High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/7855/2015disposed of

Jang Bahadur And ORS v. Union Of India And ORS

2015-04-27Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh4 pages

!"!#$% #& ()* #( '*"

!#*" +*")"

#!##(!

#( '*"

",#(# "

-$ .*- #/01)2 * 4(0

* !#*"

! 2 !# # ' "5!#& ' )* 4 .* -)#!6 1)2 * -'

*2 # * 60*#2# -

#(!#&)#"6 , "# ! #7'

6 #!# #(!

8*",#(# 4 .* !"'! 1 )"'

64 (0

* 8*",#(# #(.*

/"''

*(3 /4((!

6(0

#* 64 )#/ 7**",#(# 9 9 :

*#( )#"6* !#*"'

#((0* 3 ,!" !# ' ' 6 *#( )#"6" * *",#(# " % #0!3 '#

)**(*3'! '3,*," , ""4# *,6;< !( 0!

!"*=)!*( 7!6(7; '*",#(# " '6 #( !#*" 3 " =)!*(7;*",#(#

" >)#(* '

;" 4 ?@*,)76! ,)*,""*

3!(#!#&)*6 #!#& #('

; @ ' *("3*, ""(!# ';

*" #(

7; :

#( =)!"!

!#66 *82, # ) ; ', !#*"A2 !#&*!0 # !"

3'!6 """"!#& 2,#"

!#4 ' 7#!

" - !#" 9 #( ' :

#( =)!"!

!# 4 ?%4# 26;4"6

!)2 #(!# 3*# &* # (

'2(",!

'!")* !# "#$%&'( )(*(& +''% ,)-.(-#/')#0#(.( (&.**(&+1')#!

2342./.%45 "

&*!

66;'6(

0#!# " =)!"!

!#)#(*

6 !&'3 ;" 4 ?@4 ' 70 2# !#( 3 "

) *;

7#!

" * =) 66; (2!""!76 ' ( 6 #(<3#*" '

, !#*" 6" *6; ),# 3 ( !"!#" '!" )* 4 7 ' (

( ? , ""(!#3

21*- .(-1*(&*(+1') /')#0# 66.##.(')! *%*(&1*) 7./.#.( *(& +1')#4 #( 383

2)'6 *0)/')#0#(.( (&.**(&+1')#4 3'*7; '7#!

""6

!)2 #(!# !# *2" 70< !

( ( !"!# '!")* 4'

07#B #(( '"!2!6 *6;"!

)

(6 #(< 3#*" 6!

# 3 ",6 (),# '*(*"4##B)*" < <%4 , ""(7; '!")* !#"!2!6 * !* )2"

# " # '* &*!0 # !#*" !"

7"!("

")72!""!# ,,6!

!#" 4 '; **)##!#&*2 ,!66 * ,"

7* '! *"*",#(# <

;") ;*

'*6 " 702# !#(7#!

"7) '"

2 *3!

''6(#6;

# ',6

#(!* !#"'

07#&!0#7; '!")* !# '!*

"C"D' &&*!0(, !#*"'

0#3 ,,* '( '!")* ? '

*(6 *#( )#"6* * !"

"2 6#& ' #(&# '*)&' '* *(

',*!# !,6"6 !((3#7; '!")* !#6(#*# #( - 6 *&!#&"A" "C"),* D4 *# !#(!",) )* '*4 '

'7#!

""6

!)2 #(!# '

07#B #((7; '!")*

'"!2!6 *6;"!

)

(6 #(<3#*"0!(*(*(

(? !#'

& -!#&'A" " C"),* D4 # 6" 7 '

*(6; (!",) ( # '"

!* )2"

# "43 * '0!3

!"!2,*

!0),#*",#(#

" > #"!(* !#*"A 6 !2* '&* # "6

!)2 #( !# !# *( # 3!

' '( !"!# '!")* !#6(#*# #( - 6 *&!#&"A" "C"),* D

'3*!

, !#!" *(!#&6;(!","(!# '663!#&

*2"$< C!D ', !#*""'

6620 ,,6!

!#C"D7* # !!( 2, # ) ;< )2<:

#( =)!"!

66 *3!

'!# ,*!(#2# '* '&* #

!(7#!

"E C!!D '"

!(2, # ) ;3!66!"")# ! #(

66* '* *("8*,6;*2 '

;

) ;#(!

E C!!!D '2, # ) ;"'

66 '* *( *2!# 3'

'* * # !#*" * # 6(

!(7#!

"4", !

66;!#0!3 '( !"!#"

'!")* #( '#F76-),*2)* *6!( ),#7; ' 6 !2 # "E C!0D !#*" *)#(# 6( 4 "6", 5!#& "),,62#

*;3 *( '!" "'

667, ""( 3!

'!# ,*!()*2# '"*2 '(

!6!#&

,,6!

!#C"DE

3 C0D '

;") ;#(!

66(,"!

2)# 4! #;4, ;

76!# *2""),,62#

*(4!#!# <7 *!#&!B((,"!

)# C"D!#

#;#

6!G(7 #5 #((!"7)*"2# '*"'

7 ")7/ ' !# 6 ( !"!# ' #F76 -),*2)* !#-, !

6 :

0 ,, 6C!0!6D % % 6($ */ !* *4

!&'3 ;4+0"

/"'3 *-!#&' #( *"

, !#"

#("(!","( *(!#&6; 2

4 7$ 9).% !

4 &7"