← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/20383/2020dismissed

M/S Matrix Clothing Pvt. Ltd. v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2022-12-16Mr. Justice Tejinder Singh Dhindsa,Mr. Justice Pankaj Jain12 pages

           

!

"#$ %% 

 "#"&#'

"#$()%(%

* +, -. /",0-#1 !,% 2, % %%%%%%% ,-,-"#

!

&  3,+, "4 + 5+#+ +# ",0

%%%%  6"# #,   $  72 % 3  3 3  72 % 3 8   

 

  

     

   

   

     !"



999  3 3: %

2 # $  %& '

%'%'

() *'+ ,-) .

) /*# 0*$  

  .

)  /    $ 0  "

  ,     

 , 1 '2 %'3 $ 0  %'1*4 5  60   $$ $   $ 

 $  $ $ , 0

  0 $ 0  7'8 $ )   9   )

%

"

 $ $    $ 0    .:  '23%77;1   9    0     %'1*4 <

     

 0 

"

 

.

)%'';(   =%'';=+  .   >  

0  $         0      ;'

';

%'3() *+

  ,$     )? 4'7%14@* =%'';=   0 ? %%3'24@* # 

.

)742

      1 '2 %'3        %'1*4  0 $    ? 4'7%14@*  :       

         5    0 $       %& '

%'%'

() *'+  A              $       0 $ ,    =%'';

=  ?

 0  : $  4   

)? 4'7%14@*  $ 0   )      7'8$ )   #  ,0  ,  ) 0  $ 

 0   0       ?    !5 $0#  + 5+#+ 3,+, + 0"& -#1 "

6"

+,-"# ! % .'-  +# +.+,-"# ";;- -"# +# +#",0

( <  =       ,     ) 0          5 0 

;

B  ,0 ,  0 $  , 4  5  0  

?

1%"

 

.

)?

%''; 

0 0 ? ' >,, 00$ ** $ $ 00 , #00  "                 ,0       ?

1% ,$ $*,  4  5   ,0

        !"

    $0 $, ,0$    0) 

 

 90 .

?*%       0     ,         0    /

0 ,     $    $   0 : 

, ,0   ;;=%'';=       -) .

) #00 ( + $  0   0

 

 ,,.

)., "



A    ,0     0    $   $        $  )    ,    !0   

6                $       $

%'=%'';=  ?

1 1%  

.

)?

%''; ,           *

  



  

     

  

   

 

  

 

         

 

       

           

   



    

   

! "

# $

     



%  

 

   



       



         

       

    

 

 

        

    &   

 

   



  '      

%'    

     

       

    

 

 

  '   

  

%'    

       

            



 

      

     

 

             

    

  

 

 !  

  (    

 

)

  )  

      

              

    

  

       

   

 

 

  

" *+

         

         





       

  

          

 

 !  



    ,

 

  

 

 

    

   

  

 

    

    

 

     

     

  



    -   

   

 

 

      

      !

      

    

  



    

 



   

 

      

  

      

  

 

  ./ 



  

  

    !       

  

  

   



  

  "

1

     

   

 

  

  

       

  

 

  

       

   "

2

      %  1

  



     )  

  

  ,

   

  

 

  

   ) 

    

  " 3  

  

 

%  * 

            

  

  

   

   

 

  

     



  

    

  +

 4    

   

   

   

%  2  %  3      

 4   

    

 

   4   

   



  

        

   0

  



 "



 $ 

  

  

    

 %  # ("

#  '!

    

     %   *     

  

    

       

     

        

 

                   

         

       

('!



 %  *   

   

      

  

  '      

%'

  



      



      

      

    

   

 "

  "5 "  

    

6 7"3 3338% 6          

  "69        '      

% '    

7"1 3338%"6   

 7"# 3338%"

#" 6    

  '  7" 3338%"6  :3;   "6           '     

   7" ,3 3338%      :*;"6

 

 7"* 333"

("   # 6      

%'       7"23 3338%          0   :*;

6    

 7", *338% 6 





 7" 3338%  !             4

& *+      

 

 

     

  

  

     

 

)  4    

 



              

   

"            

      

                 

 

 

    0         

    

     

 %

  # ("       

    

 %   #   (  

   

      

  

       





 

 

 !  

 "       

  

   

    

   

  '" "7"(*

   

 < !'

 7 

 ! 

 =  %>2  

    

    

  

  

   

    

 

      

   

   



 ! 

   

 "

  56    

         

   7",3   7"*3

  "6 7"(# 3338%"6 

              

        7"3 3338%"  

     7"3 3338%"  $          6   

     7"1 3338%   

 0  "69

  7"3 3338% 

   

  





7"* 3338% 

"

, +



      

 

     

 

 

 

           !

%



  



  

 

 )  

  

       

    

  

 

       

 %   1       (    

4 

   

     

 

            

     

         

              

  



      



  %  *  

  

    

 





  

    



    )  

   



   



 ! 

 

 

 "

- 

  4

 

        

  %  # (  ) 

  



      =  % *  

 

       

% 



  =  %7 

    =  

 0 '  < !7

2,.



  ' ?     4

 

 

      

     

   &          '      

%'    

  

    

  

' &           

   

         

  

  &    

                 

4

      

     

          

 





 .        

  

  

%  -       

   

  

  

 

   

    

    

   



 



  





  %  * 

 "  

  

%    

 

    !

 

     1+

 

                    

     

  





          

 

  

  

4

"

 

        



       

      @ "0

 

  #"A

     

 )

("A

      = )

*"B    A

=  

  B    A

 

  8  

  

  8 

   

    



       

 

      

      

          

                 

  8   

     "    

   

  

 

 

  

   

   

 

   



    

  

 

  

      "C 0=%'';=    

.

)?

%'';$$  , $   $ 0         0 ) )   00   ) 0    0,

'

 

 5 0   ) ,      %'(1+=%'';=  C?

1(1+  

.

)?

%''; $   $ 0$  0$   0 )     )) 0   )    ) 0 ) 0  0) 0    

0  0   =%'';=#         0    ,   0          0 

"  ) 0, ?

1(1+0

==,$), @ >  

 5 0

:    >,  0    0) 





 90 .?*% .$     00 0 ;'

';

%'3() *+ :  5,     ,  0  $$ 

  .       $ 0  ;'

';

%'3() *+  >$  ,0 1 '2 %'3() *%+   ,< 0  .#  $0  $  0 $ %& '

%'%' ) *'   0  ,       ,   ,0   ,,$  

0     $  ,       $        $  0 :   $$



0       ;'

';

%'3       $           $  ) 



    0    ;;(4+ =%''; #  6 !5 $0  ,      + 5+#+ 3,+, + 0"& -#1 "

6"

+,-"# &6 +

 , 0 0   %' =%'';=  ?

1"

 

.

)?

%'';

   

6 ,0 ,   $ $  >$5      0  ,

 #00,

0 :$ ,  ?

1%  

    .

)  ?

  %'';                , 

 #00   0 0 



   ,   0 :    

     0  0 

 90 .?*% ?

  0) 

 

   0



  .

 ?

1%0  

  0 

9  ,    0$ 0 $ %& '

%'%'()  *'+ ?

 0 ,   $   0 =%'';=  ?

 0  

% 0

0

 3 3  

8    ()%(% &#-,+ 6? @  >$ B@ 6? ,  B@