← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/28492/2017allowed

Poonam Siwach v. State Of Haryana And Others

2019-04-10Mr. Justice B.S. Walia9 pages

  



            

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

31)%#*& 1&(1%'$(*>$/%1%)5*&%*$)$ 1%(*)$#$%/%1(*)%19('%#6*>.($/#66'*)%<3%*$(#6=%*% ($)

 1(% #'$) $/%'#)%#1%$/#$$/%5%$($(*%1.#)#55(*$%&#)-$#

31)% * '*$1#'$3#6 =#)() 9(&% #55(*$,%*$ 6%$$%1 **%?31% @ &#$%& A8*'*)6(&#$%&/*1#1(3,  8 @B 5%1 ,*$/8 .($/ $/% '*&($(*$/#$/%15%1 1,#*'%.36&=%1%9(%.%&# $%1$.,*$/)#*&( /%1.1C#*&'*&3'$.#)*$ 3*&)#$() #'$148/%1'*$1#'$.36&*$=% %?$%*&%& .%9%18 $/% 5%$($(*%1 .#) '*$(*3%& (* )%19('% 9(&% 1&%1) 5#))%& 1, $(,% $ $(,% #*& '66%'$(9%64 #$$#'/%& #6*> .($/ $/% .1($ 5%$($(*#)**%?31%@

 !"DE F

1(%9#*'%   $/% 5%$($(*%1 () $/#$ /%1 )%19('%) .%1% $%1,(*#$%& =4 1%)5*&%*$   9(&% 1&%1 **%?31% @ &#$%&   * $/% &(1%'$(*) 1%)5*&%*$ *$/%=#)() #66%>#$(*)&#$%&   .($/3$'*&3'$(*>#*(*<3(14#*&>1#*$(*>/%1551$3*($4 /%#1(*> A %564 /#) =%%* (6%& =4 1%)5*&%*$  * =%/#6    1%)5*&%*$ ) $ 8 #&,($$(*> $/% 5%$($(*%1 $ =% .1C(*> #) -$#

 31)% * '*$1#'$3#6=#)()(* ,,3*($4 %#6$/ %*$1%8C6#*#8.($/$/%'*$1#'$$ %?5(1% *  $/#$  51%>*#*$ 6#&4 6%9%66%& #66%>#$(*) #>#(*)$ $/% 5%$($(*%1 $/#$ * 9()($(*> ,,3*($4 %#6$/ %*$1%8 C6#*# /%1%(*# $%1 1% %11%&$#)

8C6#*#*  )/%#551#'/%&$/%5%$($(*%1 1 /%65 1#&,())(*(*

C6#*# 1/%1,%&('#6%?#,(*#$(*#*&&%6(9%14 #))/%.#)C*.*$/%1=3$8$/%5%$($(*%18 1%?$1#*%3)'*)(&%1#$(*)8 '*9(*'%&/%1$>%$/%1&%6(9%14&*% 1,#9(.#* )5($#6=4)$#$(*> $/#$$/% #'(6($(%)#$

8C6#*#.%1%*$)#$() #'$14*/%1>(*>$)#(& /)5($#68 $/% 5%$($(*%1 #*& &'$1)   )#(& 51(9#$% /)5($#6 #$ $/% $(,%  #&,())(*8 '*9(*'%& /%1 $/#$ $$#6 %?5%*)%) 1 /%1 $1%#$,%*$@&%6(9%14 .36&=%=%$.%%*)8@B$) 8@B8=3$*/%1,%&('#6%?#,(*#$(* &%$%'$(*> /%1 $ =% 2 5)($(9%8 )/% .#) '/#1>%& ) 8@B =%)(&%) 6%#C(*>3$(* 1,#$(* /%1=%(*> 25)($(9%#)#1%)36$ ./('/)/%

#'%&>1%#$/#1#)),%*$  /%1%564#6),%*$(*)#=3$#9(&%'6(5<3#$/%(*'(&%*$356#&%& *G3 3=%H 1./('/%?56#*#$(*.#))3>/$=41%)5*&%*$ 1, $/% 5%$($(*%1 .($/(* $. &#4)   1%'%(5$   -/. #3)% $('%  **%?31%B@&#$%&  #)$./4&()'(56(*#14#'$(*=%*$$#C%* #>#(*)$/%1 1,()6%#&(*>#*&1% %11(*>#5#$(%*$$#51(9#$%/)5($#6 1/%1 9%)$%&(*$%1%)$

 !"DE  /% 5%$($(*%1 )3=,($$%& 1%564 $ $/% -/. #3)% $('% 9(&% **%?31% @ &#$%& F 8 =3$ $/% )#,% .#) 3*& $ =% 3*)#$() #'$14#*&9(&%1&%1**%?31%@&#$%& 81%)5*&%*$  (% (9(6 -31>%*8 ()#1 '*)$($3$%& # $/1%% ,%,=%1) ',,($$%% $ '*&3'$#*(*<3(14(*$$/%#66%>#$(*)6%9%6%&#>#(*)$$/%5%$($(*%1

 /#$ $/% 1%564 31$/%1 ,%*$(*) $/#$ $/% ',,($$%% '*&3'$%& # ',51%/%*)(9%(*<3(1481%'1&%&)$#$%,%*$ $/%',56#(*#*$#$$%*&(*>1 -%%,#8 $/%1 )$#

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

31% B@F &#$%&  8 1%)5*&%*$  $%1,(*#$%& $/% '*$1#'$   $/% 5%$($(*%1 9(&% 1&%1 **%?31%@&#$%&   ;%#1*%& '3*)%6 1 $/% 5%$($(*%1 '*$%*&%& $/#$ (* $/% # 1%,%*$(*%& =#'C>13*&8 $/% (,53>*%& 1&%1   $%1,(*#$(* .#) )$(>,#$(' #*& 6(#=6% $ =% )%$ #)(&% * #''3*$   /#9(*> =%%* 5#))%& .($/3$'*&3'$(*>#1%>36#1(*<3(141#))'(#$(*>$/%5%$($(*%1.($/$/% (*<3(141>(9(*>/%1551$3*($4 /%#1(*>(*1%)5%'$$/%1%$  %1 '*$1#8 6%#1*%& &&6 &9'#$% %*%1#68 #14#*# '*$%*&%& $/#$ $/% (,53>*%& 1&%1 .

 !"D E #)$/%#66%>#$(*)6%9%6%&#>#(*)$$/%5%$($(*%1/#&=%%* 3*&$/#9%=%%* %)$#=6()/%& =% 1% $/% ,,($$%% ;%#1*%& &&($(*#6 &9'#$% %*%1#6

31$/%1'*$%*&%&$/#$$/%5%$($(*%1.#)#

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

 

                    

 



   

          

      



       

  

  

  

          

    

   

           !"       #$%&&#%'       ()""    

J

  5%13)#6   $/% (,53>*%& 1&%1 1%9%#6) $/#$ ($ .#) (* $/% '*$%?$ 9(&%'6(5356#&%&*G3 3=%H<3#$/%5%$($(*%1(*&36>(*>(* ,#651#'$('%   #&9()(*> # 5#$(%*$ $ > $ # 51(9#$% /)5($#6 1 &%6(9%14

 !"DFE (*)$%#&   #9#(6(*> )%19('% #$

8 C6#*# $/#$ ($ .#) &%'(&%& (* 53=6(' (*$%1%)$$$%1,(*#$%$/%'*$1#'$ $/%5%$($(*%1#)-$#

31)%%13)#6 &%$#(6)>(9%*#=9% 31$/%11%9%#6)$/#$$/%(,53>*%&1&%1.#)5#))%&=4 1%)5*&%*$   * $/% &(1%'$(*)   1%)5*&%*$  * $/% =#)()  ,()'*&3'$ #66%>%& #>#(*)$ $/% 5%$($(*%1 /#9(*> =%%* %)$#=6()/%& (* $/% %*<3(14'*&3'$%&=4$/% ,,($$%%%564 (6%&=41%)5*&%*$* =%/#6   1%)5*&%*$ )$ '#$%>1('#664 ,%*$(*)$/#$ # )/.'#3)% *$('% .#) ())3%& $ $/% 5%$($(*%1 #*& /%1 %?56#*#$(* )3>/$ 9(&% **%?31%@&#$%&  8.($/1%>#1&$$/%9(&%'6(5356#&%&* G3 3=%H(*./('/$/%5%$($(*%1()#66%>%&$/#9%#&9()%&$/%5#$(%*$$ >%$$1%#$,%*$ 1,#51(9#$%/)5($#6(*)$%#&

8C6#*#8$./('/$/% 5%$($(*%1 (6%& # 1%564 9(&% **%?31% @ * F 8 =3$ $/% (9(6 -31>%*8 ()#18 *$ (*&(*> $/% 1%564 )#$() #'$14 '*)$($3$%& # $/1%% ,%,=%1)',,($$%%9(&%,%,&#$%& ./%1%# $%1&%$#(6%&#*& ',51%/%*)(9% (*<3(14 .#) '*&3'$%& =4 $/% ',,($$%% #*& &31(*> $/% '31)% (*<3(148)$#$%,%*$ $/%5#$(%*$#).%66#)&'$1./'*&3'$%& $/% &%6(9%14 =%)(&%) )$#

   $/% 51(9#$% /)5($#6 .#) 1%'1&%&8 "%&('#6 1%'1&5%1$#(*(*>$%?#,(*#$(* $/%5#$(%*$.#)5%13)%&#*&# (*&(*> .#) 1%'1&%& * )#,% &#4 $/#$ $/% 5%$($(*%1 /#& ,()%1#=64 #(6%& $ &()'/#1>% /%1 &3$(%) #) 5%1 51%)'1(=%& 51'%&31% #) &%)5($% $/% 5#$(%*$ 1%,#(*(*> (* $/% /)5($#6 1 @  ,(*3$%)8 )/% &(& *$ >%$ $/% 5#$(%*$ #&,($$%& (*

8 C6#*# *1 '*)36$%& #*4 &'$1 1 #*4 $/%1 )$#

,%,=%1*&3$48(*)$%#&&%6(=%1#$%64#&9()%&$/%5#$(%*$$>%$/%1&%6(9%14 &*% 1, # 51(9#$%/)5($#6 *$/% 51%$%?$ (*#&%<3#$% #*& (*)3

('(%*$

#'(6($(%) #*& 51 (* 1#)$13'$31% (*

8 C6#*# *$%*$)   5#1#>1#5/ )  $    $/% 1%564 31$/%1 '#$%>1('#664 ,%*$(* $/#$ $/% ',,($$%%

3*&$/%,()'*&3'$#$$1(=3$%&$$/%5%$($(*%1&364%)$#=6()/%&6%#&(*>$

 !"DAE 1%)5*&%*$&(1%'$(*>1%)5*&%*$$$%1,(*#$%$/%'*$1#'$ $/% 5%$($(*%1&3%$/%1#66%>%&(*969%,%*$(*,#651#'$('% #$%>1('#6)$#*& /#)=%%*$#C%*(*5#1#>1#5/ $/%1%564$/#$($.#)(*',56(#*'% ',,3*('#$(***%?31%@F$/#$1%)5*&%*$$%1,(*#$%&$/%)%19('%  $/%5%$($(*%19(&%**%?31%@&#$%&  F *

  !"

#""$  %"!&

  '" '!

( "! " )'

  * *"!*"  (*+  ,--- ./0  128 *H=6% $/% -351%,% 31$.#)56%#)%&$/6&$/#$$/#$(*'#)% (*&(*>)#11(9%&#$(* #* %*<3(14 #) $ ,()'*&3'$ =%/(*& $/% =#'C   $/% 

('%1 1 .($/3$ # 1%>36#1&%5#1$,%*$#6(*<3(148)(,56%1&%1 $%1,(*#$(*.36&=%$1%#$%& #) 3*&%& * #66%>#$(*)8 '*)%<3%*$(#6648 =#& %6%9#*$ %?$1#'$   $/% # 1%,%*$(*%&&%'()(*()1%51&3'%&#)3*&%1+B I*$/%=#)() $/%#=9%'*$%*$(*)8$/% 66.(*>5(*$)#1()%

1'*)(&%1#$(*+ *./#$'(1'3,)$#*'%)8$/%$%1,(*#$(* #51=#$(*%1K))%19('%) '#*=%)#(&$=% 3*&%&*,()'*&3'$#*&(*./#$'(1'3,)$#*'%) '36&($=%)#(&$/#$$/%#66%>#$(*).%1%*64$/%,$(9%L  /%* '#* #* 1&%1   $%1,(*#$(*   # 51=#$(*%1 =% )#(& $ '*$#(*#*%?51%)))$(>,#L  #* $/% )$(>,# =% >#$/%1%& =4 1% %11(*> =#'C $ 51'%%&(*>) 1% %11%&$(*$/%1&%1 $%1,(*#$(*L   ./#$1%6(% L    % &% 

 

   *                        *                    +   +   

     

    ,   *     

  

 !"D E 

 

     

      *          

                          

       

    

   

    

 

   *    

              

    

     *

    

    

    

                     

 

 

       

  -.+

              

    %  

   

 /  A * 9(%.   $/% 1&%1   $%1,(*#$(* /#9(*> =%%* 5#))%& * #''3*$ $/%#66%>%&(*969%,%*$ $/%5%$($(*%1(*,#651#'$('%#)5%1 9(&% '6(5 356#&%& * G3 3=%H #&9()(*> # 5#$(%*$ $ > $ # 51(9#$% /)5($#6(*)$%#& >%$$(*>/%1#&,($$%&(*

8C6#*#8#)#6) $/%)$#*& (* 5#1#>1#5/ )  $    $/% 1%564 $/#$ $/% ',,($$%% 3*& $/% ,()'*&3'$ #$$1(=3$%& $ $/% 5%$($(*%1 &364 %)$#=6()/%&8 '*)%<3%*$(#664 1%)5*&%*$&(1%'$%&1%)5*&%*$$$%1,(*#$%$/%'*$1#'$ $/% 5%$($(*%1#*&1&%1**%?31%@&#$%& $%1,(*#$(*>$/%'*$1#'$  )%19('% $/%5%$($(*%1.#)5#))%&=41%)5*&%*$(*',56(#*'% 1&%1) 1%)5*&%*$(%**%?31%@F*#''3*$ $/%,()'*&3'$ #66%>%&#>#(*)$$/%5%$($(*%1/#9(*>=%%*%)$#=6()/%&(*$/%%*<3(14#*&$/% 5%$($(*%1*$/#9(*>=%%*#))'(#$%&.($/$/%%*<3(14%?'%5$ 1>(9(*> )/.'#3)%*$('%**%?31%B@&#$%&  ./(6%$/%%*<3(14.#) '*&3'$%&* ./%1%)$#$%,%*$) ',56#(*#*$8#$$%*&(*>&'$1

 !"DE #).%66#))$#

 $/%51(9#$%/)5($#6.%1%%?#,(*%&#*&,%&('#61%'1& $/%',56#(*#*$5%13)%&8($()'6%#1=%4*&#*($# &3=$$/#$$/%1&%1 $%1,(*#$(* )%19('%)'*$1#'$ $/%5%$($(*%1() 3*&%&*#66%>#$(*)   ,()'*&3'$ &,($$%&648 $/% )#,% .#) 5#))%& .($/3$ '*&3'$(*> # 1%>36#1(*<3(14#*&>(9(*>$/%5%$($(*%1$/%%9(&%*'%'66%'$%&#>#(*)$/%1 &31(*> $/% '31)%   (*<3(14 #*& ./('/ .#) 1%6(%& #>#(*)$ $/% 5%$($(*%1 .($/3$ >(9(*> /%1 #* 551$3*($4 $ 1%=3$ $/% )#,%8 6%#&(*> %9(&%*'% (* &% %*'%=%)(&%)'1))B%?#,(*(*>$/%',56#(*#*$#).%66#)1-%%,##*& $/%1)$#

 $/%51(9#$%/)5($#6% %1%*'%(*$/()'**%'$(*'#*#6)=% ,#&%$$/%&%'()(* # *H=6%(9()(*%*'/ $/() 31$(*'#)%$($6%& #) $  !& !' "

$ "')

% !

 !&' "

32,1.,0421 ./%1%(* # '*$1#'$ #.#1&%& (* #931   '*$1#'$1) .#) $%1,(*#$%& * #66%>#$(*)   (11%>36#1($(%) ',,($$%& =4 $/% '*$1#'$1) =3$ .($/3$ '*&3'$(*> #* %*<3(14 (* #''1&#*'% .($/ 6#. (% =4 #))'(#$(*> $/% '*$1#'$1)8 )35564(*> $/%, '5(%)   $/% ',56#(*$)8 )$#$%,%*$)  ',56#(*#*$ #*& .($*%))%) 1%'1&%& &31(*> $/% %*<3(14 #*& .($/3$ #

1&(*>$/%,#'/#*'%$'* 1*$$/%',56#(*#*$#*&$/%1.($*%))%)%$' /% *H=6% (9()(* %*'/ /%6& $/#$ $/% (*<3(14 '*&3'$%& .#) (* 9(6#$(* $/%51(*'(56%) *#$31#6M3)$('% *)%<3%*$(#6648$/%(,53>*%& 1&%1) .%1% )%$ #)(&% #*& $/% ,#$$%1 1%,#*&%& $ $/% (1%'$1 %*%1#68

%#6$/ -%19('%)8 #14#*# 1 '*&3'$(*> # 1%)/ (*<3(14 #>#(*)$ $/% '*$1#'$1) (* #''1&#*'% .($/ $/% 51(*'(56%)   *#$31#6 M3)$('% #*& $(66

(*#6(N#$(* $/%%*<3(148$/%'*$1#'$1).%1%5%1,($$%&$'*$(*3%.($/ $/%.1C#66$$%&$$/%,   *$/%6(>/$ $/%5)($(*#)*$%&#=9%8$/%.1($5%$($(*() #66.%& /% (,53>*%& )$(>,#$(' 1&%1 '31$#(6(*> $/% '*$1#'$3#6 #55(*$,%*$ $/%5%$($(*%1()6%>#6643*)3)$#(*#=6%#*&()#''1&(*>64)%$

 !"D E #)(&% #*& $/% 5%$($(*%1 1%(*)$#$%& (* )%19('% .%9%18 (* 9(%.   $/% &%'()(* # *H=6%(9()(*%*'/ $/() 31$(*!'!"

'

%')  !&5



!& ' "

 $  "!

( &6!

$"  7+!

(  !&5

"!*  !&' "

32,,.,088886(=%1$4()>1#*$%&$$/% 1%)5*&%*$) $ 5#)) # 1%)/ 1&%1 (* #''1&#*'% .($/ 6#. /% 5%$($(*%1 .36&=%%*$($6%&$.#>%).% &#$% )%$$(*>#)(&% $/%(,53>*%&1&%1

.%9%18%*$($6%,%*$$=#'C.#>%).36&=%&%5%*&%*$*$/% 1%)/1&%1) 5#))%&=4$/%',5%$%*$#3$/1($4(*#''1&#*'%.($/6#.  1($5%$($(*()#66.%&(*# 1%,%*$(*%&$%1,)  -#6(# 3&>%   1#M%)/CC/31#*# 1. Whether speaking/reasoned :

Yes/No.

2. Whether reportable :

Yes/No.