← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaESA/47/2013allowed

Prem Lata v. Jagdish Kumar & ORS

2015-10-20Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal18 pages



       

!

"#$

%& '() "* +*, --.. / 01234*+12+

-1 "#5

%& '() "*21+3. --.. / 01234*+12+

-1 % "!



%& '() "*"4*+ --.. / 01234*+12+

-1  ( 



     

 

    

 





 

 !

 " 



    #

 



$$$$         ! "#

$%  &'%(!)* +  # %  )* ,

&'%(!) '

%#%-).-( *

  /

%&'

()  ** +,* -   ./ .0

32&4  5 

6 

  5  

-   ./

32&4 

* * 7  8



 %3'

(

 ,*

    29 &2 &0/4  ,



: , 

 )

 * &:.   *, 4&222 ;, 8 <) #





    *  ,*) ,  7 <**  5

,*)          %4'

 

,   3 43 ..

*



   *  

      ,*5 *   5, ,= "

    



-

>



:

 , 



&4?

&4?=1 &10 &/.

&?2=?

&?9 ?0=4 ?9 &3??

/9 /9 ?9 ?9 ..

&&?

&&?

&?3=3 &/1 3&/3 @ ?1./ A  )     

?1./ ;, 

,  %.'

#* 7  #* * <  

, 



 #+  

( 

: , 

, 



      

 ==   (  5



 <  

,  5 * 6   ,5+ *

*:**= &!

"

,@ , 5, ,=

- 

# > 

)

@ <  

)

@



, 

)



> , (

  > ( 3!

 >

, @

, 5,

,= - 

,

"*   >  8   

,

,*

, 

 ,

 

> ( 4!



,  09 @ , 5,

,= - 

 > 

*   

* 

,  C+)

 ,

  > ( .!



, @ , 5,

,= - 

,

,5 

>  <+   



, 

,



> , ( (D ( 1!

7 ,  , @ ,

5, ,= - 



#+ *) >     

  ()

, 

,

"*   7 ,

  >

( ?!

"  @  5, ,= -  )

 8)

*, 0E?EE

>  ,5  *, 0E?EE  

 8) *, 4.=9EE

, 

 7F*  <*

( (D (

%1'

6 *

  * = &!

#*

 

,  09 * 

 4   * 

 ?

5  &:4  ( 

   > 3!

7

    , * 

 1  

,  09 * 

 4

 4!

 #*  5  5  * > , * 

 3   * 

 ?

.!

* <  , * 

 .

5  * < 1!

A  A  5 : 7 (    , * 

 & %?'

(  * 5 F,

;

, #

<  &  F , ,= 







   

    

       

 



    

  ! " #     

 $     %

& '

(  '

& '

 



 

)*     +  *,,)  )

 ** F, &4 2. &091 5  * %/'

F, > 30 21 &093

8

: 

;, F,

 

?1./

#

* 

 ) &0/4 ",

 

 F,  43.& &9 29 &09?

 * 7 

/0

   *    ,  ,  ,   ) &09/    F, =?

%9'

*,  )





?1./

 :*

5  ,:*



  5 * 

  *   *   == *

 ,

     

  %0'

"

3. 2. &09?   * * 

 * 8

 = 

 5+ &2 29 &09/   ,

=F,5)

  8

   , &2 29 &09/  ;, %&2'

*

42 20 &099 

,5 8, A < ( @  8

 F,

3? && &00.

 7#

     , /0

  &9 29 &09?

*)

,* 8 <

 , /0



 

 ,  

,   , * -F, 

   ,    * 

* %&&'

  

#

   )



,

>   *

) &00? 8

5* , 

 *  * 5

  F,

@  F, )   21 &3 322?

%&3'

A F, 

  ,   ,

 * " ;,

 5, )

F, 

 5+  F, ,

 

, %&4'

F, 

* , #  &

 < #  499.

  * 

3. &3 3220   F, 42 21 3229    

3. &3 3220   <, 

 <  1///

32&& 

E5

,*

E5

,*   &9 2/ 32&&   

3. &3 3220     42 21 3229  F,  F,  5+ )

 

, A 5+

  )   

 ) , 5+

,*

,     , = 5+ %&.'

F,   21 29 32&4 * 5+

  5+ 

 29 23 3229 @ 5+      3& 29 32&2 

  ;,  ,   3& 29 32&2 

 ,

/0

   8, 29 20 32&2 , ,*  

E5

,* *     

 

F, <,  ,    F,   21 29 32&4 * 5+ %&1'

 !

     8, #

* 33 29 32&4  )  -F,

  *

  %&?'

7 ,

     

* ,  



 *

     ,

 

?1./  ,

 20 2& &0/.     ;,

)     ,   * 

,,)  5, *

   

= ,

5 , 

 F,5 , ,

   5 , 

== ) ,5+ *

%&/'

7 ,

 ,   , /0

)

    

 * == ) , , ;, &4 2. &091   , ,  ) ,     * 

* 

  *  7 ,

, ,  

?1./

,

 20 2& &0/.    



F,   

* 

  



,)     

)

= 

     *

 *, )    ,     *    F

    

 ,

  5 =  , )

=  

%&9'

7 ,    F

, *

F,  ( *) 

  (  ) ) #

* ,5+ *

  !

 

#

- *

 ( ;,



 

       

F,  F*  " *  



    ,

/0

) &09?

,

 

,5;, 



5

* 5

, ,   *5  ,  , 

 *  ,

%&0'

     

  ,

 * F     F *,   &9 29 &09?



/0

F,

 F,  ,

* ,   5+ %32'

,

    



* ,  

  &9 29 &09?

)  ,   F

, *

  , , ) F

 ,

,5;, F, *



I

A 5

*  , ) , 5  ) F

)  

5  7 &9 29 &09?



 

, *

 %3&'

)

 ?1./

,

 20 2& &0/.

 5

     ;, 



,*5

 +

*)  , #

5  

)  (  5,   ( * 5   *

 #

,  )

 F, > 30 21 &093

8

:  

 5* * 

)  )  

  24 &3 &091  * 

A *  32 2. &002  7

 

F,

8

 

5 39 && 322?

%33'

 ;,   ,   **5 )  *  # &22:= ;,  *

 &/ &! 5!

#  I A  - 0'!  )% 1

'-)%0'!  )%  /    234  56 7,,

E5 F

 

 *  

)    6, (

  % -)(1

 --)( )% / 28759')& #6+4:

  - 0'!  )%  ,!



,  *,)  ! ).

1

 !  )% )/    272  56  2+,  

 -   0'!   )%   ,!



E5 F

  ,   **5 )

*  # &22:= ;,  *

 &/

#  %34'

,5;,)

0

1

!  & ;

!-/+44 5+6  5-16+34 

    - 0'!  )%   ,!

 =*) , ,    * F,  

,,       ,

*  # &22:= **5 ) , 

  

 * , 

 ;, 

 *,) -  F -! )- )% )1

!;'! / 28756+22



E5 F ,5;, 

%3.'

,* 

 

+

*) 

,

*  # &22:= ;, *,)  A 5

,  ,* ) *5 *

    , , ,* *5  

 5, 

     5* 5, 

) #

,

 20 2& &0/.



 5       ) @  =F 

5 

 )  ,

 A 5

=F 

 5

, 



;, *,)  A 



  )

E5 F

  %31'

#

;,   *  

) ;,  

, *

 F, 

* ,   

 ;, ,   ) , ) *

  * ,   

*

* 5

,

;, 

  **

  *  

, )

 *   * %3?'

A     5  *

 &/ &! 5!

#     ;, 5 , ,



  

 *  , )

,

    *

 F,  5 *

* ) , 5 



) ,:* 5 5   *

* , ,



 =  ,  

 *

#*    ;,   5 

 

  !

  -    

! 0'!  )%) 1

<'' ! )%) / +45-16+:8+

E5 F  

 , 5 , '   *  

%3/'

>

 &/ &! 5!

#  &029 ;, 

 * 

,,   F,  ,,) 5

A   ) ,* *)   5

  F,  

 5 

 *   ;, *,)   

=F  

    F,  * 

,,

, )

   ;,      F =F  5  I )  ) ,

 20 2& &0/.

 



 5 , #

5, 

)   F,



,



=F 

== )  #

@   ,   ,

  * , 5 *

 %39'

7 ,

  , ,

* 5    , =

+

,

*) )     * * , F,

 ,      



 , 

 @     )  #

+

,

*) )

  20 2& &0/.

, )

%30'

7 , , , )

5   *

* 

   &9 29 &09?

 

  *   %42'

6)     )

F ,  

  5 *   &/ 23 &0/9 

< #*

,+ ( 

,*

# 9222:=

*)  

 7



,5 <  &/ 3 &0/9

,*

# 9222:=

, 

34 2& &0/9



# /222:=

)   3?0

< (

,*

# .222:=   34 2& &0/9 A *     )

,5+ *

 

)



* F, 39 && 322?

8

%4&'

 * , 39 && 322?

* 

8

,*

 &9 29 &09?

F,



   

 *   

*

  





  F,



  +   , ,





  , 5* =   

&9 29 &09?



/0

  *, ,     

= 

 *    ) %43'

"    

 ,*  )    

 

,5;,   F, 

8

,* 5 ,    

8

 

*  5 *

5 ,  5 , ,)    )   F,

  

%44'

A 

5 ,

 5  

* 

5 ) ,  *

*  ,

* 

,,)  5, *

*  

  5 - 

, *

*) *)  5 )  5,  *   5  *

%4.'

&9 29 &09?

 

 

 *   * *  5 F, , 

5 , ,) ) 5 ,   5  ;, 

  ,

 

 *

,  20 2& &0/.

7 

 5+

   ) ;, 

5 ,  5 , 

 * %41'

<;,)     *,   F,     )   "5 32 32&1

& ( ") -