← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/7082/2016dismissed

M/S D.M Trading Company v. Food Corporation Of India And ORS

2016-07-12Mr. Justice Ajay Kumar Mittal,Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain5 pages



      

 

 

 

 !"

$ %&'  " 

()& $ $* +,-.$/0/120$. +,-.$/0$$/ &&( 2%&!

3 45 (&3 & 226'"( 3 45 (&3 &" (7 ' )" 3 45 (&3 &" &(8 999

 

$&" &(* " 

*(& & !

::#'

"

( &)  ;' &5!"&(&5#3 )

"(   

/':

&(&  ( 5($)( <34

& &( 5&=&>'&* ?"';:

)& ()&&@"

"&

8 .

(

(& :

&';!

&@

>&  A

8

(&5)

 &@&&(;&"&& ()&&>(

#3 & 7

8 +@&4&3  ;#  @ #    5 '!  =&>'&  * ?3  '&  ;#  ()& 3:

(

(& :

&';!

&@ &>(& '"(

83

(& "& (&5)



&@ &4 & (

8)&""&5( 4&;

&@&& 4&&

;#5&(

(&!

5

 &) ()&('5( =&>'& *A?& ()&5

 (&*

&:

'& = ?3@ ::@*

* * B 

    

 

 )'3 (@ 5'!;&('"()&;

&(

:: ::()&(& 5'!&( )&"&(

!C

 !"

#3 & 36' 3 ';!

((& &=&>'&*7? D

83:&  ()&"

5&

"

A

 :&((&

:& : @ ()()&& &';!

'

&( <  3@) 5)@ @ ()& (()&"&

<&"("&4 &@

5('

:" 34

& &(& '!!

#  &"( 

 A

  =&>'&  *

?3  ()&  &" " &E&5(& (&5)

()&;

!

::((& ()&@<(&" &(8C6 ' 42'!



-& &4& 3()&"&(

!;#@ # ()&"&&(@ ) ' )( '

5& @ ('& 5&( F'

)

()&   &(& &  '!!

#  &"( 

 A

  =&>'&  *

?3 &E&5(  (&5) ::# 

  ()&  ;

   ()&  "&( & 

! 

  ()&  (&5) :  ;

   &" &(  8  @ :#3  ::# 

;

:#'()&" #&) ;&&!

&  '

5& @ ('& !

!'

") ;

3

&5(  &" (7( 55&"(()& (&5)

!

(&(

()&! ! ::(( @< )

( "(   

/':

&(&( &(8 .&

!5(& (@)& (7

("&()&(& &;

( ::  A

3@) 5) @ ()&&>"

#

(& ()&;

3"" &(

!';!

) 

(

 D A

 : @ () :&((& ()&&4&

(&

*A* &>(& 4

(#"&

 

8

(<&&""&()&

&'"(()&&>(&

(&3 &A  

)'3

()&"

5&

 :&((&3&

 ()&"&

(;&<&"("&3@ :& (;:

<;#()&"&(

!3 (5':

() 4&;&&

 '

(

# (;

() :&

#';!

( ( "" &( &>(& 4

(#"& &'"(A  

+&

'()&5(& (&" &(8

(';!

#

<&&"

 "&()&4

(#

&;&# 78

#)'3()&(&5)

&(8)':

) 4&;&&

()  '

:&3;'()& ) ;&&@ :#

&5:

& '55& ':;

&;#&" &(  (7 7 ()&()&)

3:& &" (7 5(&  () (  ()&  (&5) :  ;

   &" &(  8  )   ;&&   )(:#

55&"(& 3;&5 '&

 :&((&3)&)

"&5

::#!&( & ( <&&"()&

&"&  5&'"(

5:' 4& 78

#

()&&

(& &>(& ()&A 

#4&4

&5!!'



=&>'&$* ?3&" &(8)

&>(& ()&4

(# "& ) (& &'"(A



()&4

& ()&5!!'

A

=&>'&$* ?3)& '()&&>(& ()&4

(#"&

()&  (& &  '"  (   7

  +&5&3  5

  ()& 

&

5!!'

3  (&5) :  ;

   &" &(  8  )    )(:#  ;&&

55&"(& +& '()&5(& ((&

!@  &" 4&3 ()& !&

(5(

()&"& &!

 "& (

&3  &"

(&  (  ;&  !

(#  &F'

&!&(  )'3  (& &    ()&

!@ ( )(:#5

&&

*7* 8  (&  '()' )( ':5

(()&';!

 !

&;#:& ()&"

( &3@&

!& ( (@   )&

::

 '" ::()&5:'! ()&(& 5'!&(@

!

(#  &F'

&!&(    ::  ()&  ;

&    "&' :    ()&  (&

5'!&(=&>'&*7?

!)@() "

A

 :&((&3()&"

5&!& ()&"&

(;&<&"(4

@ :& ("&3:&  ()&&" "

(

5&

<F'

4

(#"&

!)&(& !3';!

;#()&"&( (()&

( &  (&:

 ;&   *&" 4&    @ (   '::  "

( 5':

    ()&

 :&((&""&

>*3()&

D A

&>(&

"& ()&;

( ::A 

@':

(& &()&"&( &&:

;:& 5!"&( ()&;

"5&+&5&3()&&" )

 ()&"( ;'((&E&5((&5)

#()&(& &

!)&!

((& : &&* (&   -&5) '(

 

     = A7

83 &5



8?) "

'

&*

     !      "#  $

    %  &     &  

  

   

             

   '

'$     

            !  ()     "#   $

    %            

      



*8* * + !()       

   

  

       

   

  ,      

 ,    -   %    '     &  

 

 5(&( :& &F'

()&(&

5'!&(=&>'&*8?';!

;#&" &(8 55&& 3()& !& & '

(;& ':#

  )'3@& (

# (# ;

& 5( ()&&" 3@) :&&E&5(  (&5)

!

::((  ()&@< F'&( (&" 834

&()& !"' &  &(& &'!!

#&"(

A

 =&>'&*

?

&( 3 55

 :#3

!

&       /':#

 !

 "

  )&()&"& <  & &

1& )&()&$&"( ;:& 1&