Gagandeep Singh v. State Of Punjab And Others
1
! "!#$%$&' (
) &"!!*+$&), -**!.. & /!0%1% + ! 1&2 3 &" ,!0% -!%*&"!& % ' 4 +/+56 + 4 +6
6
!
" #$ % %&%# '( ) * ++'( "" '" ' '" , + "( - - - .
/ 0 ( #1 #& #112 + '(+3 !4
5 3 5 " !4
+ (+ ' " ) ) ( ) .
+ + ' %% #11% + '
( 6 ( ,
" """
'"
2 " " " ' "
!( ( ( %7 %&#%38 #95 :
" " - ;++ " "" '
('"
< = </=+ - + <.= ( " ' ++ :
:
" ( / "+ !$ %	 %6 % 38 %65+ "> - (8 > '"
%% % " + + ! %6 #& % >
>? 6119%&%& %6 #& %+ ' ( %7 % %&%& " (
+ :
8 " "
" 8 "'(
" " #$ @ %&&7 + " (+ ' %6(
A" "(
"" '
( %# %&%&38 915 "+ ! + "'( ) *
3
'"
) * ( ' " <)" " " %&&%="+ ("(+ ""' "( ; '" '
## (A)"%&&%+ ""' "( ""' '' " , ' %6( = ( #1 #& #112 - + '
( 6 ( + "" ( "
!(
%7 %&#% " " .
""
+8 '+ " +
( ! %# %&%& ( ! " ( + ( ; '" " + " +
+ ++ " (
+ " '( " ;+ &% %&%# + + "'( ) * > ,(
" " "(A)"%&&%
4
" ' ' + '
2 ##)" "6. ELIGIBILITY (a) The family is indigent and deserves immediate assistance for relief from financial destitution. The authority concerned must consider as to whether the family of deceased employees is unable to meet the financial crisis resulting from employee's death. (b) Applicant for compassionate appointment should be eligible and suitable for the post in all respects under the provisions of the relevant Recruitment Rules.
11. WHERE THERE IS AN EARNING MEMBER (a) In deserving cases even where there is already an earning member may be considered for compassionate appointment with prior approval of the Secretary of the Department concerned, who before approving such appointment will consult the Department of Personnel and satisfy himself that grant of compassionate appointment is justified having regard to number of dependents, assets and liabilities left by the Government Servant, income of the earning members as also his liabilities including the fact that the earning member is residing with the family of the Government Servant and whether he should not be a source of support to other members of the family.
(b) In case where any member of the family of the deceased servant is already in employment and is not supporting the other members of the family of the Government servant, extreme caution has to be observed in ascertaining the economic distress of the members of the family of the Government servant so that the facility of appointment on compassionate ground is not circumvented and misused by putting forward the
5 ground that the member of the family already employed is not supporting the family."
"(" " '! '
2 35 " " ( "( ++ " "(
"(" (
## 35 '( '
( ""' "(( "(""' " )" %&&% ;+ ( " '!"
'
##35 >+( " ("( ' 3 #&9&&B96$&&B7&&&5 " + 9# #% %&%& + ( "
C (%6 ( ' " %' 9'+ 3 '( D #%
5+ + + +
"
, (
##36 ' '
!
+
2)"
8 " (' "
+ " " " '
"( + (
(" ! "
6 !
'
" + "( + ( ""' "(+ A" ' +(" "
( (%6( =
" ( " " :
( +
"(" " " A ( + '
'("+ "(
+
+
>+(
+ ( #1 #& #112 + + '
( 6 (
8 " '" "
!( %7 %&#% :
" "
- ;+ - ' <.= + + " " ('"
< = </= ( > " ( / " ;+ + :
:
'
! $ %	 )" ( (8 " > - %6 % + !
(
%# %&%& " %6 ( ' + " "
7 " ;
+ "
( '
:
"' 6(
" ( ' ( " "
!(E + ? - + ' ' '( ) " " " )"$%,0 % "/+ ! $, 06778 +9 0 9 "......The very object of appointment of a dependent of the deceased employees who died in harness is to relieve unexpected immediate hardship and distress caused to the family by sudden demise of the earning member of the family. Since the death occurred way back in 1971, in which year, the appellant was four years old, it cannot be said that he is entitled to be appointed after he attained majority long thereafter. In other words, if that contention is accepted, it amounts to another mode of recruitment of the dependent of a deceased Government servant which cannot be encouraged, de hors the recruitment rules." + /. $2!&"!0+$&), /%+ ! 0: & 6777 9+7; 0
8
! >"
( " ' '(/.35 ( ( (A)"%&&%+ " " "
!(+ > 8 " 38 7 $ #&5 + + '
+ + ' + " (
+ "" ) ( (' "
" ' +
?
) ' .
( " " " " " '
+ " ' :
( '(
("( ' " '
"9# #% %&%& (
:
" ') F . ( %&&$ " /"
F " ' ) . F - /"' %&## > :
.
( " ) F " '
9 0(* ;+ 6( + %1( ( + " " '
" ? "(" + '8
(" - +
' +
+" !
"'( ) *
' '" ("
/+5
+
# 3!0 (6
4) "
>
A + >D '
+A?C