,/# ## #* # *'# (# # ( # # ,/( #/0"# 12 "# 3 #

!# #,,(# # #* # *'# (# # 4# ( 5 ( /# # ,# 5(( ,# 5 (/#5(( ,% ( # ,#*'# #

*# # # "# 3 #

) # # ## /#( #% '.

## #. # 6 '# # # # ' 5 *# #*'# (# #(4# !# # ,### 5#(( #, # *# , # # #*'# (# #(4 #

# (# / # # # #"# 3 #

) ##

(# #5%/# # # #% #7## 8 # /## # ## #*, # #,# # (. 5 #*( # # ## ,## # ## # #* #*'# (# # 4# ( ## (

(# #*,

# #*, # # *,/(#(# # /# #,# ( 5 # # 4# (#*( #, # ( % . # /## (# ##. # &*# 5 ,# #,# 4 (.*# #*# ((# #/ ((# /# #, # ( ,## # ## , # / 5 ' # *'#

(# # ( # /(# & *# 5 # , ## # #*# #"# 9 3 #

: / #(%. #(#*# *# # 5 ' ( # ## ##7##.%# # %#5

# % 5 *,# / *'## * # &#/% /&# # ; 15 < & &

6 2 3 ) ,,1""$$!(

: > B 4 :4 9+4 20 4 : 9 4 ;

B : > ( ( 9 ( 4 9! B ! :> 4 : 4 4 ;

( B ! B 94 4 ( )

(9 : 4 10 9!4 4AB $C,@,( ( (: &D( 9( (:9&@& * + ,3/84,505

< 4 4 4 ( :!(: :4 < 450 ,555( ::

4( :9 : ,1 ,550AB $1 :: > 4 1, < )

:9 4> 4 :

( 4 : 4 4 < !( 4 > ( (:) 4 <

! ( : 4 : 4(: (9 > 11 <0 ")

,$&1!(

4 ( : : 4 >( 9 # 7) ! * )8#

6 / 09

,, " %%% ;

( : : A9! 94 :>4 > ( ( : 4(4( : '> :9 ! 9 4 4 :

4(9 :9 4 12

4 ( ( 11 > 0- 4 : 41!0-!12!1-8@( 2 ,1 > ( -8!5,!,0/@ ;

4 ( >44 ( 9 4 :) 4!:

: :9(94 ;

4 4 ( 9 B 4 > ( ( (( 4 4 ( :

4 : 9 ;: : 9 : 4( ::> 4 > 18

!4 > 0, 0, 033/ : :! >( 1!/,!/.!,.5@ > ( 4 :( -8G: 4 4 4B > ((:9 B ") )8 23 '4

! 4 '

"" $,! ( (> ,!-,!50!,05@ 4 >((>35!/-!5-5@ <4 4 : 4 B > ((>.,!.2!/21@ 1/

( :> (94

(9 4(9 (( ( 4 4 (! 9!C0#C, :0,#01 1- < >:) 4 (>( :>( :9 B 4 4 4 ( :! 4: (9 : (94 4 >01 ,55,( (>-8> <

""$+1! 4 9:! 9: 4 : 4 4 4 > 9: 4 : 9 > 9:(9 9:

:> <( 9: ) ( (

4 :> ( 4

9: ()(, >9 : : > 1.

4 4

B&D( 94 : 03-2 ;

: : 8 4 4(9 4 > ( 4 < 9 ( :(( 4 " :(,1> 4 79: ;

& ( 05 > (9 ( (

(9 6 5- ,55, ( B 9 4 01 ,55, ( 9 :)

4:9 :

;$.$6 &

53 ,50.( :9 4 /, 05> :( 44 &4 <&;( !& : 4:9 B(!(211 %2 *56 */%7( .(#34!.&%& % 8%#% >4

4 & +7

(9+ . :4B? 8/ 10> 13 9 4 ( 4 (94 '4 " 4 <: :9 4 : 4()4 (4 ? ,5> < ( 9> 4 ) AB $C,@,,$C,@,-9 4 4 > :

:994 9 : 25 < :

;51%'

50 ,505( ( :4( :

9:9 :9 44( 4 < 415!02 (

( 0/ (

( ( 4 % -33 8 #5 # ## ##.8 %#

# # #(####(/(#,## # ##

# ,, # #*# (# # 4# ( $ 5# #. (( # # # ( ,# ## ((# 4# #,, # # #( ,*# "# . < . # (# ## # /## , # ,# ( 5 ((# ##*((### # # , ##.*% , . 5 (/#,, , # ##(# # / #(#### #*# # *# *,# ,%/(# #( 5# #4#

( 8 % # ,,(% % ## *. # # 5 # (#% /## *# # # ,## ,, #&*# #,# . *%/## # (# , # # # ,# *(( ,( . # * # # ,## #. #

# /# ## ((%/ ((# #(%

# /%# # #((# # *# ,# . ## (# ##5## # ## *((, ( ; 20 < :

;$ $ 24 " /

! "

& ' 4 ,50.! ( 8 (B40>0.

<( ( B 9 05 > 4 (

9 0 :(:> 9! > 4( :92>03 (:) 48 (> ( 41 : : > 4 4 4 4 ( )4) 9 2, ! (!4 ( 4 > AB $C,@0, $C,@,0 : > ( :9 ( &@ < * : : ;

) + :( ( 4 >& 4 94 44 :( 4:> : 4 >

21 9! 4 4 -8 > ( : > ( 9:401 ,55, 9! 4 ( ( 22 9( (:9

& 8)"".+ *

( ..%#"4%9%2(%

:"3