M/S Mannat Oil Carrier v. Indian Oil Corporation And ORS





    
 


     !"

!#$ %&%

 '(((

 ( )(*
  '(+(  ,(

+ 
 

  !"#$%&'(
##

')% '

 !"#&$%&'(
#"(& )(""

( 

%(  - * ./0( (,+ ( %( ,,1+(/0 #

')% '

*$ ,'' . ,+( 3(+ ,44* 

#5 !6 !#$7

8*( 9":3,(;<=(
*, (.(  .( +(  (# >(*>33,(3  ,  (+    0   (  (  ( +(    ;*'> +('*4  +(*  (  3,,  ,  + (  *;4     (  

## !#6?* .#6 >(*>0';'(( +( ;*'> +('*4+(*  * (> .*( ,' .3, (*4  3,  , >(*> ;'>';*3* ,   >(*>  $$# $63;'>';< ,('4+ <   *  ('*4 (+(  =4  7 =:/  30(/  =(  
3* (+# >(*> -*;?* '</,=(
,; 3,(3 (,(

 ,,+ (, ', >(*>; .;'>'  , ',4,4*;4  (  =( * '(,(+ ('*+ ,@*.4  ,*( 0'A(   65$" !#$7%& (0(* *' 0(*
  '(+( =  ,(: ,?* .,  >(*>/3,,;'>'/ ' (((''4 ,  ( 

,,(, /'( * '(,+ ((.* ,,;'>' >(*>3+*(,  ;(*(</ !#6;<, (  (4  %&  1>  %, (   >     ,  3 (,+  3 ( (( 0*(,+ (  ;(*(</ !#6/,((/, ;'>' >(*>3(.,'<8'*(4,.(  (;<, (+  ''<;*'( ,; 3( .'<3,(3 
 (.*,,+ (3 3(;'>' .(*>B,((/ ,43?* ,(*>0';'(( +( 
3 ; 9 B,((/,+ ' ?* 

''*+ , ( %( 1+(,' '0/ ('/( .

,,+ (33(;'>'* >(*> ?*  *,   (4  3  ,(  ;<   =    #" #!

!!6     +((   +*;'    ,   (    #6 ## !#6  %(  1+(  (.*  ,  , (

>,'(,,,;'>' ., > (*>+*(,3 > 3 ,4  A(,+  ,3

(3+(*4+ ,, (33(,;'>' ., >(*>+*(,;<,

 ((4%&1>%, ( > ,+*(,(4%&1> %, ( >*..,,+(0*3 (,0 .>   '

 (4, >;* 3 ;'+< ''4  / ,((/, >(*>4.,,0; ';<%&1>%, ( >  +*(,;<,+ ( ,*(

(3 <+(*4+ 

(4- ##6,0 ,,+ (33( ;'>' ., >(*> ,( 4, 4,( (4

;'>' . >(*>3,. ('+*;' ,((/4(, ,  + (  ,  ?*  ;'>'   >  (*>/  3,,  3  '(  

+*(,;<,4

;.(* 3,(3,=(
* ,+ ( (+,( >(*>  A ,, ,(+  3,(3 ., =(
3,*> 3'.,  >(*>;'>'3,  33 ;< ,(3 (/

(4( ;';(3,(3'

=(
   ?* '</  3      ,  44*    #5 !6 !#$  *;@    ,     ,  ,  + (  ,''  +(* *4     +*(,  (4  %&  1>  %, (   >  ;(  , (+   ,3(+  +( .'<    +, )-.,   $-/0

"1,) *'< / !#$

















$-/0

(