← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/22041/2019dismissed

Arsh Garg v. Punjab University Chd. And ORS.

2019-10-17Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary,Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal7 pages

   

 

        

 

 ! "  "

# 

  !!   !!    % &'

 & "

 "&& ( )*  "

 $    &*+ , "

  ' - &.!#$ "

  '/ 00000 "    %   )"$ $   ( $ ))  + 1)2  3!+$*   4 "#)     

+) 5 3 '/4 (  "+

#) 1"* "5   * )   + 1"6  .

3 '74 ))"  1"! (   8 +)( $    ()) 5  

  $ $     $

" 9:+  

+  #)  *)  (   "   ))         &  $) !$  ;&  $)!++ ;*+))5( ;'  ";! + 6

 <)    $$" , 2   2:+   3& 4   "" '  )5  

" 87= !++ # 8> 5, "+

!++  ? $ ) "@ +  1,!% $ 

+    "    )    ")     $   "  +    $   )8"  # "712 !+ )2  

  **  1  

  @

     !+ )  2     5 )  

 ! " A   $ (  "+ ++12 !+$*  "2  A(

))"! '# /%5 $$) ""+  ++  B12   !+$  *     "  2  C   " 

B1"C " B#)C ( )  )

  6 ) (  "1" "( ( "#)5  (  (      +     5     (   # 8  7-  8 "+

 "D1"E  ""

)   1" (  ))"$* ((  " #)  "5 $ "  " 

B#)C"

)   ( ))"$ B#) C5$   " "   "+ $++ B12 !+$*  "2  C "( ))"  " $     "+   $++  B12   2)    !++   2  C

@

 2  

# 5 )     ! "   @  *65   "  

))   (   (

")" 7=   " " (( ))"  1"     

))  )  "  " ))   * "  (  ))"$  " " : +    '/   8( 7/F/ # 7 (  8(

F7 ( +$ )+)(  8$     '/(  8 7/F/ )" ))"  " 1"  > "

)$   +  $  

 : +   #)()" + )  )  "  5  #)

 $ +8  +

  ))"  > "

))  +      "  < $   )" $"  ) +

" (  (    (    '/> "

))  +   +)"

 " '/    (

 + +     $   )"

" " " ) "

)$   +       )    ()) > "  

)       '/    $$

  

+

+" ) "

)$   +   $         $        + )            12 !+$*  "2   "+     "

122)  "!++   2  5$    ))  8 )"+

$

( 

+$)" ") +    " "+#) 1"         +8  +     +     "  

    $ $ ;



  "> "

))  +   ) (  ) +" $   

 '7

 )  " +  +  '7  '7   )"$1" '$"    "$    " ) "

) '/ +  +     "+    

( $ " "

)) ")  +   $ $

 > "

) ' -%

 + 

$     

  )$ $   5

;$ $ )( "

   

  $

$ $ A)  + 

  

  ";

 A"+ ) "

)$  "(  ) $ ""+  ) )  )  + ) "

)$ 

$$   ( "<)    )  )  "  $" + "

$" "+ ")     '/      "+

#) $"    B#)C ()) B1"CA(   )' + ) B1" C5) +$   $ $   

      '/  3&  5   4   "  + #)   1"  ) + 

"" #)

$  ")" "+

#) " )

 " '/# /%5 

 8* )' "  +  "D1"E  "$   " : +  #)  ""+

    "5 3 '/4  1" "+ ")  $       ())      '7   "  / $$) "  ) ( $   (

D#)E "  '7( D1"E # /( )  ) " #) ())

1"   $    !*  3,   "+

 !++   ,!% 4% D*8)"#< + *$    G!) 7 ") (  ))+  ( 7 -") (  ))+ <

 ) + ( <  ) %

" )  +) 

""

   "  ( " " @

"+ " ")   (  ))"$  " " #))' - -F 7 "  " ( ))" '/ (  + )   ))+  " % "   " 

 '/ "+

  "    )    %      

  

"" " "

" " % "+

 (  "       '7    $      ))+

< " " !) 7 - "$      ) + ( ( +  " %#

%

/

  " % " ))+

<       ) % 5 ))+ "  $$

  " 

     +  *+ 

  (      1+   A   !    &'()&*!&+&),(-&./*&*,(0.(1&01(+&*,&*.'2134!.&.2

&&*,.'214

5675/3/076 @  "  $) $   ( +    + " )" "+

  $  $$

$ $

 " $ 

 )" 

 ) $ ( +    $  "

<@( )"(  " 8 "+

    <   "    +      + 

$" "+ "  " 

  " $ ( 

 

 * + )

( )  H))1  !

  *,((8.&34/12-.1 !81.4"(*)&9

7!

# (  ( )"+ " "  

 

  ";)" " +"  + " * + ))  H))1  !  &)!/*:'

34 &'&14'/&;&*&*,*/3214/.;

72-2*.!213/-24(,:+2*.4 6 ) "

$$ ") )

  + " "  

   "  $  "  "     "    "



$"  " " " "   "+

@( )")  ) "+

   "

$ $

" 

<   :+   ""+

+"



 

 $ $ ( 

)(  (( 8 H))1  !  &'(01&9'&=&134(*)&92-'*/-&0*/3214/.;"&0&*,'&1&*,.'214

<5#7! <$$ $ )( "  $  )   @ ( ()) )($   "



"           " "  

     "  +           "   " ""

)  +     

 " ) "

)$    "$ $    " +    "

+

"   

  

 

 

     I $8 ; "

J ;' I#$ ) J ;'