High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/2844/2017dismissed

Suresh Chand Sharma v. Union Of India And ORS

2018-07-25Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath3 pages

!" "#$%$&'

!" "#$%$&'( ( ( (

)*"%++ &,+ *- "!$!$&"* .% &$& &,$ &,!+"*% "%/&,"&!% 0'1 20 0'1 20 0'1 20 0'1 20330 330 330 330 *"%"&!' 0* 4/ 56,7# !"6

*!+"/"!$!$&"* 0*3 * &$&4+6,7# !"6

*!+"*"%/&,"&!% 3306 3306 3306 3306 +" /"!$!$&"* + % /* 8", * !+" $%%) &#" 9*$! $& !+" & !)*" #"*!$* *$ * :) %+$&4 !+" *,"* , !", ;<

= / %%", >8 *"%/&,"&!>8 9+$#++$% //5$# !$& **"&"9 5 +$%#"*!$ $# !"! /* #!$#" %! *8+ %>""&*"?"#!", & >*$"

6 !+" /"!$!$&"*6 /* #!$#$&4 ,7# !" ! $7$5 )*!% -/5"@6 &4*)*6 $%!*$#! !$ 5 6 9 % $%%)", #"*!$ $# !" >8 !+" *"%/&,"&!%!/* #!$#" %! *8&<

* /"*$, (8" *%)&,"* !+" ! *$"% #!6 ;( A * %+*! B!+" #!1C +" % $, #"*!$ $# !" 9 % *"&"9", *-

(+"/"!$!$&"* //5$", * *"&"9 5 +$% ! *8 2$#"&#" (; $& $5" (D<(<EF;; & ;<

(9$!+ ,* ! =

F!$% 55"4",!+ !!+"*"9 %& *"%/&%" ! +$% //5$# !$&6 !+"*"

*"6 !+" /"!$!$&"* %"&! *"-$&,"* &

= &,*"#"$7",!+"$-/)4&",*,"*, !",;<

= 4 $&%!9+$#+ +"- ," *"/*"%"&! !$& &,+ %)5!$- !"58 $5",!+$%/"!$!$& 2" *&", #)&%"5 * !+" /"!$!$&"* + % %)>-$!!", !+ ! !+" /"!$!$&"*#)5,&! //58 *!+"*"&"9 5 +$%! *8#"*!$ $# !"9$!+$&!+" %!$/)5 !", !$-" % /*"%#*$>", )&,"* )5" !+" ! *$"% )5"%6 ;(=6 *" , 9$!+ !+" ! *$"% D-"&,-"&!E )5"%6

A * %+*! B!+" )5"%1C >"# )%" +$% 9$ " + , %)

"*", >* $& + "-**+ 4" $& )&"

! $% %)>-$!!", !+ ! +" %+)5, + 7" >""& 4$7"& & //*!)&$!8 ! "@/5 $& !+" ,"5 8 & !+" !+"* + &,6 5" *&", #)&%"5 * !+" *"%/&,"&!% + % %)>-$!!",!+ ! %/"*)5" !+")5"%6!+" //5$# !$&%+)5,+ 7">""&

$5", %$@ -&!+% >"

*" !+" "@/$*8 7 5$,$!8 ! $% &! ,"&$", !+ ! !+" 7"*&-"&!- 86"7"& !"*#&%$,"*$&4!+"*" %&% *!+","5 8%! !",$& !+" //5$# !$&6*"5 @!+"#&,$!$& %)>-$%%$& //5$# !$&>"

*"!+" %/"#$ $#/"*$, + 7" +" *, 5" *&", #)&%"5 * !+" / *!$"% &, /"*)%", !+" *"#*,9$!+!+"$* >5" %%$%! &#" +"*"&"9 5 !+"#"*!$ $# !" ! *8$%47"*&",>8)5" !+")5"%69+$#+$%*"/*,)#", %)&,"*' "&"9 5 "*!$ $# !" * #!$#"

"&"9 5 "*!$ $# !" * #!$#"

"&"9 5 "*!$ $# !" * #!$#" +" "*!$ $# !" * #!$#" $%%)", )&,"* %)>*)5"D E *)5" - 8>"*"&"9", *

)*!+"*/"*$, $7"8" *%&/ 8-"&! /*"%#*$>", "" & //5$# !$& * *"&"9 5 "*!$ $# !" * #!$#"%+ 55>"%)>-$!!",

< ! !+" //*/*$ !" 7"*&-"&! >"

*" %$@ -&!+% *-!+", !" "@/$*8 $!%/"*$, 7 5$,$!8 *7$,", !+ ! !+" //*/*$ !" 7"*&-"&! - 86 !"*#&%$,"*$&4!+"*" %&%%! !",$& !+" //5$# !$&6 *"5 @ !+" #&,$!$& %)>-$%%$& //5$# !$& * *"&"9 5 #"*!$ $# !" /* #!$#" >"

*" !+" >7" %/"#$ $#/"*$,H )5" !+" )5"% + % >""& !+*)4+58 ,$%#)%%", $& ,"#$%$&*"&,"*",>8!+$%)*!$& == <

=!$!5", %G""* ? G""* ? G""* ? G""* ? 3)- *0 +"%+% *$ 3)- *0 +"%+% *$ 3)- *0 +"%+% *$ 3)- *0 +"%+% *$.%&$& &,$ &, &!+"* &$& &,$ &, &!+"* &$& &,$ &, &!+"* &$& &,$ &, &!+"*HHHH,"#$,",&

9+"*"$& !+" ,"#$%$&% ! I"& >8 )*!% 9"*" 5% #&%$,"*", & !+" % $, # %"6$!+ %>""&,"#$,",!+ !$&# %" ,"5 86 *!+"/)*/%" ! I$&4 ,7 &! 4" !+" /*7$% ! )5" !+" )5"%6 !+" //5$# &! + % ! -"&!$& %/"#$ $# *" %&% $& !+" //5$# !$& ! !+" !$-" //58$&4 * *"&"9 5 &, &! %)>%":)"&!58 $&#"6 !+" /"!$!$&"* ,$, &! $5" %)#+ & //5$# !$&6!+"*"

*"6,&! $&, &8 )5!&!+"/ *! !+"*"%/&,"&!% $&*"?"#!$&4+$% //5$# !$&9+$#+$%/ !"&!58>"8&,!+"/"*$, 5$-$! !$& /*"%#*$>", &,!+)%6!+"9*$!/"!$!$&$%+"*">8,$%-$%%", D330E D330E D330E D330E ( ( ( (

+"!+"*%/" I$&4F*" %&", '

"%F +"!+"*"/*! >5" '

"%F