High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/26512/2018allowed

Diwakar Saraswat v. The Chairman Permanent Lok Adalat (Public Utility Services ) And ORS.

2023-02-22Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj10 pages

2023:PHHC:047896

"#$#%&''( DIWAKAR SARASWAT

THE CHAIRMAN PERMANENT LOK ADALAT (PUBLIC UTILITY SERVICES ) AND ORS.

)& *+) ' ,- ,' .....

!# $$$$$ - ,' /'0 1 % &'(' "))*")+*,- ./0 1 . 2& , !' " 3 1 4 !".5 %6 7 8 9 2 , :7 ;0 6 1 %79<1 1 "))*= !>! >61&6 1 &

, ( 1 ! +#?0 6 +))) !)"/?@/8)"/?@A

-2- )A)B"))* !<.".+))+*"#)B"))* 1 C 3 & !+@)= +) !<.".+))"A % = 1 . %= 1 . )+)*"))?9 !".7

' ++BA? 'C' 6 ++).+++ =' +#)""))?D <' 2= !".

7 = &'

1 9 !" = 1 ' % +) ' !*@A*)/"?)A"))?C #) 1 = ' 1 % '

1 ' 1 6 1 !".7 ! 1 E1 E 1 = (1! ' = - = ' 1 ! == = 1 = F9 !+/#)")?")+#= ' @)/@")@/B@/A

-3- @/*+").3#@ 9<= ' ' !". 7 = 1 =

!' D ")+B= =( 1

CD +*+)")+B = = ( 1E ( 1

' 1 1 ' ' = !".7 1 +*+)")+B 1 CD

!' - .#% . !".7 #) = !".7 '= ' = !".7

' 1 !".7 ' = 1 "+)@")+A ' &' '= G+)H F ' "",<0 2' +?*A = 2& , !' # ! = = 2& , 1

!' .

= 1 1

' 1

)#)*")++=7

-42' 1 1 1 ")+A % 1 ( = = &= '9 = . )?)?")+)E "A+)")+)E +/)"")++E +B)@")++E "*)@")++ = ++)A")++ % = = = ' !+@) ' 2& , !' @

= "" ,<0 ,@.A0 2' +?*A C= 1 1

16 "",<0,*0 2' +?*A= & 1 2& , !' B % = - =

'= ' F9 = 2' ! = - % 1"# - ( )#)*")++ / 1 - ' 2& , 1 !' 1 '

' 1 C

-5A 2

&' ( = ' 1

' % 1

& = (

1 C

( &= 1= = 1 CD #++)")+B ' !".7 = ' C !".7 #)

1 1 (' =1 1 1= '= ' %1 &= ' 18 ' % =

!".7 ( * % !".7 = = 1= 1 = 1 ' =

= % 1

#2$4

#%#%5 %# '(6

#"72 1$

%% '

-6- + 7 2 ' 1 *#)*))5. )?)?")+) - ./ " 9 2 ' ' ' "+))))5. 1 1

*#))))5. "A+)")+) - .A # 7 2 ' 1 +#B+)))5. +/)"")++ - .* @ 7 2 1 +#B+)))5. +B)@")++ - .? B 7 2 ' 1 +??/"))5. "*)@")++ - .+) / 7 2 ' 1 "*A+)@B5. ++)A")++ - .++

#2$4

#%#%5 %# '9

#"72 1$

%% ' + 7 2 ' 1 *#)*))5. )?)?")+) - .+" " 9 2 ' ' ' "+))))5. 11 *#))))5. "A+)")+) - .+# # 7 2 ' 1 +#B+)))5. +/)"")++ - .+@ @ 7 2 1 +#B+)))5. +B)@")++ - .+B B 7 2 ' 1 +??/"))5. "*)@")++ - .+/ / 7 2 ' 1 "*A+)@B5. ++)A")++ - .+A ? C ' ' '&1 !".7

& 4 1 .

1C ' 1 1 1= 1 2& , !' 9 (= )#)*")++ = 1 . 1

-7- ")+A 1)/1 % ( 1 ' 1 ' '= 1& 1 ' C

' = 1 ' 1 1 1 . '=

1< = 1 = +) 9 ' ' ' '= ++

1 ( 1 !".7 ' ' 1 6 ( = 1

' ' =

1 7 %=< 1 ' C ' 8 % 1 .' +" I ' ' = 1 ( = 1 = 1 &= '

-8- +# < 1 ' 2 1=' 1 +B)@")++C ' ' 1 1 = 9 = '

(' = 1

=1 ' +@

6 < ? ")H = 1 = %

'= )/)@")+) = 1= C )#)*")++ 1 ' = = +B ( !".7 === 1

= ' ! % ( =9 ( ( & =1 1 J

-9- 1% &' ' 1 ' &= ' 9

&= ' % 8 1 = = 1 CD

#++)")+B= = ( )#)*")++% !".7 1 ' &= D ")+B = ' 1 C 1 = &= ' +/ 9 (

&= ' 1 #)+)")+B =

% = 2& , !'

= ' 1 ")+A +A F !".7 &= ' = = 1 1 =

1 1 ")+B

( 1 1 ' =

-10- +* %

' 1 =

1 2& , !' % = = )/=&

1 < '= G /H = ! ")+B (VINOD S. BHARDWAJ) JUDGE FEBRUARY 22, 2023