National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Rattan Singh And Others
!
!"# $ %
! ""
#
$%&!&
& $ '()* &+,- *,+& *&.+/- '
$ $(!) *& '
#"$& +(!) , '
& " (!) ,
-./
'
3&*!
$ '(!) ,
4-- ,01!1.02 3 ""
0
+"5 & , ! & ""
% * ! ! ! 6- -7 76-7 " ! 15 '
+ 1( !& 8
,
! 9& 1:; * !% +"
, <(=6(666/0 +, &,+ 2$%&8
,
!9&
!:;( % ! 7- 5 ( + )
*& $ %
% 0==007-4> 8
,
! 9& !% :; 7 & + "
( +&)
1 ! & +
" 7<,*?0
! " #!$ %& '%&() & *( + ,
& % - . /0& &(*&
1
1& 1 *0&
2+ , %2 & 34& 5 /0& &(*& 21 6784%%2 *-9 &&:
*1 1 4 &
;< = - > 1 % 1& 2
1 & 34 5 2 2 3 5 1 353?
:5 1 1 1 4 11/0& 1 "414 4 1 21 /0 & 3 5 1 /0 & &( *& 402 41 1 14411 1 2 1 /0 & && &(:& *(+ ,%& &( ) & =9* & &( %0 & 4 4 2>@4%11 1.
1 ./0& .
B = @&
+"5& & % * !( + &) ,
8A 0-.0076-.;
3% &
+
, +"
* !15& 1 < & 1 *&
!% ,!% - & 1
!&
* !! !
)%,& ,, 15 !
+ , +"
* !
+* +" !,*?0 8; +
+ 2$%& 8; %
7-5 !15& 1 B666 8; '&5 + !
! 8); C,8;1) ! !* !
D"
B66607B66;E 7B66"
+& 87B66A-7A-<;E <76666 8); +"
!,
""5% & +"
,-<) *,% , +&
8); +"
* !,
D"
-6666 B
5( 3
8A 0-.0076-.; , ! 15
+
3% &
+ , +"
,
+/
& , ! & 1+ 5 , % ,
+"
"
1
) , :1 "
D
!" ## "
$( *& & * <6F !! + !
* ! ,
"
"
! "" , +"
*& +"% +, +"
, ,!
!
5"
%
!"
% , +0+&
.
0
+"5& !" * !15:1 "
D ,
"( &( + , +"
( *& & 1 * !
+* 3,*?0
8; '&5 + !
! !15& 1 B666 "
B666G7666;E >666/0"
+& 8; <6F , 8; 1) !!
! * ! ,
8; C,8;1) ! !* !
D"
>6660=B66;E =B66"
+& 8=B66A-7A-H;E >B.666 8); +"
!,
""5% & +"
,-H) *,%
8); +"
* !,
D"
!, 76666 44 > * + ""
8 -6<B , 76-=; , ! 15 &
+"5 H
& % !&
40 +$%&*!
(*& & % !5+ *&
!$ *$%&( ! 0* (*
D+ !
,, 8$ ;(+ 5(
>0& + &
I !
+ + &) D+ ! ,&
!( *& * 0* , &
@07
$%&(1 &
!(* D+ ! 0* 2," & 153%"
+ !!! )!
+5,
$%&
1 &+ + ! 0* & +"
* !
! 0* )
5 % * ! 0* & &1+ !15& "
!
!* 1 %1 &
! &, &
% & ,)
, +1 1 !&&
* ! !
)%,& ,, !%) (* , 1 5
0 5(*& &+ *&
(*
5%B6"
& 5(*& &), ,, &
0 5" %
) 4
&) % !&&
!+ ! & I , !
+
! + & 8!
,, ; &! !
! ""
* %) & *
% !%&
$%&(1 &
!(& ! & & * ) % & 5 & + ,
! & + +
! 1 ! !15
+%&+
* &" )1 ""
(*& &
,$
&!
0 5&!) ,, 15
5% " %
& 5( &" )1
-6 & * + !
! *
!% &) !+
1&) % !&3"
!
,!
!&+ , *!
!&& + (!
,, !%) *!
)% +
& + ,
&% "&, & ,
"
! , &* &
, & ! & &! 3 "
@& 0 5 &! ! ( & * 5% "
"
) !/!+ !(& DI 1 ,
1 *!
+ &*&
&!3 "
@& D+%
)!
!(& 1&1
!&& ,, !%) , && !& & 5(
,*& && 5 * ! ,!
&
!, & % !!& ,, !%
& ! & 1 3 * *& , & + (
& , I,& +
+ * ,
1!*1
!" -7,& * !,*?0
> 1
14 4 1 % & =9* 1&>441 41411& 44 %& 44 1 > 1 . ) 9 > 1 @ 1 1 12 C 1 =9* C * & :4 & 44 1 1 %& 4 $21=9* 111 D
B -- J
"% ) * & , & !
* D+ !K &
!+ !K +5 , @07
$%& 1 ! ! & +
% ! & & 1 &
!K,!& 1& ++ !
*& !%&
* ! ! & ! , !
, ,, !% & " , 1 5
!15 & &1,
&*
!!
0 5( ,(&! 0 5,
5%" %
( &)
! !
)%15 + $%& &
* !15& ,, !%) ( &(""
%
,, !%) &1
%&5& !1
"1 !
+,5&
! -7 I ,+51) ! (& 8 -6<B
, 76-=; , ! 15 & ""
0
+"5 & +
! & + !+ ! *&
8A 0-.0076-.; , ! 15
+0
-.&) +
!
" ! * !,& 1+!, !!& +"
* ! +, &, + 2$%& &
!, +<(=6(666/0>(>.(666/0 & &
+, +"
*
5
L>F"
+, +& ! , ,% ,
M ""
0
+"5 1 %
* !
" & &
+ & 13
"5 & + & %& !
+! !
, + - ! 7 1 % "
, !
! * &
& &
+, +"
,*?0 - + -8,&
; ? =6F 7 + 78+&
; ? >6F -= & ,!
+ ,5,& +1 ,
,
!" , & ""
( +"
, &/&
&
& 1 "! ))% +
1"5 3 % ,+& *&.+/- 23 + .* D42 ( 7(% D4 7(%