High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/28415/2017dismissed

Gram Panchayat Manak Majra And ORS v. Union Of India And ORS.

2023-01-06Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj14 pages

!"!

#$%&&'

( ( )(

+ *

($, -( & *. *&

& ////

Mr. Anil Chawla, Advocate for Ms. Monica Chawla, Advocate

1-U.O.I.

Mr. Nitin Goel, Advocate for Mr. R.S. Madan, Advocate

2 and 3- NHAI.

Mr. Manjeet Singh Advocate for Mr. Ranvijay Singh, Advocate

. *&

0 &1 -2 ! " #$ #%%& ' $ ( )*+, -

$ ! $ .$ $

/ # # %),0%,)+12$ 345

6 # # 7!6! $#$ #8$.

6. 6 9 #6 $..

) 3 : . 6 #! ## '$ ! $".

%3 7(

$ $ : 1 73)5 7( # ; 6 %,,& ! <# &# $ 2 $ ! - < $#$ ## !## " ## 8$#6 " " $ " : 1 73)5 #. $6 7(

## #

# . 6 $ $#$ # ( "

$". ! $". 6 7!6

# .! $#6 "6 ! $ $

)<&=%<+ > !# $# $

! )<0=)&,> .! 3 " )<+=%,, > )<+=*,, > ! # " $ $ ! # $

6 " # %),0%,)+ "6 7!6 : . ( 12$ 345 )<&=%<+> ."# %4"6!6

? " ; @ 7( " # (

##6 #6 $"

..$ ,4,<%,)A 12$ 3%/+5

##! "

"##-;

!"# $%%&'( ()**+

$,- !"

*%.*+/."0** " 1 ,&"2. 3,'

* %* /. " %

&%. 0** & %+*456--"+% 7"+% +** *"%% / 5 " *5/"*"1"&"2.*+"

"5"%*8+5% " "*5""+****& 5""*7 952"/5:9; .""/5*1 %**"5*0**& *+%%% "8+ "+**"* "%2 /5 * % < " 2'2. *5 * %* *+"+&"+3% ""%%" 5 +** * 2%% * " %%& ' ( ()*%**+/."0**" * "**&**" 1,&"2. 9"*=:* ""%2"+** "5/ */+&"(&

>: *"%%.**/%*+"*+** 5%%& ( () * " #%" * " " +**2%% 5"(&*5+?

( $ $ $

$# $

3 " $# # # 6 " "

# $

# 0+,. !# ##

# . # ( $ " $# $

" ##

! -#. $

" .

. (

"#6 $

)<+4+%! # # "# $ $

; . "

$ " ! . " # "6 %,)A! #

$".

! #( $ .$ $

3 #"# #

-#.

##- ! # )<&=,,, > . #6 $

#6 B ## "

..$ ( # $ # # $ $. #! ! "#

( . $ # # !## $. $# $

" #. )<&=,,,> #7!6! . " )<0=)&,> ! 3 " )<+=%,,>)<+=*,,> # " !# $

" )<&=*<+>( "#6.$## 62 "

" ! !-#. !6 .# )<&=,,,> $# $

"! ; $# .

. / $ # $# $

/ $

/ 3 " "

##6 ! # 6

. C$ $ 6/2 " ! %-#. $ $." 6/2 " " $

. #6" $ ## .

# $ $ ; 7( # " $ 6 $ "#6 $6 2. # !##

6( $ ; 6/2 # 8$ " ." $"; . 2 " $." - !# 6/2 .

#7!6!$#" 7'$ 6 $ ;$ # ! - "6 2 ! ! ##"### # $# $"6 .# . # 6"

$ "# $ 6 2 # 6 "

.( 6 $

$ 2 ! ;$ # !$ # %%&/%%0 ' $ ( $ / # $

# .# # # ( # 6 " # "6 7D"# $ . '$ $ $ ; " "# ! . 2 7'$ !$#2 ;$ # ! # -"62 "$#$

; 6/2 /

. "6

; 2 #

$ 6 $

. 6.

"$ ! / # #! $ #! . !$# " #6 ! $ $ ! ". "6 7D"#$ .'$ #. " #

& '

(

)

% % % * % ( +* (

# $ 3 @> ,: 2%% / * " 3,9 * **%%. & *+. /. "5& =* " %5% 3%,&"2.*!" 1* 5%5& *+ 2 "&"2.* 2& 5% " =*& "&"2.*: 2"" 5% 5% *++ " +.: +* =*"%"&"2.*9 ****"5& 5* 2%&=*"%"&"2.5% 3,9 * % * 1* %&5% 3%,&"2.* "+&"*+./.=*%*#%1 * & 52 " %5 * %+& *.

"5. 5"+% %& +/% * !" 0+* %% 8+ + " 5/%.*/%."+%12""" +%%& 2+%*+/*5"%&+/%*9 *+" *: " * 1+% 52 * 5. % !" 0+ +%%. " 8+* % : * **:"+%1:*+/='. " %2+ %*9"* ":".

"*/ */%*" " "& % "* / 5 !":"+"%%&/*+*?

C$ @ 9 '$ . ', -

% ./"01 & ( / ) + ) # $%

* % #

%%% 4 # $ 3 @>**:"*2"52*5"2 ."5*+&&*8+"%"%2* -+"*+&&*/&."+/%*"*/ *: *%%. 2" 3,9 * = 1/ "5& 5 * && *+%. =* :(A*B9 5$-+"522* /.,C/% =0+#!

# #3!."&)4"56*5

7#3

8"0 12 && & 1!9!62 '': %.& 2 " 3,9 * **%%. & *+. /. "5& =* " %5% 3%,&"2.*!" 1* 5%5& *+ 2 "&"2.* 2& 5% " =*& "&"2.*: 2"" 5% 5% *++ " +.: +* =*"%"&"2.*9 ****"5& 5* 2%&=*"%"&"2.5% 3,9 * % * 1* %&5% 3%,&"2.* "+&"*+./.=*%*#%1 * & 52 " %5 * %+& *. "5.

5"+% %& +/% * !" 0+* %% 8+ + " 5/%.*/%."+%12""" +%%& 2+%*+/*5"%&+/%*9 *+" *:"*1+%52*5.% @ ( " $ ; $ 7!6 !/$. $ $ '$ 6 # 2 ( . -!# 2 # #.. 7!6 E ; $6 " .##!

6 $ ." " $ "#"6 2 $ ! 2 $#" #6 !"6 7 '$ 2 ! ;$ # ! $ # %%&/%%0 ' $ ( .# ! ! - "6 7D"# $ . '$ . 5 6 7

,% & 5 &% ',

% 3

( +** ( !

# 3 %%% #2 $ 3 @ D " " 2 " %% * 2"%%. +2 "* +* %** +/% *0*+****%5% *++.-!"%-&%"" #5* " " ,&" 0+ 2 =*& 2 1+%52+2"""*"-2*

*%./.+1+**%2/."*0+9

((( " # $%

.441!

! * %%+".5"*"-!"*0+

((( .* 1"%*+E == == == !"+."+**%"8+* %&%.9**"+%/E D""*'

&+".=*2*F 0

%2:

/""+%*+%1+*:

" * 2"" */% /+% 2+% "5":

/+**2*

!": * " + 2"" +% %. +% * " +%%% "%.*9*%.2""

2"""***"5/ !"= "+.%.2%%5. **-"%. +: " &+* + 2"" *5 * *+/1 % /. 1+% 52 / %** * +E 469%%&%.E!"* *"*'

+*+* %. " %2 " &+%* "* *' & 2 +*&5 469%.: %.:D*/+.+*/%** 46 +% . !"/5%."/&+*/+*+%+ +"&+*+* * :G5-.-", # := H460 I:$#% **%%. 5% : %.: " **/% & " %%.9%%"***"*/ * " " + *"+%: @* 2"" * "& "* & 2& + & 2"" 8+**5? == == == !"%*+/% "/5E 46 !"

* 1+% * *5 46 !" + * * * + % /+ %. 52*" 2"""*2* 46 !"

** 2%%/*+/*+&*2*: 2"+"**.=*2""*% ./%%/% == == == 6!"B5 +*"5 9" 2*:%."1****. *5 /. +& *5 *"8+*' *5*",25:"*

+* %. / * /. " % D*/+. %*/%**4%+&*"* +/56/+ +*/ /**/. /*+/. %* 6 J+*"& ** . * "5. *5 /+" *%*+' /+& =+ * "* %* 2 2%% = "*"***".

+** "%*? === === === !"* 0+ *+ 2 + " 1+& *(** " # $%

% :3 4 : 32"2*"%"" 0+* +*%)"% *""52""%**

% * +% +* 9 * 5%5& "% **+*: " 0+* *"+% / 5 %+ /+* * +* 1+&*K /* "5 " **. =* 1+ + "% **+* /. + * % 2 " 1+& * /5: " 0+* *"+% +* &.& &%** 2"% *& " * 5.* %% * % /&/%+ 9 : " +* +* &5 7 %. " 1*7 " &5 +/%*+ &* * 0+* +* %* 2" *+" 2+% +* +**. %** " +/% ="8+ 9 2* "% * +E'

@!"*0+/&"&++ %&"** +. /+ 2" " * /**: %.: %*/*,25:"*0+%% " * ** "* + & " +* *"+% =* % * 2"% =*& "2*1+%52+%

* !"* 0+ * %%. %" +% *+%**%'+*/** %*/*%.* + +* / " . . +/% * + &* 2""5+*.!"* /2 5 * *+/1 *+. + 2 1+* 3 +/: " /* 2"" - 2" " & % " 0*+ /+%. /%"21+* *+ +*: /+ "* *. 2 +* / =*2"&%*+ == == == !"

** " %2 % 2 " 1+& * /5*"=**+L" 52"% & +/% * 1+*. 1+% 5 * 5%5& " * *+ %*L"+**"+%&52." " =* +%** " * * %%. /. +*/%L"+**% +% 5"+".L"+ +*%)" " +". %& " * " /* 1+& * 8+ *:":"+K**"+% / % !" +".

2"" %* " "* +" " + * * " /* 1+&*"2"+ *"5/92 * **/% " " " +" +* / !" +* 2%% %. 5 /**: %.

5*.D""*" :2*"%%%2" "**? 4;

"***+%6 )< ( !

#6 !:5 *;

3 !6 8;#& - 3& 9& ( #

86 - 3&08 ;

3"*#-!# *0 '$ $ ! $ !# ! / 6 ! $#.#6 .6 #6 2 $ ; (! # $ @ ;5 2"% & " 2 A &&"*.2""+% %. .%."=+ " (& 1*: +* / / " . *+*%. " =+ " 1* +/% */%* " - A * &*A *+ %* *"&& " *+% %&% /%& 2* " )* !": " ,&" 0+* *"+% / = %. +% + * =* * * 2"% & *+" * A2"%&&*.

*+" *;5* 2"",&"0+*" "" ****+"5*A/.A*+* %*A5+* :2"%&*+" 2 A ** . : ,&" 0+ . + " 2 K* " *"%**"*%.=+ " 1 + *+" &* /. " A: "A". ./*%2"" &*+*%. =+ *+" 1*: 2"" . / + *+" 5%+*%&*/." AD""*2* +5*:2*" "%5 "2* "0+4*6:2""+% %. .

% " %& +/% * " % * 5%5?

-"*+**++1 & 52 " " %&*%+ " *++ 1**"+%/*.:",&"0+2+%"5/ 2%% 5* "% * " *. " *+ " *++1-+"5**"+%/ 525 /."D0+2"%=*&*1+*+% "0*+9 === === === === === === !"0+*"5"=*= " * *"*. 5*"- "*% *"+%/ 520+**"+%/5

%+ & 2" * 5%5& "% **+* * " * 8+ " **. =* 1++*+"**+* 4;

"**-+%6 . " # $

$." 6/2 #7!6

# " #6" $ #

# " $ # 6/2 # 7!6 - ##

#7!6 .!$#

$ #.# .2 ..$ / # # 7!6 $# 2$ 3%/+ "66 . ##"# $ '$ # ! "$

$. " $ $

- #6

"#!#!"67D"#$ .'$ !## "6 '$ ( 6 $

$ ! 3$ 6 $

.# )<&=%<+> #7!6

#6 .

1. *&

%&&' 7% D""* &A* EM*A3 D""/% EM*A3