High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/28370/2017dismissed

Manoj And Others v. State Of Haryana And Others

2022-02-03The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Arun Palli13 pages

CWP No. 28370-2017 1

!"!#$ % #& #' ()" *

+)"," -

#' ()" * "/#'#

)"# $0 %)

1!2 ",/

3'4

3) (/ !#)" %) #5,) %!

23 ''2 '4

#) 23 ).

( %)- ,) 7(% 83""!"

#) 2 ).

%"9,"( 2'/9 ,)% # ( #'

3'4

) ()"/#'# :( )"

!' /)"# !" 7!#8 ) )'' (),8( 4!' #)# !#8 "!# /) '!#8" )7!#8 #', '!#4!) 2,) ;

( # )4)".!#424'!# (1

)

#')424" ),#'

//2!

7!2!

. - !# <:; !8(

!) 1/#"

) #"/ )# . !# = #' >,!"!

!#3 7!2!

21# 3 # (

" "6()!# )',#')"

( = #' >,!"!

!# ?<6 ##,# '# ?!1) #!4 .

)"/)!) ( 11# 1# ( # < # #'' 7. ( / !#)"3 #!

() ( /""""!# #' ( " 7#

5#7. (-

#) 1/#"

!#( "7#/ !'@'/"!

!22'

# 4!6 "

"3 /) .) ( " 7# 1 ' ' 2 ) /) '!#8"( 42 /"',#')"

!#<:;

CWP No. 28370-2017 2 (!# )/)

!#"

!#<:; ( ')1 !#',#') 2,')2#8,# !2!

!# 22. 1 7' !''7. (#"

!## ( ( #A72 -,/)1 ,) #'!

!# "

36()7. (/B ,) ( " 2 !' '6# ( 8,!'!#8 /)!# !/2" !# )') ' !' 6( () !# 8!4#

#' !) ,1"

# "3 !#/) '!#8" #7' 2 )'

( 47#2 /"'!#4!6'1!#8!

!#/)4!'',#')"

!#<:; ( # 2,'!#8/ 8) /(C (&,'81# !")/)', ' ()!#726$0 D* ! "

$#$ " %

" !"

! &' ! "(

) !"

! & " % ) % %% !! *"

( " ) ! " ' "(

$#)$! "

! & "

! +

! ) & , % -. "

#$ ) %

) -. -., ! "/ "( "

#$ ! "

! & 0

" % "

! ! ! "

" ! "

' ! ) 0"

) %' " ) 0' "

)

'!"

)

' ) 0

,* 1 1 !"

#$ ! "

! & "

! "

" , "/" ! 2

#$ " ) % "

3 ! (

)!" # %$ ! !" !

"/ "

! "

! +

) "

"""% !

! &" ) ( "

& ! 4 "/ "

! +

) ! !

' "

& ! "

")( 52 !"

#" $

! "/ "("!2 % "

3 ! (!! '"

CWP No. 28370-2017 3 "

! & ) 6 %6

! !" ! "/ "

! +

7 " ) "

& $ ! "

' "

"/ "

#$ 2 2 ! "

" , ) ( "

)

( "

& $4%% ! ""

%( !" ! ( "

' " "

"( "

#$! "

! & , "

#$! "

! &

) ! "

#$ ! "

$#)$ 8 , ! 0( "

#$)%(! / 9 :"%)

0( "

! "

! +

' ( "

#$ ! "

! &'" ) 0 "

#$ + , ! "

#$ ( ! ! "(

") " ! "

0 "

! ! )! "

! & " !"' "(! "/ ( % ""

, ! ) " ! ) " ) *"

#$! "

! & (

% " ! "

/ ( ! ""

"( ! "/ "

"( ( !!" ! "

! &' '

2) ""

% / ( ! ! 0(

"( ! ! "

! " "/ . ( B/"!

!# 6 1 ' 7. ( /B ,) # # 7 ",11 )!E'!# (226!#81 ##))1) 2 )!

.# (/)!# !/2"2 !' '6#7. (#"

!## ($0

CWP No. 28370-2017 4 :

; # 22 (" "" 6()!# !# /) "" ( ' 7# !#!

'7, )'( "# 7# ##,# ',#')"

( ?<3# ('

11# 1# ( ! <3 () !" # 2 /" /) '!#8" 1 6!22 # !#,3 (64)3 6!

( )!')

1/#"

!#( 7'

)1!#',#') (/)4!"!#" 22 (" ""6()!# )',#')"

( ?<( "7# ##,# '/)!) 11# 1#

( 3 (/)4!"!#" ( 6,2'( 4# )!#8 ) //2!

( /) '!#8" 6!22 # !#, !# )"/ (" ""3 " !3 ( ?< ( " # 7# )/ 2' :7; ( 6)' D)A ,"' !# 7 6# ( 7 ( # !#8# !" !#<:; ( !" 7) "-.) "-. 6(! (1 #"

"52 /"!#8 !#/) '!#8" 7 ( # !#8# !"1,"

7,2!22'% #!#8 ()7.3

( /""""!# ( ' 7#

5# 7, ( 1/#"

!# 6 " # ) !4'3 ()6,2'7#2 /"-!1!2 )2.3! 1/#"

!#( 7# '7, (/""""!#( "# 7#

5#3 ()6,2' 7 # 2 /"!#8 #!"

&&#$ ! 3( $ : ; " ) "/ 1/#"

!# ) >,!)' !" # )#'3 (#A72-,/)1,) #'!

8)!

22. 7")4'

( B/)""!# / !' !# ( 1 !# / "

<:; ( '" # !# 2,' '/"!

1/#"

!#!# ,) (

!")>,!)' 7/)4'!"

1/#"

1,# 6 #')'6(! (( "7#B/2 !#'!#

CWP No. 28370-2017 5

#')!#8 1,# 6,2'1 #

1,# !"1 ' !2 72 #'6#)

6,2'7 '!" ( )8 (72!8

1 5 (/ .1# #'!#

4# ", ( /)"# 7/# 2!E') (' ,2 !#1 5!#8 .1# (!2)))!#8 "

!# :

;3 :;3< (

?< #' 1/ )!#8 (16!

(/ 1

/)4!"!#"! !# #' ( 3 (#A72/B,) " 2 )!!'

( #2. #">,# ##0/ .1# 1/#"

!#!" 1 5 (/ .1# !# )"

"/)"

< ( ?<4# (#A72-( ",) () 2 )!!'

.1# 1/#"

7# )'@ #')' ,#') "

!# :

;3 >,!)!#8 ()!

7/# 2!E')##0/ .1# 1,# ")1 !# ,#/ !'', ),"

2 7. #'6#) 2 )!.!

,) ()3 (#A72-( ",) ()7")4'

! 2 #'6#) "!2' ())# )(!8() 1/#"

!#( 2 !1

(6 "# !' 1,# :'; (!2) '!#8 (/)4!" "

!#7/ "

!#<:;

( 3 (#A72-,/)1,) " 2 )!!'

"3 ( ) ) / .1# ( " 7# 1 ' 7, # '/"!

'3 2!

7!2!

. / . 1,# 2#8 6!

( !# )"

",7"!"

#' ! # '/"!

' ) 1 &)!

. (2'!#8" ) !4 .

)" ) 1)3 1/#"

!# ,#') ( ( 7 / !' #'6#)" " # ( '

# !!

!# ) 2 ,#')"

!#< ( ?< )'!#8 ('/"!

7# 2 )!!' !# ( &,'81#

) ( (!8() 1/#"

2263 ( 1#. "(,2' # ( 4 7#

CWP No. 28370-2017 6 '/"!

'6!

(= #' >,!"!

!#22 ))!# ",). ) !# ( ,) 6!

( )"/ 1 &)!

. 2 #' (2'!#8"3 #!#8 ()7.!!

6 "'/"!

'!# #. ()1'" 6!

( )"/ 1 &)!

. (2'!#8"3 ( (!8() 1/#"

6!22# 22637, !# )"

,#')"

!#< ( ?< 6,2'7 ( #">,# :; ")8 )'" (1'

5!#8/""""!#3 (#A72-,/)1 ,) ' 2 )!!'

') 6!#8!#>,"

)/) @11) #',1 6,2' 1 #

/(."!

2 /""""!# ( " 7#

5# ( 2 6 6!

()8 )' 4"

!#82 #'( "# !#7)!

(2'

# (/""""!#( "7#

5#,#')"

C ?<3 #'4"

!# (-

() 7 #. '!4"

!#8)2 /"!#8 :; (!2 1/, !#8 (8 //)!'!4.

)"7 6# ('

)' #' 11# 1# ( 3 #.!# )!1)') ",7"!"

!#8!" 7B 2,''6(! (1 #"

)B 2,'!#8 !# )!1)')3 (/)0)>,!"!

8 //)!'F.

)"!"# ()3

(/)4!"!#""

!#<:; 7!#45' :8; (#A72,) ",) () 2 )!!'

! !# #'( )2!)7# ( 22#8' !#6 ",/(2'3 6(! ( 1 #" ( /) '!#8 "

' # 2,''3 ( ,17)22 /)

!#"

!#<:; ( 7!#45

'"# )4!4"

2 !17 ))' 2 !1" :(; # / 3 ( #A72 ,) ( " 1 ' !

2 )

/)4!"!# "

!# <:; ( !" 1 7 !#45'7. (7#! !

)!"!2 #'6#)"6(6)) )'' "

!1!"", # # !!

!#,#')"

!#<

CWP No. 28370-2017 7 ?< #. ",7">,# /,) ( ")3 (2') ) ()6!"3 !#45 (/)4!"!#""

!#<:; < "/) "/, ) (7. (/ !#)"3 (. #' () 0"( ))" 6)6#) #'1 ",)!#8F 5 2?1 )2 !#9!22 @

#82 @@ @ :F0;3@@@1!#:0;3:0;3%!#:F0 F;3?@<:

0;3 :0 ;3<@:0;3@ :0?;3@ :F0<;3<@:C0;3@ :0; #'/ !#)""( )!" G #' !# ( 1!2. "

21# #' 1 ",)!#8 F 5 2" FG % )2 !# 9!22 @

#82@<@:0;3@@<@:C0;3@ :0;!"8!4# =

-1 "() /(! @ -( 9( ', ( / !#)" "!

' 6!

(!# )4#, "

+!22 8 %62 % &/,)3 !"

)!'

' ( 4 !1'

4 #"

), ',72 ). (,""@"(/"@ 1/2" !# 9( ") @@<@ :0;3 @@<@ :C0; @ :@; # #' !# >,"

!# 1, ( 7) ( !"", # # !!

,#')- !#< ( ?<(2 #' (/ 2#86!

#' ()2 #'6#)" 1 7 >,!)'7. (-

4!' # !!

!#" '

' < ?C #' < ? !"",' ,#') "

!# < !# C ( = #' >,!"!

!# 3 ?<3 226' 7. )' '

?) (/,72! /,)/"# 12.342/1#

!2!E

!# "!'# 2 #' 11) !

2- )<C/

)!'

' !",) () # #''

( /)' "") !# !# )"

( / !#)" ( )2!) 22#8' !#/) '!#8"7.!2!#8!4!2)!

!#C ??3 6()!# '!"/""""!# ( / !#)" 6 " "

.' 4!' )') '

?? #',2 !1

2. ("

!'6)!

!#6 "'!"1!""'7. (!" ,) 4!')')'

?#4!6 )"

"3!

"7# # #''

# ,# ##0

5!#8 /""""!# #'

CWP No. 28370-2017 8 !#)" 4# ) ##,# 1# )'3 #' ##0/ .1# 1/#"

( / !#)" >, >,!)' 2 #'3 /) '!#8""( 227' 2 )' ( 47#2 /"'!#4!6"

!#<:; (/ !#)( '!2'!4!2)!

!# F "5!#82 /"!#8 !#/) '!#8"# (8),#'"1# !#'()!#

743 6(! ( 6 " '!"/"' 7. (!" ,) 4!' )') '

' F 6!

('!) !#" ()!

!" ' !' ()/)"#

!#",71!

'7. !#)" 7. / ""!#8 "/ 5!#8 )') () )3 ( / !#)" 6)

22')/)"# 2( )!#8#? C6()!#3 (.",71!

/(."!

2/""""!# #'!"6!

(1 (.( 4# ) !4' !) 1/#"

) ,) () ) '. '/"!

7 5 ( / 1/#"

!#) !4'7. (1!

(, #"!')!#8 (",71!""!#" !#)"3 ( )"/#'# " ( 4 )& ( )/)"#

!# !#)" 4!' )') '

6(! ( ( " 7# !1/,8#' 7. !#)"!# (!#"

!# F # )"/#" ( ",71!""!#" 1 ' 7. ( / !#)"3 %) #5,) %!

232 )#'''!

!# 2'4

#) 2 ).

// )!#8)-

3( " # #''

(/)"# !#!"">, )2. 4)'7. /)!# !/2"2 !''6#!##')42/1# , ()!

.:-,/) ; (,"3( /) .')!

"'!"1!""

2 !"(!" #

)1"

)>,!)1# ) !#45!#8 "

!# <:; !"

)' 1,"

( 4 7#

##,# 'F.

)")1)/)!) (#

1# !3 "# <(/B,) "(2'

6(!2'

)1!#!#8", (/)!' F.

)"3 (/)!'',)!#86(! ("

.6 "!#/)

!#"( 227B 2,'' =!56!"3!# "

(/)' "")!#!# )"

(/ ' ( 22#8' !#/) '!#8"7.!2!#8 #C ?? 6()!#'!"/""""!# (/ !#)")12 #'!#>,"

!#6 ""

.'7.

CWP No. 28370-2017 9

(!",) 4!')')'

??("

!'"

.)1 !#'/)

!4 !22

('!"/"

2 (6)!

!## ?", (/)!'!"B 2,'' 6(!2'

)1!#!#8F.

)",#')"

!#<:; 3 (/)!' F.

)"/)!) <!"# ,2!22' (,"3# (!"8),#' 2# !#<:; 7!#45'7. (/ !#)" ,) ()( " # #''

!#>, )"

#'6 ",/(2'3 ())3 !#4!62 62 !''6#!#/ F? (&,'81# !##')42/1# , ()!

.:-,/) ;3- !#<:; 7,"' 2) )4!4 2 # 2,'' /) '!#8" #' "

2' 2 !1" /) '!#8">, #'!#>,"

!#( "7#,/(2'7. (!",) 4# ()6!" ( /""""!# #' "

#'"

5# 7. ) )'!#8

E# 1 ( # '

' ?6(! ( 1,#

5!#8/(."!

2 /""""!# )'!#82.2 #'!#>,"

!#"

#'"4"

'!# -

))1 22# ,17) # "2"3 ")8 )'" ( 1/#"

!#!

!"(!" # 1,# 1/#"

!#6 "',2. #')' (/

2#8 6!

( () 2 #'6#)" 6(! (

#'" ",7"

!#)" ( 4 ) !4' ( / 1/#"

#' ( ' !2' ))# ,#')- ?<

()7."5!#8#( # 1# !# 1/#"

#' ( " ) !4' 1,# #( # ' 1/#"

!# 6!

( )"/ 5( ") #@@ @ :F0;3:0;3 :0;31!#:F0;3@@ :0?;3@ :F0 <; #' @@ :0?; (!" !1/2!"

( / !#)" ( 4 ("# # ) !4 ( 1/#"

!# !# !# 22. #

. )"

!' ",71!""!#"3 %) %!

2 ( " 4(1# 2. # #'' '!"1!"" ( /)"# 6)!

"## (""# 2)>,!)1# ")4#!#45!#8"

<:; ( "# 7#,2!22' ,) ()3(( "",//) )') '

/ ""' 7. ( )"/#'# " ( 4!#8 7# / ""'

)',2. #"!')!#8 22 (",71!""!#" (/ !#)"

CWP No. 28370-2017 10 C )( 4!#8/),"' (/2 '!#8"7 ( # !#8/ !" ) )'!#8 (!) # !#"3 6 ( 4 # ("!

# 2,'

)

( #' !" ">, )2. 4)' 7. ( /)!# !/2" 2 !' '6# 7. #A72 -,/)1 ,) #'!

!# " #') 42/1# , ()!

. :",/) ; ( /) .) ( / !#)" 2 !1!#8 2 /"!#8

!# /) '!#8" '")4" '!"1!""

2 !# 4!6 ( 226!#8 "#"$0

; !" # '1!

( / !#)" ( ' ( 22#8'

!#/) '!#8"7.!2!#8 #C ??(!" ,) ( " "

.' ( '!"/""""!# ( )1 #' !# >,"

!# 4!' )') '

?? ( "

!' / !# 22. 1 7 ' !'' 4!' )') '

!#2 #'>, )"

#'6 ",/(2'-!# )

( /)!' "

!#8 )1 ?? !22 ? !# )!1 )')6 "!#/)

!#3F.

)"/)!'/)!) <!" # 1/2 )B 2,'!#8", (/)!'3(# 3!#4!6

8)! 7")4

!# (/B,) )B 2,'!#8", ( /)!' ',)!#8 6(! ( "

. 6 " !# ",7"!"

# 3 6 ) #"!')'/!#!#

(F.

)"/)!'/)!) < !"# ,2!22' (,"3/ !#45/)4!"!#" !#<:; 7;# ''!

!'3 ( /B ,) !# #') 42/1# , ()!

. :-,/) ; (

8)!

22. (2'

- !#<:; 7,"' 2 )4!4

( # 2,''/) '!#8"6(! (( 47# 2) '.,/(2'7.

(,) "2 6# "

"6223 (/)' "")

CWP No. 28370-2017 11 !# !# )"

( / !#)" ( ' ( 22#8' /) '!#8" 7. !2!#8 # C ??3 6(! ( 6 '!"1!""' 7. (!" ,) 4!' )') '

!# /) '!#8" 6) ,/(2' (!" !1/2!"

(

!#/) '!#8"

(,"3 #6 ( / 7 226' )/# # 2,''/) '!#8"!#4!6"

!#<:; ;(,8( (/)"# !#!"# 1 !#

!# 72!#4!6

()>,!"!

!4.

)"/)!'/)!) <!" # 1/2

!# /) '!#8" ( 4

!#'!# 2!

.3.

6'1!

//)/)!

))

,"/""""!# "622 " 1/#"

!#(/""""!#!#

#'!""

!' ( 47#

5#7.) )'!#8

# '

' ?3 6(! ( !1/2!"

/(."!

2 /""""!#2 #'!"6!

#'2 #'"

#'"4"

'!# -

) )1

22 # ,17) # " " )8 )'"

1/#"

!#3!

!"!1/)

(!8(2!8( ()

(#A72 /B ,) 6(!2!# )/) !#8 (6)'D/ !'A ,))!#8!#- 0 <:; (6)'D'/"!

'A,"'!#/)4!" - <:; ( " 4).

8)!

22. 7")4' ( 1 #!#8 7 (7.(2'!#8

(6)'D/ !'A'"# !# 2,' '/"!

#' !# "3 1,# ( " 7# #')'3 72!8

/ . !" ,2!22' (

6,2' #"

), 1 # H

I( "7#B/2 !#'!#

1 #

1,# !"@6 " 1 ' !2 72 #'6#)

6,2' 7 '!" ( )8 ( 72!8

1 5 .1# !" ( "/ !! "

#' "/#'#

CWP No. 28370-2017 12 1/#"

1,# 6 "',2. #')' #'6#)" 1"

#'"",7"

')1 (

1/#"

2#8 6!

( #( # ' 1/#"

!# "

#'" ) !4' 7. !#)" ( )"

3 (,"3 8" # "(6

1/#"

1,# 6 "',2. #')' (/ !#)"7,

(. ( 4 ("## ( "

1 (,"3#6 (.

2 !1

( 1/#"

!#( "# 7#/ !' (!1 " ()>,!"!

/)!'!4.

)")>,!)')!#45!#8- <:; !" # 1/2 ) B 2,"!# /)!' "

.3 ,/2' 6!

(

!# /) '!#8" >, >,!)' 2

#'",/(2'7. (!",)

1/#"

1,# "

#'" #')'3 !#4

!#"

!#<:; !"# /""!72

(!#"

(/ (,"3/)"# 6)!

!#!"()7.'!"1!""' ) / !#8 6 2 !

//)/)!

)) () # !# %) %!

( -

>,!)' #' ) ( /,72! /,)/"/,72! # 12.)'42/1# #', !2!E

!#2 "!'# 2

#'11) !

2- )<C

)!'

'(/,72! /,)/"!" (!4' 7.') 6!#8@ //)4!#8 ., /2 #"/) ., /2 #/)/ )')

!#!# >,"

!#3 #' !#>,"

!#!"4). 1, ( ""# 2

(!4 ( /,72! /,)/" #' !

( /2 ##!#8 housing board colony as per the layout plan( 4 #"!')' (!"/ )8,1# !"'7. ()"/#'# #'6 )!# 1/2 8)1# 6!

(!"!" #!1/)

) 75/ !#1!#'6(!2'

2!#86!

)!"!#8, !#2 (!4 (/,72! /,)/" #'!

()!

.6(!"!# (7"

/"!

' !' 7, , !2!E

>,!)'3 )!

4!#87#4"

'!#-

CWP No. 28370-2017 13 ? " ">,2 74'!" ,""!# #'!#4!62 6",11 )!E'!# C#')42/1# , ()!

.:",/) ;3"/ !!

22. )( 4!#8 ) )''

!# " !# ( #'3 )>,!"!

/)!' !4 .

)" !" # 1/2 '3 !#/) '!#8""

#'",/(2'3/""""!#"

#'"

5#3

( 72!8

!# ) / .1# 1/#"

!# "

#'" '!" ( )8' 2" #"!')!#8

#'!#>,"

!#!"4).1, (""# 2 (!4 /,72! /,)/"36( 4#("!

(2'

!# (!#"

",22.'!" ( )8'!

"72!8

!#>, 7 ( # !#8# !" ,))!#8 !# "

!# < :; #' !

7!#8 "3 ( /)"# / !# 1)!

'!"1!""

2 #'(# 3 (!#"

!#!"'!"1!""'

4!#8 '!"1!""' ( 1 !# 6)!

/ !#3 22 /#'!#8

//2!

!#"3! #. 2"1 ("

(6)!

!#!"'!"1!""' -

,">,! #."

#'"4

' : +-9 ; - :

==; 4!#') ( ()"/ 5!#8@) "#' "@ ( ())/)

72 "@