Raj Kumar Jain v. High Court Of Punjab And Haryana & ORS.

  

        

  !"#$#%&'&()*
 

!+,-.!/!&( #"&"&(#/ '

0#/'-' 1#&21 -/"-(+!3!($!/4!(!!($!("1#/  #'5($#(" '

)  67  8      67  8 , 78  /#'#(")9 /!/.&($#/8&(21:$;%!"#:

/5#"&"&(#/ /0&<!'8-/&:$;%!"#: //#'5($#(" /-(##"!=&:8#(&/$;%!"#:>&"1:

/0&31!;!&(:$;%!"#:!($ //-( -5"!:$;%!"#:

//#'5($#("


1#"1#/"1# #5/"#/'=%!=(#>'5!5#/.!43#!==>#$" '##"1#+-$2.#("?

 3#/##//#$""1# #5/"#//(" @ 1#"1#/"1#+-$2.#("'1-=$3#/#5/"#$&("1#$&2#'"? 99 99 , 78 : #"&"&(#/: !+,-.!/!&(:>1&'>/<&(2!'$$&"&(!=!($ 8#''&('-$2#:,!/(!=:&(8"!"#!/4!(!:1!'&(;<#$"1#>/&"+-/&'$&%"&( "1&' -/" -($#//"&%=#'

A !($

B  ('"&"-"&(($&!:/ C-!'1&(2/$#/$!"#$
B  ((#D-/#99 :34>1&%1/#5/#'#("!"&( 5#"&"&(#/$!"#$@

 ((#D-/#99B :>!'/#+#%"#$:;#/=<&(2"1# !%"  "1!"  "1#  $.&(&'"/!"&;#  ('"/-%"&('  $!"#$ 

@


 >#/#  !=/#!$4 /#$-($!("34>!4$.&(&'"/!"&;#('"/-%"&(':!55#($#$" -=#':&''-#$ ($!"#$AA

>&"1/#"/'5#%"&;###%"/.

1-':5/."&( /#'5($#("
("1#3!'&'"1'# -=#'&'&==#2!=!($!/3&"/!/4

9
9 /!4#/&' !='.!$#/$&/#%"&(2"1#5/."&(5#"&"&(#/>&"1##%" /.



:"1#$!"#/.>1&%1/#'5($#("
:+-(&/"5#"&"&(#/ 1!'3##(5/."#$!'$$&"&(!=&'"/&%"!($8#''&('-$2#/!4#/&'!=' .!$#/C-!'1&(2/$#/B
  ((#D-/#99A :;&$#>1&%1/#'5($#("

 
 1!'  3##(  5/."#$  !'  $$&"&(!=  &'"/&%"  !($  8#''&('  -$2#: /#"/'5#%"&;#=4:<##5&(2&(;&#>"1#!%""1!"$.&(&'"/!"&;#('"/-%"&(' $!"#$

@


:2;#/(&(25/."&(:1!$ !=/#!$43#%.#/#$-($!("34 >!4((#D-/#:!55#($#$" -=#'$!"#$AA

:/#"/'5#%"&;#=4>&"1 ##%"/.

#"&"&(#/+&(#$!'! &;&=-$2#9 -.9-$&%&!=!2&'"/!"#!'!

.#.3#/  !/4!(! &;&=  8#/;&%# -$&%&!= /!(%1  ( 
B **B # 3#%!.#"1#.#.3#/8-5#/&/-$&%&!=8#/;&%#(*

 #'5($#("


:(!.#=4:/8!(+##;/4!+&(#$"1#'#/;&%#/#'5($#("!'! .#.3#/!/4!(! &;&=8#/;&%# -$&%&!=/!(%1 (
B **B!'! &;&= -$2#9%-.9-$&%&!=!2&'"/!"#!($>!'5/."#$!'!($$&"&(!= &;&= -$2# 8#(&/&;&'&( &(!/%1:
 #>!'"/!('#//#$!''-%1" &'"/&%"  -/"'  !/>!(!  ( 

B   #'5($#("   
 1!'  3##( 5/."#$!'!($$&"&(!=&'"/&%"!($8#''&('-$2#>&"1##%"/.



"1!'3##(-/"1#/'"!"#$"1!"5/."&(""1#5'"$$&"&(!= &'"/&%"!($8#''&('-$2#-($#/ -=#A

!/4!(!8-5#/&/-$&%&!= 8#/;&%# -=#':
B:&'.!$#""1##D"#("5#/%#("/.!.(2'""1#

&;&=-$2#' 8#(&/&;&'&(

1&#-$&%&!=!2&'"/!"#'

$$&"&(!= &;&= -$2# 8#(&/&;&'&( ("1#3!'&'5/&(%&5=#.#/&"9%-.9'#(&/&"4!($ 5!''&(2'-&"!3&=&"4"#'"1#"1#/5!/""1#/-=#&'("/#=#;!("/"1# 5-/5'#5/#'#("5#"&"&( 
@5'"'$$&"&(!=&'"/&%"!($8#''&(' -$2#'&(8"!"#!/4!(!>#/#("&&#$"3#&==#$&(34>!45/."&(

9@9 ("1#3!'&'5/&(%&5=#.#/&"9%-.9'#(&/&"4!($5!''&(2'-&"!3&=&"4 "#'"1#>/&""#("#'">!'%($-%"#$(


2!&('"
@5'"':A -$&%&!= &%#/'>#/#%!==#$"!55#!/&("1#>/&""#("#'"0&;!;%#>!' 1#=$/.
B@

"
*@

"&'%=!&.#$"1!"%/&"#/&!/#C-&/#$/ #;!=-!"&(&'!/3&"/!/4("1#/'#"/-=#'>#/#("&&#$(AA

>&"1 ##%"/.

 "&''"!"#$"1!" /#'5($#("
>!'2/!("#$ !$;#/'#/#.!/<'&(

#!55/!%1#$"1&' -/"34>!4&=&(2  

!($ A


1#>/&"5#"&"&('>#/# !==>#$34!&;&'&(#(%1"1&' -/"(
@!($

 /#'5($#("    
 >!'  -52/!$#$   /.  6 9#=>  ;#/!2#6:  6("#2/&"4 -3"-=6"6E $6%%/$&(2=4:1#>!'/$#/#$"3#%('&$#/#$/ "1#5'"$$&"&(!=&'"/&%"!($8#''&('-$2#>#;#/:1#1!'3##( &==#2!==4  5/."#$  &(  %('#C-#(%#    $.(&'"/!"&;#  ('"/-%"&('  $!"#$ AA

 1#  &21  -/"  1!'  "!<#(  "1#  '"!($  "1!"  5#"&"&(#/  1!$ 5!/"&%&5!"#$&('#=#%"&(5/%#''!''#''.#("'-&"!3&=&"4"#'"">!' '"!"#$"1!".!""#//&==&(2-5
@;!%!(%&#'$$&"&(!=&'"/&%"!($ 8#''&('-$2#'-($#/ -=#A

!/4!(!8-5#/&/-$&%&!= 8#/;&%#

-=#':
B:>!'&(&"&!"#$&("1#4#!/

""1!""&.#:"1#%/&"#/&!$!"#$ @ 
B>!'"!<#(&("%('&$#/!"&(&#&%#/1!;&(2"1/##6E $6 /#5/"  /  5/#%#$&(2  &;#  4#!/'  !($  >1  !/#  ("  1!;&(2  !(4  6("#2/&"4 -3"-=6/#5/"&(!(4

"1#=!'"&;#4#!/'1#&%#/':-=&==&(2 '!&$%/&"#/&!:>#/#%!==#$/!''#''&(2!($"#'"&(2"1#.#/&"!($'-&"!3&=&"4 ;#("1'#&%#/':>1'#/#5/"'!/#6 ;#/!2#6!($  !2!&('" >1.

$&'%&5=&(!/45/%##$&(2'!/#5#($&(2:>#/#%!==#$/!''#''&(2!($"#'"&(2 "1#&/.#/&"!($'-&"!3&=&"4-($#/'!&$ -=#'/"1&'5-/5'#:"1# ..&""##

99 8&D8#(&/'"-$2#'#D%=-$&(2"1# 1&#-'"&%#>!'/.#$">!'

'"!"#$"1!"5#"&"&(#/ !+,-.!/!&(!($"1#/&%#/'$&$("C-!=&4/ 5/."&(!'$$&"&(!=&'"/&%"!($8#''&('-$2#'!2!&('"
@;!%!(%&#' !'"1#(!.#5#"&"&(#/&2-/#$!"8#/&!= &("1#.#/&"=&'"!($(=4
@!/4!(! &;&=8#/;&%# -$&%&!=/!(%1  &%#/'&("1#'!&$.#/&"=&'"

>#/#/#%..#($#$/5/."&(""1#5'"$$&"&(!= &'"/&%"!($ 8#''&('-$2#'  #2!/$&(2/#'5($#("
/8!(+##;/4!:&">!' '"!"#$"1!"1#>!'$#'&2(!"#$!'$$&"&(!= &;&=-$2# 8#(&/&;&'&( &( -== -/".##"&(21#=$(
@

#>!'2/!$#$6 #=>;#/!2#6:

6("#2/&"4-3"-=6/"1#4#!/
B9
#>!'/#;#/"#$!' &;&=-$2#

-(&/&;&'&( 9%-.9-$&%&!=!2&'"/!"#34-== -/".##"&(21#=$( 

 /8!(+##;/4! /#'5($#("
1!' %1!==#(2#$"1#'!&$ /$#/34>!4&=&(2

3#/#"1&' -/"1#'!&$ >/&"5#"&"&(>!'!==>#$34!&;&'&(#(%1"1&' -/"(
@ !($1&'/#;#/'&(>!'1#=$"3#&==#2!=:("1#2/-($"1!"1#%-=$("3# /#;#/"#$"=>#//!(<>&"1-"1=$&(2!/#2-=!/&(C-&/4!($1&'2/!$!"&( >!'-52/!$#$/.6 #=>;#/!2#6!($6("#2/&"4-3"-=6"6E $6 81/&1!=&"81!/.!:>1&'(>>/<&(2!'$$&"&(!=&'"/&%"!($8#''&(' -$2#: #>!/&:!($>!'&..#$&!"#+-(&//#'5($#("
/8!(+##; /4!:>!'5/."#$!'$$&"&(!=&'"/&%"!($8#''&('-$2#:!'!/#'-=" 5/."&('1#=$&("1#4#!/

""1!""&.#:%/&"#/&!$!"#$@ 
B!($ %/&"#/&!/.-=!"#$:;&$#/#5/"$!"#$@
 /5/."&($$&"&(!= &'"/&%"!($8#''&('-$2#:>!'"!<#(&("%('&$#/!"&('"1#

 /  8!(+##;  /4!  >!'  -52/!$#$:  "1#/#/#:  1#  >!'   1#=$  #("&"=#$  " %('#C-#("&!=  3#(#&"'   #  >!'  %('&$#/#$  /  5/."&(  >1#(  1&' &..#$&!"#+-(&/'1!=&"81!/.!!($'1>!(&,-.!/>#/#5/."#$(

99



 1#'-&"!3&=&"4"#'">!'/2!(&F#$//8!(+##;/4!(
A
 :>1&%11#5!''#$ 1#/#/#:1#>!'5=!%#$&..#$&!"#!3;# 1!=&"81!/.! #  1!;#  1#!/$  "1#  =#!/(#$  %-('#=  /  5#"&"&(#/:  =#!/(#$ %-('#=//#'5($#(" !($=#!/(#$'#(&/%-('#=//#'5($#("


!($1!;#%!/#-==42(#"1/-21"1#&=# " %.#' -" "1!"  "1#.!&(  2/-'#  5#"&"&(#/ &' "1!"  / 8!(+##;/4!:>1&'5/."#$=!"#/(:>!'5=!%#$!3;#1&.&("1# '#=#%"&(

34%/#!"&(2(#'-5#/(-.#/!/45'"&(!$$&"&("
@ ;!%!(%&#':>1&%1>#/#("&&#$$.&""#$=4:5#"&"&(#/1!$!55#!/#$&("1# '!&$#D!.&(!"&(&("1#4#!/

:3-"!&=#$"%.#(.#/&"&/'"
@ %!($&$!"#'1#/#/#:1#>!'("!55&("#$/8!(+##;/4!:("1# "1#/1!($:("1#3!'&'+-$2.#("&(1&'!;-/34!&;&'&(#(%1 "1&' -/"&(

(
@:>!'1#=$#("&"=#$" !=="1#3#(#&"' %%/$&(2=4:!"#/1&'>/&"5#"&"&(>!'!==>#$34! &;&'&(#(%1"1&' -/":!'-&"!3&=&"4"#'">!'%($-%"#$/1&.(
A
   !($  ;&;!  ;%#  (  B
    '  1#  C-!=&&#$  "1#  '!&$  "#'": "1#/#/#:1#>!'5=!%#$!3;#1&'&..#$&!"#+-(&/1!=&"81!/.!!($ 3#=>1&'&..#$&!"#'#(&/!'3&/8&(218&$1- #!/#"1#;&#>"1!"(!%%-("'#""&(2!'&$#/#;#/'&( /8!(+##;/4!!($-52/!$!"&(1&'

:1#>!'1#=$#("&"=#$"!== %('#C-#("&!=3#(#&"':>1&%1 1!;#3##( 2/!("#$ "1&. 1#C-#'"&( /#2!/$&(2  5/#5!/&(2  .#/&"  =&'"  !($  ;&/#'    -=#'  1!;#  3##(  '#5!/!"#=4 %1!==#(2#$&( 
@

 @:>1&%1>&==3#$#%&$#$'#5!/!"#=4 >#;#/:'!/!'5/#'#("%!'#&'%(%#/(#$:/8!(+##;/4! /#'5($#("


>!'/&21"=42/!("#$"1#3#(#&":-5('#""&(2!'&$#1&'$#."&(!($

9A9 -52/!$!"&(

 1#&21 -/" !55=&#$"1#!55/5/&!"#/-=#'!'

5/#;!&=&(2!""1#"&.#"#'" #>!'#("&"=#$"3#5=!%#$!3;#1&' &..#$&!"#+-(&/:>1&%11!'3##($(#1#/#&'(&==#2!=&"4/&(&/.&"4&( "1#&.5-2(#$/$#/:2/!("&(25/."&("/#'5($#("
 ('#C-#("=4:

>#  $  ("  &($  !(4 .#/&"  &(  "1#  >/&"  5#"&"&(  !($  '!.#  &'  $&'.&''#$ >#;#/:&">&==3#'-3+#%""$#%&'&( 
@

 @:"&"=#$!'

 



 
       



 :>1#/#&( 5#"&"&(#/'1!;#%1!==#(2#$"1#;&/#'/-=#':!$.&(&'"/!"&;#&('"/-%"&(': %/&"#/&!/5/."&(!($%#/"!&(/-=#'/5/."&( 

   

, 78           *
  '+<'

1#"1#/'5#!<&(2 /#!'(#$ ) #'  1#"1#/ #5/"!3=# ) #'