High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/8090/2015disposed of

Modern Textile Shuttle Company v. Union Of India & ORS

2015-04-29Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh4 pages

!"!#$% &'(#) !*+,-

*./ #0

!#( 1("-"

#!##'!

#' ,("

"/#'# "

+$ &(

23 ( #+!#4,1(5 6'7

( !#(

! ! . !# # , "5!#4 , -( 6 &( +-#!* 3-.

( +, (.

# ( *7(#.# +

#'!#4-#"* / "# ! #8, * #!# #'!

9("/#'# 6 &( !",! 3 -", *6 '7

( 9("/#'# #' &" &-#!", #',!6 ''* '7

#( *6 -#2 8(("/#'# : : ;

(#' -#"*( !#(, ", #''7( < /!" !# , , * (#' -#"*" ( ("/#'# " % #7!< ,#

-(('(<,! ,</(/" / ""6# (/*0= !'

!"(>-!(' 8!*'80 ,("/#'# "

,* #' !#( **!#4!#7!** 41(5 6,"!* !"

.(!

(6 "-**0'" (!8'!#/ ( ,<(!

!#6, '

8# >-!('80("/#'# " #'-#'( ,

6 ? ? , < (' < " / ""' !# , 0 ( 80 , ;

>-!"!

!#** (9./ # - 0 @ ,/ !#(A".

!#4(!7 # !"

<,!* """"!#4 ./#"

!#6 ,8#!

" + !#" :6 #' :% , ;

>-!"!

!# 6%6# .*06"*

!-. #'!# <(# 4( # '

,.'"/!

,!"-( !# "#$%&'( )(*(& +''% ,)-.(-#/')#0#(.( (&.**(&+1')#!

2342./.%456!

4(!

**0,*'

7#!# , " >-!"!

!#-#'(

* !4,< 0" 6 ?6 , 87 .# !#' < "

- (0 8#!

" ( >- **0 '.!""!8* , ' * #'=<#(" , / !#(" *" (*0 -/# < ' !"!#" ,!" -( 6 8 , '

@/ ""'!#636

21*- .(-1*(&*(+1') /')#0# 77.##.(')! *%*(&1*) 8./.#.( *(& +1')#4 #'

2)'7 *0)/')#0#(.( (&.**(&+1')#4 <,(80 ,8#!

""*

!-. #'!# !# (." , 87= !

' !"!# ,!"-( 6, 78#) #'' ,"!.!* (*0"!

'* #'= <#(" *!

# < "/* '-/# ,('(6##)-( =6/ ""'80

,!"-( !#"!.!* ( !( -."

# " # ,( 4(!7 # !#( !"

8"!'"

"-8.!""!#

!#" 6",!"(-##!#4(./!** ( /"

,! ("("/#'# =

0"- 0( (* " 87.# !#'8#!

"8- ,"

. (<!

,,*'#*0#

,/*

#'!( !#", 78#4!7#80 ,!"-( !#,!" " , 44(!7'/ !#(, "#< //( ,' ,!"-( , 7, ('* (#' -#"*( ( !"

5 *#4 , #'4# ,(-4, ,( (' ,/(!# !/*"* !''<#80 ,!"-( !#*'#(# + * (4!#4"A" "B"-/( C6 (# !#'!"/- -( ,(6 ,

,8#!

""*

!-. #'!# , 78#) #''80 ,!"-(

,"!.!* (*0"!

'* #'=<#("7!'('('

'@!#, +!#4,A" " B"-/( C6 # *" 8 , ('*0 '!"/- ' # ,"

!( -."

# "6< ( ,7!<

!"!./(

!7-/#("/#'#

" #' #"!'( !#(A" * !.( ,4( # "*

!-.

#'!# !# ('

# <!

, ,' !"!# ,!"-( !#*'#(#

#'+ * (4!#4"A" "B"-/( C ,<(!

!#!" ('!#4*0'!"/"'!# ,**<!#4

(."$= B!C , / !#( ", ** .7

!# 8( # !!' ./ # - 0= -.=;

#' >-!"!

** (<!

,!# /(!'#.# ,( ,4( #

!'8#!

"D B!!C ,"

!'./ # - 0<!**!""-# !

**( ,( ('"9(/*0(. ,

- 0#'!

D B!!!C ,./ # - 0", ** ,( ('

(.!# <, ,( ( # !#( !" # *'

!'8#!

"6"/ !

**0!#7!< ,' !"!#"

,!"-( #' ,#E8*+-/(.-( (*!'

-/#80 , * !.

# "D B!7C !#(!"-#'# *' 6 "*"/ 5!#4 "-//*.#

(0< (' ,!" ", **8/ ""'

,!# /(!'-(.# ,"(. ,'

!*!#4

!#D B7C ,

0"- 0#'!

", **'/"!

, .-# 6! #06/ 8*!# (.""-//*.#

< ('6!#!# =8 (!#4!)''/"!

-# B"C!#

#0#

*!F'8 #5 #''!"8-(".# ,(", ** 8 "-82 , !# * ' !"!# , #E8* +-/(.-( !#+/ !

* ;

7 // *B!7!*C % % *'$ (2 !( (6

* !4,< 0617"

2",< (+!#4, #' (" (!

!#"

#'"'!"/"' ('!#4*0 2

4 8$ :).%

4 48"