High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/8121/2015disposed of

M/S Divya Bhaskar v. State Of Haryana And ANR

2015-10-14Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal,Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan6 pages

!""#$%$&'(

)%$*+ , %- .

// "!$!$&".

0".%1% 2! !" .+ & &!,".

// "%3&4"&!%

."%"&!'/

. 5"%,.. 64*# !".!,"3"!$!$&".

. ,17"*2$&8,66 .+ & ,"$&%! &!3"!$!$&$%4$."#!"4 8 $&%!!,".4".4 !"4(

&&":1." /;6 3 %%"4 <+ !," &!.77".6 .$&!$&8 2! !$&".+ "3 .!="&!6 .+ & 6."%3&4"&! &6>,"."<+ !," 3"!$!$&"./$.= , % <""& 3".= &"&!7+<7 #-7$%!"4 .$!".!$. .$$% 7%%18,!. ?1 %,$&8 !," .4". 4 !"4 @@ &&":1." /( !," .$&#$3 7 2"#."! .+6*! .+ & 6 .$&!$&82! !$&".+"3 .!="&! $.=$&8 !," #!$&<7 #-7$%!$&8

"%3&4"&!&$%%1"4!"&4".&!$#".3.$&!$&8 &4%1337+ !":!<-%.#7 %%"%A!, ! !, % 7%.3.$= .+#7 %%"% %! ! !, 3".! $&$&8! # 4"=$#%"%%$&+" ./ 2"#!$&@!,"&!$#" $&*$!$&8!"&4".%4" 7!>$!,$&%!.1#!$&%!<$44".% &4#7 1%" !,"." 8*".&"4> .4&!. #!2"#!$&@ %1<#7 1%"B>174<"."7"* &!

.!,"#&!.*".%+ !, &4 &4$%."3.41#"4,"."1&4".'/

" # #

$%%

$& '(( "

%% ! (*

" # +&&

'(( "

% , "

-( ( # .

% #

'((#/ ( %$ # # $"

0 (

% #"

% "*

$%%

$& '(( "

#( (

% #"

#( !

- &1 "

$"# !

# &&1

" #

( !

" "

%$"1 "

% #"

% - &$

&#/ +%

# &1 5 !

( "

# "

(

+&& '

% #

(

( '1

&& "

#%&$(#/ " $"

'& %6 & #/

&/'&

#( +&&#/ "

# #%

# &1 % # '

"( "

&& "

+&& '

# &

#( '#(#/ $!

" , &$"

$%%

$& '(( "

% !&1 +

8$"

& $

#( :

% # :

&& % # $

$% # /"

$#(

##$& #

+ "(

#( " $"

# 1* # +%

- #*

" #

+ "(

# & +

;- &$ ( <(( "

+&&#/

% && "

# + <( = @

"!$!$&"./$.=3 .!$#$3 !"4$&!,"!"&4".3.#"%%<+%1<=$!!$&8 !,"!"#,&$# 7 %>"77 %$& &#$ 7<$4>$!,$&!,"%!$317 !"4!$=". =" .&"%!=&"+ %7 #%> % 7%417+4"3%$!"4 &31.%1 &#"! &"8!$ !$&%, *$&8! -"&37 #"<"." 23"#$ 7$8, >"."4 1.#, %"

==$!!""6 !,"3"!$!$&"./$.=> % 4"#7 ."4 !," %1##"%%17 !"&4".".& B &31.%1 &#"!,"."!!,"%1337+.4".4 !"4B> % $%%1"4$& *1.!,"3"!$!$&"./$.=%3".2"#!$&@ #7 1%"B $$6 C3"..= &#"%"#1.$!+> %!<"4"3%$!"4>$!,$& 3".$4%"*"&

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

."%3&4"&!&4$."#!"4."$!1."!,"" .&"%!=&"+ =1&!$&8! % 7 #%%,># 1%"&!$#"# ..+$&8"*"&4 !"$"@ /A > % 7% %".*"4 13& !," 3"!$!$&"./$.= #&!"=37 !$&8 !," 3"& 7!+ <7 #-7$%!$&8.&!, *$&81&4".! -"&!,"3.$&!$&8>.-!, !, 4<""&417+ 77!!"4 "37+!!,"%,># 1%"&!$#"> %1.&$%,"4 (

"%3&4"&!&$%%1"4!,"$=318&"4.4".4 !"4(

/;<7 #-7$%!$&8!,"3"!$!$&"./$.=<+$&*-$&8!,"#7 1%"B

$$2"#!$&@!,"&!$#"$&*$!$&8!"&4".% &4 %%1#,4"< .."4$!.= 4$&8 &+3.$&!$&8<1%$&"%%>$!,!," .+ & *".&="&! ," 33" 7 3."".."4<"."!,"2! !"*".&="&!, %<""&4$%=$%%"4*$4".4".4 !"4 @@ /(63 %%"4<+."%3&4"&!& &4!,".4". <7 #-7$%!$&84 !"4(, %<""& $.="4

E" .&"4#1&%"7.!,"3 .!$"%, *"<""&," .4 !7"&8!, A ,"$=318&"4.4".4"%&!="&!$& &+3".$4 &4!,1%!," 3"!$!$&"./$.=%! &4%<7 #-7$%!"4. &1&7$=$!"43".$4!$="21#, &

/(/ .4".3".= &"&!<7 #-7$%!$&8$%1&%1%! $& <7"$&*$">!,"5148"="&! !,"&F<7"213."="1.!$&

! "

#$%&

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

3"!$!$&"./$.= >174 7% , *" = !".$ 7 <" .$&8 & !," %3"#! <7 #-7$%!$&8!".!," > .4!,"%1337+.4".6!,"3"!$!$&"./$.= !!," *".+!,."%,74, 4":3."%%"4$!%$& <$7$!+!":"#1!"!,"% =" &4, 4$!%"7 $&*$!"4!,"3"& 7!+."$!1."" .&"%!=&"+4"3%$!!$%&!"*"&!," # %"!,"."%3&4"&!4"3 .!="&!!, !!,"3"!$!$&"./$.=, 4"&8 8"4$& &+#..13!.. 1417"&!3. #!$#" !,".& ##1&!!," 33" 7 8 $&%!

!,".4".<7 #-7$%!$&84 !"4(, *$&8<""&-"3!3"&4$&8 &4 4"#$4"4&7+&@@ 6!,"3"!$!$&"./$.=, % 7." 4+%".*"41! 3".$44"< .="&!$&":#"%%$*"+" .% &4".%1#,#$.#1=%! &#"%6 !,".">174<"&51%!$$# !$&!3".=$!!,"."%3&4"&! 1!,.$!$"%!."*$%$! !,"$%%1">$!,."8 .4!$=3%$!$&3"& 7!+<7 #-7$%!$&8 B &*$">!," <*"6>.$!3"!$!$&$% 77>"4=318&"4.4". 4 !"4( /;63 %%"4<+."%3&4"&!& &4.4".4 !"4

/A/ @@ &&":1." /(6 3 %%"4 <+ ."%3&4"&! & ." %"! %$4" E$<".!+!3 %% &+."%,.4". %."8 .4%<7 #-7$%!$&813&!,"3"!$!$&"./ $.=$%%3"#$$# 77+4"#7$&"4

"!$!$&$% 77>"4$&!," ."% $4!".=%

"# $" $%&& $'!

() $%& "

*') ("

*%"

+,+-.-+/ 71#-+ ,"!,".!<"."".."4! "3.!".I"%