High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/6437/2012dismissed

United India Insurance Company Ltd. v. Raj Kumari And ORS

2019-12-18Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan12 pages

! !"# $%&'

(

&&)) *#" +%

,- ."%# /#

!""## $#

$ & '

( )(*

$ + ,,,,, +%

,- ."%#001 2 3" '#1 ,/")1 2 3"

'#%# 1 +' 2 3"

'#%# "2/#1 #/ 51 2 3" 4 '#%/# 6#% $/1 2 3" '#/# 7#/ ."%#1 "#" 5% #

/ 3#"2/ )% & "# +

# */) 1

# /# 8/ 9 2 #&

+/'% ()#5#1 / ,0# ! !"# $%&'

( /)"## #" $#

7 :,

# 3#5'

;/ 2 #;1 )%2 %&

<#)'

# /

7#/ ."%# )2 0/ <)- $/ = <)- :# +2/ 0 22 #% +//>&"# *))2 ."#)1 ?/) 7#2#/1 # %3)1 0 +&)# %#') 0/" "%3# 0// 0 32 #5 7#/ ."%# ## ) / # %# &

61 0/ /'

#/ <3&"# ?& +//>&"# %3) ,1 %0/)1 2 # 32 #5 #& 7

5#'

#/ 2)2 %# % #% &&

2 "/ '& #52 #1 7#/ ."%# A %#') B#% ) / # A/ 3#% 3" 2 # / 2 %#') 22 0#2 #

,"))'1 /# ## %#') )) 0 )2 0/ %#') "# %")&) -"#

+/'% () #5# # && 3" 2 -"# &#1 / & 0'

)) /# -"# 0# A $5) :&) 7#2#/1 /05#1 0'1 <)- +2/ ""%3 -"# "# /%

!-"# :# +2/ 7#/ ."%# 0# ### 6C!1 $/2#/

(# 1 7#/ ."%# ) ""%3 -"#

&# 5# )%1 7#/ ."%# 0 0#A2

/&A&# #2 ,

@ &# %/

?/ )% 0# & "& / #2

% / /1 / 0 2 3"

'# 0 )'

3# 0# %)'

22 1 )) /# #& &" &&#

,& 7

) - 0# %1 '2 5)5% 2 # 1 2 / ) !, / 3 2 #2# )% 2 #& 7

?/'

&#' # %) )% &

! 0# #&)'

) #& 7 "# %&'1 / A 5#" )2) 3- "#'

1 2 / #5# # 0 /)2 5) 5 #52 ) % /#01 #% "# &)'

0# 5)

! 1 "/ #& &#' # %) )% &

&)2 &#1 ))02 " 0# #%

D//# 7#/ ."%# %# 5/")# "##2 " #/ 2)2 #52 #" $# 7 :,

#& 7

D//# )% # ) %& &#' #

! 1 0/ B #% 0/%E 6$

D//# #& 7

0 /)2 )2) 5)

#52 ) % 1 1 E 6,

D//# #& 7

/ %% 3#/ #% "# &)'1 1 E 6, & ,)

?/ &# ) 5 "&&# /# #&5 )%

# /#2 #2"%1 # $)% ?#3")1 ++ 72#1 /)

# /# ;/ ?#3"); " 7

5"# )% 2 #&1 " 7 0 5"# #& 7

0/#1 " 7 0 &# "#2 "# #2"% "/1 2 #& 7 5 0#

)% & 0 & 2 )% 7

%& , 1

@ 0/ # = &

#% )2 )% & )) ") #)> 0 0# &#@)%

?/ #& 0# /) )3) &'

/ %" -)'

5#))'

! 0 # / %& %" 3 &&# G") /# %2 )) )%1 0/#1 /# )% 7

0/ # %# 3 & 0/ % )> 3A #% ,1 )) /'

%-#'

:05#1 #& 7 "# %&'

) 22#5 0# / &&#/ / $"#1 0'

& )2 &# &&)1 0// 0 25 #&1 0/ /5 &" &&# /#"2/ ") #

?/ )% /5 ) &### # 3- # /% %& 0# /% ?#3")1 0// 0 25 "# %&'

-!!

# (#

!" .

(.!!

* .(* 0#

!""##( *"01! . (* !!# *

* !-' !-'1

! * 2 3# .!* !"

4 * !

! * 3# .!1 "

( !! ! !1 (# !5! ( !!

"# 1 (# ! "

!* "

#! !* 0

!6 0/! ""

##( 1 ! " ! ( !# ! # ! #* *"

*!(

*"07!

!8( 0! *#9 (

( !! 01 #! 2! # (#

! #* ! !*#0 (! . ! ! #0

.!*

!*(! . !

#*!( (##0#! ! !! 1!!! ! # !# ! 5"# (

! .#.

. . 0 $

!0*:# ! .! # .

(.!!

- !! .(* 0# (#

""## 1!

(0* +

& 0)# )2)

! 0 &#5 &#%& %& &#1 0/ " -"#'

# 0# &#&#'

%2 # )2) #&#5 &#1 0/ 2 A)) #

:'&# /) &&#/ 3 & 0/) -"2 "/ '& &

?/ ")A #%) 0/# 2") " /) #G"# 3 3)/ &#"

! # # / ) )3#'

&# 5)51 /##1 5#'

# &# B& #%)

)22 !, %'

3 #)5 # #%) 3" 0/) -"2 )% & "# +

?/ ?#3") &#&# )' 5 ## #&# )0 / #2/)'

% )" / #& 7

+/'% () 0 "/# /

.#.

. .

1!! $ !

)(* ! # !#

%#* ' )(* .. ! *

" !! .!#* " 23# .!! # "

1!! !#*- (# $ "

!1 6 !!!! ( ! 0! ! .#.

. . *# #0

!' 1 . .! *

1!! # .. ! 1 # ! 9 (#

$ !

"0 ( .* ;

1!!!0*:#! 8( 0! *#9 ( 3(!( .*

!#"!

*(!/! *!!0*:#1

(. ! *"# . ! 1 !## (" # #( ! #

(.!

! 1 8( ( !

! * ! ! 1! !( <( .* *# ( .("

!/ (# !

(.!

*0! *

#!* /!/ (# ! 1 #(

(

(.!

. ( *"0 ! ##( 1!#* $ + (!

* ( ! - 0 (# #! !0*:#1 (# !

!*#

!..!*# # (

. #!9 ( .(*

( ! .!

4 1!"

#0 .! ! 1!

(0 !0*

*# #0 $ ! ' 1 (# ! !!# ..! 5 "

0! "

# .. # ("

(.!9 ( ! 0 ! .

(

!5 !#".! " %#*/!

!##. ##( 1 !"

*50 .

* . *

. (* ! !-'

-' ( " #0 "( "

! *# *! 0* -' .

.! ** .=#

. 0" 1!

*.!

*.! ! ! % !*# - #0 ( .!.

!!! *"#

0.( # .

.!*

! ** ! " # ! /!

(# ( 1!!

0! / (#! ! .#.

. . 0

$ !0* :# ! ( ! 1!!

$ !)(* ! # !# *

.(* 0# (#

""##1!!

" 1 .!*

0# 1!! .#1

! ! *.!!5 "#

# !

(# 5 (

; .#. - (""

! ! !

( .*09

3! !9 (

1! 1 !*

0# . 1 " ( 0*

!1 " !!

1##! ! " !>!1## #

#!!# #0

!1.! ( !

". 1## #0-! 1

.!*

0# # 4 !1!1 ". ! "## /!

! / (# ! .!#0 * !

#( !1 (

0.#.

?! *.! $ & @! 1

# (#

! #* !

!! !.

1!$ !)(* ! #

# !*

10 (#!

./!

!! ( ! 010 ! .! # # (#

!" - !!

(.! "# . *

0# ""

( 4 ! (! ! (#!. ! 1!! $ !

)(* 1 !. (##

# !*

!! 1

.* /! !.

! !

!#*!$ !)(*

.!*

0#*

# !

. ! . *.

! .#.*

5!*

0# 6 *5! *

(! 0.

. 6 *# ! ! !!*

0#/! * $ ! .

5 (

0.#./!( .*

0# (#

!""## !#" (# !* (

(* 61!!(!

! * /!

. * ! ""# # 0!( *"0 !* * $ 1 *.

# !# #*

1 . .

( 0 !#* !/ (# "! !

1 (.!

" .'4

%" * ! 1

!* !#0 *1 '&

% 1!! 8( "

" ""

A.15 0 1

* (!

(( "

" - 1 ! (!

0 !

" #$ % &'( )

$ )* +,

1!! 1!..

(" & 0 1# *"# 0

&@ * 1

(( "

" - ! 10 ! * !#0 * !

#(# ' & %B&

& D .!(* " *#0**

!* ( ( 1

" # #.

6" ?

.! !* !#0 " 0 #* * ( ' B & 4D (# " 0' &

% .!.

*(#"# &1

.!#0""# 0!/ (#-!10 ! # *"

5 ( ' &

% -1 !( .* )* . B("

D #* # .' &

% ( #

' &

% ( # 6" " $ 1

1 # .'

% ( #

(*/ # * (( #! * ( '

! * ( ! # *" "0#

% /!/ (#!1

*" '

% !#*/!(

# *" "0# #*

%B'4

%D# .

1! F&@"

*! #. ""###(#

#= /!##0 "0!* (1 (#

# ?/ &&#%1 % %# &'% /)) #% % # ?#3") %&"2 0#

#2)'1 &&) ) "# %&'

% # 3- ) )%

H<I$ $!!

&#)'

))0

;

/*0 !

1 23 2!! "5.% G $

2!! '"

# G $