High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/28501/2017disposed of

Sonu & Others v. State Of Haryana & Another

2017-12-22Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan8 pages

"#$ $%&'&() $%$*+$,-

!"#$ ##$% ,$'$(#).

' (/0"#,"#0- $(&, 12%"#$- 3&#0,"(1$4- 12%"#$- ,/($$#"5&- $(&, 12%"#$3&#0 , $$6"78/*",- 12%"#$"(1 , "'+&,,- 12%"#$- ,#0$6$#&#&($,' ,8 (-

-",4"(" &'( )! * '+ #&%$ *#&(3"'&''/$1&(#0&'6$#&#&(( 9

- ,$#/,("+5$(

- 3&#0 (#&%$,$:",1&(: '#"4"5' 0"2&(: +$$( &''/$1 (,$'6('$#0$,$#-"'0,#,$654+43"4 "("

&1"2&# #0$ &,$%#,-5$*$(#",41/%"#&(-",4"("-"(%07/5"-0"'+$$( &5$1+4#0$ 5$",($1 #"#$%/('$5&(/,##1"4-"%64 30&%00"'+$$(:&2$(##0$ %/('$566'&#$"(1#0$,$ ,$&'#"7$((,$%,1 (#0$"

,$'"&1"

&1"2&#-#0$+"%7:,/(1 #0$5&#&:"#&(0"'

+$$(:&2$(-##0$$

$%##0"#; 6'#' $"%0$,'3$,$"12$,#&'$1+4 #0$",4"(" %05$"%0$,' $5$%#&(",1&(#0$4$",

<&(#$,*' 30&%0"12$,#&'$*$(#(($ #0$6$#&#&($,'3"'$5&:&+5$#"6654"'#0$4 1&1 (# /5 &55 "( $''$(#&"5 =/"5& &%"#&(- &$ #0$4 0"1 (# 6"''$1 #0$ ",4"("$"%0$,'5&:&+&5&#4$'#"'(#0$%/#

1"#$ &>$1&(#0$'$5$%#&( 6,%$''?

($ (#&*8/*",&-"5(:3&#0#0$,%"(1&1"#$'- &5$1 (?9@

?-'#"#&(:#0$,$&(#0"##0$40"16"''$1#0$" #$,#0$ "12$,#&'$*$(# 3"' &''/$1- +$%"/'$ 6,&, # #0"# #0$ ",4"(" %05 1/%"#&(",10"1(#%(1/%#$1#0$'"&1$>"*&("#&( /,&(:#0$%/,'$ 0$",&(: #0"# 6$#&#&(- " '#"#$*$(# 3"' *"1$ +4 #0$ 115 0&$

$%,$#",4-2$,(*$(# ",4"("- $6",#*$(# $%(1",41/%"#&(- #0"##0$2$,(*$(#3/51%('&1$,#0$%5"&* $2$(#0'$%"(1&1"#$'"'

0"1%5$",$1#0$'/+'$=/$(###0$%/#

1"#$-"''/

&%&$(#(/*+$, 2"%"(%&$'3$,$"2"&5"+5$&(#0$1/%"#&( $6",#*$(# (2&$3 #0$"

,$'"&1'#"#$*$(#-#0$%"(1&1"#/,$ '/%0 %"(1&1"#$'3"'%('&1$,$1-"(1#0$",4"(" #"

$5$%#&(**&''&( *"1$",$%**$(1"#&(( 9

-+430&%0#0$6$#&#&($,'&(#0$ 6,$'$(#3,&#6$#&#&(3$,$"5',$%**$(1$1 ,"66&(#*$(# 3$2$,- #0$"

&1"2&# &5$1#1"4 /,#0$,'#"#$'#0"#"55"66&(#*$(#'3$,$'#"4$12&1$ "(,1$,1"#$1

@6"''$1&(A (@ @

@-#&#5$1"'",1$$6 8/*",2 #"#$ ",4"(" ( 9

-#0$'#"43"'2"%"#$1":"&('#"66&(#*$(#

$"%0$,'- 3&#0 1&,$%#&(' &''/$1 +4 #0$ &2&'&( $(%0 # &''/$ "66&(#*$(#,1$,'#$5&:&+5$%"(1&1"#$'/,'/"(###0"#-"66&(#*$(# ,1$,'3$,$&''/$1(B 9

-&(%5/1&(:##0'$ /,6$,'('"'

0"2$+$$(,$ $,,$1#+4#0$6$#&#&($,'&(#0$6,$'$(#6$#&#&("'+$&(: 53$,#0"(#0$*&(#0$*$,&#5&'#-&$&$"*#"-$(/",$'08/*","(1 ",1$$68/*",$,,($/'54,$ $,,$1#"'#0$6,&2"#$,$'6(1$(#'&(#0$ "

&1"2&#- "' ( 6$,'(' #0$, #0"( #0$

&%&"5 ,$'6(1$(#' 0"2$ +$$( &*65$"1$1"'4$#&(#0$6,$'$(#6$#&#&( !$# /,#0$,-#0$"

&1"2&#'#"#$'#0"#"(#0$,,1$,3"'6"''$1(

+4#0$ &2&'&($(%0-30&%0,$"1'"'/(1$,). C$"(30&5$- #"#$ ",4"("&'1&,$%#$1#&1$(#& 4#0$ ##"5(/*+$, 6'#'#+$ &55$1&("'6$,#0$,1$,1"#$1 9

-"'

"5'#0$(/*+$, '$5$%#$1%"(1&1"#$'-30"'6$,#0$,&:&("5*$,&#5&'# ,,$2&'$1*$,&#5&'#,&(#$,*' #0$1&,$%#&('&''/$1+45$",($1 &(:5$

/1:$'-",$$(#&#5$1 ,"66&(#*$(##&' /,#0$,1&,$%#$1"'"(&(#$,&* *$"'/,$#0"#"66&(#*$(#'+$

$,$1'#,&%#54&(,1$, *$,&#"'6$,#0$ ,$2&'$1*$,&#5&'#+/#'/+D$%## &("5/#%*$ #0$'$6,%$$1&(:' '*$6'#',$*"&(/( &55$1"

#$,"66&(#&(:#0$%"(1&1"#$'"'6$,#0$ ,$2&'$1*$,&#5&'#-#0$'"*$*"4+$

$,$1##0$%"(1&1"#$'&(3"&#&(:5&'# 6,2&1$1#0"##0$##"5"66&(#*$(#'1(#$>%$$1#0$"12$,#&'$16'#'E *60"'&'"665&$1&(#0$6,$'$(#,1$,(54 /,'/"(###0$"

,$'"&1,1$,-"FD&(#*$,&#5&'#F&''#"#$1# 0"2$+$$(6,$6",$1+4#0$,$'6(1$(#'-%(#"&(&(:#0$("*$' #0'$( #0$,&:&("5*$,&#5&'#30&%01&1(#%(#"&(#0$("*$' #0'$300"1

6"''$1"

#$,#0$%/#

1"#$-"'"5' ,*#0$,$2&'$1*$,&#5&'# %(#"&(&(:#0$("*$' '/%06$,'(' #&' /,#0$,'#"#$1+4#0$ &,$%#,&(0&'"

&1"2&##0"#"'#0$ ##"5(/*+$, "66&(#*$(#'3$,$(##$>%$$1#0$(/*+$, "12$,#&'$1 6'#'-"66&(#*$(#,1$,'3$,$3&#01,"3(&(,$'6$%# #0'$"66&(#$$'

,*#0$ &,'#,$%**$(1"#&(5&'#-30%"*$53$,&(*$,&#&(#0$D&(# *$,&#5&'# 0$(/*+$, '/%06$,'('3"' ; ,$'52$#0$&''/$-"*$$#&(:&''#"#$1#0"2$+$$(0$51 #0$,$"

#$,(

-/(1$,#0$0"&,*"('0&6 #0$0&$ &(&'#$,- ",4"("-"##$(1$1+4#0$ 12%"#$$($,"5-",4"(""(1'$(&,

&%$,' #0$2$,(*$(#-30$,$&("1$%&'&(3"'#"7$(#"66&(# ;($354 ,$%,/&#$1#$"%0$,'("("10%+"'&'-30'$"66&(#*$(#5$##$,'0"1+$$( %"(%$55$1-"'"5'

9/$'#$"%0$,'"66&(#$1$",5&$,(%(#,"%#/"5 +"'&'- 30 0"1 +$$( ,$5&$2$1 #0$&, 6'#'- F' "' # $('/,$ #0"# #0$ $1/%"#&( #0$'#/1$(#'1$'(#'/

$,F-+$%"/'$ "'0,#":$ 6,&*",4 #$"%0$,'&(#0$ #"#$ 0$"

&1"2&#"5',$ $,'#"(#& &%"#&(

;;

-&''/$1+4 #0$0&$ $%,$#",4##0$2$,(*$(# ",4"("-&*6'&(:"+"(( *"7&(:"10%"66&(#*$(#'-+/#D/'#& &$'#0$"66&(#*$(#'(3,1$,$1 ("10%+"'&'-("%%/(# #0$'0,#":$ 6,&*",4#$"%0$,' #&''#"#$1#0"##0$,$ ,$",$5">"#&( ,*#0$6,2&'&(' #0$ "

,$'"&1(#& &%"#&(3"':&2$(+4#0$0&$ $%,$#",4(

"'#"1D/'##0$"

,$'"&16$,'('(#0$6'#' 6,&*",4#$"%0$,'(F"10% +"'&'F ",":,"60 #0$"

&1"2&#:&2$'#0$(/*+$, 2"%"(%&$'

'B'"' 553').

$ ,$6,%$$1&(: /,#0$,-&#&'#+$'#"#$1#0"##1"4+$&(:#0$ 5"'#1"4+$ ,$#0$3&(#$,2"%"#&(-"("665&%"#&(&''/:0##+$ &5$1&( %/,##&*65$"1#36$,'('"'&(#$,2$(,'B6, ,*",$'6(1$(#'&(#0&'

6$#&#&(-#0$4+$&(:&1$(#&%"55465"%$1"'#0$?6$#&#&($,'300"2$ &5$1#0$ 6$#&#&( $(%$-&#&' %('&1$,$1"66,6,&"#$#&*65$"1#0'$300"2$

&5$1"("665&%"#&(&(/,##1"4 ,'/%0&*65$"1*$(#-"'6$#&#&($,'

&#'$5 &(#0$6$#&#&(-(#0$:,/(1#0"##0$4#",$'&*&5",54'&#/"#$1"'#0$ 6$#&#&($,'-+$&(:0&:0$,&(*$,&##0"(#0'$30",$6,6'$1#+$:,"(#$1 "66&(#*$(#("10%+"'&' 0$"

,$'"&16$,'('",$"%%,1&(:54&*65$"1$1"'6$#&#&($,' (9"(1 &(#0$6$#&#&( #05$",($1'$(&,%/('$5"66$",&(: ,#0$6$#&#&($,'-"'

"5', (-5$",($1 #"#$%/('$5-0"2$"11,$''$1",:/*$(#'&(#$,*'

#0$65$"1&(:'&(%5/1&(:#0$"

&1"2&# &5$1#1"4 "2&(:%('&1$,$1#0$",:/*$(#' 5$",($1 $(&,%/('$5 "66$",&(: ,#0$6$#&#&($,'-"'"5'5$",($1%/('$5 ,#0$ #"#$-&(#0$ 6&(&( #0&'%/,#-(%$"D&(#*$,&#5&'#0"'+$$(6,$6",$1+4#0$ ,$'6(1$(#'#0$*'$52$'-"

#$,#0$,1$,' #0$ &2&'&($(%0&(A

(@ @

@-#0$,$"

#$,-:,"(#&(:$2$("10%"66&(#*$(#'#6$,'(' 53$,&(*$,&#&(#0"#FD&(#5&'#F3/51+$0&:054&*6,6$,"(130554 ",+&#,",4-'/%0"%#&(-&($

$%#+$&(:"($:"#&( #0$D&(#*$,&#5&'# 6,$6",$1 0$,$ ,$- #&55 #0$ 1$%&'&( A (@ @

@- &(#$,&* 1&,$%#&('0"2&(:+$$(,$%,1$1&(#0"#"66$"5-#0"#$2$(#0'$300"1 6"''$1#0$"

#$,#0$%/#

1"#$&(#0$'$5$%#&(6,%$''&(=/$'#&( 3/51+$%('&1$,$1 ,"66&(#*$(#-#0$D&(#*$,&#5&'#+2&/'54($$1'# +$"10$,$1#2$(#/"554& &#&'0$51#0"##0'$300"1(#%5$",$1#0$ +4#0$%/#

1"#$%"((#+$"66&(#$16,&,##0'$300"1 %5$",$1#0$$>"*&("#&(-("#/,"554#0$ &2&'&($(%03/516"'',1$,'"' &#1$$*'"66,6,&"#$3$2$,-&(#0$*$"(30&5$-#0$&(#$,&*,1$,' #0$ &2&'&($(%0+$&(:+&(1&(:(#0$,$'6(1$(#'"(1#0$4#0$*'$52$' 0"2&(:6,$6",$1"D&(#*$,&#5&'#"%%,1&(:54-#0$4",$+/(1#&*65$*$(# &#&(5$##$,"(1'6&,&# ('$=/$(#54-#0$&*6/:($1,1$,- (($>/,$.-&'0$,$+4 =/"'0$1"(1"1&,$%#&(&'&''/$1##0$,$'6(1$(#'#*"7$"66&(#*$(#' &(#$,*' #0$%*+&($1*$,&#5&'#6,$6",$1+4#0$*-'/+D$%#("#/,"554##0$ /#%*$ A (@ @

#$,"55 #0$"12$,#&'$1 6'#'&(#0$'$5$%#&(6,%$''&( =/$'#&(0"2$+$$( &55$1/6"%%,1&(:54-#0$,$",$'#&552"%"(%&$'#30&%0 ,$'6(1$(#'3&'0#*"7$"66&(#*$(#'("("10%+"'&'-&(,1$,# $('/,$#0"##0$'#/1&$' #0$'#/1$(#'",$'"

$:/",1$1, ,"(4#0$, ,$"'(-'/%0"66&(#*$(#'+$*"1$":"&( &,'#54'#,&%#54"'6$,#0$,1$, *$,&#&(#0$D&(#*$,&#5&'#"(1(54"

#$,"55'/%02"%"(%&$'"'#0$ #"#$ 3&'0$'# &55&(",$ &55$1&("%%,1&(:54-3/51"66&(#*$(# /$'# $"%0$,'B ,*$,/$'#$"%0$,'+$*"1$(#0$,$*"&(&(:2"%"(%&$' , (- 5$",($1 #"#$ %/('$5- 0"' '/+*&##$1 #0"# #0$ "

,$'"&11&,$%#&(3/51&(#$, $,$3&#0#0$1&,$%#&(':&2$(+4#0&'/,# &((

-&(30&%06$#&#&(#0$6$#&#&($,'",$#0'$30 #0$,3&'$%*$3&#0&(#0$*$,&#5&'#-+/##0$&,"66&(#*$(#'",$/(1$," %5/1- &( 2&$3 #0$ "%# #0"# #0$&, &(:$, 6,&(#'B#0/*+ &*6,$''&('B'&:("#/,$' ",$ &( 1/+#- 30$( %*6",$1 3&#0 #0$ &(:$, 6,&(#'B#0/*+&*6,$''&('B'&:("#/,$'+#"&($1"##0$#&*$30$(#0$40"1 "66$",$1 ,#0$ 0"#+$&(:'-&#&'1&,$%#$1#0"#"',$:",1'#0$(/*+$, %"(1&1"#$'30",$#0$,3&'$&(#0$D&(#*$,&#5&'#-+/##0$&,%"(1&1"#/,$ &#'$5 &' /(1$," %5/1 "' "

,$'"&1- ,$:/5","66&(#*$(# # #0"# *"(4 (/*+$, 6'#' 3/51+$7$6# &( "+$4"(%$#&55 #0$1$%&'&( (

0$4#*"4-03$2$,-+$ &55$1/6 ,*#0$D&(#*$,&# 5&'#("("10%+"'&'-&(#$,*' #0$1&,$%#&(':&2$(0$,$&("+2$-":"&( '/+D$%###0$/#%*$ A (@ @

0$"

,$'"&11&,$%#&('+$%",,&$1/#3&#0&("6$,&1 #3 *(#0' ,*#0$1"#$ ,$%$&6# "%$,#& &$1%64 #0&',1$, $%$*+$,-

&'( 2%:",:

0$#0$,'6$"7&(:B,$"'($1) !$'B( 0$#0$,,$6,#"+5$) !$'B(