High Court of Punjab and HaryanaESA/40/2013dismissed

Parminder Kaur v. Manjinder Kaur And ANR

2016-01-11Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal13 pages

!"#$%&'"(!)"

**'++!%,-

!%.$%&'"(!)"!%&!%,/'"

'-*%&'%,- 01 2

3/',/'""'*",'"- +4!+%'5-*!*'"-#!67'!++5'&, -''.)&8#'%,9

7'"'

'""'&,"'*",'"-"%,9

3/',/'",/'.)&8#'%,-/)+&7'"'*",'&$%,/'$8'-,9

! "##

$% "&"# ! " #

:::::

; '(

)

&

$!

* +,-.

/

"

" .

0"!

,#

-"

& - !"

!

.

- 0"&

$!

- - .-

&

3 2 * +,

"

# "

'(

##

.5 /

" -5

" 6 " ##

-5 . "

#!

"54. - "

-" . *

4"

4" "

5

#

" .

41- 4"+7

87

!

4

# *

4"

4" 54. - +- 4" "-5 ##

" 4

+ + "-5 ##

#

#

+- 4" -"!

0" *

++++ +

! " -5 ##

"-

" "

"

"! ) " , 54. - "

-" "

"#

"-5 ##

!"

# " -""

"#.#-5 ##

5 4

". 3 + - 4" # " -" 0"&

* 8+ + , 9

: -"! "##

"

"

" ! -5 " -

#

" ## # " - " "

.

4

"#

"-5

',(

0" 54. - "

-" -

#

"!

4

"#

" ! "

4

4

"#

+; & & -

4 , < ,"" -

4

7

" " ". +=>& &

0"

##

!%#

"

# "#

.

"! ?

@)$ * 81 8 <

++)&

4 4-54. - "

-" -"!

"# 3"@)$

-

!-"& " 3 0" 54. - " !#

" "

##4.

,

"

"54. -"

4" !

/ !

# - 4"-

,-

A $

+ . " $

8 " "!- # 46 " 6 0"! !

" ""

4 -

". "

&

#

- "

44. , 0" & "

;

;

)

"

" !

" 4" "-5 ##

0" ;

; -

."&-

. ."& " .

-54. - "

" "!

4"% 4 +1 +

!"-5 ##

3"#

+;& & - " !

." "-5 #" 0"-5

"!

4 % 4-"

4" -"!

#

4" .#4 54. 6

0"4" " 54. - "

##

4

"54. ;

;-"

. " .# 4

B"

4

4

"

".

0" "

" 6 4 " 6 "4""4 "& "-

4 * ;,;

"!-4

0"-5 ##

.

4% - "

4 .

## 4

" + 1

4" * ;,;-"##

.

0" "

! " " !

"-

4.

#

##4

4"6 #

"

" ! 6 " # " #

+; +& & .

##

" ."#

454.

< +

&

* 8+ + ,

?

.

4% -"54. 6 " .

4

4

* ;,;

". " 1"-5

"

4"54. ;

; "

"

#

4

-5 , <

" 6 4"-

54. ;

;

'+(

0"-5 ##

"

"

"4 "4.

,

4

. " "" . ##

" 4" "-5 ';(

"

4"

.

1

"

-" " ) "

. "4""

""! "## "

"-

4"4.

, "

"

# -" "

" 0"

4 . " "4 % - "3##

"

-" "

0"

4 ## - " 54. - 4

" 54. " &"

- % - " " " " " ## "

0" 26

4 & " %

6 # "

-"-5 %

4#.

=

5 4

"!

4"*

4" "

4" "

" "!

- 4.

, 6 - " " ". "

# "54. #

* 8+ + ,"!

.

4

#

"-5

!

" + + % 4

2! "! "

4"

4"

## 4

"54. #

#.

5

-"-5 "

4" % -5 4

4# - " 54. -"!

4

+ " -

44.

" " - %

- "

-

54. - -5 '(

C .

1

"

"

""

4"

" .

4 - .

/ 4

"

. #.

5

0"-5

"!-

"4 "" + + 6 -"

4"*

4"

4""

-

# - # "

!

- "-5 ##

> '1(

4

"

.

4" -5

"-5 ##

"-5 ##

## - "

4 @"4" "

-"

""

.

-"

4 @"4" "

- !

54. + "

""# 2 .-

"

&

'<(

)"!"

"#

'8(

D

"##

" 4" "-5

-"##

" "!- -

4### .

4

?-5

- ..

" 4

4

"4 ""# - # "

!

- "##

-5

'(

D

"##

" "4 " "

##

- " 54. -

!

.

-"

4"

&

* 8+ + ,

"

"" .

44.

, - "

4"

/

# .

4- 4" -

,-

2!

"

-" " " . #

" -5 ##

" - 4 !

# " 54. .

? - #

;

;

0" # "

-

4 .# "-5 ##

.

4 % - " + +

'(

) "

4""- !

.-"E F- #6 &

!

"#

$

% &&'

(

)

*#* #+,

" "- ./ #0 12 # 3

$## # ), "#

" ##

4 " ##

! ""

"6 #

#!-

! )

# -"#

4"#

"

4"-6 " - -

- "

- .#

4"

. # ) 3 "

" -

% "

"

26

4 & " . ##

"

" "!# -

4###

0"6 # ;0

# $ ?&& .

-

'(

?$ &&# - " "

4

8< "

##

-

@ 6 "#

..!- ## -# "."54. -"

" ##"

"

"

""

#

"

#

"#

',(

D

4 " ; 0

# <<

6 #

) " # ! "4" "

" - #

-" . - "! "

4" " "

4

"" 5

" ! " ##

4

" 54. ;

;" .

"

'+(

D

"##

5 # 6

, )*#* #474 " "

! 3

! !

"6

"""

!

3 " ." -

% "

""26

4& " "!."

';(

* "3 "

"

-

" # ##

"""& - "! 4"

.

"-5

".

4

" "!

"-5 # -

!

#!

?$ 81 "&&G*

-?$ "&&#!

"$ 8< "&& "

## "

-

6 "#

..!- ## -#

"."54. -"

" ## "

" " 4

-"6 #

;"0

# <<# "" "

"

!

"

" 4" ..!- ##

! ! " ##

-

"

"- #" " 4" "#" "

". -."

6 # "" "&

".

. .#

'(

6 # #!

;"

" F "

## " "

! #!-"#

4"#

" " "

"

4" - 6 " -

-

- " "

! 0"

4""

"##

.

..

3 .

"# # - " -5

" "! - -

4###

'1(

?

""" 4

"

" # "

# 54. "

&

0 "5 6"5

) *#* # + " " #

# "

4"##."54. -

4" " ##

" " "

- - " 0

#

# ."!

! " ""

%

.4" ""

""

#

'<(

D

" # " "

# 54. "

&

!8$"

"5 "5 ,, ## # 4 (! 6 "50

## # +4+ (! "##

".

4

3 "

.

4"# "# "

- -" E

#

54.

"- E 4" &

8- 899 3 /: *' ,,# # # $) 8- 54. 7.-E 4"

&

1 #'

0

; ;-&

## # , -&

"54. / %E 4"&

% " 0& ,,,

## # +

%

80"--8%''

$ # # # +)+ % "

4"

4" " "

"

" ##

" . "##

- #.

# ".

#

C" "##

" !

".

4"

" #

" & " . ##

.

"##

?$ 81"&& '8(

## " 54. ;

;" -

-"-5 ##

-&

"

"

#

4-"

& .

" + + .-6

# 1- 4"+ -

4"#

#. "

"

8 0" #

!

-

!

" "" -"!

. "

4"

4" -

. ! 4

"54. ;

;"##

-"D ##

& " .

.

'(

) !

" "

-

""

;

;

! - 54. - " "

'(

E!

4

" -.

"

4"" #

% -!"##

-4

4 -"

&

!

" "

""

.-6

4"#

"

"

8 !

"54. ;

;" -

-"-5 ##

-&

"

"

#

4-" &"

##

-

! . " .

.

!%)!"6

;

=

5