High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/22025/2019allowed

Ranjit Malhotra v. Union Territory, Chandigarh And Others

2020-07-14Ms. Justice Jaishree Thakur10 pages

!" #$%& & '& ()&&& "%*&%%& #+

& & ,"-&./0% &'1%/ "./"

&%+& &2$ "-&-* "

&()"%*&%

)%+&2*% 0&% &

3 1 %&+&*&/%&1 .31&4&5&66 7 ,-888" %3"% &+%/ +/& &+&%/* 1*3%&*& )% +& %& + &% /% &1 .31&4&5&66 7 ,-888" % &% 9

&3 & %:

&+(+ %; <

0%%"/%0/&%3%*&% 7

)%+&191$& 9 &3% #*&*.

%& % 3+ % &3

1 &+ &%*%/%= )%& &+ &%*% /% &3%0%&0&2%1 %&1 &0>&-2)%+&%& &++% %& %*&% &&*&*%/%*0%& 3 -" % &*& 0 " % +& &+&% %&1 /"*% * 0&+ ; & ," & -& ./ * 0% & '1%/ "./"0 &*%%&+ 1& &% &+%&*& %/%" 3 &&&8&* %%*/1 %#)%% 1 /& 8 &*%0% & & %& &3% %*&%&*& %/%%3 %+&"

%/%1 &&&/%&0

8&* %% >+ & &*&% %&+%/ &3+%% & %&%1 %* &3??

! @&-& &0%+%*&+%

%/%>0%%+3+%%% & /%%1%*%12*& &3%3 )%1 %&%1+& +/&.&0 %+%*&+%.> & %/%1* 1 % &&5%"0%%& % % 3 +&-/& +& + )% & & + * % 0% %&

;

&&"&2$ "-&-* &% %*&%.3&"0 &*%%0&++&3 & %&+3&%&*&%/% 3+ &-!

%&'%.

77 "# $%&& &%&8 &*%%/%0+ 7

%0/&%8+&&

+%/%% & &*/%%1%* &30%3 6 &8&* %%+&%

&% &+& & %/%"1 3*% & %/%?0%A0%&+ /&8&* %/%1&%*%&* + 31 %3

&&"0%%%0 1 % & %/% B 8%/%&%& &%+&0%%& %/*%& *%%+*%0 < .3 "% &+ "%& &"%& &&%38%12*& "%%&= %&= & & 0 1 0%%& % &+ %/ && &*&*%/%= C 7 )% &%1&"0%%&% 0& +&3 & &* 1 % -& -* & % &+%*&%.3&"&& &

%1 + & - !

% .

77 % ++ & &*&)%+&%&%++ &&*& %/% 1 *% &3 %" % 3+ % & &3 *1* &3%#*&*.

%&%)%

&+%& &*&%&+/&&+& 7

" !7

" 7

1*3"0%%%

* %+2*0&% & &.& B % 8% %&1 &3* %& "0& 33 0 131.+& &3%"% &+%/2*&%0&3"% &*&10%+&%%*% &

%/% &3?%A? &A% %"1 %0&+31

8&* 1 %& &%&+%% & &*&*/%+ D&+ %/% *0%% 31&"%&+ % &?%A )%& &%&%1&"0%%0 %*%&* + 31 %3

&&80&31 &+&$ *&*&%/%+&3& % *& %% &%1%* &3?%A? &A

%&'%.

77 3&% 0%% %&&

&*&/%&&

&0%& &*&-!

&+& %& &

# $

% .&* % &0 & %% %& &

&*&/%&&0%& &*& %/ & 1/ % % 3& /% & % 3% & 3+ 0%%&= &3 %.

77 & % & 3 %& & & % ++

&% +& & +&/ &*& %/%&

%&- %.

77+&%+&/ &*&*& &'%

E!&"'

( )

*( )

!/"'

0 !&"

1 -

2 - 3

!4"

!/"

!"$

!"1 +

0 !&"

!/"

!4" !"

)%&'%.0%0&%*&3

%*+&&1 & %.

77)%%*

< %102+*/0%&= &3 & *+ 3

; @& & % +& & + & $ *3&&1 %- +&3 &%3& '"

(

)( !*") ## ) ( + ")! ,)! ! (-( ( +)( ( + ( ") ./0$%12 *)3" )(!!4//)%- +&3 &0F 0%%&&/%0%%/&0%%+& & %& &*&+&31)%++1 & %- +&3 && $ *3&&1 %G&5*% &0%&0&+0 1 %0& %/%= &*&%1 1 /&%% >1 *%

31 %%0%%0%&* %+ */1 %3

& %/%)%- +&3 &0%= &+ &

%&'%.% &H E44

, 5 ,

6/!&" 6/!&"

1 / $

, 5

1 /!&"

&/8 ,

&/8

$71(9&:0/999 64

1 /!&" $

! "

! !

# ! ! $

%&'

%'%('

!%'

!"; 1 / !"

! )%& &"0%1 % &$ *3 %3&/%1&%>%%&0 1 /& 0% % + % &

&*&I &%&3&>+- & + %

%3%*%& & /%"0%%& %*1 &

8%+&"%&+ &

&*&% /%= % 3&-!

%.%1 50/&"%/%= %& &3% /.+& & +&/ &*& %/%%/1 ++*0%%)%/% = %1 1$ &0 %*1 & &"&%%&1%* 1 &)% &* &*&*&"%* & /% +& &* &*& &3 ?%A ? &A" 0% 13*%%+&% 0&*0%3* % & %&0%

B .+& %+%*&+%++0%%0&+ 0 & %%/%"0%%.31&&"%1+

+)%&%*%1 & %&0%%&30% 1%&0&2 + &

"1 %%*%

%&&%%/%1& 3&0%% +&31 /& - %.C)%0&% */

< . +&0%&/ +%4)#0*"

= " &

+$1"12D & %& 2%+ %& &3 33 G%3&G 2 3&-3 %& A&E)* 56+

, 6+- + -

60- 1

)%& 2&1

&0%&0&23+&%%&.+& &3%"

&&+ *0%2&+&/&%3 /& & %%0&%/&/"%3331*E23)4

785 , 3+&-2&&+ &"2&0%%%0

+ & 11 %&"0%%&E/ #

&* & 1.+& &3%"/&3&+ +1 "1 %+$1*0 3+ %%&%1 & /%%1%*"&%1& %

7 )%& & *&*&3& %*& % %&&0&2%1 %/%"0%&%1&3 0%" *. &1+& 32 %0% &%3&0&2 +@2/0%+& 0& )%1 & %/0 &3)%8+&% &1&& 0% 0%33&" * %&3 %+&

= %0&+0)%&+& 0&% & 3 &*%3&*&% /%0%+& 002 &3 & ++& &&&8 % 32*"%+&1*/ &13

&%%3 -$9/0/0 .

1 %%&+2*D& J