High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9038/2014dismissed

R K Bansal v. Union Of India &ORS

2016-10-25Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan7 pages

! " !

!#$% &%'()(*+'$,%- ./ 0

1 #*)#2 %$($(*%- 3%-)4) *(* *&(##*&#*$5%- %)6*&%*$) + 7 8 918!9 -%)%*$+

!" "# $% ""# &'

() *% ! + &'

('"

% () 18!9 8 , !- . " # # ( , "

/(( "'*"($ -''

# ""$' '0 122

( (' ' 34$ " %

5 , $67 5,78

2229'"

% ""#

#2 223 :' ( 422 ;

<', #" # & 0 "

" '"

<',38#2 223 , " '" + 221 <', , $#'"

5, # 2 223 * 5 (

$ ( ""$>' * "

' ""#( $ " 5 /"$ 3 " , $ :'"$ >+ 9221* 12122= <',8" # ' <'2?

, ""%" , $. ; 5, !

2229 ('" 3$ ,

2229 ' $ $% #""%< ;1 2229 * $ " # 223 ""# # 2 2=221 * $" $"6 <',+8* ' 2? " 5,

2229 # 2 223 %' # " '"

<',38 "5 /"$ ## '( ' "%#>%' $@' 223#( ' "

2 223 $ "

$ "2 2A223* ""

" "$ $0(/ ' * " " + 9221* 12122= $ " ( ""$ >'

* "'""#( $ "5

/"$ 3 " , $

#%$' " '6 8* # ' <' 2? , ""%" ,.;

2229 ('" 3$ ,

2229 ' $ $% #""%< ;1 2229 0# " '%

3212 # , 5,

2229 " 12122= #'"

% ' #'"

% 2 223 '%:' " '% 42=2 5

%" 5,

2229 ' < 0 5 "3A 222A= 2229#' $( $"

2229 % # 12122= * " <' !9 !9+ "$ 0 5 $ " 3A 222A= 2229 #' $ 5,,'# ( %$.

5 2A22

# ' #

#( $ ;229 <' $ " ;22

;229#2 24224,

!'" 26! , $8 !'" 221 ( "$ #( <' $ $ " $ 223 " !'" # ( < "" 2 2422A * # "(%"

" " 6 <',38 # ("$ " " '" " '""$('( "

"$ " >+9221*

12122=6 <'!9 8' " '6 ' <'2? , ""%" ,.; 5,

2229 ('" <$ ,

2229 ' $, $. #""%< ;1 2229* # % 2 223

"$ %($"# ' 2? " 12122=6 <'!9 # " 5,!

2229#2 223 # ' " " '% 3212 26 <'!98 #"("

12122= 6 <' !9 # , 5,! 4229

2229B C 6 8+D 6 8 12122=E#'"

% ' '#'"

% 2 223 *" 3212 26 <'!98

# '% (# " "" '% 12122=* #'"

2229# % ""# # 12122=#"

<'!9 # ' >' ' 5

. ' '%:'" '% 42=2 26 <'!9+8

# #"(" 12122= %'"(%"$

222 4229 # " #F /< '< 0 5 " 3A 222A= 2229#' $( $"

2229 '" ( 5,

2229 < $ *# "# '

( $ "# 12122= # " '( % ( 0 5 " 3A 222A= 2229# 12122=%' 2 223 A2122= '"

% ( 5,

2229 " % # ( "' 12122= <'!9 8#" %$ ' " '% 3212 26 <'!98 5,# " 12122= 223* 2 223 A2122= " 5,!

2229 '%:' " 42=2 26 <'!9+8 '% 5, !

2229# " %$0 5 " 3A 222A= 2229 # 12122=*% " %" '# ,# ' " 12122= 0 5 "3A 222A= 2229 %(

0 2 223 A2122= " 5,

2229*# ("$

" ( "%$F # ( '( ((

'" 6 <',38

# " "

"$ # 2 24224 '"

' "# < @'"$ $ $ "$ #" < % $ " @'"$ #""%( < @'"$ " ( " <' ,3 5 '" < '" ' G

!!"

$ % %&

& ( $ !!)%& $

% ## !!)

* & % %

& #+ !!) #!

!!",

$ %&

%& *

$&-

' " % " < # "$

# # '( ' "# "( ' "

2 223 # <' $ " ;229 # %(

: # $ 2 2422A # "" ( ("$ 2 223 # (( "" $ # " $""

2422A*' " % <',3(

" #(( ' $ # ' # 18!9 ! '$,%- ./ 0 (9 H ! %"G