High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/7055/2016disposed of

Ram Lal v. The Central Administrative Tribunal Chd & ORS

2016-04-12Ms. Justice Navita Singh,Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri3 pages

"#$ %$&'(')* +,'-

"/0"- $#'#')$, 1$,(2( 3$$)#,"- %/')'(#,"#'4$,'52)"-.3")%'6",3 ")%#3$,( $(+)%$)#( * * * * 70 88!

9 70 88!

9 70 8 70 8 70 8 70 8 ,$($)#* ,$($)#* ,$($)#* ,$($)#* ,8"#5',8')639"),'". %4&"#$

3$#3$,$+,#$,( 0&"-+"+$,(/":5$"--;$%#($$#3$<2%6/$)#=

5$,$ $,,$%##3$$+,#$,(,)#= > 3$#3$,#3$<2%6/$)#(32-%5$,$+,#$%')#3$ '6$(#= ?????

?????

9 . 8!

9 . ,"- ,"- ,"- ,"- 3$ +$#'#')$, 3"( -"'% &3"--$)6$ # #3$ ,%$, %"#$% @

. ;3$,$5:. #3$ $)#,"- %/')'(#,"#'4$ ,'52)"-. 3")%'6",3 $)&3 %'(/'(($% #3$ ,'6')"-

++-'&"#')');3'&3#3$,%$,(&")&$--')6#3$"--#/$)#

,$('%$)#'"-A2",#$,

BC .8$&#,> .3")%'6",3")% "--#/$)# " )$; ,$('%$)#'"- A2",#$, ') -'$2 #3$,$ .

5$",')6 C.3"(5$$)2+3$-% $#'#')$,")%,$(+)%$)#",$($,4')6')#3$

'&$ 82,4$:, $)$,"- )%'" $#'#')$, ;"( #,")( $,,$% ,/3")%'6",3##3$8#"#$ 9.;3'&3'( %$&-",$% " 7%'(#2,5$% 8#"#$7. #3$,$5: +$,/'##')6 3'/ # ,$#"') #3$ 4$,)/$)# "&&//%"#') "# 3")%'6",3

3'-$ #3$ +$#'#')$, ;"( ') &&2+"#') #3$ ',(# -, A2",#$,. #3$ ($&)% -, #3$ ("/$ ;"( &&2+'$% 5:

,$(+)%$)# 3$,$ ;"( (/$ ')&'%$)# "--$6$% /'(5$3"4'2, 5: #3$ () ,$(+)%$)# ;'#3 #3$ +$#'#')$,7( "/'-:.;3'&3#3263;"("/'&"5-:($##-$%.52# ) 2,#3$, ,$+,$($)#"#')C&2/C&/+-"')#. " "&# ')%')6 ')A2',:;"(3$-%")%5"($%#3$,$2+)#3$"--#/$)# #3$ +$#'#')$,"(;$--"(,$(+)%$)#;"(&")&$--$%#3 #3$/.3;$4$,.;$,$"--##$%"-#$,)"#'4$"&&//%"#') "-)6;'#3";",)')6##3$+$#'#')$,#3"#3$;'--3"4$# 5$3"4$+,+$,-:;'#3#3$)$'6352,(. "'-')6;3'&3#3$ ,$(3 "--#/$)# (3"-- "-( 5$ &")&$--$% ;'#32# 6'4')6 2,#3$, ++,#2)'#: 3'-$ ,$(+)%$)# 3"( (3'

#$% # #3$ )$;

"&&//%"#'). #3$ +$#'#')$, 2)(2&&$(( 2--: &3"--$)6$% #3$"&#') #3$"2#3,'#'$(5$ ,$#3$,'52)"- $3"4$3$",%-$",)$%&2)($- ,#3$+$#'#')$, ")%",$)#')&-')$%#')#$, $,$;'#3#3$'/+26)$%,%$, $(":( ",#3$,$"()(#3"# ',(#-:.#3$'((2$"(#;3 ;"(,$(+)('5-$ ,#3$2) ,#2)"#$')&'%$)#'($(($)#'"--:"

A2$(#') "&#.;3'&3)$$%)#5$6)$')#5:#3'(2,# ')$D$,&'($ '#(;,'#<2,'(%'&#') 8$&)%-:.#3$;",)')6 '((2$%##3$+$#'#')$,3"($/")"#$%2# )#)-:#3$ ')&'%$)#')A2$(#')52#"-((/$+,$4'2(')&'%$)# #3$ +$#'#')$,7(%'(+2#$;'#33'()$'6352,#'()"&&2)#

> #$/+$,"/$)#"- )"#2,$ #3$+$#'#')$,")%E,3'( "/'-:

/$/5$,( #3"# #3$ "2#3,'#'$( 3"4$ 6'4$) #3$ "-#$,)"#'4$ "&&//%"#');'#3",'%$,$($$),$"() ,%$-$#') #3$;",)')6"##3'((#"6$."(#3$+$#'#')$,;3'-$$)<:')6 #3$+$,&$'4$%,'63##4$,)/$)#"&&//%"#').;$(" %2#: 6% 5$3"4'2, #;",%( 3'( )$'6352,( 3$,$ &"))#5$"):,'63#;'#32#"&,,$(+)%')6%2#:3'(3"( # 5$ ;$-- 2)%$,(#% 5: #3$ +$#'#')$, ")% 3'( "/'-: $$%-$((#(":#3"#'

#3$+$#'#')$,&)#')2$(#/"')#"') &,%'"-5$3"4'2,;'#33'()$'6352,(3$;'--5$"#"-'5$,#: # "++,"&3 #3$ "2#3,'#: , #3$', (:/+"#3$#'& ,$&)('%$,"#') ,%$-$#') #3$

$)%')6&)%'#') '(+($% F8!

9 G F8!

9 G F G F G F G F G

+,'-

H"%:")