← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/44486/2021allowed

Munish Kumar v. State Of Punjab

2022-02-15Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl23 pages

   

  

    



 

     !"

#"

$"  %# &' (  

 

   %)%* #"

$"  %# &' (



 

   &" !"

#"

$"  %# &' (

      #"

"%#+%*%

,)"("

 -  .

"/&%* ,)"(" -

.

"%( !"# ,)"(" - .

"% ") " ,0 # &'

   23   ""

 "  (  '"*  4   



 

+ "% 

"#"*""* +"'+("-."/5 4    "*" "%-. - +".4""

*#3"(% ', 

-""'"""6,

7.#+%3 8( " "/"8 # &'

++(      '  +  '3 &"  !"

'+'3%)%*   '+'3  !" 9+" +"("    !"-("  .'8+  :" +"("-.) '! (" ("/5 '&" !"

  %)  %*    '  (("  ;    ,)  '"*

*"4#2   ' ("       ,)    "("  (+3  ""3  '*  ;  +3* -    ."!; + <'+; !"8:=+#+ #"!+>?"!+@3"+"'+;" ")" :" +-."&" !"-("  .%)%*-("

.) '"(+3+'3"2  "*+3 +8+3"(";""3"'

""3!"("(+3'*-;"*+3"+ "("  *+=  ""3  '*         ""+3 "+"("(+3 . '(+ "2 ") *"  '+    ("    "'!)" ""('3" 2 " 

          !

 "#     !"("  $%&$'& %( )* #)     !

"("  $ & $'& %+ 

    (  ,*- #,*     ! :" +"("-.) '! (" ";"!(+% ,



!

;+*)*"! "%

,

' '*) (**"'"*""0= A"# &'+3?(((""!/5+

;(* (5 "" '!+!* "**"'"0=A"# &'

 ;% ,

:"   +-.  "    ("&"  !"   %)%*) '! ("" 3    +++"3'(" "" ;  ; )'<!3   + "++8+38! !"  );("A$5

(!5 "" '! ("")+)3" :"   +  "    ("   !"      "* ! " '3  +-."  (" &" !"("%)%*  "" '!" ")"3"!("  !"("   !")!/55"* ' !(+++3'+ "!&" !" @"+ (& *!('3@B'+% ("! " .   #        .'  /  "("     $ &   $'&

""('3"2 "

     

   + 0-  #    

 !1 """"2   

(    !!"##$! +    62   #      

341  +8 ("+3' ("*'+ "!  ")"3'"!("  +' *"''++ "!! '"(+; +'!'+)@ ""

 '!("  (";(8 ( "!    '   (!'3+5, % /"8 ;;")+" "!C";8 ++ ?+9+ /"8 ;8;"(++ ; ""

"'+3!(+("'3;* ""          "    '  !      ""      -,< "#.

;(*

(("'8  ;(+'";+"* *((+"

("")*!"""*"*"*"3("* 5,%/"8 *2 ?,+%C *

/"8 )""    ""!%5 % ""%**'("") "*+3 (((+:" +" (" '!!; ++(("'+* (" +  !"

 '++3!(+:" +"("  !"

 "" '!(")+)3" 4! A  )    "  % ")  "  ,0  # &'

(("('+% '!  ++3("(""* !" "@(( ')"("*""* +"'+("-.

 '! "

"!,%5!8 "%*  ")"3'"!&" !"%)%*   "'+")'"&*" +D); "(  !"

'  !"  ""*)+!0 ( %*;; ((+!!   !" ""+! &" !" %)%*5 '!+ * "")"3"!

  !"

'

"";((';  !" &" !" :" +"("  !"

"'

+ "* !  '!("++ ""  ;((0 (' ' '3(+ ? ""+" +"(" ("

(("'8

 ,("

+/5; +;++*")"3 ;"!"("(+3""3'*- 

  .-;"*+3"+"("*+=""3'*   ""+3"+"("(+3

.;;+3*",) ; ;'*")'3("&" !"%)%*; (++""!?"2 "%&'(

%)*+,%&'( %)*-.%-/-% (".+ "

   

  

 

 !"#"#" $

%  & '& % ##

'$% ( )

 ) *) + 

+ ))

  """ 

,



- #  .   

                 +       

 +  +  ++ ) + )  +        

 /0    %      

   

+1    )         ) 

    

      )       2"    

, 

-  )  )    

 )     + 

 ,  3+-.%   ) 

   

+   +    4+ 2     

   5   )



      +            

+  + +  + )  



+  )    6   + 

+    +  )   +   

 + +  )    +           

            +)

         +)   

 )



   +

  +                      

    7        

  6

8 96'+9  #!#"# %6*:;< =

'> %

;1;

..?

8<';>@ ,("

+& *!; +;+ *   ")"3;!!"+E 3'

;  ")"3;"!"("(+3'* ! !("  ' +;'")"

;*+3 +8+3(";!!*; "("' ; +""3"'"(" (+3'* ?"2 %-0%*%&(&1,+%--)-.%-/ -% (".

""*)"+& *!!   +*""* +"'+(" +)("& *!"("  "

AAAAAA #    

 .) % .%

$7: 9*9

!"#B

#"#"?

 * &&C  ;

%

$7: 9*9

25!2

#"#"? 9%%

$7: 9*9

!"/5

#"?   

 )  A +  +))     + /$        

%+  +

 

3+ 

    )         

    

 2& + ) 7  

         

          + 

+   '$%(             )

    "5     2##"    +       

.  6'+ 9  7    

 

    DAAAAA@ ?  "  2       "   (&2/* %)* +

31%-.%-/-% (".

+ "

AAAAAA # . 

   +  

  +  1   +  +

/!+

    + 

1 

 +

  

+



1   

  

 ) +"""   

1+ 

   ))

+ .   +

)+ 

A   + )    +  )  1    

 +      )        1        +"!#" AAAAAA 2 .  %             +  

 +)+





7 %  &  '+  %    $  %   ( +    +

 

"#

#4+  1      



 



   

 +   DAAAAA B ( 

             )        

    $       + 

 

 )     

                 

)   +

+           +

    )

   +

  +

    )    )     





 )       +  

    ) 

 )  +A 

   

        7  3    6+            

   

  DAAAAA@ ,("

+')& *!; +; '+ ;*"(;" ; 3 +3"(""!%!+"+3  %0,4(&2/*(&1,+ %0,%-.%-/-% (".

"2 "+

"

AAAAAA #. 

$    

  * &

 E 9*9

25!2

 #"#"*&C ;

%

$7E 

     

'%   )

+  &  

                )    

+  '$%(

        +       )  

    +&    

"# #4+ /  +$   "!       

+  '$%( 2  

      $      +     

 5  (        

      +    +      $     )      

          

.     B' 

@ ,(""!')(" 

!"

 "" ! + "* ! "     "3")"3;!"!  !"

"; !/5'!(+++3' + "! &" !" , "2 " - #5  -% (".(++;*""

    



 +  

//#2#"% # '$% ($

% .

 '8  #

 +  )+ 

 



9 $ % $$% '+  % 

$

  %*'   %  '8 :

 ? 

 * %   )   / 

 *

&% )

  

4C,1 -'  

    

   )  3  +   2 . 

      +  )  



   )  5 0          %               )     

     +  +  

 

2/ #2#"B    %   5  #  ##  '$%  (  $

 % % .

F

55#"#" % /"4 !B //# /5/ ##2 ##5 2#4 2! 2 $ $

% % .

G

// ###"% 5 # #5 # '$%( $

% C B

     

  4

                )     +

          

 

        ++

))    

 ( )       

      +  )   +



 ! 1   

 )  

 + 



       



   7

           +          

 (6   0

  1 )    

7          ) 

             

  )   (6 0



  +    % 2/!:#?$ 

 )     7   

   +6   



 

 @ ,""2 "2  #5 -% (".(++;*""

$ 

 +  % 2/!$

!! "!"2#"#"% 5 ! #4( #

'$%( % 2" !! #B 2 2#" 2B4 2B! 24 242 $% B

0

 % ($

% $ ) 'C

$                



 

 *  ) #2!

 + C5"" 

 C )  

 )         

  

   

 

    3







 ) #4"5#"#"

)     

  7    0    #4"5#"#"          H*

0 



 *   

 

             % 2/!$



 +            

!!   !2#"#" 

   

    % 5 ! #4*( # 

'$%( !5$

 % $ ) 'C . 

                      +    + 



 

 *  )  +

#2!

 + 5"" 

  

)       



     

   

 +



  

   )

 

  

           

+

  

3   )   )    1    

    +     

    



 

"4#"#" 0

  9%  '(; 1+  9)    7           

   +6 0

0  

   



   6 

      

7  )



+    % 2/!:#?$ + 6  $7/)78/93:7:,& ; ):2"9   )7 

     + 

% 

% )  ) ) )+

 





 )+ .%    

   )

  

          *     

     ) 

      

  *       )  



%         A  $ 7     %        + 

         

  1  

            

       



    

  *    + &   

7+

.  #< 

.'/='7

/

6    %)  

) )  )    %   5/ 

'$%  (      



) 

% #5

> ((+     





)  +% #5

>( % % B4

'$%(      





'$%(

)



   )  7      #4"5#"#" )  +  

 0  + )  

 7         )  3        +  

0



+   % 2/!:#?$ $  

@ "+'!""   

-,< "#.('3,+%C * /"8; (*

(("'8"";)* 

 ;"* !("  !" ; (8  (          '   

 (!      '  ++3 !(+'3;*""'    ? "* !;""((++"("")*!" ""*("*"*5,% /"8"! "+)"( %5% ""%* " !*'("")"*+3  ((+;( ,++'); +;"" "* '+ (    ) "     ("-.  ?  ("&"

!"("%)%*" 3    ("  !")("("   3     ++("+"3'+ "" ;  ; )'<!3   + "++8+38! !" );("A$5

(!?("-." +')+)3" 9"('" "% ,

 ; +'"+)"")" & *!('3@B'+ % ("! ";++'3@* "5'7

/ >(6    2')< : 8 @B'+ % ("! ";"++*"*;; "(  8*"'6*&7   '*!!"+

3 ;(+*"'+"*""@*  "  ;"      ((+  "  *"    "* +"  '+    ' "& ,"2 "+& *!+ 7*' <    !"(" 

$& $'&  "(")% ,

<*"'+;)+)!!"+ 3?"+)("& *!"("  "

AAA**AAA**AAA &   

% /4:?:?:?    

   

 )    E+

E    

 +    

3 )+   %                     +   (          

 

  ))     +     

               +  E+

E E

 '$% (E          +            +       + 

           1   

   3    

  @ ? %(+ :) # -"!+. "3 4  

  +*"& *!"2  " ;!'3@B'+% ("! " / ""

)""      

"2 "*""* +"'+ ; ;)+);"")"3; 8*6"7 -!!"+E 3."'* 3" 3"!? ""; (+'3@B'+% ("! ")""    #"%(+:),((+-"+.4 F 

+0/;;<    1 ?  @B'+  % ("!   "    5  )  ""  

   ("!+,((+4  + 07'

#< 3';1;(+*""* +"'+ )+)* 8* *"!6"7("!"+3*"   '+ 3+ "+; ++8+38! +  5  "!+  ,((+  4       +   *'

3<     @B'+,(< ") & *!   ;+(+*"'+;" 3"';!!"+ " ,"2 "



+ 7 4'/<    ! " !" )A""  

"8*" ( +% ,

;(+*""* +"

 '+)+)*!!"+E 3;!( ("";+*"*'+ ;"("(" & *! ;" "



# 1 )     

7   +

  +

 '$%(     

  

+

+       

     

      +   @ / ""

)2 ")& *!

   (  ,%  %2

+  3  #< /8<##7#;4 *"  (;"")"3;!!"+ 35')!""

)28 "    "*  )  ;       ("F)  "

,"+  5;"*"(3"+/ ""

& *!@B'+% ("! " $/. 2&<

,*?$  &6 + ;+8  (")% ,

;"" ((+((++"; ("("!"+3 "*(" 3((+((++" +((+;+8+3'""  " """;+!)2& *!  "2 #<    !? +$ &   $'&

 % ();8+"%*B- (".;"" ++;5')& *! ;+*"  " "* +"  '+     '" *     (     ;    "  )  5    (("      !   "E "!% ,

)"  ")8 "!"(" 3 ;""""* '+(!" 3+ E  @G'+% ("! ;++)"  @* ") *"'+))+)*!!"+E 3 (*);" !   "+(" "")"+"* '+( )+) ;; +'"! "*"+ + *( +!(+   ("-."+*""* +"

'+/ ""

 "("(!( ; + !'&% ,

 ,"*+3 ++"("("++; ("-.""'"+"* +"'+" "* '+F "3'"+ "F 3*"

 '&!'*"E "3"?("-.++ +''3++;* 

?("-.;++!(";) "*"+  ?  ("-.  ;++    (" "=F!    ("  ;-.



?("-.;++(("'""+ "<

+("+("<!(  ?("-.++!!!+" ;3"  ""!!;3"  (

?  ("-.  ++    "+3  "  "+3  !8  3  ! ""("!3("E ;  !F""!+*   ""3(+""!(";) @;)"

!+" 3'3 ("-."!(+"3;  ; +'(%!)((+"++'+ *"("-. 4*')++'"

<(" (      !"            "+  ; +  (" (+3'")!(";"+3 "( "(& *("'+((+ ,++(*!++ ((+ 3 ++ ();')& *! "5

 $)   6,/',/*-7/%0(&18*/%-3&/2!

/-83 6,/',/**/73*'%9:/!

/-83